HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EliRivers

6,140 karma · joined January 21, 2010

submissionscomments
EliRivers··on Working quickly is more important than it seems (2015)
My highly specialised sarcasm sensors (honed in the UK) suggest that this is not in fact your current deliberate strategy; that said, I have worked for so many groups and companies where that is exactly what happens, even if they think they're planning for something else to happen, and it's obvious to pretty much everyone involved that that is what is happening and will keep happening.
EliRivers··on UPS strike could devastate the economy, and could be eight weeks away
And it would all work out, because the army would actually be composed of the striking workers, hired on short-contracts to intimidate themselves, and any strike-breakers would also be striking workers hired at greater pay; where else are you going to find people with exactly the right knowledge and experience, AND available suddenly? :)
EliRivers··on North America is now the growth leader for new battery factories
Sure, but lumber is cheap. Hundred of dollars per cubic metre; literally 1% or less the value of the same volume of quality electronics or high-processed goods. That is the point here; high value density goods are so cheap to ship that making your EV battery plant near your car assembly plant is a false economy if you can save just a few tens of dollars on parts and labour on the other side of the planet.
EliRivers··on Ask HN: As a developer, do you consider the carbon footprint of your apps?
desktop apps have so many issues (installation/breakage/crashes) that web apps are the only way to deliver software that just works.

I wonder if this will always be the case, or if we just need to keep going for another order of magnitude or two before we manage to render web apps as painfully difficult for ourselves as we've made the desktop.

EliRivers··on Ask HN: How can a junior dev maximize their income?
Find a new job with a significant pay rise every couple of years. Think hard about the next jump each time you make a jump.

All the best pay rises I've ever had involved finding someone willing to pay me a lot more for basically the same thing as I was already doing for someone else.

Barring winning the "pick the exact stupidly-overpaid technology of the future", banking on any particular technology would have done me far fewer favours than just finding new jobs paying more money.

EliRivers··on Google doesn’t want employees working remotely anymore
You also lose the ease of just walking over to someone to ask a question

Depending on who you are, massive massive benefit. In the office it was hard to get people to stop turning up at my desk at a time convenient to them, regardless of what I was doing, to interrupt me.

training is AWFUL remote. Not even close

Definitely agree with this as a statement on how things currently ARE (in general), but they don't have to be that way. A lot of companies who struggle with this turn out to be just really bad at training in general. Previously, they got lucky; the people in need of education scrounged it by interrupting people or watching people or asking someone to metaphorically hold their hand. Companies were training by chance, rather than by design. Remote working demands a different way of training people, a different way of managing people and measuring output; a lot of companies are failing badly at this and falling back to failing less badly at it in the only way they know (i.e. everyone back to the office so we at don't suck quite so much at training and management and collaborating).

EliRivers··on High prices make textbook ‘piracy’ acceptable to most students
It's been a little over two decades since I first attended university, but I recall that very few of the courses had a textbook. The lecturer wrote notes, be it on paper to hand out or on the boards to be copied and annotated. Now and then a reference was made to a textbook for further reading or for some specific proof or some such, but in no way was any course taught from a textbook in such a way that you simply needed the textbook. This was at a university in London, reading Physics.

I wonder how unusual (or not) that is? Is the heavy textbook emphasis a US thing, or is it more common?

(About a decade later I read Maths with the Open University, which is basically the student on their own for six years learning some trick mathematics; a couple of those modules definitely taught from textbooks, although by no means all of them; some of them again simply provided notes and explanations and problem sheets generated by the university)

EliRivers··on Third-party Reddit apps are being crushed by price increases
Indeed; as Cory Doctorow calls it, the Enshittification stage. The point at which the platform begins to extract all the value it can from its users and its advertisers.
EliRivers··on North America is now the growth leader for new battery factories
Shipping high-value items can be an astonishingly small part of the total cost; especially if you're sending it by sea. A few years ago I calculated that an (at the time) maximum sized container vessel carrying a full load of electronics in containers (which is very unlikely, but I picked a high value density item just to get an idea of the general numbers) would be carrying a cargo worth on the order of a billion dollars, and the cost of shipping each electronic good (I picked something around the size of a small PC tower; about 0.05 cubic metres) across an ocean, port to port, was on the order of a dollar. That kind of money.

So I guess if I scale that up to an EV battery, volume about a third of a cubic metre, so about seven or eight times the volume, that's still less than ten dollars per EV battery shipped across an ocean, if you've got a ship full of them.

I don't know what the total parts and labour cost of an EV battery is, but by this admittedly fast, brutal and half-remembered back of envelope calculation the numbers only have to be a few tens of dollars different to make it worth building them on the other side of the planet and shipping them across an ocean.

EliRivers··on ‘Tired’, ‘lonely’ and hated by locals: the reality for the digital nomad
Ah, the Daily Telegraph. In recent years, it has become more and more like a broadsheet version of the Daily Mail. They are on a long-term anti-WFH push; this is part of that narrative.

To be fair, at times their defence coverage is still surprisingly solid, though.

EliRivers··on Automate the CEOs
I understand it's typically not so brazen that two people are explicitly setting each other's pay, but an incestuous ecosystem. There's a fair amount of literature examining it and finding things to be concerned about.

For example, Baker, Bivens & Schieder (2019), "Reining in CEO compensation and curbing the rise of inequality", suggests that compensation for CEOs "is more likely to reflect CEOs’ close ties with the corporate board members who set their pay." https://www.epi.org/publication/reining-in-ceo-compensation-...

Bebchuk and Fried (2004), "The Unfulfilled Promise of Executive Compensation", is a literal book discussing it all; it suggests (amongst other things) that CEO remuneration is not always closely tied to company performance but can be influenced by peer benchmarking and the interdependence of corporate boards.

An old (1992) article in Management Review (V81, Issue 5) "Can we put the brakes on CEO pay?", contains suggestive ideas such as "Most CEOs have invited these people to be on board," Denton adds. "It's easy [for directors to be relatively generous.", so this is by no means a new situation.

And of course, veteran shareholder activist Rob Monks has been complaining about all this, and a lot more, for decades.

EliRivers··on Automate the CEOs
Would they? I understand that in many cases, CEOs are often selected by, and their remuneration awarded by, boards made up of incestuous groupings of people who rely on each other in the same way. Their incentive is to award big paydays to each other.

Do you have any evidence that boards would not do this?

EliRivers··on Ask HN: Where have you found community outside of work?
If you've got the time and the inclination, depending on where you live and your circumstances, reserve forces can provide connection, purpose and places in spades.
EliRivers··on C++17’s useful features for embedded systems
std::clamp ; I got it exactly wrong and would have introduced a bug if the compiled didn't tell me I was discarding the return value. I thought it updated the value I wanted clamped. It does not. Don't know why I thought that, but I did.

The function is entirely useless and pointless to call without using the returned value, and [[nodiscard]] pointed this out to me. Perfect.

EliRivers··on Sweden's 250-year-old Freedom of the Press Act gets UNESCO status
If that individual is distributing his writings or speech by mass media, he is part of the press

Not under the common definition of the press. By all means have a different definition, but if you do, it's only fair that you state up front that you mean something other than the common definition.

EliRivers··on Qt 5.15 Standard Support for Legacy License Holders Ends Today
Having recently seen a product move from Qt5 to Qt6, there sure are reasons! Off the top of my head, some of the things that had to be done:

Remove every use of the previous QRegExp class (no longer existed in QT6), which was always bad, and replace it with the similar but slightly different behaving QRegularExpression class. Different enough that it's not just a simple grep.

Rip out huge chunks of XML processing code that used QT5 XML libraries that were outright withdrawn, and replace them with alternatives.

Rewrite some sound generating code to switch away from Qt5 classes that straight up no longer existed, to something else.

Rip out uses of the QT5 web engine classes; I think I recall it was replaced wholesale in QT6, but it was nothing but trouble through its life so there was an outright rewrite of everything using it to just do something non-web instead.

Any others that were outright withdrawn we also must have replaced. Can't remember them all, but here's a list: https://doc.qt.io/qt-6/whatsnew60.html#removed-modules-in-qt...

Some of those have an extended life in a QT6 "QT5 compatability module", but that's clearly not going to get a lot of security and bugfixes and there's no telling when it might vanish.

Lots of very fiddly changes to the Qt metatype system had people trawling through weird and wonderful error messages working out what was going on and how they could replace it.

QT6 demanded to be built under C++17; after switching the compiler to that, there sure was a whole lot of old code that either didn't compile at all, or flashed heavily red when the compiler looked at it, that demanded a rewrite.

All this, and when you're done, you've got something that's probably functionally about the same as what you had beforehand, but the previous version of the software under QT5 had a decade of use testing and this is brand new.

No customer is going to pay for all this effort, so there is very little impetus on anyone to move from QT5 to QT6 if the QT5 version works and updates keep coming. It's only at the end that people are finally forced to make a move.

EliRivers··on Sweden's 250-year-old Freedom of the Press Act gets UNESCO status
It's called "the press" because of the printing press.

Yet what "the press" means is "the body of news and journalism organisations". It is very possible to have a heavily constrained press, while individuals who are not the press and not part of the press have much more freedom to say what they like into the aether.

EliRivers··on Sweden's 250-year-old Freedom of the Press Act gets UNESCO status
Is a single individual "the press"? I could see heavy press restrictions with political officers and commercial interests supervising newsrooms and having editorial veto, while individual people are able to spout whatever they feel like into the aether at large.
EliRivers··on Ask HN: What is your proudest little invention or discovery?
In my life, I have invented the holographic lens, bicycles and network cables.

Sadly, as I arrived at each invention and contemplated it, I realised it had already been invented.

EliRivers··on Bringing the power of AI to Windows 11
Maybe the AI will be able to delete files and directories faster than me doing it myself with a magnetised needle and a steady hand.
EliRivers··on UK’s GDPR replacement could wipe out oversight of live facial recognition
When the UK was in the EU, I was protected from some of the worst excesses of the UK government. The UK didn't leave the EU to make those protections stronger...
EliRivers··on “PayPal forcing me to have a cellphone to access my account”
Just so; in some cases we are already beyond the point where you need to be in some way wealthy or privileged in order to interact with a company beyond the basic automated phone and web-based interface.

Yet every so often I still hear someone (to be fair, not nearly as often as I used to) suggest that poor people (and sometimes refugees) having phones shows that they're undeserving of assistance, since they can clearly afford a phone. As you say, it's becoming the cheapest and in some cases only way to interact with a lot of businesses and services that are necessary simply to operate in society.

EliRivers··on WeWork has frittered away $46.7B in value as the stock sinks below ¢50
Is it Uber for offices? Uber's model is that individual people with cars and spare time effectively loan out that car and their time to people wishing to make journeys, with the two parties being connected and the deal arranged by Uber, who take a cut. All the vehicle ownership risk was shoved onto the driver, and in the event that there was suddenly zero demand somewhere, that risk also was borne by the driver (at least, until various jurisdictions started enforcing minimum wage so that drivers who had no rides all day still got paid).

WeWork's model didn't appear to involve individual people with spare office capacity loaning it out for short periods to other people needing an office for a short while. WeWork's model appeared to be that WeWork itself leased office space, and rented it out to people. WeWork paid for the lease, and took on all the risk of that and all the risk of the demand vanishing.

EliRivers··on Office Workers Don’t Hate the Office. They Hate the Commute
I used to do a lot of my reading on the train. Over an hour each way.

Now that's I'm 100% WFH, I do that reading on the sofa at home. While I don't know everyone's circumstances, if people can only get the time to do things that they want to do (like reading) as a side-effect of what would be otherwise useless travel time, I feel that there's a better time-management solution than an office commute.

EliRivers··on Cargo Cult AI
"I asked ChatGPT to prove that 1 + 1 = 3 and it happily spat out a proof."

I bet there are LOADS of proofs of that in the training data.

EliRivers··on We Don't Know How to Compute (2011) [video]
If there are a billion different ways to solve this problem, it would seem much more of a coincidence if with LLMs we've "oops-ed" into an approach just like the one inside our heads. It would seem more likely that they're unrelated approaches.
EliRivers··on Baltimore sues Hyundai, Kia over spike in car thefts
You hurt someone intentionally, you should not be breathing free air for a while.

Genuine question; is that only physically? If I like causing people pain and anguish and suffering, and my weapon of choice is words, should I also be incarcerated because I hurt people intentionally? I tend towards not giving people a free pass simply because their weapon of choice is words, but (amongst other things) the US has a reputation for being very permissive with the spoken word.

EliRivers··on Apple is bigger than almost any stock market in the world
Americans make up 4-5% of the world population.

Is this about Americans owning 60% of the value of all the equities in the world, or is just that 60% of the value of all the equities in the world are listed on US markets?

Over half of my stocks were bought on US exchanges and I'm not a US citizen. Very roughly calculated, Norway owns about 1.5% of the world's equities so Norway owns a nice piece of that $40 trillion and they're also not US citizens (well, some of them are, I expect).

EliRivers··on You don't need Scrum, you just need to do Kanban right (2022)
I've had similar experiences with waterfall; projects running on time, over multiple years, on which the end users never reported so much as a single bug.

As you say, it demands really good requirements, which can only come from high-quality customers. Most customers are not high quality. They are low quality. They are bad. They don't know what they want and don't know how to express themselves. As you suggest, a really good requirements person can tease these details out of them, but in my experience a great many companies don't even realise how bad and incompetent a lot of their own customers are.

EliRivers··on Arianespace CEO: Europe won't have reusable rockets for another decade
Indeed. I understand that if you want the world's most advanced chip-making machines, it's ASML or nobody.
← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →