HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Draiken

2,689 karma · joined April 16, 2012

submissionscomments
Draiken··on Two kinds of AI users are emerging
They don't care. This is clearly someone looking to score points and impress with the AI magic trick.

The best part is that they can say the AI will get some stuff wrong, they knew that, and it's not their fault when it breaks. Or more likely, it'll break in subtle ways, nobody will ever notice and the consequences won't be traced back to this. YOLO!

Draiken··on Two kinds of AI users are emerging
Take Claude Code itself. It's got access to an endless amount of tokens and many (hopefully smart) engineers working on it and they can't build a fucking TUI with it.

So, my answer would be no. Tech debt shows up even if every single change made the right decisions and this type of holistic view of projects is something AIs absolutely suck at. They can't keep all that context in their heads so they are forever stuck in the local maxima. That has been my experience at least. Maybe it'll get better... any day now!

Draiken··on GOG: Linux "the next major frontier" for gaming as it works on a native client
Come on... it's always the same reason: money.

Companies don't support Linux because it's not widespread enough so it can't outweigh the costs. They don't give a rat's ass for the market's resentfulness or lack thereof. The Linux market was basically not a real market before because their market share was simply too small.

There are plenty of products made for resentful markets and as long as they keep being profitable they don't care.

Draiken··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Most game studios pay someone else to make the anti-cheats and many already have Linux versions that the studios choose to not enable.

Besides, if your anti-cheat only ever looks at the system level, it'll easily be bypassed by hardware cheats. At some point I think anti-cheats will have to "know" the game to be able to detect anomalies. It's the only way to effectively stop many categories of cheats.

Draiken··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Of course running one system is better. Use Linux and stop being miserable ;)

Still, you haven't said what are these extremely horrible cons that two systems have. For me they're so small it's not even comparable to having to submit yourself to a shit Windows system only to avoid the "hassle" of having two systems.

I used Windows only for gaming and Linux for everything else. Now I'm fed up with games that choose to block Linux out, so I no longer need the two systems and couldn't be happier.

Draiken··on A few random notes from Claude coding quite a bit last few weeks
Looking forward for those 10x improvements to finally show up somewhere. Any day now!

Jokes aside, I never said it's not useful, but most definitely it's not even close to all this hype.

Draiken··on A few random notes from Claude coding quite a bit last few weeks
If it ever gets there, then anyone can use it and there's no "skill" to be learned at all.

Either it will continue to be this very flawed non-deterministic tool that requires a lot of effort to get useful code out of it, or it will be so good it'll just work.

That's why I'm not gonna heavily invest my time into it.

Draiken··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Which are?

I've had Windows in one disk and Linux in another for maybe a decade and use the boot selection to pick what I want. Never had a single issue.

Although I haven't opened Windows in months, so I'll likely nuke it soon and give more space for my Linux.

Draiken··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
> That's why some developers choose not to enable it

That's an excuse. It's mostly incompetence or more often than not the company doesn't think it's worth the effort. With more Linux users, the balance will eventually shift from "fuck them" to "we have to figure out a way".

Draiken··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
Still has an anti-cheat, they just bothered to allow Linux support.

Companies don't do this out of laziness/incompetence, but even some large anti-cheats work on Linux and some games simply choose to not enable it (cough, Tarkov, cough). Their problem, I'm no longer gonna play games that don't work on Linux.

Funnily enough the best FPS game ever (Counter-Strike) runs absolutely fine on Linux. Thanks Valve!

Draiken··on cURL removes bug bounties
> Is it not reproducable? Someone up thread reproduced it and expanded on it. It worked for me the first time I prompted. Did you try it or are you just guessing that it's not reproducable because that's what you already think?

I assumed you knew how LLMs work. They are random by nature, not "because I'm guessing it". There's a reason if you ask the LLM the same exact prompt hundreds of times you'll get hundreds of different answers.

>I looked for, found, and shared evidence

Anecdotal evidence. Studies have shown how unreliable LLMs are exactly because they are not deterministic. Again, it's a fact, not an opinion.

>I'm talking about filtering spammy communication channels

So if we make tons of mistakes there, who cares, right?

I only used this as an example because it's one of the few very public uses of LLMs to make judgement calls where people accepted it as true and faced consequences.

I'm sure there are plenty more people getting screwed over by similar mistakes, but folks generally aren't stupid enough to say that publicly. Maybe the Salesforce huge mistake qualifies too? Incidentally it also involved people's jobs.

Regardless, the point stands: they are unreliable.

