HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EdwardCoffin

1,760 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
EdwardCoffin··on Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?
For managing (storing) files I've concluded that it is impossible to find the ideal hierarchical structure for containing everything, so just go for reasonable structures that might have redundancy - for instance, accepting macos photos' way of organizing photos, adding in another directory for photos not managed by the photos app, plus photos that I include in my journal which is yet another set of directories.

For finding things, I've found it impossible to give sufficiently unique names to everything, and just go for names that are somewhat descriptive. If there is a way to annotate them with descriptions, I try to make the descriptions as complete as possible, am diligent with proper spelling and try to use canonical forms in my descriptions. I also try to settle on a standard set of words I use instead of their synonyms. This allows me to use standard searching mechanisms to find things without worrying about whether I am searching for the right word. I can with confidence to a system-wide search without worrying whether I'm searching using the right words: because I know which word from a set of synonyms to use, because I don't have to worry about finding misspelled variants, and because I know which order I will have put the words in

EdwardCoffin··on Game of Life, simulating itself, infinitely zoomable
A digression for anyone interested in Hashlife: I want to recommend Gosper's original paper [1] over the various other explanations of it. It is brief (6 pages), lucid, and was the paper that finally made me understand how hashlife works.

[1] https://www.lri.fr/~filliatr/m1/gol/gosper-84.pdf

EdwardCoffin··on Vernor Vinge has died
The page is not presenting right, I think. This HN comment from a few years ago [1] points to a script that purports to munge the files into modern HTML, but I have not tried it myself.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24876236

EdwardCoffin··on Vernor Vinge has died
The annotations are there in the RTF files, but there is something quirky about the format of those RTF files - perhaps they predate standardization or something. If you open one of the RTFs in a straight text editor like emacs or vi, you'll see them. There was a bit of discussion around this here, a few years ago, when this version was re-released [1]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24876236

EdwardCoffin··on Vernor Vinge has died
you have to open hugo.zip, or click on the view contents link beside it
EdwardCoffin··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
In Dune, the villain is arguably the emperor, and we only find out what will happen to him on the last page, the last page of a whirlwind chapter that concludes all sorts of things that were building up for the whole book. So I don't accept your assessment that Dune ends less abruptly than Snow Crash's.

I don't see how Shakespeare gets excused because he wrote stage plays, but Stephenson does not because he writes books. They're both fictions, with endings that could have been wrapped up with more ceremony.

No gotcha, I'm not even trying to persuade you of anything. I'm trying to point out that Stephenson's reputation on endings is largely undeserved, pretty much just a self-perpetuating myth, and that even if he does have a few abrupt endings he is not unique in this regard. I never hear anyone complain about Herbert's or Shakespeare's endings, which are demonstrably abrupt.

EdwardCoffin··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
I presume that you dislike Hamlet, Macbeth, Dune, and Children of Dune on the same grounds then? All of those end in similar ways.
EdwardCoffin··on The Emacsen family, the design of an Emacs and the importance of Lisp (2023)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39404903
EdwardCoffin··on The Emacsen family, the design of an Emacs and the importance of Lisp (2023)
I really wish that Deuce [1] [2] got more attention as a source for ideas for Emacs alternatives. It sounds incredibly cool.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20221002093520/https://groups.go...

[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20210407151341/https://discuss.a...

EdwardCoffin··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
Talking about Neal Stephenson's works always brings up several topics: endings and editing. He's responded to criticisms of his endings in various book talks, for instance his Author's at Google talk about Anathem [1] (prepositioned to the relevant bit @10:54). One of his editor's at Wired magazine also made a comment about editing his work in his book talk about Fall or Dodge in Hell at the Interval [2].

This is a transcript of a part of the Authors at Google talk for Anathem (first link prepositioned to 10:54): [10:54] Q: How do you think about ending your stories? They seem to run the gamut from some where the action just ends, and others where there's the equivalent of a movie ending with a ten-minute car chase in it. [11:11] A: Well, I'm reasonably happy with all of my endings, but I know that some people feel differently. [11:21] But as you've noticed, they're different, it's not always the same thing. All I can say is different books end in different ways, and different people have different tastes in what they want to see. I'm well aware that there are certain people frustrated with the endings of some of my books. But I also think that it's one of these things where people's preconceived ideas sometimes drive the way they perceive things. I've seen people complain, for example, that Snow Crash doesn't have a good ending. But I can remember that at the time I was writing it, I told a friend of mine that the climax of Snow Crash was now longer than Moby Dick. There's a helicopter that gets brought down, and there's a private jet that blows up, some people die, there's confrontations, and the girl goes home with her mom, it seems like a good ending to me. So I think that my experience is that once you've written a book with a controversial ending and that meme gets going of Stephenson can't write endings, then that gets slapped on to everything you do, no matter how elaborate the ending is. [12:59] For The Baroque Cycle, I created a kind of NORAD bunker in which to write the ending. It was this complete, you know, the wall, the ceiling, the floor, they were completely covered with timelines, charts, and all kinds of technology that I was using to bring all the plot lines together into an end. [13:27] I think Anathem does ok on that score. I'm sure I'll be hearing from some of the Stephenson can't write endings people, but I think it's got a decent enough ending on this one.

This is a transcript of an unknown (to me) Wired editor talking about Stephenson's copy: I will tell you I was working under Kevin at Wired when Neil did a story of following the fiberoptic cable around the world, and it was a forty five thousand word piece, and I will say when you brought the copy in I could not improve it as an editor. It was the cleanest copy I'd ever worked with ever with any other writer and I actually worked with a lot of writers so I will say you have something going on there about your first drafts that are uneditable. [2]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnq-2BJwatE&t=10m54s

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkxuzwCps70&t=3253s

EdwardCoffin··on Plan 9 design rule: if a feature doesn't work for everything, don't do it
The tweet cites a google groups post [1]. The title was extracted out of this paragraph from that post:

On Plan 9, the rule tends to be: if feature(X) can't be implemented in a way that works for everything, don't do it. No special cases allowed; it's why mmap is discouraged. This has led to a system that is quite uniform and a pleasure to use, albeit lower performing than its competitors in many places.

[1] https://groups.google.com/g/comp.os.plan9/c/24mMVoy6wXA/m/JW...

EdwardCoffin··on Common Lisp's block / return-from and unwind-protect
Smalltalk only allows the return from the block's lexically enclosing method, not an arbitrarily specifiable context like Common Lisp does. It's discussed a bit on c2.com [1]

[1] https://wiki.c2.com/?SmalltalkBlockReturn

EdwardCoffin··on Running Open Genera 2.0 on Linux
I think the best description of the kind of thing the lisp machines (the Symbolics ones, at least) supported is described in this thread mostly carried by Kent Pitman [1]. I'd at least read all of the comments he wrote as well as whatever else you need for the context he is posting in.

Edit: this thread too [2]

[1] https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/QzKZCbf-S6g/m/K...

[2] https://groups.google.com/g/comp.lang.lisp/c/XpvUwF2xKbk/m/X...

EdwardCoffin··on How to Design an ISA
Bob Colwell touches on an issue that sounds like it is this one in his talk Engineering Lessons from the Pittsburgh Steelers [1] at around 1:05:02 (link prepositioned). I'll bet that he went into more detail in his book The Pentium Chronicles, but I don't have it handy at the moment, so can't cite a page. It does not seem to be in his oral history [2] (PDF), which I had thought contained pretty much all the meat of his chronicles though.

If you're more interested in just concrete examples of this kind of thing, apparently IBM's System/360 team ran into heaps of this kind of issue when emulating the IBM 1401. It's mentioned in Frederick P. Brooks, Jr.'s book The Mythical Man-Month in the Formal Definitions section of Chapter 6, and I think he probably discussed it in more detail in his (and Blaauw's) book Computer Architecture.

Edit: pasting in a cleaned up version of the relevant part of the transcript:

1:04:56 It's required to run every one of those well, how do I know it does? I can't test them all, so you say well you as long as you design to the architecture spec that should be enough. Right? Ha no for example, inside the architecture spec there are places where it says this condition flag is undefined as a result of this operation so you'll do – I don't know what it was anymore, add operation or something, no, it can't be add pick a different [thing] – there was some instruction that would say I do not guarantee what the carry flag will look like when I'm finished and you go as an architect hey that's cool it means I can do it either way whatever way is easiest. No it doesn't.

Yeah if you think that you're going to get in big trouble. Because what what will happen is – and this literally happened which is why I know about this – you put the chip out and then you discover oh it was easiest for my team to set the bit to a 1 didn't matter because it was undefined right I get to pick, but all the previous chips were setting it to a zero although they were calling it undefined. Now you're in trouble, because what you're going to discover some goofy app out there required that the bit be a zero after that operation even though the book said it was undefined. And they didn't notice because up until now it always was a zero. But your chip comes out, the software doesn't work anymore. Guess who's at fault? You are. Can you go "hey look at what the book says, can't you read?" and they'll say "I don't care what you say your chip doesn't work my software, you're a loser, your chips busted."

[1] https://youtu.be/jwzpk__O7uI?si=iy23ZM5tQX-hI87C&t=3903

[2] https://www.sigmicro.org/media/oralhistories/colwell.pdf

EdwardCoffin··on List of Animals That Have Passed the Mirror Test
I haven't (yet) read the paper that they cite about this, but apparently though the journal it was published in is perhaps questionable, the authors themselves are respectable, having published other things in respectable journals. Perhaps the findings were outlandish enough that they had to resort to this one to get them out there. I'm getting this from Peter Watts' post about it [1].

Edit: I couldn't access the link to the ants paper from the article under discussion. Here's an alternate link to the paper that works for me: Are ants (hymenoptera, formicidae) capable of self recognition? Marie-Claire Cammaerts and Roger Cammaerts [2]

[1] https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=6822

[2] http://www.journalofscience.net/showpdf/MjY4a2FsYWkxNDc4NTIz...

EdwardCoffin··on Dynamic soaring
The first few pages of Part 3, when Kath 2 returns to the ring.
EdwardCoffin··on Dynamic soaring
The third part of Neal Stephenson's novel Seveneves [1] has a neat application of this.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves

EdwardCoffin··on Ask HN: Best resources on abstracting and dealing with complexity
Butler Lampson's 2020 expansion of his 1983 paper Hints and Principles for Computer System Design [1]

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.02455

EdwardCoffin··on Poor Charlie's Almanack: The Essential Wit and Wisdom of Charles T. Munger
I read this book fairly carefully a number of years ago, found a lot of good stuff worth taking notes on. I'm glad to see it becoming more easily available. Stripe is also good. I have their printing of Hamming's The Art of Doing Science and Engineering and am quite happy with the quality of the printing and binding.

In a discussion thread [1] on this same book, on this same website back in 2016 I was able to find a citation that the book does not give, for a book Munger did not specify, only described, when I quoted the bit from the book [2] someone was able to come up with what was almost certainly the book Munger had in mind [3].

Reproducing the essential bits of that thread to save the click throughs:

In section 17, Stress-Influence Tendency (p21-22), he mentions some final work by Pavlov, but doesn't provide a citation. I spent some time trying to find it when I first read this years ago, but was unable to. I'm wondering whether it's even reliable: I'd think that work by Pavlov could be found with him as an author, rather than in a "popular paperback" written by an un-named psychiatrist. If anyone knows what book he must have been talking about, or can point to the particular papers by Pavlov, I'd like to know. [1]

""...popular paperback, written by some Rockefeller-financed psychiatrist, when I was trying to figure out..""

Battle for the Mind: A Physiology of Conversion and Brainwashing - How Evangelists, Psychiatrists, Politicians, and Medicine Men Can Change Your Beliefs and Behavior - William Sargant [4]

"In 1938 Sargant was awarded a Rockefeller Fellowship" says author's wiki. I think this book fits the bill." [2]

It does indeed seem to be the book. Thanks.

The author seems to be controversial. The Wikipedia entry on him [1] says things like "his reliance on dogma rather than clinical evidence have confirmed his reputation as a controversial figure whose work is seldom cited in modern psychiatric texts.", and others "described him as 'autocratic, a danger, a disaster' and spoke about 'the damage he did'". [3]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12159242

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12159503

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12159809

[4] https://www.amazon.com/Battle-Mind-Brainwashing-Evangelists-...

EdwardCoffin··on Frank Herbert on the origins of Dune (1965) [video]
I listened to this last night and found it worthwhile. I learned a few things I hadn't known before: he wrote parts of Dune in Haiku and other poetical forms, for the pacing those forms imposed, then expanded those parts into prose [1]. The magazine editor John Campbell turned down Dune Messiah because he (the editor) disliked (Herbert thought) the fact that the story explored the downsides to prognostication [2]. Herbert and the interviewer also discussed Joseph Campbell's ideas on cycles of stories.

[1] at 1:19:17 https://youtu.be/A-mLVVJkH7I?si=lMcNQJCB0dEYalIH&t=4757

[2] at 53:27 https://youtu.be/A-mLVVJkH7I?si=_Iz5-Dm9qcrHXd_H&t=3207

EdwardCoffin··on Apple’s first online store played a crucial role in the company’s resurgence
I recall an interview with someone about this - I think it was Tim O'Reilly - where it turned out that Bezos had a hard time getting the developers to even see the value in it. They kept putting in confirmation dialogs and he'd have to go back and tell them to take the confirmation out, and that was what persuaded O'Reilly it really was innovative, the fact that it was difficult to get the programmers of the feature to even understand the requirement.

Edit: maybe not O'Reilly, since he penned this [1]. Maybe it was Kevin Kelly?

[1] https://www.oreilly.com/pub/pr/537

EdwardCoffin··on MfsBSD: ISO file that create a working minimal installation of FreeBSD
From the readme: This minimal installation gets completely loaded into memory.
EdwardCoffin··on The importance of handwriting is now better understood
By vouch do you mean upvote?
EdwardCoffin··on The importance of handwriting is now better understood
I'm wondering what value you think has been lost through the book being a scan? Virtually all of the pages contain little more than handwriting, so a scan is the appropriate representation.
EdwardCoffin··on No morphological differences between living and non-living systems are yet known
Anyone who likes this kind of thing might find Freeman Dyson's paper A Model for the Origin of Life [1] interesting. It's a purely statistical model, dealing with the most abstract properties of the component molecules. The summary from the paper:

A simple statistical model is constructed, describing the transition from disorder to order in a population of mutually catalytic molecules undergoing random mutations. The consequences of the model are calculated, and its possible relevance to the problem of the origin of life is discussed. The main conclusion of the analysis is that the model allows populations of several thousand molecular units to make the transition from disorder to order with reasonable probability.

I got on to this from the bit of his Web of Stories interview talking about it [2]. I listened to the whole interview recently, and highly recommend it.

[1] https://www.icts.res.in/sites/default/files/LivingMatter2018...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxlYsAzM_8I

EdwardCoffin··on The importance of handwriting is now better understood
I keep a big notebook (12" x 9" I think) that I write quotations I like in, with a fountain pen. I try to transcribe one quotation per day, from a computer file of such quotations. This keeps my hand in with respect to handwriting, keeps my fountain pen from drying up, and doesn't take too much time.

I also keep a journal, but I do that on computer because I value being able to electronically search it.

EdwardCoffin··on The importance of handwriting is now better understood
I only see the teacher's book at that link. Were the copy books elsewhere?
EdwardCoffin··on How to fit a large program into a small machine (1980)
I think it isn't a constrained enough topic to write a textbook on. The conclusion section of the article under discussion summarizes the technique pretty well.

I have encountered brief discussions of the technique in a few places though. Jon Bentley wrote a column called Programming Pearls, collected in a couple of compilation books, and one of those was called Squeezing Space which talked about this a bit. I think that Peter Norvig had a chapter on it in Paradigms of Artificial Intelligence Programming but couldn't swear to it. I've also read that KDB+ uses this technique, and I seem to remember that one of the few columns that discussed implementation (it's proprietary technology, so there's not much on it) talked about stuff like this.

The general idea was also briefly discussed in Dynamic Languages Wizards Series - Panel on Runtime (from 2001), though they didn't go into methods, just trade-offs [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LG-RtcSYUQ

EdwardCoffin··on Michael F. Flynn has died
I'll second that and add in The Nanotech Chronicles, which was way ahead of its time in pondering implications of nanotechnology.
EdwardCoffin··on Hints for Distributed Systems Design
It's kind of odd that the author should cite Butler Lampson's 1983 paper without mentioning that Lampson produced a greatly expanded version of that paper [1] in 2020, which itself includes a lot on distributed systems design.

[1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2019/0...

← PreviousPage 4 of 18Next →