HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EdHominem

452 karma · joined February 19, 2016

Not a lawyer or a wingsuit pilot.
submissionscomments
EdHominem··on Bitcoin slides as China's central bank launches checks on exchanges
Bitcoin is also traded off-network so the market would remain liquid and you'd be paying miners an extra $300,000 per block so they could easily afford the transaction fees to settle large amounts.

You'd just make Bitcoin a reserve currency.

EdHominem··on California man fights DUI charge for driving under influence of caffeine
> You can be impaired while on legal substances that don't show up on drug tests.

Right, but they aren't just a lack of evidence for coked-up-driving, they're actually evidence FOR clean driving.

> They're also prosecuting him for reckless driving.

Well, they're using the reckless driving charge as a license to fish, falling back to it only when they've exhausted other avenues.

> "Without a confirmatory test of the specific drug in the defendant’s system that impaired his ability to drive, we do not believe we can prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt,”

The DA is taking for granted that he was on something and is blaming the tests for failing to show that, not using that as evidence that she might be mistaken.

They go on to say "not believe we can prove the charge beyond" when they should be saying "believe there is no evidence whatsoever for this charge."

The tone of the article is that this man is guilty and the system is simply unable to prove it.

EdHominem··on California man fights DUI charge for driving under influence of caffeine
Nor any evidence whatsoever that there was intoxication.

The DA should be saying "There's no evidence of that", not "There isn't enough to prosecute". She's lying by implying that there's a body of evidence that is just not quite sufficient to convict, as opposed to the FACT that all evidence points to not-guilty. Not insufficient, but directly contradicting the charges.

EdHominem··on California man fights DUI charge for driving under influence of caffeine
"Violated policy". Wowza. Pointing a gun at someone during false-arrest for something that isn't even a crime, is a mere policy violation.

Then the court seals the records to hide this, and the main policy change is that a uniformed cop must be present during this (these were undercover cops who'd pulled the guns) instead of - you know - not arresting someone at gunpoint for the pointless crime of buying bootleg liquor even if it was actually liquor.

EdHominem··on California man fights DUI charge for driving under influence of caffeine
> No, far from it. It is the issue, the reason the courts need to be "streamlined" is because they have been over burdened by these non-crimes

Very true. If we had to actually have a trial it would interfere with the profitability of the criminalization cycle.

> shortcut due process and extort people into signing their legal rights away

Yeah, the prosecutors aren't in it to increase society's safety, or even to enforce laws, they're in it for their conviction stats. They'll do anything to game those numbers higher and it's easier to win convictions for strict liability crimes (possession, etc) so they focus on that.

EdHominem··on Bitcoin slides as China's central bank launches checks on exchanges
And yet the market dynamics of that wouldn't be all that bad.

They'd never get 100% of the blocks, so all they'd be doing is slowing down the flow of transactions and increasing the fees (because people would be paying for fewer spots in the non-DoS blocks, which would incentivize other miners.

Bitcoin scales fees, instead of scaling transactions/second, so for a while it wouldn't be economical to use it for small purchases where the fees would be almost as much as the price, but for larger purposes, and as a store of value, it'd work just as well.

EdHominem··on [dead]
Well, I'm not a lawyer so maybe I said it wrong but if you keep coded notes, etc, I've heard it makes it much easier to prove intent.
EdHominem··on [dead]
They've always said that their goal is to get the maximum coverage for the leaks. That's not unfair, or biased, and it's exactly why leakers pick them rather than just releasing the information themselves.

Can you show that they do different things based on the content of the leaks, or the identity of the leaker? Not that having a bias is a crime, even if you could prove it.

> You think trump is going to be any different?

The goalposts were fine where they were, thanks.

> He's Swedish

No, he's not.

> and leaking information gained from a politically adversarial country.

I know for a fact that you don't have any evidence for that statement.

> Neither of which get a vote in our election.

And yet he's entitled to an opinion, and to share any information he has with others, to influence their opinion.

EdHominem··on Call Centers May Know a Surprising Amount About You
Right. The goal isn't to find a real manager, the goal is to bypass the "I'm not a manager" excuse.
EdHominem··on [dead]
> use a bitcoin tumbler for obfuscation.

Not a worthwhile amount of obfuscation (almost none), and it provides evidence of nefarious intent.

EdHominem··on Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Government Pressure
> Sex workers didn't suddenly become less vulnerable simply because they're posting Craigslist ads.

Actually, they did. With a red-light district you have to be there, exposed to the pimps, to be exposed to the customers. And the density allows pimps to control more people, enough to make the activity profitable.

With out-call services from ads you avoid the presence of the pimps in the first place, and the configuration (outcalls) makes capturing a sex-worker much harder if they try which makes the economics much less attractive. Pimping is a crime of opportunity and outcalls remove most of that.

Also, not being street-people, call-girls get much more respect from police if they need to report a crime.

EdHominem··on [dead]
> the release of the documents was politically timed to be as impactful as possible with hyped and staggered releases.

Umm, yeah. Why bother leaking documents straight into the trash?

> It's one thing to release the documents in a fair, unbiased method.

Wikileaks can only leak whatever is given to them. Did you send them Trump email that they refused to leak?

> He and wikileaks took sides and that is not something I consider ok.

The point of a vote is literally for everyone to take sides.

> He had/has a vendetta.

I'd have a vendetta against a politician (in a position of military command) who asked if I could be killed extra-judicially. How can you fault someone for this?

EdHominem··on Poet: I can’t answer questions on Texas standardized tests about my own poems
> The essay's point is that the reader's judgement is just as valid as

But it's not. The question isn't "what does this mean to YOU", but "what did this mean to the author".

If I pick words randomly I can say with authority that there is no meaning in the words, and for all your understandings you can't change that the words were picked blindly, and thus without meaning.

> The author is not the final and not the only interpretation that's valid.

As to the author's intent, yes it is. Whatever intent there was is set down with the ink on paper. You come later, as a reader, so your interpretation is at most an addendum and not part of the original.

> [...] can be interpreted by the reader as having meaning even though Noam Chomsky says it's a meaningless sentence.

Sure. But an interpretation isn't a change in the nature of the actual thing. Even if I interpret an elephant as a butterfly it won't fly away.

This entire literary "discipline" (cough) is based on refusing to use an accurate description of the practice. Everyone agrees that a text can invoke various things - even unintended things - in various readers. That doesn't mean you're finding something inherent in the text but in the reader.

EdHominem··on The Distorted News Epidemic and Bridgewater's Recent Experience With The WSJ
That he said things to the press about the Apple/iPhone incident that he had to know to be untrue at the time didn't indicate his lack of principle?

He said the agency was pursuing terrorists and he thought the locked iphone was important, but he specifically didn't actually take it to anyone who could help, indicating that he was 1) lying or 2) willing to let more attacks happen to make a point.

EdHominem··on The Distorted News Epidemic and Bridgewater's Recent Experience With The WSJ
He decided to try to blackmail Apple by taking the matter to the news when they didn't comply with his illegal orders. It's like the police coming by your work to arrest you for questioning as intimidation.

To make the undue public attention worse, they (he specifically, as well) lied to the press about the facts of iphone issue, saying things he couldn't know as fact (the difficulty for Apple to crack the device) and inventing other details.

Also, I know he had offers from security firms to crack the phone from day 2. He sat on what he claimed to have thought could have been important evidence in an attempt to force Apple's hand. He could have ruined the investigation and let terrorists escape because he thought it was a good time to showboat.

Also, under his watch the FBI has pursued numerous stings against mentally handicapped Americans in America. Trying to create terrorists by inundating them with hateful propaganda, providing functional arms and ammunition, etc, and encouraging them to commit horrific crimes in an attempt to make the FBI look competent when they catch their creation.

We've rarely had someone either so incapable of doing their job, or so efficient at destroying everything the agency has stood for. In the end what's left will resemble the political wing of the KGB.

EdHominem··on The Distorted News Epidemic and Bridgewater's Recent Experience With The WSJ
Actually, it seems to be incredibly broad and could cover anything deemed to help the "enemy". Considering we don't declare war anymore this is either absolutely unenforceable, or is totally open-ended as to what an enemy is. (Is ISIS an enemy? The Free-Syrian Army? The Kurds?)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Three_of_the_United_St...

"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."

EdHominem··on The Distorted News Epidemic and Bridgewater's Recent Experience With The WSJ
How do most people choose which articles they're exposed to?

Usually by going to Facebook or Google News where an algorithm shows them the thing most-likely to make them click on an ad.

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
Which should be paid for by the hotels and reflected in the room rates, not hidden in tax.

I'm also sure it doesn't cost $45 per room night to inspect a hotel room in SF, so the tax is out of proportion. Which is expected because the people it impacts don't have representation to change it.

And to the degree they can avoid it, it is only by the broad brush of avoiding the city entirely which has negative effects on merchants in business which don't unload their costs onto others.

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
> I think national hotel chains are capable of advocating their interest,

It's not hotels the tax hurts, so I don't think they would have advocated very hard. In fact, to the degree that tax pays for anything related (inspections, etc) they would support it as it would externalize their costs.

> I don't think I have ever seen an example of someone imposing a tax "just because they can".

Of course not, but because it reflects positively on them and yet doesn't impact the pocketbooks of their constituents. Which amounts to "because they can."

> If your state or local community doesn't limit taxing authority

Copyright is limited - to any finite duration. So yeah, there are limits. Our goal as a society shouldn't be to tax everything to the limit though, but to cover externalities to avoid burdening others.

In this case the people presumably using the resources (the tourists) are being taxed, but only indirectly on their hotel stay. This unfairly doubly-impacts a local who needs a room and it ignores the usage costs of those tourists who don't stay in a hotel, or rather saddles the hotel using tourist with the RV-tourist's share.

The fact that the tax badly fits the supposed problem is an indication that it's just a cash grab with any justification tacked on.

> then be part of the change you want and pursue a limit.

The "you're in a democracy so it's all your fault" answer. Fwiw, the first step of change is identifying and discussing the issue.

I'm not saying the answer isn't to change broken governments, but first you need to realize that the system exists to produce this state. We didn't end up here by accident and to fix it will require a reasonable alignment of incentives.

EdHominem··on Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews
> I am not quite sure what you mean with your comment, as "relying on a DB to do the work for them"

Maybe "to do the thinking for them" would be more accurate.

> sound like a good thing to me.

You did what they do - you assumed based on some your usual workloads that a DB and the overhead of using another language, and a non-compile-time checked language, with poor integration (type mismatch), is the solution for the problem I'm working on.

What I expect them to do is ask questions. How many values are there? Are they complex types or something that would map to tables well? What are the querying requirements? Are there any relational elements to the data?

> Its usually way faster than doing stuff in the application code

If shoving things across two sets of pipes, to a general-purpose app not tuned to your workload, is faster - you're writing your main app incorrectly.

> the declarative nature of SQL usually means less bugs.

A declarative language usually means less bugs. But adding a second mismatched language usually means more. Especially when it comes with a whole new system that takes experts to properly tweak.

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
Oh, you're a "snarky dismal" guy?

And in America, we all are. Taxes taken without representation, for no good purpose, are theft.

Otherwise you'd be good with a 100% tax rate, right?

The way we ensure good laws, and reasonable taxes, is to call out all unreasonable cases.

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
That's probably just changes in the regs since the house was built, not that foster children (or tourists in the case of a hotel) are more fragile than others.

Good standards are good, double standards are not.

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
> Hotel taxes support infrastructure and city services.

So restaurants that don't charge the extra foreigner-tax are destroying the city infrastructure? Or are their regular taxes expected to cover it?

Why not with hotels? Why can't they simply be assessed the real cost of supporting their usage?

If there was a cost associated with hosting an out-of-town guest, why is it a percentage of the room rate? Of course, the answer is "because it can be." Takers gotta take.

> Hotel taxes [also support ...] things like proper safety and fire regulations in hotels ensure that guests know where fire exits are, that fire extinguishers are available and operational, that smoke detectors are present in the proper locations and functioning, etc.

No. The room rates support that. The hotel doesn't keep the taxes so none of the taxes go to helping make the hotel safer.

> AirBnB offers none of those things.

Neither do a newspaper's classified ads.

Whose laws should they support? The guests? The hosts? The country the servers are in?

Should the newspaper have a similar burden? If I sell a car should they have to inspect the car first to make sure I'm not trying to pass off a lemon?

EdHominem··on Up to a third of Airbnb's price gap with hotels is due to tax treatment
> Which hotel regulations do you think are overly onerous and ridiculous?

The many extra taxes and tariffs on guests. Occupancy taxes, tourism improvement fees, etc, that the city is only able to capture by abusing its control over the hotels.

It's easy to pass laws that don't affect people who live in your area because nobody is that motivated to stop you. Hotels and other legitimate businesses suffer because the city stole (took because it could, for no good purpose) money from the guests that they'd have otherwise spent on services they actually wanted.

The hotel should only be billed for services delivered. If the guests consume a lot of water the hotel needs to pay for it, etc. If that rate is below cost, it should be raised.

The extra tax is just a "because we can" and is one of the things an efficient economy will route around.

> they're definitely knowingly enabling their customers to do illegal things.

They're enabling a primarily legal operation - people renting things. It's not their job to police which units are legal to rent and which are not.

I could buy legal things at Costco and commit a crime with them and it's not Costco's duty to stop me.

EdHominem··on Lessons from 3,000 technical interviews
Interestingly, one of my 'no' signals is people relying on a DB to do the work for them. Don't know how to index this? Shove it in the DB and query it back.

If you don't have a relational query in mind a relational DB is a bad fit, or at least premature optimization.

EdHominem··on Uber Freight
By eyeballing an Emma Maersk diagram, I think you could get three more stacks of containers, for ~5% more capacity.
EdHominem··on Rogue One – An Engineering Ethics Story
> ___ is going to offer better advice than anything Freud wrote.

You could replace that with "A Bucket of Clams" and the sentence is still true.

EdHominem··on 'All I wanted to do is build a house' (2010)
Right, that's not self-driving at all, but they claim that it is. Shifty.

The problem is that they've put drivers in the car as backup; they're not supposed to drive or it ruins the experiment. So they won't be ready to take over when needed. One already missed their cue and the car ran a red light...

EdHominem··on 'All I wanted to do is build a house' (2010)
... disclosed as self-driving car accidents.

They're pursuing self-driving tech in a shifty way - paying a driver to perform backup (in a way that Google has shown can't be done) and otherwise letting an unfinished AI have full-control of the vehicle at road speeds. When the cars make a mistake (run a red) they blame the driver so they can claim a flawless self-driving record.

If they said they were self-driving, and got the permit, they'd be required to log activations so we'd know who was supposed to be in control at the time.

EdHominem··on Famed poker pro with ‘remarkable’ $9.6M scheme has to pay it back
> However, Im very interested to hear how you propose to make an economy work without limited liability.

Fwiw, I'd be interested to hear how you think the current system could work if we didn't come along and bail the economy out every few years by backing these bad business debts with public money.

> corporations in general

The sole defining characteristic of a corporation is limited liability. Everything else a corporation is, is inherent it being a group of people.

Further, all benefits we enacted corporate law to provide are now handled much more directly by bankruptcy statutes and welfare. You don't have to risk everything to engage in a business anymore.

> simultaneously missing the actual social structures causing the problems you list and the benefits of corporations.

So many benefits you couldn't list them all in the space provided? You favor a system where I pay for the crimes your business commits so the burden of proof is yours.

← PreviousPage 6 of 26Next →