It prevents mind reading.
290 karma · joined March 26, 2013
It prevents mind reading.
I'm not going to say that these companies are fantastic. I'm just not, but I will say that perhaps this isn't really their fault.
Let's say that BIND has a critical vulnerability that allows people to snoop on the requests made. Does that make the ISC guilty of giving the NSA access to every BIND DNS server on the internet?
No, it doesn't.
But on the topic of modular malware, what would the initial discovery of Flame look like, if it were still in-progress after 3 years? Would it or would it not seem like this? It's got odd transmission methods, and the possibility of more to come. But if deleting data, self protection, and propogation aren't the attacks, then what are?
but ALL of that? In the BIOS?
(I'd like to point out I am nowhere near the caliber of the man who's supposedly experiencing all of this. I do not know the true size of any of the aforementioned payload.)
that can communicate via Sound (Requires DSP)...
that can defend itself against the registry editor (Deep integration to the OS, for at least windows, linux/OSX noted as well)...
that can alter data...
that can infect network cards (implied in the article)...
that can possibly use the power system to communicate (Ok, on a laptop, that might be possible. Otherwise, PSUs aren't completely isolated from the computing system's logic?)...
that all still fits within a BIOS chip? Either BIOSs are complex (read space-intensive) enough to stop being Basic, or they can fit this AND a functioning BIOS in to a payload that would be delivered by sound, USB, network cards...
Can it modulate the fans to transmit data too? Or change the screen brightness faster than the human eye can see, but can be detected with cameras? How about using the Wifi, HDD activity, sound mute, caps lock, numlock, scroll lock and power indicators to transmit?
How about opening and closing the HDD to transmit data?
I can't agree more with MacsHeadroom's assertion that this is a situation where the simplest explanation wins.
Not to mention I REALLY don't want this kind of thing to exist...
EDIT: Added fans paragraph
And how long until some virus engages the hardware locks on the modules and forces you to pay a fine to upgrade your phone ("Vendor" lock in).
Or, on the contrary, when Ara modules start sliding out of their positions, crashing the phone, corrupting pictures, etc.; causing Motorola (or whoever) to build in locks.
Or software that doesn't rely on hardware, but refuses to run when you don't have modules x, y, and z; or refuses to run when you DO have modules a, b, and c.
I just hope the Linux drivers are open source, if they're not piggybacking off bluetooth or something.
Oh, and I did the graphics. Comments, complaints, pointers, etc. would be much appreciated.
But hey, what do I know?
If they can't get the data in transit, they'll go for the sources and destinations. Legally mandated keyloggers, anyone? An 'adversary' as markedly omnipresent as the NSA has had no problems [1][2][3] with intruding upon infrastructure, and I doubt your pesky little Win8 tablet or your pretty little Linux box would be able to withstand even a fraction of what the NSA could set up as a push-button intrusion system.
A click of a button, and you're compromised.
If you mess with the bull, you'll get the horns.
[1] http://rt.com/news/snowden-nsa-china-hack-120/ [2] http://venturebeat.com/2013/06/12/nsa-global-surveillance/ [3] http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/snowden-says-nsa-ha...
I'm new to the public school system this year. I live in an area that has no shortage of gun ownership and advocacy, and, the weekend after Sandy Hook, I went to the guidance office to express worry that perhaps some connections would be made that aren't really there. (Not about me individually, but about some poor soul that would slip up and get caught in something)
I was called back to the guidance office later that day, only to be told that I was effectively suspended until I could be, and I quote, "Mentally evaluated". It was handled as a "School Crisis", and I was a "Threat to the school".
Lucky for me, my parents acted quickly enough so that the school system's psychologist could be contacted.
It turned out to be nothing.
(This is the third of four encounters like this. I'm fairly certain I have the high score for most school crises caused in a single year.)
What a dangerous and shady person I am.
I don't want some Google balloon watching me every step of my day.
Even less so if what it's seeing is published near-instantly
The Government/NSA is now a terrorist group? Are they fighting themselves? Why not just use the secret surveillance system called PRISM to discover that the enemy has a secret surveillance system called PRISM?
More detail of the theoretical system: http://personofinterest.wikia.com/wiki/The_Machine
The situation is even worse when one wants to work with computers. Minors plus computers OBVIOUSLY equals someone staying online every hour of their life, playing video games where you violently kill kittens. </sarcasm>
I wonder at what phase 'Don't be evil' would break down, or alternatively, when their definition of 'evil' would be changed to exclude what they were doing.
The concept is a goldmine. You need to convince potential users of its security an privacy protection, should there be any. If there isn't any, your product is a ticking time bomb.
I'm disappointed to see people skewing the results. I was hoping to see the lower brackets. So much for that.