Want to trust LLMs blindly for your weekend project? Great! The only potential victim for its mistakes is you. For anything serious like a huge open source project? That's irresponsible.

Draiken··on cURL removes bug bounties
Yet this is not reproducible. This is the whole issue with LLMs: they are random.

You cannot trust that it'll do a good job on all reports so you'll have to manually review the LLMs reports anyways or hope that real issues didn't get false-negatives or fake ones got false-positives.

This is what I've seen most LLM proponents do: they gloss over the issues and tell everyone it's all fine. Who cares about the details? They don't review the gigantic pile of slop code/answers/results they generate. They skim and say YOLO. Worked for my narrow set of anecdotal tests, so it must work for everything!

IIRC DOGE did something like this to analyze government jobs that were needed or not and then fired people based on that. Guess how good the result was?

This is a very similar scenario: make some judgement call based on a small set of data. It absolutely sucks at it. And I'm not even going to get into the issue of liability which is another can of worms.

Draiken··on To those who fired or didn't hire tech writers because of AI
> but it also increases the quality of the higher-tier

I truly don't see this happening anymore. Maybe it did before?

If there's real competition, maybe this does happen. We don't have it and it'll never last in capitalism since one or a few companies will always win at some point.

If you're a higher tier X, cheaper processes means you'll just enjoy bigger profit margins and eventually decide to start the enshittification phase since you're a monopoly/oligopoly, so why not?

As for FOSS, well, we'll have more crappy AI generated apps that are full of vulnerabilities and will become unmaintainable. We already have hordes of garbage "contributions" to FOSS generated by these AI systems worsening the lives of maintainers.

Is that really higher quality? I reckon it's only higher quantity with more potential to lower quality of even higher-tier software.

Draiken··on No management needed: anti-patterns in early-stage engineering teams
I agree with the parent because what you're describing doesn't indirectly motivate people, it merely avoids demotivation. If the person doesn't feel motivated by themselves (e.g. someone burned out or who does not care) they won't suddenly be motivated because the environment is good. It's still an internal force.
Draiken··on CLI agents make self-hosting on a home server easier and fun
LLMs give you that dopamine hit without the effort.

I did it! Except you didn't and you don't know anything about what it did or learned anything along the way. Success?

Draiken··on CLI agents make self-hosting on a home server easier and fun
I use Ansible.

It's simple enough and I had some prior experience with it, so I merely have some variables, roles that render a docker-compose.yml.j2 template and boom. It all works, I have easy access to secrets, shared variables among stacks and run it with a simple `ansible-playbook` call.

If I forget/don't know the Ansible modules, Claude or their docs are really easy to use.

Every time I went down a bash script route I felt like I was re-inventing something like Ansible.

Draiken··on CLI agents make self-hosting on a home server easier and fun
This summarizes what LLMs are best at: hobby projects that you care mostly about the outcome and won't have to actively maintain forever.

When using them with production code they are a liability more than a resource.

Draiken··on CLI agents make self-hosting on a home server easier and fun
Write scripts for everything.

If you need to run the command once, you can now run it again in the future.

It's very tempting to just paste some commands (or ask AI to do it) but writing simple scripts like this is an amazing solution to these kinds of problems.

Even if the scripts get outdated and no longer work (maybe it's a new version of X) it'll give you a snapshot of what was done before.

Draiken··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
> ASML's secret sauce is not that secret or uncopyable.

You must've watched a different video. They took a decade to get there and they're happy to show all the how-to's because they know the devil is in the details.

Draiken··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
Which is better because?

We can't copy/paste a new ASML no matter how hard you try (aside from open sourcing all of their IPs). Even if you do, by the time you copy one generation of machine, they're on a new generation and you now still have the bottleneck on the same place.

Not to mention that with these monopolies they can just keep increasing prices ad infinitum.

Draiken··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
And you learned nothing and have no clue if what it spit out is good or not.

How can you even assume what it did is "better" if you have no knowledge of kubernetes in the first place? It's mere hope.

Sure it gets you somewhere but you learned nothing in the way and now depend on the LLM to maintain it forever given you don't want to learn the skill.

I use LLMs to help verify my work and it can sometimes spot something I missed (more often it doesn't but it's at least something). I also automate some boring stuff like creating more variations of some tests, but even then I almost always have to read its output line by line to make sure the tests aren't completely bogus. Thinking about it now it's likely better if I just ask for what scenarios could be missing, because when they write it, they screw it up in subtle ways.

It does save me some time in certain tasks like writing some Ansible, but I have to know/understand Ansible to be confident in any of it.

These "speedups" are mostly short term gains in sacrifice for long term gains. Maybe you don't care about the long term and that's fine. But if you do, you'll regret it sooner or later.

My theory is that AI is so popular because mediocrity is good enough to make money. You see the kind of crap that's built these days (even before LLMs) and it's mostly shit anyways, so whether it's shit built by people or machines, who cares, right?

Unfortunately I do, and I rather we improve the world we live in instead of making it worse for a quick buck.

IDK how or why learning and growing became so unpopular.

Draiken··on Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscriptions
Funnily enough, I didn't know about opencode and will now test it out and likely use it instead.

Improve your client so people prefer it? Nah.

Try to force people to use your client by subsidizing it? Now that's what I'm talking about.

As others said, why not just run a bunch of agents on Claude Code to surpass Opencode? I'm sure that's easy with their unlimited tokens!

Draiken··on Anthropic blocks third-party use of Claude Code subscriptions
> CC isn't just the TUI tool. It's also the LLM behind it.

No, Claude Code is literally the TUI tool. The LLMs behind are the models. You can use different models within the same TUI tool, even CC allows that, regardless of the restriction of only using their models (because they chose to do that).

> consider that OC can focus 100% of their efforts on their coding tool.

And they have billions of dollars to hire full teams of developers to focus on it. Yet they don't.

They want to give Claude Code an advantage because they don't want to invest as much in it and still "win", while they're in a position to do so. This is very similar to Apple forcing developers to use their apps because they can, not because it's better. With the caveat that Anthropic doesn't have a consolidated monopoly like Apple.

Can they do that? Yes.

Should they do that? It's a matter of opinion. I think it's a bad move.

Is it embarrassing? Yes. It shows they're admitting their solution is worse and changing the rules of the game to tilt it in their favor while offering an inferior product. They essentially don't want to compete, they want to force people to use their solution due to pricing, not the quality of their product.

Draiken··on Sergey Brin's Unretirement
Putting all your eggs in one basket is one big reason.

As a developer if, let's say, AI does make my profession no longer a viable option monetarily, what would happen if my entire identity is tied to it?

You cannot fully control your career no matter what. Many external factors can affect it and you deeply if that's your identity.

What if you can't even teach after retiring because nobody else cares about it?

For me it's about risk/reward and unfortunately in our current system the fact that all my efforts reward someone else disproportionately more completely taints it.

Draiken··on Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android
I guess we can't win, can we? I worried more about random developers getting compromised since the surface area is much larger, but at the same time one entity compiling all packages makes them a more attractive target.

We've seen the released bundles being different to the source code before too AFAIR, so whether it's a single repository or F-Droid, both can easily screw users up if compromised.

I don't want to be paranoid but the world's not making it easy.

Draiken··on Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android
TIL!

IDK if I would consider not blindly trusting an unknown third party to read all my notifications being paranoid, but if it is, then yeah, I guess I am.

I've used F-droid merely due to the open source guarantee, so how fast these apps are patched isn't a deal-breaker for me, but I'll definitely look into Obtanium now.

Thank you!

Draiken··on Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android
TIL! What a find. Thanks mate!

I might actually try this now.

Draiken··on Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android
I would love to use this, but I don't want to allow a third party app with closed source to read all my notifications. This can read OTP passwords, full messages, etc. so it must be open source for me to consider it.

I would donate/pay for this if it was open source on F-Droid.

Kudos to you for building it. I put off building this exact same application so many times it's not even funny. Too bad I'm too lazy to maintain something like this.

Draiken··on Nvidia's $20B antitrust loophole
You mean like Google/Apple/Meta already are?

I don't see how we're not already there. There's no competition, only an oligopoly splitting their spoils.

Draiken··on I'm a Tech Lead, and nobody listens to me. What should I do?
I think Occam's razor explains this: the majority of people are incompetent.

People get to positions of power through many means and very few of those are related to competence. Be it nepotism, boot licking, friendship, inheritance, people failing upwards or just plain luck, these all lead to the same result: incompetent people making decisions.

Add to that the fact that it's very easy to hide incompetency in large organizations and we have the perfect recipe for these kinds of disasters.

Even on small organizations this is common. I've seen plenty of incompetent people getting funding for startups making all the wrong decisions. They're good at selling some BS to investors and that's about it, but now they're at the helm of an organization with people under them. Another good example is people opening businesses from their successes in other areas (I made money here, now let me open a restaurant with zero experience in this industry) or even out of their parent's pockets.

Incompetence is almost always the culprit.

← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →