HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

EvgeniyZh

9,025 karma · joined April 27, 2016

https://evgeniizh.com/ https://t.me/j_links https://twitter.com/evgeniyzhe
submissionscomments
EvgeniyZh··on Willow quantum chip demonstrates verifiable quantum advantage on hardware
It is not very clear from the text and from what I can say there is no "verifiability" concept in the papers they link.

I think what they are trying to do is to contrast these to previous quantum advantage experiments in the following sense.

The previous experiments involve sampling from some distribution, which is believed to be classically hard. However, it is a non-trivial question whether you succeed or fail in this task. Having perfect sampler from the same distribution won't allow you to easily verify the samples.

On the other hand these experiments involve measuring some observable, i.e., the output is just a number and you could compare it to the value obtained in a different way (one a different or same computer or even some analog experimental system).

Note that these observables are expectation values of the samples, but in the previous experiments since the circuits are random, all the expectation values are very close to zero and it is impossible to actually resolve them from the experiment.

Disclaimer: this is my speculation about what they mean because they didn't explain it anywhere from what I can see.

EvgeniyZh··on Show HN: I'm making a detective game built on Wikipedia
I've played one game of ransom. This is fun but I have some comments/suggestions.

1. Letters are sometimes barely shuffled 2. Sometimes same clue with different redacted words come one after another so you know which words are redacted 3. Sometimes (foreign names for example) the answer is not redacted due to accents. Same for similar words (complexity uncensored for "complex system"). Sometimes picture or video contains answer. 4. I guess you use some popularity metric for articles? I got Greece, ancient Greece and archaic Greece, though the topic is allegedly physics? Maybe filtering a bit more would be better 5. Before I started game I didn't know how long it is supposed to last. Apparently it's indefinite, and I lost on purpose to verify it. 6. Some feeling of progression with harder tasks would also feel nice.

EvgeniyZh··on M5 MacBook Pro
No, only from settings.
EvgeniyZh··on M5 MacBook Pro
Launching unsigned app now requires to go to settings manually and allow it there instead of just allowing on launch
EvgeniyZh··on Nobel Prize in Physics 2025
It's highly non-trivial claim that macroscopic system can have quantized energy levels and exhibit measurable quantum effects. You can't just solve Shroedinger equation of 10^24 particles to show that.
EvgeniyZh··on Interstellar Object 3I/Atlas Passed Mars Last Night
Trip to Mars (~its closest point) is much longer than time we had. The chances the next one will be close enough to Earth and low enough speed so it can be matched is astronomically low and such interceptor would be quite expensive
EvgeniyZh··on OpenAI Is Just Another Boring, Desperate AI Startup
> Given they still offer 3.5, three years is probably a more fair depreciation schedule.

But the usage should drop considerably as soon as next model is released. Many startups down the line are existing in hope of better model. Many others can switch to a better/cheaper model quite easily. I'd be very surprised if the usage of 3.5 is anywhere near what it was before release of the next generation, even given all the growth. New users just use the new models

EvgeniyZh··on Show HN: The text disappears when you screenshot it
Probably the lower frequencies of noise are not matched? Not sure if the frequencies of the order of movement frequency can actually be matched
EvgeniyZh··on Determination of the fifth Busy Beaver value
So how many sporadics would be left if we run the same on 6-state TM?
EvgeniyZh··on Ireland will not participate in Eurovision if Israel takes part
Well clearly this one isn't flagged. Hope you update your priors
EvgeniyZh··on Ireland will not participate in Eurovision if Israel takes part
What are you talking about? There were multiple anti-Israeli articles on main and in top (150+ votes) [1-7], including Al Jazeera, funded by same people who fund Hamas. I can't remember any single pro-Israeli article that wasn't flagged to death.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45094165

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44714221

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44576782

[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44496391

[5] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44402896

[6] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42467375

[7] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38616550

EvgeniyZh··on Ireland will not participate in Eurovision if Israel takes part
> I still don't think the killing children part is complicated at all - there's zero justification for it.

So if hamas has a child hostage in every arm warehouse (which is more or less what happens) and with every terrorist squad the only justified action for Israelis is... to die?

EvgeniyZh··on Why haven't quantum computers factored 21 yet?
The real limit for quantum chemistry in NISQ is the circuit volume, since it requires O(N^4) gates.
EvgeniyZh··on Israel committing genocide in Gaza, scholars group says
Well the whole discussion is under an article by the source entirely unreliable for this news.
EvgeniyZh··on Israel committing genocide in Gaza, scholars group says
It is not hard to separate military-purpose infrastructure from civilian one. It is hard only in a sense that it'd be immediately destroyed and all the combatants would be killed.

In fact "hiding among civilians" is an excuse for collateral civilian damage, international law allows attacks that harm civilians in order to achieve military goals.

By the way, did you know that Geneva convention don't apply if you're fighting someone who haven't signed it and also doesn't "accepts and applies the provisions" [1]

Green account with random set of letters for a name calling someone a bot, how ironic

[1] https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/gci-1949/arti...

EvgeniyZh··on DeepSeek failed to train a new model without using Nvidia hardware
https://archive.is/a2RzY
EvgeniyZh··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
But you replied to comment that specifically pondered about flagging and moderation. There are enough users (though still in minority) to submit and upvote the stories for the opposite view. There are comments supporting "wrong" view that survive. There is no downvote so the only way to suppress the submissions is to flag then and this is indeed what happens.

Political stories are usually getting flag enough by people who don't want politics on HN, people disagreeing with it/believing it's not good content and eventual mod interventions. So if "accidental" framing bothers you, I can rephrase.

Either mods are not intervening, and HN consensus is strong enough to overcome the flagging on this specific topic. I would expect more stories on main in this case, but it is an option (what I called accidental).

Alternatively, mods do intervene, either by manually unflagging some stories, or manually demoting some, but not all of them (what I called intentional). In this case I'd want to know what's the argument [1] for it

And the sun either rises by design of whoever designed our universe or because the solar system appeared by accident out of initial conditions of the big bang.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42993906

EvgeniyZh··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
I don't see a false dichotomy here and if there were posts against right to privacy that are flagged while posts for it were not (either with admin intervention or without) I wouldn't say "there is nothing to see here". I would definitely prefer to see both sides of issue and I wouldn't flag posts against privacy, though not upvote it either.

If you think it's nice when media is biased towards what you consider to be right, and that's the point of your analogy, I disagree.

EvgeniyZh··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
Why is it false? Either admins intentionally make only specific articles to appear, or they do not, i.e. it happens unintentionally/accidentally. What other options are there? If something happens it is either intentional or not.

Not sure what wrongness has to do with that either. In the first case it reflects the political preferences of the admin, in the other it reflects the preferences of HN bubble. Either could happen independently of who is wrong and who is right.

EvgeniyZh··on ‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF aid site [video]
Is it accidental or intentional that all political posts on this war are biased towards one of the sides? Do you think it is the best option?
EvgeniyZh··on Quantitative AI progress needs accurate and transparent evaluation
GPU compute per watt has grown by a factor of 2 in last 5 years
EvgeniyZh··on About 30% of Humanity's Last Exam chemistry/biology answers are likely wrong
I submitted questions to HLE. I tend to agree that the review was far from perfect. For example, some of my questions were just not understood, and another was claimed to have the wrong answer, though it wasn't.

I think the situation is better for math and physics, where answers are more straightforward to verify; probably even worse in the humanities. I also believe that releasing the models' answers would help verify the questions, but it has never been done (possibly in fear of even more train-on-test?)

Edit: to clarify, when I contacted orgs they helped me with the problems but I guess it wouldn't happen if the problem was in opposite direction

EvgeniyZh··on Investors bought 27% of US homes in Q1, as traditional buyers struggle to afford
What happens in this scenario to all the people who currently rent and who can't afford to buy house even when it becomes cheaper?
EvgeniyZh··on Investors bought 27% of US homes in Q1, as traditional buyers struggle to afford
But that's the intended outcome, isn't it? The proposal is to increase supply of housing for sale by decreasing of supply of housing to rent.

The cost of investment increases, so to keep the profits investors increase the rent, less people can afford it so the demand for rent decreases and investors sell houses. The supply of housing increases (I agree this is quite convoluted way to increase housing supply) and prices drop. Top cohort of renters can now afford to buy a house, and the bottom cohort is... fucked?

EvgeniyZh··on A 17-year-old teen refutes a mathematical conjecture proposed 40 years ago
Ph.D. is training in how to do research. Solving one, even very hard problem not necessarily means that you don't need such training. It's especially tricky with counterexamples which sometimes question of raw talent and luck rather than skill.

The next step for someone who has PhD and want to stay in academia is postdoc. After solving one problem, you would not necessarily have what's needed to get a good postdoc, such as clear research agenda or proof of ability to publish consistently.

EvgeniyZh··on Engineered Addictions
Camera and video calls feels like two major drawbacks. Also I've heard there are NFC problems.
EvgeniyZh··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
> Alas, the text is misquoted, as it doesn't appear anywhere in the document.

I wrote the direct quote after the colon and ">" symbol. The part in quotes in my rephrasing. Of course AI wouldn't write such thing directly, they need to hide it deep into the report behind convoluted language.

This paragraph consists of

1. Explaination how genocide definition is interpreted by international courts, specifically ICJ.

2. Claim that existing interpretation preclude a finding of genocide in the context of an armed conflict (for example, war in Gaza). I'm not sure that it's true, because for example, Srebrenica massacre happened during armed conflict and was found an act of genocide, but let's take their claim on face value.

3. Conclusion that we need change the interpretation of definition of genocide to be able to find during war conflict (specifically, war in Gaza)

Part 2 is what I summarized as "Israel is not commiting genocide according to existing definitions", and part 3 is what I summarized as "thus definitions should be changed". Technically they want to change interpretation and not definition, so the better summary would be "Israel cannot be found guilty of genocide according to existing interpretation of genocide, so the interpretation should change". Or do you disagree with this one too?

EvgeniyZh··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
The citation is from page 101 of the report you linked. Have you read it?
EvgeniyZh··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Bringing up Al Jazeera as an unbiased source about Israel is weird.

Amnesty international emitted report that say "Israel is not commiting genocide according to existing definitions, thus definitions should be changed":

> As outlined below, Amnesty International considers this an overly cramped interpretation of international jurisprudence and one that would effectively preclude a finding of genocide in the context of an armed conflict.

Somehow people cite it as a proof of genocide.

BBC has produced a documentary with narrator being son of Hamas official, and were forced to apologize for that [1]. They sheleved another documentary with impartiality concerns. They have contributors calling to "burn Jews like Hitler" [2].

So yeah, there are unbiased critics of Israel, just none of those you listed

[1] https://www.bbc.com/mediacentre/statements/gaza-how-to-survi...

[2] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/04/26/well-burn-jews-l...

EvgeniyZh··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Iran has official discrimination against both ethnic and religious minorities.

On the other hand, Jews had to leave the Muslim countries both in Northern Africa and the Middle East, with the total Jewish population there shrinking from hundreds of thousands to hundreds. Compared to that, Iran, from which only 70-90% of Jews left, looks not that bad. However, there were testimonies that members of Jewish families aren't allowed to leave the country all together, so I'm not sure if everyone is staying there at will.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →