HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EdgarVerona

695 karma · joined February 9, 2012

submissionscomments
EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
The problem is also with the industry itself, particularly if it's perishable. If this continues much longer, there's going to be a point (and perhaps it's already there? We don't get numbers about capacity - though I'd love to see it if there are numbers available!) where these companies reach peak capacity, and would have to incur significant investments in order to scale: investments that would become a detriment once the market comes back to normal, particularly if everyone has a glut of stored supply by the time this has ended.
EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
To bgorman: (apparently I can't reply directly to you, there's some nesting limit in Hacker News [EDIT: apparently not? I see a "reply" button now where it didn't exist before? odd])

>I would much rather be able to buy one package of toilet paper for 50 dollars versus being able to buy zero for 5 dollars.

Yeah, because you have 50 dollars to spend on that. What's a person supposed to do who is only barely making ends meet? Do they forsake eating so they can wipe themselves? Underpay their rent? Go into debt so they can wipe their ass?

My point here is that this isn't an either/or situation. There's other alternatives, though some people won't like it.

Rationing - at least by stores if not by the government - is one that we don't like these days, but that has worked for us in historical times of trouble.

This law is meant to be another alternative. It's certainly not perfect - I'd have taken rationing initiated by stores over that - but it is an alternative to the "pay 50 for a roll or not have a roll at all" options.

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
I was about to respond to you with the same response I made below - but it turns out we're basically having the same conversation twice. I'll refer to our other conversation below instead of repeating myself.
EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
This is how I feel, precisely. There are real, human consequences to these price increasing theories. It will be felt by people who are, by a large margin, not the target audience of Hacker News. It'll be felt by people who have to choose between having basic healthcare supplies and paying rent, or eating.

Indeed, at that point I think rationing - either by the companies selling the product, or by the government (as we have done in times of crisis in the past) is in order. Would people be yelling about free markets like this if World War 2 happened today, and there was the kind of rationing we saw in those times? What would have happened to our country if people were so selfish back then?

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
Unfortunately we don't have the data, only the evidence of whether their capacity is meeting demand. Right now it's not - but we will see in a week or two. If it continues to not do so, it seems rational to believe that they have reached the level of capacity where it would become more prohibitively expensive to increase supply. And at that point, the industry is going to have to face either severe short term shortages or potential long term financial trouble for short term gain.

I hope it doesn't reach that.

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
I definitely agree with that. I'm totally in support of the idea of limiting quantities, and I do think that would be a rational solution in the face of these current extenuating circumstances.
EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
> only the producers who could scale without "too much" cost would scale. > the rise in price incentivises the market to produce more of the product / incentivises more producers to enter the market

It sounds like this is built under an assumption that there is extra capacity available without significant or permanent costs. I don't know the level of capacity at which they are currently producing, but rationally speaking the mere fact that the shelves are empty due to demand would mean that intelligent companies would already have ramped up that capacity in response. So if the shelves remain empty, is that a sign that we've reached the level of demand where the cost of additional supply becomes more expensive/ongoing?

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
> To a very good approximation, the marginal impact of any hoarders on the scarcity of a product is zero. Hoarders are not trying to drive scarcity themselves, they are trying to buy a product now because they think the price will rise, but they're not trying to make the price rise by buying it. The distinction is important!

Are you sure? https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-pu...

"Mr. Colvin said he had posted 300 bottles of hand sanitizer and immediately sold them all for between $8 and $70 each, multiples higher than what he had bought them for. To him, “it was crazy money.” To many others, it was profiteering from a pandemic."

> This completely ignores the fact that the cost to produce a product is not a fixed amount, but rather that higher prices induce producers to make more product sooner.

How will they make more product sooner? By expanding their businesses - making new factories, procuring new manufacturing machinery, hiring new workers? What happens when demand reduces, and they're back to not only having a normal amount of demand, but having that further reduced by the glut of supply - supply of a nonperishable good in particular?

We have certainly fallen back on rationing during times of emergency in our society - even here in America. If it comes to that, I know many people will find it distasteful, but your point of:

> The higher price means that those who demonstrate a higher desire for an item (by their willingness to pay) end up getting it.

Is unfortunately the truth (though it's interesting that you chose to phrase "ability to pay" as "willingness to pay" - that discounts the fact that many people have a high desire for these items, but could be forced to choose between them and other items needed for basic survival), and left unchecked it will result in a pretty quick reversal of the "rising tide lifts all boats" argument for Capitalism if this situation continues long enough. It'll be pretty hard to argue that the free markets help all Americans when only people who can afford to do so can wipe their ass, or have access to basic health necessities.

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
> They only would have made the decision to scale production if they estimated the profit from filling this short-term demand would make up for the cost of having to eventually scale back the temporary investment. It's not exactly hard to predict that the demand won't last forever.

So what you're saying is, they wouldn't have scaled production, so your entire proposition about why the price increase would be an effective means to alleviate the problem was false.

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
But if we created it at the dramatically and artificially increased demand that it has right now, it would be disastrous for that industry once this panic subsides. Imagine the increase in infrastructure these companies would have to build to keep up with this fake supply. The workers, the real estate, the building of supply chains and machinery. Now imagine what happens to that industry when suddenly the market's demand tanks back to a reasonable level, and there's suddenly not only far more capacity for production that is now unprofitable, there's a huge backlog of supply already in the hands of consumers.

This situation is just as bad for the manufacturer as it is for the consumer.

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
Really? Regardless of the consequences? What becomes of that toilet paper when this fear has subsided? What becomes of the companies that had to scale production, create new factories, hire new workers etc... when the existing glut of supply is not only so much that those new facilities are hurting them, but also that it has decreased the demand for their product even with normal production capabilities?
EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
You neglected to mention that when people see fake headlines about toilet paper scarcity, there's a nontrivial percentage of people who see that as an opportunity for said arbitrage.

There's two kinds of hoarding happening here: fear-alleviating and profit-seeking, which allows the profit seeking form of acquisition to be possible. Several weeks ago, it wouldn't have been feasible for someone to scoop up the entire market. Profit-seeking acquisition is however both a self fulfilling prophecy for the fake headlines about insufficient production, and a means by which the people seeking these products to alleviate fear have their fears justified.

So is your solution "good on them, they're taking advantage of people's fears to help make the rumors true?" Just what price do you think toilet paper should be right now in stores?

EdgarVerona··on $5000 per violation of price-gouging in CA
A lot of people in this thread are willfully ignoring some basic facts here. These products are being made in sufficient quantity for everyone. There is not a significant decrease in production. There is a significant increase in hoarding, and in many cases it is for the explicit purpose of creating artificial scarcity to increase the price of a product.

This is not a case of toilet paper suddenly costing more to produce. The price gouging law is not bringing toilet paper to levels where the producer of the product is taking some kind of operating loss or even reduction in profit of any kind. This is a case of consumers attempting to create small niches of artificial scarcity so that they can profit.

The free market arguments being made here are baffling, and willfully ignoring the aforementioned truths of this specific set of circumstances that have driven these specific laws. Have we lost all sense of humanity for the sake of our ideology?

We would be doing our entire society a severe disservice if our solution to this problem is simply "create so much toilet paper that people can't hoard it." The fuck are we going to do with that much toilet paper.

EdgarVerona··on Ask HN: Do you ever truly use your revision history?
Just a few weeks ago, I had to dig back to try and root cause a very old bug. It ended up being in code from back in early 2012, but the root problem was drift in functionality that it didn't keep up with and eventually broke in an unexpected way. I would never have known the context around why that code existed in the form that it did without being able to go back through the history.

Granted, the context didn't really change what the fix needed to be, but it did provide a useful moment of reflection on the ways in which software can break through subtle changes over time that stack up, and it helped to know that the section of code that broke was indeed originally intended to work the way it did (and not that it was a bug from the very beginning).

EdgarVerona··on Pegasus Mail, 30 Years On
Until I switched to google for my email, Pegasus Mail was my go-to client. Amazing to see it still kicking after all these years, and still updating! Kudos to him for keeping up with it!
EdgarVerona··on An Antique Toaster That's Better Than Today’s [video]
That is pretty brilliant.
EdgarVerona··on The myth of the teacher pay gap?
What does common core have to do with how they get compensated?
EdgarVerona··on The myth of the teacher pay gap?
I agree about fast food work being draining. Even on the hardest day, I've never left my software engineering job at the end of the day feeling half as exhausted as I did at my high school fast food jobs. From standing for 8 hours a day to the incessant churn of customers to the insults, condescension, and unreasonable demands that some of those customers would make, it is a demoralizing position.

If salary was determined based on the emotional and physical toll a job takes, I feel like a fast food worker would make more than I do as a software engineer.

EdgarVerona··on Ask HN: Who Wants to Be Fired?
I was sort of in a similar situation when I was your age - in over my head at a complex project where the owner had never heard of version control (though in my case, I was too green to realize that it even existed). They had 30 copies of the same software, one in a folder on a shared hard drive for each customer. If there was a bug and it wasn't specific to a customer, you had to go fix it in 30 different places.

I promise you, if they don't want to provide version control they aren't going to provide you with other benefits and necessities that you deserve.

Related questions to benefits and necessities:

* Are you getting healthcare? * How is your pay compared to other Jr. software engineers in your area? * Are they paying you hourly? If so, are they actually paying you for hours worked, or are they finding ways to reduce that number of hours? * What if you demanded that they used version control, and brought your best arguments: what would they say?

Consider the answers to those questions, and if you don't like the answers, I strongly urge you to leave. There's a complacency that can come with "settling" for a place that is a "known constant." Don't settle here, when you deserve more.

Put what you've done on a resume, and give it to a headhunter. They will find you a better job - maybe not an ideal job, but a step up. And your career will truly begin.

EdgarVerona··on Plane Tests Must Use Average Pilots, NTSB Says After 737 Max Crashes
I agree. Though I would also feel pretty disheartened if I got a call from them after that decision was made -

"Hey, we need someone of your skill level to come in and fly some test planes"

"...okay"

EdgarVerona··on New publisher Modern Wolf declare commitment to “ethical game development”
If an entity can choose to discard ethics because it negatively impacts their bottom line, then they probably had no ethics to begin with.
EdgarVerona··on 'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada credit card customers
It's sad because it's true.
EdgarVerona··on Pirate our games, don't buy them from key resellers, say indies
Agreed. This is a case of an untrustworthy "authority." It is in G2A's extreme best interest to pretend there's not a problem, I wouldn't trust any numbers that they put out as if they are authoritative.

I should also note that I would trust numbers that indie developers are putting out. If things were working the way G2A claims, indie developers would be getting paid in the initial transaction and they wouldn't have a problem with key resellers to begin with. No incentive for them to lie in this situation.

(not that anyone is implying that they shouldn't trust indie devs: but in case anyone is wondering where a more credible source for information is, I feel like that's a good place to look given the lack of incentive for them to be lying about this)

EdgarVerona··on Pirate our games, don't buy them from key resellers, say indies
Chargebacks. So the idea is that the unethical agent buys the keys (either themselves or with a stolen card), sells them to a key reseller, and then initiates a chargeback to get their money back (either for themselves, or the person who had their card stolen does it to understandably get back the money stolen from them from the illegal purchase).

Suddenly, keys were "generated" for money that no longer exists. The key hopefully gets deactivated at this point, but then someone buys one of those keys and it doesn't work. Support calls and angry customers ensue.

EdgarVerona··on GDPR Enforcement Tracker: List of GDPR fines
I'm impressed at the creativity and disgusted that they thought this would be okay at the same time.
EdgarVerona··on The Rise and Fall of Visual Basic
Yes, ActiveX was the sauce that made VB quick and even fun to use! I tell people it was the Python of its day.
EdgarVerona··on The Rise and Fall of Visual Basic
Yet another interesting benefit of/interesting feature of VB is that it was the Python of its day in terms of the "there's a library to do that" factor. Not only was it easy to pick up, but (while not built-in like Python) it had access to thousands and thousands of easy to install and easy to use ActiveX libraries. There was almost always an ActiveX Library to suit your needs, ready to literally drop into the WYSIWYG editor and use.

That combined with the easy to use WYSIWYG editor and the edit and continue functionality were, to me, what made it such an amazingly useful language for creating quick utilities or small programs. It was truly a "Rapid Application Development" language.

I also saw some nightmares in my days, though I don't blame VB as much as the people who created the app. The most notable one was a document management system that I'd been asked to port from VB3 to VB6 (so that it could run on win32 among other reasons) and to turn the system from a batch system for document processing facilities into a desktop DMS for home use. I will never forget when I opened up the project and there were 60 some-odd "forms" in it, and when I opened any one of them up not a single one defined a variable. They all - every last one - was defined as a global variable in a single globals.bas file. There were thousands of global variables. Every single one in the entire application declared there, and edited at will in any of the myriad forms wherever they fancied. My first task became "untangle the global variable mess."

EdgarVerona··on Things I learnt the hard way in thirty years of software development
I agree with your perspective on this, as hard as it can be to admit.
EdgarVerona··on Things I learnt the hard way in thirty years of software development
This one's definitely a weakness I still have. I read that and thought "yeah, I do this in a lot of places and often end up regretting it."

I think named parameters don't actually help, because the underlying problem with the boolean (aside from the mystery about what it means when looking at code calling it) is that it implies a potential separate "mode" of operation for the function. That the single function might actually serve two different purposes. It doesn't always imply that I imagine, but it's pretty likely.

I'm guilty of this in my code, and I know that my code quality has suffered for it - for some reason, the way he put it in this article gave me a moment of introspection there, and it's something I'm going to try and take away from it and improve my own code with in the future.

EdgarVerona··on Things I learnt the hard way in thirty years of software development
Definitely true. And I think, in retrospect, that's not so bad. I think the important part is realizing - and convincing people to allocate time to it - when it needs to be refactored: when it reaches a point that it can't sustain itself and doesn't solve business problems anymore.

Until then, if it's solving a business need and you're not pouring tons of effort/money into it, it's more about pride than a real problem. That is a lesson I had to learn the hard way, and still struggle with: accepting that sometimes a janky, hobbled-together solution that solves a business problem still solves that problem and might not be worth the cost of "fixing."

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →