HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DomreiRoam

224 karma · joined February 5, 2010

submissionscomments
DomreiRoam··on Selection bias is the most powerful force in education
I would like to read a study that evaluate the value of education for the full society. I think we need an educated public because Democracy needs it.
DomreiRoam··on Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through security community
Why didn't the FBI ask for an extradition to the UK? If the case was solid they should use the proper channel to deal with foreign (supposed) criminals.

When you use this strategy, you deprive the arrested of the right he would have in his country and you add the crazy cost to defend yourself in a US court. So it's possible that the case is not that solid or need some Parallel construction. It's pure speculation but it seems fishy to me.

I can understand the use of shenanigans to arrest previous dictators or very powerful crime lords as a last resort for Justice but here it seems very unfair.

I think we may see a drop of attendee to US conference and/or a drop in tourism.

DomreiRoam··on Have Smartphones Destroyed a Generation?
I think we can't see the 2008 the 2008 as only a one time event because the 2008 crisis caused a period of stress for a while for a lot of families.

I agree that the smartphone has a strong addictive power but so does the internet, alcohol, various drugs ... It wasn't alone in a "source of shifting stressors".

So I think it s difficult for me to be completely convinced on this thesis because they didn't speak about the nearly concomitant 2008 event that in my mind could explain why teenager would fall to addiction. The fact that the smartphone was the new addiction is not irrelevant but it isn't the full explanation.

DomreiRoam··on Have Smartphones Destroyed a Generation?
For the graph part, I find weird that we believe that iPhone introduction is stronger than the 2008 financial crisis on teen anxiety issue.
DomreiRoam··on Second body cam video of Baltimore cops manufacturing evidence discovered
Police have a monopoly on legal violence and Society act like their words are more trustworthy in a courtroom. It is not acceptable that it is not counterbalance by a high level standard and scrutiny. Police work is difficult and I admire people that have commitment to protect and serve but we can't give a blank check or a get out of jail free card for criminal or unethical conduct.

I think we see in a lot of communities that the police and other public worker are no more trusted and I think we will see the raise of alternative actors to fulfill the gap. Such actor could be criminal groups like mafia and terrorist group that then can use this to build up their base.

So I think it is immoral to allow this and I think it's stupid in Machiavellian or realpolitik way.

DomreiRoam··on Sperm Count Dropping in Western World
I think you are quite correct to point that law and regulation reduces personal autonomy and that the law is violent in is nature. I agree 100% that the impact of marketing on the result of election and it scares me a lot the new trend to use social mass data to win election. I m more and more in favor of sortition for this reason. I agree also that you have regulation set up by people that seek rent above everything.

I think I fear also the harm that powerful people or corporation do right now and I think someone need to take action. What is difficult is to have the right balance between liberty and regulation.

We see a division between continental Europe and Anglo-saxon country; In Europe we have more regulation and I think less economical growth and less innovation and the US where it seems you have less regulation but often more meant to create rent and crazy companies behavior but you have growth and more innovation.

Thanks for your comments, it s nice to have a good conversation :)

DomreiRoam··on Sperm Count Dropping in Western World
I think I fear that marketing forces are stronger than consumer knowledge. I spend too much time debunking facts on Facebook posted by relatives to think that people in general want to spend time looking for the truth. Also we have studies that shows that doctors doesn't understand enough statistic to understand medical studies and make good choice. I also see that ordinary folk don't discern the difference in knowledge between a TV pundit a TV-star and an expert.

I don't believe that government are perfect and the only solution but I think they can be part of it. You have classes of problem where regulation is an answer, one of them is when the condition of a fair market are not met: Monopoly, information asymmetry (You don't have the same resource as GS to understand the market condition ). So some regulation are in place to allow a market to work for all.

The state is there to define the boundaries of acceptable behavior because he is the only one that is allowed to use violence to enforce rules. I think we need to have a minimal level of regulation because we need some liberty to have innovation. This minimum is difficult to agree on and I suspect the level of regulation i would accept is higher than yours but I think you accept certain level. Most people would reject slavery, experimentation on human, kidnapping, extortion ... as normal behavior. But they were accepted at some point.

DomreiRoam··on Sperm Count Dropping in Western World
We have already plenty of certification companies that take your money in exchange for a nice logo/label on the packaging. You still need an expert to tells if they do it right. I think the difficulty is to find a source of 'Authority' that can control the controller. I don't believe that the State is always doing the right think (Flint water ...) but the private sector has already been caught doing very nasty thing (Asbestos, Cigarette ...). I believe the democratic can provide a last resort authority most of the time. In fact the Courts are sometime used in this capacity.

Also we need to take in account that you cant only take in account the consumer point of view. Other aspect like geopolitics or pollution or security need to be addressed: Japan still try to support agriculture because they don't want to have starvation in case of a maritime blockade. We still have states secure maritime transport and fight piracy.

The difficulty, is to see what need to be regulated and what can be let to the market force. And there is no definitive answer because the market react to regulation and regulation are adapted according to market behavior. But ideology and culture background are determinant to define what proportion you want. It is clearly the opposition between collectivism and individualism. I think both to the extreme are wrong.

DomreiRoam··on Sperm Count Dropping in Western World
I think you need good regulation and that is difficult to achieve. Seriously you can ask the consumer to be a little knowledgeable but you can't ask all consumer to have the equivalence of master in Biology, Chemistry, Material science ... and conduct testing on their food, water, car ... when you have sophisticate actor with huge budget and can make profit by tricking consumer.
DomreiRoam··on U.S. math team finishes 4th behind Korea, China, Vietnam
There is a study that shows that European languages can make number acquisition and arithmetic more difficult and I noticed that sometime it's easier for my daughter (5 year old) to do addition and subtraction in Khmer than in French.

But I don't see how it would cause a problem long term for the best student. I believe that STEM is still esteemed in Asia and less so in Europe.

DomreiRoam··on U.S. math team finishes 4th behind Korea, China, Vietnam
If you go to see the full results: http://www.imo-official.org/results.aspx , you can see that asian country have a lot of good results. Do you know what the cause is?
DomreiRoam··on Should we break up the big tech companies?
You can make the point that even in a market economy, the internal economy of a company is communist: it is centrally controlled/planned and not market base. Outside, big companies can distort the market because of they weight and there ability to use international difference (price transfer, little effective tax paid, lobbying).

So I think, if you believe in the invisible hand and that a fair market is good for everybody, I think we should have smaller companies. But it's not only for tech companies. We have facilitate fusion/acquisition a little too much and we see less competition and even some time cartel.

DomreiRoam··on Generating music with expressive timing and dynamics
Thanks, it make sense to do so. Do you know it they use use this approach only in game with a scenario or also in multi-user settings? Because in one case they can use static triggers where in the other case they would need to measure user's sensation or stress. I mean the music could be more intense if you are in abttle and your armor and health are quite low.
DomreiRoam··on German MPs vote for new law to fine social media companies over illegal content
Remember that german population are getting older and there is a case to allow younger people to come in to pay for the pension. The only country that really don't want to rely on immigration for a growing elderly population is Japan. They choose to try robotizing a lot of support function.
DomreiRoam··on Thoughts on Insurance
NGO are trying to cut cost down. They tray to focus to their mission as efficient that they can. Doctor without Border is faster in some case than public emergency service.

The difference is that what is seen as cost, private company often see the product they deliver as a cost.

DomreiRoam··on Generating music with expressive timing and dynamics
Could it mean that you could generate music for games that would follow the action and help build up tension?
DomreiRoam··on Why Not Have a Randomly Selected Congress?
I m interested by this topics and I recommend a book by David van Reybrouck that speaks about this topic: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/jul/18/against-electi...

I think the way we produce new legislation and control the government is not satisfactory as it is. My favorite approach would be to have a sortition (based on a quota method maybe) then some intensive training (law, constitution ... ) before the one term and after that training of the member of the assembly that go back to the civil life.

DomreiRoam··on How to read and understand a scientific paper: a guide for non-scientists
I would like to have a digest or an overview written for a IT practitioner. I did go SC/IT conference and enjoyed the talks and I noticed 2 things: 1/ You learn new things and new approach that can bring value to our job 2/ It seems that the research sector discover stuff that are already known in the industry.

I think it would be great to have a journal/blog that would construct a bridge between the industry and the university.

DomreiRoam··on Wal-Mart is telling some vendors they can’t run applications on AWS
I think they have the expertise to switch to another solution quite fast and if amazon try something nefarious it would be a very bad signal to their customer and maybe will alert government bodies like the EU's Directorate-General for Competition and others. So is it possible amazon to try this? sure but I will say it's improbable.
DomreiRoam··on Show HN: Kooba, an interactive graph for finding new books
If you're ready to invest some time www.librarything.com allows you to catalog your books and then gives you recommendations.

Still I hope to see Kooba working to find other books to add to my reading list :)

DomreiRoam··on The Turing Tumble lets you and your kids build real mechanical computers
I m always looking out for games that teach something for my daughter. I m a huge fan of https://wewanttoknow.com/ that produce very nice math games. But I like this concept because it is not on a tablet but you can touch the piece and see the ball falling and all the moves of the physical object.

By the way, any suggestion for more fun and smart game?

DomreiRoam··on The Future of Go Summit – Ke Jie vs. AlphaGo
Thank you
DomreiRoam··on The Future of Go Summit – Ke Jie vs. AlphaGo
Do you think that they will propose match with handicap?

Do you know if it will change the value of the komi?

DomreiRoam··on Cannes Will Ban Streaming-Only Movies from Competition
To protect the movie theater from the TV competition. The wikipedia in French can be found here: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronologie_des_m%C3%A9dias
DomreiRoam··on The Etiquette of the Victorian Ballroom: Twenty Tips for Single Gentlemen
Why would you use a salad fork for dessert?
DomreiRoam··on Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident
Middleman have some utility but I think often they extract more money than the value they provide.
DomreiRoam··on Is the F-35 a Trillion-Dollar Mistake?
I think we need to compare the benefit the USA's population gets from this Trillion-Dollar spending with other possible program like free college tuition[1] who would around 70 billion/year.

I think democracies need a tool that help explore and explain what we gain from a law/program and what are the cost associated. But consequence and indirect cost is difficult to foresee: Obamacare (ACA) increased the number of people going freelance (author, artist, start-up ... ) because they were able to get insurance without a part-time job.

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/01/heres-e...

DomreiRoam··on Spanish scientists create a 3D bioprinter to print human skin
I m hoping that in some point in the future we will be able to print directly on the body to repair damage .

I suffer from Keratoconus and the only actual solution is corneal transplantation; I would be wonderful to be able to grow the cornea in situ. Bio-startup idea anyone?

DomreiRoam··on Warning: 2016 MacBook Pro is not compatible with Linux
I did buy one od these XPS developer edition. It comes with ubuntu.

If we want to signal to the market that we want laptop with linux we need to support this kind of initiative. The fact that linux just work without any changes is great.

DomreiRoam··on ThoughtWorks Technology Radar November 2016
I like the TTR because it allows me to check if it make sense to spend some time on some tool and make me discover new tools/approach that are already vetted.

I like also the "Call me maybe" serie by aphyr (aphyr.com) because I can check if it make sense to spend some time on a distributed system.

Do you have any other resource that could play the same role?

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →