HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ElViajero

914 karma · joined June 15, 2021

Happily working in IT for many years.

A good action creates good karma, as does good intent. A bad action creates bad karma, as does bad intent. Let's keep a positive karma.

submissionscomments
ElViajero··on Insurance is like gambling, don't overdo it
> I can't prove collusion, but mandatory insurance seems wrong.

I do not know how it works in the USA. But in Spain the mandatory insurance is for 3rd parties, for the damage that you may cause to others.

It has historical roots. A driver will crash their car and damage or kill others. That driver has no insurance and no cash. So the victims are left with high costs and probably in poverty. Mandatory for 3rd party insurance assures that when that happens, the victims can collect some money that will alleviate their economic situation.

ElViajero··on Massachusetts health notifications app installed without users’ knowledge
It is obvious that we need better legislation to deal with all the new possibilities that technologies have opened.

The installation of this app, even done with good intent, open a lot of questions on what should be possible or not to be done by government and corporations.

When you get a device with pre-installed, uninstallable, or auto-installed apps. What are the rules?

> "By enabling this service, you can be quickly notified if you’ve likely been exposed to the virus by another MassNotify user, allowing you to reduce risk to your loved ones, seek medical attention, and slow the spread in your community."

In this case it seems that the same goal could have been better achieved by SMS that do not depend on the brand of your phone. The dependency on proprietary app stores and OSs seems a risk for the continuation of a free and reliable communications.

The only thing that is impossible to achieve without an app is to allow the user to select contacts to whom send a notification. Corporations like Google, and Apple know the list of all your contacts. So, it seems that the intention of the app is to reduce friction and send notifications as easy and effortlessly as possible to avoid that procrastination causes people to delay the warning.

But, instead of the silent install the government could have spend money in advertisement campaigns to assure a correct amount of installations. It costs money, but, people pay taxes so the government can engage on this type of initiative at a scale. This could have been a very good alternative, even if it means increasing the budged. Medical emergencies are worth the investing.

ElViajero··on Multiple local news stations say the same thing verbatim [video]
> Televised news is harmful manipulative crap.

Not all news stations are the same, not all countries have the same TV news.

It is easy to just give up and think that you cannot trust anyone. But, the reality is that there is many journalists that care and try to create high quality news. To put them all in one bag is not fair, nor helpful.

ElViajero··on I Treated My Unhealthy Gaming Obsession with More Games
> But I’ve also recognized that I will often turn to gaming when I’m not being challenged enough or fulfilled enough elsewhere.

I feel your pain.

Games are incredible good creating challenges and rewarding effort. Both things are quite lacking in the corporate world.

ElViajero··on HBO Max accidentally sent an integration email test to users
> "This template is used by integration test only."

No, it is not only for integration test. It is also used in production.

They need to update that description. :)

ElViajero··on There is no “us” in team
That is a very interesting point, and it is solved in negotiations between the teams. One team cannot use a technology that forces another team to change theirs. That will take away the autonomy of one of the teams.

e.g.

If one team decides to use Protocol Buffers for their public APIs instead of HTTP/JSON that is the standard, that needs to be discussed at a higher level. As that decision forces other teams to change their tech-stack, one team cannot make that change unilaterally.

If the team's application is composed by several micro-services and they want to use Protocol Buffers for their private/internal APIs, that is not a concern for anyone else.

The directors or architects will be arbiter of the discussion to make sure that it is taken fast and everybody opinion is weighted in. And, if the end there is no agreement, then the director will take the decision to keep things moving.

The main downside of this approach is when a team changes project and ownership of the code changes hands. In that situation you get a tech-stack that you may not find attractive. Usually the team will end changing that tech-stack to something they are more comfortable with, but it takes a long time.

ElViajero··on Internal competition can often be the most dangerous kind
> Isn't the incentive getting paid?

Yes, that is my point.

If I get paid more if your project fails because there is more budged for my project. My motivation is against collaboration.

I do it for the money. And the company, thru forcing me to compete with my colleagues for budged, and bonuses, gives me an incentive to not help, or in the worse case scenario, to sabotage their work.

And managers cannot do much about it if there is a strong economic incentive to be hostile to your colleagues.

ElViajero··on There is no “us” in team
> The organisation quickly adapts to this balkanisation and optimises for it.

That is a very good point. Once you have a company optimized for individual work, as opposite to team work, any collaboration is seen as wasteful as the company has reached a local maximum.

> It means in some cases giving anyone the autonomy to make some choices, but giving someone with more expertise the autonomy to override those choices.

This working very well in some Swedish companies. (In some places it falls into the no-body decides so the default ends winning, trap). But, I have seen it working most of the time. A team own the product, the team has its own internal dynamics and power-structures. They have a lot of autonomy, know well the technology and the product. Architects, Technical Directors, and the like barely override any team decision if at all.

In Spain it was the opposite. It has a very top-down company culture. I think that Spanish software developers work 20% to 30% harder that their Swedish counterparts. But the team is building something that is in the brain of an Architect or similar role, the team does not know the product, the team does not choose the technology. The result is many hours working and in meetings for low output. (And very unhappy employees, you want to go to Spain on vacations and not for a job).

I agree with most points of the article, and it is a good though piece.

ElViajero··on Internal competition can often be the most dangerous kind
> If one of us discovered a new technique for, say, dealing with a particular corner, we shared it with the other.

What is your incentive to do that? I see that as the key. In a company, employees needs an incentive to work together and be constructive. They are not friends.

If you do not get that incentives, if your department success means less budged for mine, if my colleague success puts my job at risk, if your project success creates a problem for mine, I will not be motivated to collaborate.

If you create that incentive of collaboration then the "challenge" factor will be there. I have worked in great teams where we were evaluated as a company, where bonuses were for everybody or no-one. And it was a very competitive environment, I wanted to be as good as any colleague, know as much as they did. And, I wanted them to succeed because it was awesome to see such great projects but also because it was good for myself.

I have not found any healthy company were competition was enforced top-down. Only when collaboration is designed and encouraged top-down then healthy sportsmanship arise from great engineers and teams.

ElViajero··on After 50 years of the war on drugs, 'what good is it doing for us?'
> It was started by the Nixon administration to reduce the amount of left and left-leaning voters, particularly black Americans.

That is interesting information, thank you for commenting.

It shows that there was not a misinterpretation, as the article suggests, at least, not the initiators of the "War", but more of a well-calculated hidden agenda that had nothing to do with "drugs".

ElViajero··on The Hair Dryer Incident (2014)
Many are missing the point, this is a story about transgender rights, not about psychologist knowledge.

The original article, linked in the post, starts with:

“I’ve made this argument before and gotten a reply something like this:

Transgender is a psychiatric disorder. When people have psychiatric disorders, certainly it’s right to sympathize and feel sorry for them and want to help them. But the way we try to help them is by treating their disorder, not by indulging them in their delusion.”

And then goes to explain the "Hair Dryer Incident" as a counter point.

ElViajero··on After 50 years of the war on drugs, 'what good is it doing for us?'
> "The war on drugs was an absolute miscalculation of human behavior," said Kassandra Frederique, who heads the Drug Policy Alliance, a national group that advocates for total drug decriminalization.

For me it would be incredibly interesting to know how much it was a miscalculation or actually it was very well calculated.

The "War on Drugs" have failed to make USA safer, healthier or any other positive metric.

But, it has provided many with an excuse to pass restrictive laws, to win elections, to gain contracts with the government.

I am sure that many believed, even believe today in the "War on Drugs". But, it would be very interesting to know the reasoning to start it. And how much the people that started it failed to understand human behavior, or it is just that their goals had nothing to do fight drugs problems.

ElViajero··on The High Cost of Keyword Search
> This is really important when looking for something obscure.

Sadly I do not think that Amazon goal is to optimize searches so you get what you look for, but so as many people as possible find something that they purchase.

There is many complains in this threat about how bad the "smart" searches are becoming. But, the reality is that "smart" searches are becoming better and better at their goal: to maximize profit finding something for you to buy/click/etc. regardless of what was your initial search.

e.g. If you look for a 3$ book that gives Amazon a profit of 50 cents but they know that they can show you another that you are going to buy for 50$ with 2$ profit Amazon will show you what is right, for their own profit. If the book is just in a similar topic or not useful at all to a minority of people, that does not matter meanwhile it maximizes profit.

ElViajero··on IBM unveils first quantum computer in Germany
"Quantum computers like the Q System One are still very much experimental devices. They can’t outperform classical computers at useful tasks (in fact, your laptop is probably more powerful when it comes to real-life computation), but are instead supposed to be research tools; letting us work out, qubit by qubit, how quantum devices might work at all." from https://www.theverge.com/2019/1/8/18171732/ibm-quantum-compu...
ElViajero··on Cryptocurrency is bad, except it’s not that simple
> I’m not going to speculate on what caused the BTC crash exactly, but the bad press associated with cryptocurrencies isn’t helping anyone with crypto balance in their wallet.

But, he is going to speculate anyway and blame the press.

> In practice, BTC isn’t really an evil force. In the wake of climate change, we should be ramping up our renewable energy production to the point where we always have an excess of power in the grid.

Ramping up production is not enough, reducing waste is key.

> One fact remains, that energy will be used by someone else who pays for it or simply wasted.

That is not how it works. Natural gas plants burn more or less gas depending on demand. Less demand is less consumption.

The article is just non-sense. Most things do not work as described in the article. The conclusions are bizarre.

ElViajero··on How Indian Zoroastrians helped shape modern Iran
That is interesting because one characteristic feeds the other. The more rich and educated the more polite and lower rates of crime. The lower rates of crime the more prosper a society is.

That is why it is so important to help people to get out of cycles of violence and crime.

ElViajero··on Equilibrium Effects of Pay Transparency
That is a very good point. If employers have the information, and they could already share it to lower salaries. Why are they not doing it?

Or something is missing, or the employers are going to realize their mistake and implement transparency.

ElViajero··on Europe's Software Problem
>In order to be innovative and compete, we need very flexible working laws, people with a big growth mindset, a less relaxing lifestyle and AMBITIOUS people.

False. Sweden is in the top 10 competitive nations in the world. And it is because it has a relaxing lifestyle, support for children and parents, etc.

If desperate people was more innovative or productive, the list of successful USA entrepreneurs would not be filled with upper-class or rich businessman.

Easy of mind, education and time creates opportunity. Desperation only leads to bad decisions.

Late years Sweden in going down because it is moving towards more neo-liberal policies, thou.

ElViajero··on Americans’ inflation fears reach a fever pitch as consumer prices rise
> At the same time, consumers surveyed by the New York Fed also expected household income and spending to increase, particularly among households with annual income of more than $100,000, the central bank said.

Quite interesting how much there is, at least, a two tier economy. How to deal with that with just one lever, interest rates, it is very difficult. You may stop inflation in one tier and send the other one down in a spiral. Or the other way around.

ElViajero··on 80% of tech could be built outside IT by 2024, thanks to low-code tools
This is known as shadow IT. And it is a risk for any big corporation.

Are you going to leave to "users" to implement GDPR and other regulatory compliance? No, that would be too risky.

"low-code tools" seems misleading.

On the other hand, I agree that if you think that data-scientists are not tech people. There is going to be a big increase on non-tech people (data-scientists) working in IT. But this is more a definition problem that any fundamental change.

ElViajero··on Universities have formed a company that looks a lot like a patent troll
I understand that there is a historical expectations that Universities should provide education and be a role model for society. But, as far as I know, in the USA universities are just another business.

The USA should stop being surprised each time that a company rises prices of a live-saving treatment or starts a patent troll company. Some of this kind of problems are exclusively a USA problem and do not exist in other developed parts of the world.

Why is that?

My 2 cents are that you need is to create rules for a fair game. As a society you should regulate how companies behave, what is permitted and what is not. You elect your government make it work for you. It is not always easy, as there are many interests, but it is possible.

For the USA citizens that may read this, you know better your country. What is your opinion?

← PreviousPage 5 of 5