HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Fraterkes

2,758 karma · joined July 20, 2016

submissionscomments
Fraterkes··on Maybe you should learn something
I’ll chime in. I started learning to draw in my early twenties, couple hours a week. What helps a lot is joining a club, I’ve got a group in my town that just goes to a bar one night a week and draws and chats for 3 hours. Great way to ensure that you get at least a few hours of drawing in, even if your week is too busy for “practice”.

It takes about 2-3 years of mild practice to get good enough that you’ll routinely impress yourself, about 5 years to get good enough that you could do paid commissions.

Seems like a long time, but unless you start in your seventies you’ll have decades left of enjoying being an artist afterwards.

Fraterkes··on Spain Orders Blacklist of Palantir from Public and Private Companies
The world's a scary place, but that's no excuse to make it worse.
Fraterkes··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
Any resources for getting better at that skillset (high-velocity but largely stable ai-enhanced coding, if I understand you correctly)? I’m always pretty skeptical of these claims but I wouldn’t mind being proven wrong
Fraterkes··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
I honestly think that a 1$ “deposit” to submit a pr for new contributors (to be returned if the pr is merged) could help with a lot of OSS problems
Fraterkes··on Changes to Our Contribution Policies
The part about ai contributions being demoralizing for reviewers because it could otherwise be an opportunity to educate a new contributor is pretty salient imo. Especially with so many people wondering what's going to happen to junior positions in the future.
Fraterkes··on Words Are a Byproduct of Consciousness. For LLMs, It's Backwards
Because we are, in our life, not always conscious.
Fraterkes··on Words Are a Byproduct of Consciousness. For LLMs, It's Backwards
I don’t know why I’m consciousness, but I know that I am. Other people are outwardly very similar to me, so I assume the same is broadly true inwardly.

A rock is outwardly pretty similar to me; in that it exists in the world, has obvious physical boundaries, and is affected by the passage of time. But it is not so outwardly similar that I assume consciousness.

An LLM is also outwardly similar to me, in that it can express itself in language, and seems to ‘contain’ notions about the world. But it is again not necessarily so similar to me, outwardly, that inward similarity is obvious (to me)

Fraterkes··on Words Are a Byproduct of Consciousness. For LLMs, It's Backwards
An LLM is a big equation that we solve to get textual output. If Ai proponents already believe an equation can contain consciousness, what about the Chinese Room presents a more compelling counterargument?
Fraterkes··on Words Are a Byproduct of Consciousness. For LLMs, It's Backwards
The assumption of this sort of argument, if I understand it correctly, is that consciousness is just an ordinary byproduct that appears (or grows gradually) somewhere on the spectrum of complexity.

If that’s true, mastering language is basically orthogonal to being conscious (as you’d maybe expect, GPT-2 was pretty good at language, but had a relatively tiny amount of “neurons”).

The same is arguably true for world modeling: a math textbook has a very complex and coherent model of a world, and is, probably, unconscious.

Then the question is: what reason do we have to assume that these models have some form of consciousness?

Fraterkes··on Words Are a Byproduct of Consciousness. For LLMs, It's Backwards
Do you have a source for the pupil dilation thing? Sounds fascinating!
Fraterkes··on U.S. government will decide who gets to use GPT-5.6
"We believe in broad access, and we plan to make GPT‑5.6 Sol, Terra, and Luna generally available in the coming weeks. As part of our ongoing engagement with the U.S. government, we previewed our plans and the models’ capabilities ahead of today’s launch. At their request, we are starting with a limited preview for a small group of trusted partners whose participation has been shared with the government, before releasing more broadly. During this preview, we will continue testing and coordinating closely with partners as we work toward broader availability. We don’t believe this kind of government access process should become the long-term default. It keeps the best tools from users, developers, enterprises, cyber defenders, and global partners who need them. We are taking this short-term step because we believe it is the strongest path to broader availability in the coming weeks, while we work with the Administration to develop the cyber Executive Order framework and a repeatable process for future model releases."

This amount of courting the current administration is pretty scary imo.

Fraterkes··on Jerry's Map
You guys are welcome: https://marcmajcher.github.io/jerrysmap/
Fraterkes··on Steam Machine launches today
It's funny how this (imo) almost feels like an inherently inert topic to discuss:

Is it dumb of them to do this? Not really, they got unlucky with the timing and they already designed the machines. Selling them below cost to subsidize steam-sales would probably create bad incentives for them.

What will this mean for Valve's future? Nothing, they're still a relatively lean company with a money machine.

Will this dissuade them from creating hardware in the future? Probably not, the Steamdeck was really succesfull and they've got more than enough resources to do a few failed experiments.

Fraterkes··on Windows 11 New Media Player Uses 3.5x More RAM, Charges for Popular Video Codecs
Kind of a pity that we used up the phrase "a fractal of bad design" on php, it's so applicable to much of the stuff coming out of MS. I've been using PowerBi for a few weeks now and I'm sometimes impressed by the novel ways it finds to suck.
Fraterkes··on Amazon drops Sam Altman movie after announcing OpenAI partnership
Why do you agree that Amazon shouldn't be the one producing the film if you don't believe there's any evidence them dropping it is related to the partnership?
Fraterkes··on There are no instances in ATProto
I'm sorry, just to clarify: in your scenario where the app/company is suddenly vaporized from the face of the earth, if that happened to Bluesky right now it would effectively mean that >90% of content currently published using Atproto would be lost?
Fraterkes··on Lore – Open source version control system designed for scalability
I’ll chip in here and say theres ime a world of difference between the amount of condescension and acerbic noise produced by Blow versus Casey. Casey comes of as grumpy but fundamentally pretty respectful in the stuff I’ve seen him in.
Fraterkes··on After AI takes everything
I, everyone here, has read all these discussions a thousand times now. I've tried to have a more nuanced view, I understand the excitement and I think there can be real value in automation being accessible to everyone.

What matters to me is, I like programming and making things, and I'm okay at it. I can learn to enjoy, and get good at, other work (I hope). Close a fairly brief chapter of my life where I felt some certainty about what I wanted to do for the coming decades. But it's maddening to not have any idea if I will need to.

Here's my point: it may not be bad to live in a future world were ai and llm's are very prevelant, ordinary technology. But I think living in the now, while that world is (slowly) being born, can get to be pretty bad.

Fraterkes··on The state of building user interfaces in Rust
This isn’t Rust-specific, but I’m always slightly surprised I don’t see more people talk about Pangui (https://www.pangui.io/) (it not being out yet is a pretty good reason I guess). If the demos on the site aren’t vaporware, it seems to me like a really promising addition to the current options for desktop gui dev.
Fraterkes··on Python JIT project was asked to pause development
People in this thread writing conspiracy theories over the biggest language in the world requiring a bit of bureaucracy lends some credence to the idea that programming is not real engineering.
Fraterkes··on Zig Zen Update
I think people criticize that line in the zen of Python because Python has now become very maximalist. On it's own merits, I think "There should be one obvious way to do it" is much better, less clunky, than "There is an idiomatic way to do it".

Also, importantly, the Zen of Python is kinda written as a set of ideas that Python should aspire to ("there should be one obvious way to do it") instead of a sales pitch of Python's merits. I prefer that.

Fraterkes··on Changing how we develop Ladybird
If I don’t word these critiques in the most diplomatic way possible, this immediately turns into a discussion about the prevalence of anti-ai sentiment on hn. Which would be boring.
Fraterkes··on Changing How We Develop Ladybird
Gratitude was maybe the wrong word. As the article mentions, before ai I think larger PRs, while sometimes inconsiderate, at least implied some amount of care / effort / good faith. In my experience, that was often rewarded with the maintainers at least taking a look at the code. I meant it's odd to have the same expectation when you dump 3000 lines in a pr that you won't even personally write a description for.
Fraterkes··on Changing how we develop Ladybird
I've been looking a lot at Godot (another big open source project) PRs lately, and there's been kind of a surge of wholy ai-generated PRs (both code and description). This is agains project-policy, so people creating these PRs usually get mildly told off. What's surprising is that while many submitters take that fairly well, some people get really indignant, essentially calling the maintainers ungrateful.

It's kinda surprising to me that even the people who are all in on ai haven't internalized that there's no inherent value in producing a big lump of code. They've massively decreased the work they put in but still expect the same pre-ai reaction/gratitude when submitting a big PR.

Fraterkes··on Brume is a 24-voice multi-timbral desktop synth for the CM5
Just out of curiosity, and without judgement, how much ai was involved in building this (ie was it vibed)? I'm trying to get a better idea of the kind of stuff people are making.
Fraterkes··on The Public Should Own Half of the Big A.I. Companies
But isn't that exactly what's going on here? An ai-company has created value by developing these models, and the public should capture that value via the instrument of government.
Fraterkes··on 90% of the T Distribution
This is neither here nor there: I was reading the about page of the author, and it contains a passage that slightly confused me: "My name is Chris and I live in Sweden. I have a beautiful, supportive wife whose love I will never be able to requite, neither in degree nor kind." English isn't my first language, how should the second sentence be interpreted?
Fraterkes··on Uber, Lyft drivers in Massachusetts form first US ride-share union
And it’s a win for the new group of drivers who ostensibly used to have a worse paying job. These dollars probably have more marginal utility for the people delivering doordash than for those consumers. If we want to be technical.
Fraterkes··on A few interesting modern pixel fonts
So, Analog Mono and Geist both have enough pixels per glyph that they don't really read as pixel fonts below sizes of ~20px. Analog kinda aleviates that by being made up of big (overlapping) blocks of 2x2 pixels. Geist just kinda looks like a downscaled vector font (to me) though.
Fraterkes··on What we lost when we stopped letting kids leave the front yard
Which parts are not a joke? If someone asked you who your main child was you’d be able to answer?
← PreviousPage 3 of 16Next →