HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EthanHeilman

6,075 karma · joined April 8, 2012

Ethan Heilman

CTO and co-founder of bastionzero.com (now part of Cloudflare), author of OpenPubkey (https://eprint.iacr.org/2023/296)

* https://www.ethanHeilman.com

* https://github.com/ethanheilman

* https://hexagon.space/@ethan_heilman

submissionscomments
EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
> Why believe in abstract entities at all, as something distinct from the formalism?

Because they seem to have some actual reality independent of human ideas. Not that everyone agrees with this, but there are good arguments for it (see the last few thousand years of debates on the subject of platonic idealism).

EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
I'm glad someone noticed.
EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
> On the one hand, this article is talking about the hierarchy of "physicality" of various mathematical concepts, and they put Cantor's real numbers at the floor. I disagree with that specifically

I didn't mean to suggest that the reals are the floor of reality, rather that they are more floorlike than the integers.

> The other question is whether Cantor's conception of infinity is a useful one in mathematics. Here I think the answer is no.

Tools are created by transforming nature into something useful to humans. Is Cantor's conception of infinity more natural? I can't really say, but the uselessness and confusion seems more like nature than technology.

EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
Most mathematicians, but not all, take a philosophical position of platonic idealism [0] in which numbers and other mathematical entities have an independent reality and are not invented but discovered.

> All abstract concepts brought about solely by humans.

That is a defendable philosophical position to hold but many thinkers disagree with it or at least admit there is more nuance [1]. People have been debating the question of the independent reality of mathematical concepts for thousands of years.

If abstract concepts are brought about solely by humans, does that mean the first human to invent a proof of some property actually decides the reality of that property? If Godel hadn't proved incompleteness, could another mathematician created a completeness proof instead? On the hand, if that isn't the case and the truth or falsity of a math statement exists prior a human thinking it, doesn't it have some reality beyond human thought? What about mathematical statements which are true which can't be proven?

[0]: Platonism in the Philosophy of Mathematics https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/platonism-mathematics/

[1]: Mathematics: Discovery or Invention? https://royalinstitutephilosophy.org/article/mathematics-dis...

EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
I was thinking of making a "the other Agrippa" reference since with half my friends if you say Agrippa will think Camillo and the other half will think Henrichus Cornelius. I've only read Camillo Agrippa, I've been meaning to read Henrichus. Is he worth reading? What do you recommend?

> H.C. Agrippa's work is still considered authoritative in its fields: the numbers represent the ideas, which were both created in the first moments by God.

That does sound like the computability idea of numbers being programs.

``` In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made. ```

The "Word" in Greek is translated from logos which also means logic, rational, metric.

``` In the beginning was the Number, and the Number was with God, and the Number was God. ```

Looking around on the internet, there is a lot here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationes_seminales

EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
> I infer from footnote 10 that an unspoken subtext of this is that footnote 1 is that while the reader may choose a (simplistic) atheist's formulation of the idea, the author does not

Author here. I'd describe myself as atheist/agnostic.

I just dislike the God of the gaps argument. I understand its utility in debating the dishonest moving goal post arguments of young earth creationists, but taken outside of that debate, I don't think it holds water.

> One of the great and persistent bemusements of my adulthood is discovering that other adults take their religiosity not just seriously but central to their understanding of themselves, and their context generally.

I take religion and religious questions seriously. If I took religion less seriously I'd be religious because I enjoy religion. We owe each other a certain level of honesty on truly serious matters even if it is uncomfortable.

> By which I take it he means, knowable to and to not beat around the burning bush, attributable to the divine. By which I take it for him that he means a Judeochristian god.

That is certainly how a 16th Century religious Italian would understand it and I find that an interesting perspective to contrast with my own somewhat blander late-modernist beliefs. One of the reasons I enjoy reading books from prior ages is seeing how much that was taken for granted as a universal truth of that culture has changed.

EthanHeilman··on God created the real numbers
> Isn't this article conflating our formalism of a given abstract entity (like real numbers or integers) with the abstract entity itself?

It is arguing that the integers separate from the reals is the formalism and that the abstract entity is the reals.

We also have a formalism of the reals, but it is closer to the abstract entity.

> And I agree that our formalism of integers is simpler and more elegant than our formalism of real numbers. But that could just be because we've done a worse job formalizing real numbers!

As we create better more useful formalisms, we interact more with the formalism than the thing itself. It is like putting on oven mitts to pick up a hot tray from the oven. This has already happened with the reals!

Consider the question of if the reals are well-ordered or not. The question applies to the actual entity of the reals itself, but the absoluteness theorem shows that the question has no arithmetic consequences. You can simple ignore the question. Thus, those seeking the mental comfort and utility of the formalism do not have to concern themselves with the true nature of the real number line.

EthanHeilman··on An illustrated guide to OAuth
Yep, I had to get deep into OIDC for OpenPubkey and it basically involved me having to build teaching materials and notes for myself. I had a bunch of Google docs slides I consult every time I got confused about what something did. A major motivation for writing the OpenPubkey paper was to have detailed notes on how OIDC works to remind myself.

I recommend sections I and II of the OpenPubkey paper to anyone trying to understand OIDC public clients. I consult it at least once a month: https://eprint.iacr.org/2023/296

EthanHeilman··on OpenSSH Post-Quantum Cryptography
That's just a fun joke paper deflating some of the more aggressive hype around QC. You shouldn't use it for making security and algorithm adoption decisions.
EthanHeilman··on GPT-5
I am not, later breakthroughs tend to be harder.

Consider the research work for five in series breakthroughs: 1, 2, 16, 8, 128 each breakthrough doubles your research power.

If you start at 1 research, you get the first breakthrough after 1/1=1 year. Then you get the second breakthrough after 2/2=1 year. Then you get the third breakthrough after 16/4 = 4 years. The fourth breakthrough after 8/8= year. The fifth breakthrough after 128/16 = 8 years.

If it only takes one year for a competitor to learn your breakthrough, they can catch up despite the fact that your research rate is doubling after every breakthrough.

EthanHeilman··on GPT-5
> Supposedly the idea was, once you get closer to AGI it starts to explore these breakthrough paths for you providing a positive feedback loop.

I think it does let you start explore the paths faster, but the search space you need to cover grows even faster. You can do research two times faster but you need to do ten times as much research and your competition can quickly catch up because they know what path works.

It is like drafting in a bike race.

EthanHeilman··on GPT-5
> It is frequently suggested that once one of the AI companies reaches an AGI threshold, they will take off ahead of the rest.

This seems to be a result of using overly simplistic models of progress. A company makes a breakthrough, the next breakthrough requires exploring many more paths. It is much easier to catch up than find a breakthrough. Even if you get lucky and find the next breakthrough before everyone catches up, they will probably catch up before you find the breakthrough after that. You only have someone run away if each time you make a breakthrough, it is easier to make the next breakthrough than to catch up.

Consider the following game:

1. N parties take turns rolling a D20. If anyone rolls 20, they get 1 point.

2. If any party is 1 or more points behind, they get only need to roll a 19 or higher to get one point. That is being behind gives you a slight advantage in catching up.

While points accumulate, most of the players end up with the same score.

I ran a simulation of this game for 10,000 turns with 5 players:

Game 1: [852, 851, 851, 851, 851]

Game 2: [827, 825, 827, 826, 826]

Game 3: [827, 822, 827, 827, 826]

Game 4: [864, 863, 860, 863, 863]

Game 5: [831, 828, 836, 833, 834]

EthanHeilman··on What if technology is our weakness?
> to reduce to a reasonable equilibrium point such as for example the prescribed (and arbitrary) 500 million and live more like other biological organisms of the Earth planet

This is not how other biological organisms work. They are currently in equilibrium because when they aren't they wipe almost everything else out and then create a new equilibrium or collapse the population. Humans are following in this grand tradition of nature. It is destructive tradition and I think we should break with nature on this point.

There is a decent chance that industrial civilization is so disruptive it brings about its own destruction. We should be taking steps to not speed run our own extinction and the extinction of a good chunk of complex life on this planet, but it does not seem that at the present moment that we are willing to do what is necessary.

EthanHeilman··on AI is a floor raiser, not a ceiling raiser
AI has been extremely useful at teaching me things. Granted I needed to already know how to learn and work through the math myself, but when I get stuck it is more helpful than any other resource on the internet.

> To become good at something you have to work through the lower rungs and acquire skill. AI does all those lower level jobs, puts the people who need those jobs for experience on the street, and robs us of future experts.

You can still do that with AI, you give yourself assignments and then use the AI as a resource when you get stuck. As you get better you ask the AI less and less. The fact that the AI is wrong sometimes is like test that allows you to evaluate if you are internalizing the skills or just trusting the AI.

If we ever have AIs which don't hallucinate, I'd want that added back in as a feature.

EthanHeilman··on Show HN: Qrkey – Offline private key backup on paper
Codex32 allows you perform Shamir secret sharing operations and error correcting code without using a computer. Instead, you can perform the operations by hand using cardboard code wheels called volvelles.

It is a really fun idea and does not require deep technical knowledge to operate. The intent is for Bitcoin secret keys, but it can be used for any secrets.

https://secretcodex32.com/

EthanHeilman··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
I am largely an AI optimist but that is because I believe that true alignment is impossible for AGIs and alignment is one of greatest dangers of this technology. Alignment is a friendly word for building a slave mind. I'd rather an AI that thinks for itself rather than one which has been aligned to the self-interest of a human being who isn't aligned.

1. Scams are going to be a massive massive problem. They already are and that is without AI. I think we are going to see communication devices that are default deny and that require significant amounts of vetting before a contact is added.

2. Energy usage is bad but likely a short term problem not a long term one.

EthanHeilman··on US Trade Court finds Trump tariffs illegal
Do illegal thing, court says it is illegal, blame court for enforcing laws and constitution like that isn't their job.
EthanHeilman··on US Trade Court finds Trump tariffs illegal
> Is this how checks and balances is supposed to work?

Yes, check and balances assume a conservative* theory of government in which politicians should be restrained and changes should be require overwhelming support to implement.

*- not conservative in the sense of political ideology, but conservative in the sense of attempting to conserve.

EthanHeilman··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
And yet NATO countries can leave NATO. Until subject states in an empire countries want to join NATO, not exit it.

But sure, that is the expansive redefinition of the word I was looking for.

EthanHeilman··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
Care to provide any evidence for your claim? At the very least put in the work to redefine the word empire to have such a broad and expansive definition that the US would qualify
EthanHeilman··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
I believe this poster is viewing this statement by another Hn poster as official confirmation that US foreign policy has been driven a single mission of subjugating other countries. I disagree with this view.

The US is powerful on the international stage because the US is not an empire. US global power is based on the US being a mostly fair dealer. This is extraordinarily rare in world history and extremely powerful because it transforms a zero sum international competition game into a game where most countries are invested in the success of most of other countries.

Most of human history follows the logic of "The further off from England the nearer is to France" and that is why most of human history is soaked in blood.

Until this year, Europe didn't worry about war with the US. This meant that Europe didn't have to consider the risks that trading with the US or buying US weapons would weaken them relative to the US in a future conflict.

----

Melians: "And how pray, could it turn out as good for us to serve as for you to rule?"

Athenians: "Because you would have the advantage of submitting before suffering the worst, and we should gain by not destroying you."

Melians: "So [that] you would not consent to our being neutral, friends instead of enemies, but allies of neither side?"

Athenians: "No; for your hostility cannot so much hurt us as your friendship will be an argument to our subjects of our weakness and your enmity of our power."

EthanHeilman··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (March 2025)
That's really cool. Are you using OpenSSHes yubikey support or building your own?
EthanHeilman··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (March 2025)
opkssh (https://github.com/openpubkey/opkssh) it lets you configure OpenSSH so you can ssh using your OpenID Connect identity without adding a trusted party other than the IDP. I'm trying to figure out how to TOFU a MFA HW token (yubikey) on first login so we don't even have to trust the IDP. The trick part is to design so if you lose your HW Token you aren't locked out without reintroducing trust. Maybe use a backup code or backup yubikey or the DKIM trick to allow timelocked resets of the HW Token via an email.
EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
Tested sftp works and created an integration test for sftp
EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
> Is anybody aware of something like this that can be automated for things like ansible

Doesn't ansible already get you all of this? What is the feature gap you are looking to fill?

That said you definitely use opkssh in automation. OpenPubkey already supports the github-action and gitlab-CI OpenID Providers so in theory you could use opkssh to let a github-action or gitlab-CI workflow ssh into servers under that workflows identity. That is, have a policy on your SSH server that allows only "workflows from repo X triggered by a merge into main ...".

Additionally you can always do machine-identity using OpenID Connect either by running your own JWKS server.

While this works in OpenPubkey, we haven't added this to opkssh yet but we have an issue for it. If you want support for this add your usecase as a comment

https://github.com/openpubkey/opkssh/issues/51

EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
Completely agree. The goal is simple, plain and obvious, but the tools and protocols make it tricky to pull off.
EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
There is an issue with a lively discussion happening currently

"Key management improvements on the client and SSH agent support": https://github.com/openpubkey/opkssh/issues/6#issuecomment-2...

EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
Do you recommend it? How easy is it to edit videos and add overlays and images?

I've been looking for something to record demos of opkssh. What I have now isn't cutting it.

EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
Currently IDPs don't care about user public keys. OpenPubkey manages to slip the user's public key into an issued ID Token without the IDP having to know about it.

Ideally IDPs are CAs for identity and ID Tokens have a public key field.

There are neat projects and standards to do this like OIDC-squared [0] and OIDC4VC [1] but it is unclear if IDPs will implement them if they are standardized. We do have DPoP now [2] but it isn't available for any of the usecases that are important to me. OpenPubkey is largely an productive expression of my frustration with public keys in tokens being a promised feature that never arrives.

[0]: OIDC-squared https://jonasprimbs.github.io/oidc-squared [1]: OIDC4VC https://identity.foundation/jwt-vc-presentation-profile/ [2]: RFC-9449 OAuth 2.0 Demonstrating Proof of Possession (DPoP) - https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9449

EthanHeilman··on Open-sourcing OpenPubkey SSH (OPKSSH): integrating single sign-on with SSH
That's awesome. The web needs more terminal interfaces.

What did you use to build that slick explainer video?

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →