HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

FrenchAmerican

130 karma · joined December 21, 2021

submissionscomments
FrenchAmerican··on Putin’s Game Ends
If the planning was not poor, then the current situation underlines how poorly the Russian soldiers have been fighting for the last five weeks.

I admire the fortitude of the Ukrainians fighting back against this unprovoked invasion.

The decision to shell to the ground whole towns and cities where many civilians still live display to the world the cowardice of Russian soldiers, who are much better equipped than the Ukrainians.

Russia is a tiger of paper with nuclear claws.

Nobody knows where the front line will be when a treaty is signed - but Russia has lost for a century its rank among the leading nations in the world.

Just another despotic state with a second-class army and an economy surviving through the exportation of natural resources.

I hope that western countries will welcome all the Russian political refugees: they are the elite of this nation and having them working in our economies will be a big plus.

Already 70,000 IT workers have left Russia - and this is only the beginning of this escape from despotism and generalized corruption, a "kleptocracy".

FrenchAmerican··on Watching the World Wrecking
There is a specific context though, that makes the propaganda far more believable to many Russians than what they read online through VPN or - for most Russians - through word of mouth.

I watched a Russian elderly lady, who appeared like a decent person, respond to a western journalist. She said that she knew for sure that the news from the West were untrue "when they said that Russians troops were shelling Kiev and Kharkov - which is impossible".

Many Russians - most in fact - consider that Ukraine is historically a part of Russia. Which is untrue, but that's "common knowledge". So Ukrainians are their cousins, their brethren.

Hence the syllogism: if Putin has sent the Russian army to Ukraine, then:

1/ it doesn't make sense to kill civilians and shell cities to the ground

2/ the attack must have valid reasons ("Nazism", existential threat to Russia by joining the USA' side through NATO, ...)

When you are in such representations, believing Putin's propaganda is quite rational.

By the way, we should also be more skeptical of what we are told on our own channels. Our media are relying all the time information they get from the US government, the British intelligence and the Ukrainian government WITHOUT any possible way to cross-check them.

No journalist can cross check the idea that Putin is being lied to by his generals, by his entourage and by the FSB. It is quite possible ; it would explain a lot of what happened during the last month ; it is logical since despotism reign by fear - and truly we have all seen how fearful these people appeared to be during the televised Russian security council.

But our journalists are relying what our governments and the Ukrainian government say, without verification. Most mention that fact, directly or indirectly ("according to...") - but they five credit to this narrative anyway by propaging it.

Russians are wrong to support this unprovoked and atrocious invasion of Ukraine - but they are rational, not gullible or escaping a disturbing reality because it's easier to cope with, even unconsciously.

Humans are rational. Russians are rational and we are too in the West.

A good reading about this: "the Savage Mind", 1962, by the anthropologist Claude Levi-Strauss. He demonstrates that Natives' way of thinking in the Amazonia was as rational then as we are today, as were people in the Middle Age or ancient Greeks or ... jihadists from All Qaeda.

Not that I like it - but just let's stop with the ideas that people we disagree with are not rational.

Even Flat Earthers are rational people! It sounds absurd at first but it's really not. The Enlightenment movement of the XVIIIth century was precisely of discuting everything that was proclaimed as a Truth in common knowledge or by authorities (the Catholic Church, ...).

It's not irrational to think that Earth is flat. Most of our day-to-day experience tend to prove this idea. Demonstrating that Earth is a globe is not that easy. It's easy to make simple experiments that hint that Earth is not flat, but explanations can be found to explain the discrepancies. Really proving to people that Earth is round without a mediation like films from space is not easy. Of course, the Flat Earthers are prone to detect conspiracies everywhere, so they discard the films as fabricated. Which is not irrational. The proof needs either a direct experience in which Flat Earthers would have total control, or a decent level in Mathematics and Physics. Most of people who are right to think that Earth is a globe don't know how to replicate the proof of it. They believe what Science says - which is a very rational attitude.

The only way to change the mind of most Russians is to find people they trust (for any reason), send those to Ukraine with cameras and have them do their independent reporting. Showing the atrocious results of Putin's invasion, eg massive civilian casualties, destruction of whole cities, war crimes, ..., will create the emotion that humans need to reconsider what their rationality led them to think.

Humans don't change their mind when confronted to a "rational presentation of facts". They need a strong motivation to accept to reconsider. Only emotions can provoke the shock required.

Many experimental psychology studies have demonstrated that "rational demonstrations" by scientists to whatever-believers (antivax, ultra-nationalists, jihadists, flat Earthers) lead to ... the reinforcement of their beliefs.

Our rationality is driven by our emotions. Which doesn't mean that we are not rational. Many scientists complain that they are perceived as super cold people, which they are absolutely not. But their very core of their job is to chase their own biases all day long. And that's a difficult task. Hence the crisis of reproducibility in many fields of Science, where the "publish or perish" tyranny nudges scientists to get results all the time. Some of them are just manipulators, of course, but the crisis of reproducibility is much deeper.

FrenchAmerican··on Missing wheat from the war is less than 1% of global wheat crop
> Wait, isn't there a contradiction here? You said countries need to protect their agriculture to remain sovereign, which is what the EU is doing. Then you blame the EU for protecting their agriculture. Which is it?

I get your point. The issue is the hyper-productivism of the EU's agriculture. Public money, e.g. the citizens' money, is used to ensure revenues to farmers. I have no issue with that. But since that money is public, it is supposed to serve the general interest.

The EU could decide to encourage organic farming rather than industrial agriculture based on Monsanto seeds and pesticides. The latter make possible high levels of production, but to a huge cost for biodiversity and even climate dereliction. And it destroyed agriculture of subsistence, forcing them to specialize in monocultures like banana and chocolate.

We pay our farmers to destroy our ecosystems, polluting the rivers, with proliferation of a green algae on our beaches which vapors can kill a man. So public money is spent to clean the beaches to protect tourism. Farmers themselves have health issues since they are exposed to high levels of pesticides.

All this because the EU, and especily France, need to export food for its commercial balance, instead of producing high quality food for its population.

20%/of pesticides in France are used on the vineyards, which amounts to 3% of the agriculture surface. Around Bordeaux, pesticides are found within the children hair - meaning it is ingested by merely respiring.

The "good part" of maintaining African countries dependent for basic food is to keep them producing what we made them produce during the colonozation., e.g. exotic fruits, coffee, chocolate etc.

The US does just the same. Cereals are heavily subsidized and the same dependency is organized to keep Central & South American dependent for basic food. The soils of the great plains of the Midwest are being mistreated to the point of desertification. Well, with enough water, huge amounts of fertilizers and pesticides, the industrial agriculture still works, even if the yields are on a diminishing trends. But the climate dereliction imposes o the US larger and longer droughts every year.

Food sovereignry is important, but preserving fertile soils in the long term is a must. Biodiversity enablea an ecosystem to adapt to a changing climate, to some extent. Nowadays, the change is far too fast to allow Nature to self-regulate, e.g. to keep the soils alive by the natural selection of the adapted species.

American billionaires are no buying huge pieces of preserved land in New Zeland for no reason. They know. No that it is difficult to know, we just prefer to ignore it.

It's like Putin's threat on Ukraine or the emerging imperialism of China. We all know but don't act accordingly.

The Covid pandemy is the direct consequence of industrial meat production. Too many animals concenteqted on small surfaces in the name of productivity, in contact with humans. Virus emerge, some kill the animals, like the avian flu, and some jump to men, in general indirectly through bats or pangolins or rats ...

If that Chinese lab in Wuhan was studying coronaviruses, it's precisely to have vaccines ready for the pandemies that will inexorably happen since we don't want to change our agricultural practices.

Many scientific reports are gloomy, like the IPCC, because the numerous meta-anaysis of ten out thousands of studies give us a very clear picture of what is happening (the 6th great extinction of species on Earth) and the climate dereliction. 50ºC temperature in Australia, in the Middle East are now annual. Droughts in the US and Europe, huge fires evverywhere.

We are stupid. Big money make people believe in the virtue of free markets to ensure the public good. It just ensure that the 1% get always richer and the 0.1% doubled their fortune thanks to Covid, in less than 3 years. And people turn to billionaires like Musk to save the world(as if he cared) or to populists with anti-liberal agenda, on the far-left (Chavez) but more often on the far-right (Trump, Putin, Bolsonaro in Brazil, Modi in India, Orban in Hungary, neo-fascists in Italy, Christian-nationalists in Poland, Erdogan in Turkey ... just to name those who were.elected).

Sorry for the gloom, I just don't see a way out since democracies are failing to put in power the right leaders. At best, we have some Obama, Biden or Macron, who are not bad guys but in the end, do nothing to correct the economic system. Our democracies keep electing people who protect the 1% class they belong to. So more and more popular and middle class voters elect far-right leaders who have no solution but the hate of their scapegoats of choice.

FrenchAmerican··on Missing wheat from the war is less than 1% of global wheat crop
Or maybe we need to stop relying on globalized markets for vital production.

A country is really sovereign if it produces enough food for its own population.

One of the main reason of the food dependency of Northern African countries is ... the EU policies.

Huge amounts of public money are given to farmers each year so that their selling prices are competitive on the global markets.

Those global prices are lower than local production cost in Northern Africa.

So the European Union basically made these countries dependent through its agriculture policies.

Egypt has also a very large population for its very limited arable soil. But Algeria, Tunisia, Morocco have plenty land and water enough to feed their population. And yet they are dependent on food importations to survive.

So the Egyptian case is specific and hides a larger truth. Many West African countries are dependent as well to subsidized European meat. Local farmers can't compete.

Each country should be allowed to put tariffs on food importation high enough so that local production is enough to feed the country.

The USA, Brazil, Argentina, Australia, New Zeland, Ukraine, Russia and the EU just won't allow it.

The EU put a large fight to protect its farmers against competition from the aforementioned countries. And that was and still is a good strategy. But it goes too far, as described before.

We need to stop building such a fragile global economic system. Free markets are simply NOT efficient to ensure access vital goods and services.

Self-sustainability for vital needs should be a priority, at a minimum on the country scale, but the smaller scale possible is always preferable: that's resilience, hence sovereignty.

Food, water, shelter, security... and love are the humane true necessities. A country should be able to guarantee this to its population, whatever happens : large war, pandemy, unseen solar eruption that kill most electronic devices, extreme and unseen natural disaster due to climate dereliction.

We are not ready to face uncertain times.

FrenchAmerican··on Stop scaring children about the climate
Just plain denialism.

The IPCC reports are presented in a quite counterfactual manner.

The IPCC presents different possible scenarios at each report ; the first report voluntarily played down the risks, for many scientists were afraid to be perceived as fearmongers.

What happened? The worst scenario possible according to that first report.

The recently published second report presents different possible scenarios, accordingly to the measures taken or not to nullify our emissions.

Globally, the trend of emissions meet the worst scenario of the second report. That's not fear mongering, that's science.

Let's not wear masks against Covid, it scares the children.

Our children need us to act against the climate dereliction. If we really acted on the issue, it would not afraid children.

Children are afraid of our inaction.

FrenchAmerican··on Putin and Russia meet the textbook definition of fascism
As a binational, I am always amazed by the nationalism in the USA. I'm not even talking about "ultras" like many far-right groups, just "normal decent people".

An US flag on almost every house, the pledge of allegiance at school, the belief into the American exceptional destiny, the belief to be the best country in the world...

I lived in Brazil for 5 years and they are very nationalist as well. Many young Chinese as well.

Patriotism is one thing, nationalism another. In Europe, we have learned that the hard way. Obviously, we are slowly forgetting the horrendous wars of the past, since nationalist political parties are getting more and more votes.

The distance from nationalism to ultranationalism becomes very short when a crisis appears. At the beginning of the Putin's unprovoked invasion, many Ukrainians wanted to fight for democracy. With the huge destructions and killings, I hear more and more their initial patriotism turning into essentialism: I'll die for Ukraine, Russians are barbarians by nature, etc. That's quite understandable, but still is a concern.

Note that I do think that a large majority of Russians are favorable to this war, in the sense of a necessity. Even if they were able to listen to independent media, I doubt that it would change their mind. The collective representation is that Ukraine is part of Russia - which is not true but still taken as a self-evident truth.

If the Russian people had access to independent information, they woukd be angry towards Putin for not succeeding, for the disorganization of the Russian army, for putting their sons at risk with a bad strategy and bad intelligence. Only a minority would oppose the war on historical grounds, or in the name of the sovereignty of the Ukrainian people.

When the French army was fighting against the independence of Algeria, or during the Vietnam war, few were opposing the war. The opposition went larger and larger in the US when the draft was imposed to the youth. Otherwise...

Unconditional support of "our" troups whatever the reasons for war is widely expected, if not considered as a civic duty. To me, that's the essence of nationalism: we are right because our country can't possibly be wrong. That's exactly what many Russians say when interviewed by western media. "Of course, Ukraine is a part of Russia. Of course, our army don't kill civilians."

When I cite the 2nd Iraq war, most of my American friends (educated & decent people) say: "Oh, that was a mistake". Yeah, a "mistake"... Tens of thousand civilians killed is a bit more than "a mistake". In France, most people don't know that hundreds of thousands of Algerians were killed during the Algeria War.

We, humans, are not social animals ; we are tribal animals.

FrenchAmerican··on Trees Are a Faster Solution to Climate Change Than Technology
Meat is by far the production that require land. 1 cow requires 2.5 acres of land, if my memory is right.

If we cut meat consumption, then we have plenty of space available. We should eat much less meat in all cases, that's one of the few points that meta-analyses of effect of diet on health have pointed out.

We really need one piece of red meat like beef per week to get the vitamin B12. And no more than one meal with meat every other day.

Or we can have the same amount per week but with half portion everyday - for example if the dish requires meat for its taste.

With much fewer cows, we can then let them roam freely in forests, which they prefer by far. Grass without shade is good for golf, not for cows.

In the US, most cows don't even have grass ; they walk all day in their own shit, parked in overpopulated enclosure, and fed with soja.

That's so disgusting that cattle breeders went to court - and won - to forbid any photo of their enclosures.

I'm not a vegan, not even a vegetarian and I consider humans to be omnivorous by nature. But I want to eat the meat of happy cows, happy pigs and happy chicken.

Without hormones, without antibiotics, without GMOs feed. That means a more expensive meat but it tastes so much better, really.

Chicken are super tasty when raised in natural conditions. Pork is unbelievably better.

FrenchAmerican··on Yale employee admits she stole $40M in electronics from the university
Indeed, but that's also true for any large organization, whatever their status: public, private, nonprofit.

I witnessed large sums being spent for very dubious reasons in private firms, mainly in order to meet ridiculous demands by executives. Show-off features despite no interest from customers, "visionary product" e.g. implementing a blockchain or "artificial intelligence" that classic algorithms could do as well for much cheaper.

The idea that private entities pay more attention to money than public entities is a prejudice. At least in modern developed democracies.

Financial scandals in private firms tend to be muted in order to preserve the external reputation: hence the impression that public entities are less careful.

It's all the same everywhere, no general rule in that matter.

FrenchAmerican··on The World Is Splitting in Two
Britain should apologize, but France as well and all other countries implicated (I reckon I don't know which).

The US and the democracies in general ought to put a huge pressure on Japan. I don't feel that we belong in the same alliance if the Japanese people don't do their homework. It will be very difficult for them, but a necessity however. I'm not holding my breath.

The whole thing is indeed depressing.

FrenchAmerican··on Our soil is dying! - We and our governments need to act!
It's not senseless at all. Cows also prefer shade rather than direct sun when it's warm. Like we do. :-)

There are no unique best way to protect soils. Different approaches may work on the same spot depending what you want to produce. In all cases, even if one approach may really be by far the best in one location, another approach will be required a few miles away.

FrenchAmerican··on The World Is Splitting in Two
I will certainly not defend the US (or France, my second country) for having been exemplary in the past. Both have ventured into their specific form of imperialism, at different times. Both have directed or contributed to coups against democratically elected governments (Central & South America, Africa). Both have helped infamous dictators to stay in power.

However... China's imperialism is a real threat. I don't think that the citizens of the western quite imperfect "democracies" have just knowledge of the Chinese grievances against us.

The West immensely abused China during the XIXth century. On all levels: economically first, but also culturally. The resentment of the Chinese people is both very vivid and grounded on very factual facts.

Putin has shown where resentment leads. We thought that he would not invade Ukraine for the benefits were low in comparison to risks, e.g. large sanctions. But he did nevertheless, for Ukraine is - in his view - a central issue in the identity of Russia.

When we sacked the "Old Summer Palace" during the opiums wars, it's as if the Louvre in Paris, the Palace in Versailles and the castle of Chambord had been voluntarily plundered and destroyed. The Opium Wars meant we put millions of Chinese into addiction in order to counterbalance our commercial balance.

Putin's claims on Ukraine have no historical grounds, whatever he and many Russians think. But Chinese resentment towards the West are quite understandable.

Furthermore, Japan devastated China between 1937 and 1945 - with a rare level of atrocity. The Cold War has now made Japan an ally of the US, and of the West more generally.

Most people in the West have no clue about that part of History. It's not taught at school, or in passing. Which makes it even worse for many Chinese: not even knowing what our countries did to them is the worse insult possible. We also don't push Japan to acknowledge their outrageous war crimes.

If we want peace with China in the coming 50 years, we should start acknowledging what we did and ask for forgiveness - e.g. demonstrating our respect. Being able to apologize with very official, large ceremonies is not a sign of weakness.

And since this must not be taken as such, we need to be military ready, to be economically ready (not depending on China industry as we do nowadays) and socially ready.

By socially, I mean to be capable as societies to endure tough times. The invasion of Ukraine has shown that we don't care enough about democracy to stop the flow of petrol and gas from Russia. The EU pays Russia 600 million euros * per day* for it. We are not ready to go through an economic recession in order to save Ukraine.

We are weak.

We provide a big amount of weapons - but that's not a huge one. No planes, no tanks. We even stop ex-army volunteers to join the Ukrainian army! We could perfectly give temporary vacations to volunteers from our armies, as long as they disperse and go there by their own means.

So we need to stand up against Putin much more clearly than we do, just keeping the few legal appearances to avoid OTAN's country to be implied as an official belligerent. We can do much more and we don't. We could decide to limit the temperature in our homes to 16ºC. But our politicians are no Churchills.

China is looking. China wants revenge and I find it quite understandable - even if I despise violence to solve issues. We should prove our strength, our will to keep up collectively with China and its vassals (Russia becoming one of them very soon). And ask the Chinese people for forgiveness for our past behaviors, by providing all the symbolic reparations they rightly deserve.

True adults know when to apologize and when a bully needs to be stopped.

Our Western politicians have not enough courage for any of these necessary acts.

Let's hope that the coming war with China will stay "cold". Or that a common enemy appears to force us to cooperate. Aliens would be fun but, well, improbable... :-) Climate dereliction has the potential to be bad enough to collectively get our priorities right.

For sure, nor our politicians neither the Chinese are doing what is necessary, so huge "natural" disasters are on their way. Like Greta Thunberg repeats: that's what Science predicts, not a point of view of mine.

FrenchAmerican··on The World Is Splitting in Two
I wonder if China had any choice in its Covid strategy. They used the only tool they had, e.g. their control of the population.

When they had a vaccine, it proved of mediocre effectiveness. So they could not rely on it as the main strategy. And they still can't, obviously.

The (still called) Communist Party is very aware of its citizens' opinion. When pollution became a constant muttering, they acted vigorously, so that no "green movement" arise.

The Party has a huge power - but it is expected to deliver, otherwise social unrest ensue. Not being able to control a pandemy is unacceptable, since the dominance is justified by the common good.

The control of the Party on the Chinese population is ambivalent: very real and quite fragile altogether. The Party knows that very clearly.

FrenchAmerican··on Capitalism Is Ruining Science
Economics = capitalism?

It feels as if capitalism was some sort of "natural" economic organization.

The mere existence of various forms of capitalism is by itself a rebuttal.

In many countries, the civil society is fighting back against the very notion that every sector of human activity should be turned into an economic matter.

Moreover, the opposition between public and private sectors is outdated. The "commons" is a much more fertile way of building a future.

Decentralization of power and means of production through cooperatives opens a whole new path to get out of the public/private fruitless debate.

All educated people should either work solo or join/create a cooperative. Capitalism will slowly recede without the executives and intermediate management, and experts of all kinds.

No revolution of the masses is needed to fight capitalism back. But the "commons" need the creative class to take responsibility and lead the society in this gradual change.

Or you can stay within the US extreme capitalism to fight alone against billionaires, chasing the American Dream that only 1% reach (and many of them just inherit) - and in reality paying your mortgage and your education back so that you're debt free when 75. ;-)

FrenchAmerican··on Why banning men from leaving Ukraine violates their human rights
TLTR: The international laws on war are based on the fiction that only armies are fighting. The article is also quite gender-biased, even insulting.

I consider that the fight of Ukraine against Putin's invasion is fundamentally the defense of Human Rights and democracy.

However, the ban of leaving the country for men doesn't necessarily imply the obligation for all of them to carry a weapon.

Just consider the millions of men in Ukraine and the few hundreds thousands who are on the front.

In such a war, fighting is not only on the front. The nurse is fighting, even in an hospital hundreds of miles from the front. A cook who prepare meals for the drivers need to supply the front, he is fighting too.

The LGBT+ case is - in my opinion - very dubious and even insulting. As if a gay man could not be a warrior. Many other men are facing specific threats if captured, like elected officials who organize civil defense, Jewish people will probably be mistreated or worse etc.

Mothers and their children, aged people, and people who need it for various reasons should be evacuated. But I can't help feeling that the restriction on men only is nothing but a gender bias, like the LGBT+ already mentioned.

Women can fight, both in the front or wherever they are or feel more relevant to. Kurdish women have proved it quite enough, among many other examples. You don't need a pair to be a warrior. Women, gays, queers, transgenders, ..., can fight as hard as heterosexual men.

In the end, the whole article is based on the idea that only "army men" are supposed to fight in a war. That may be true according to international laws, but these laws are a pure fiction. During the XXth century, more than 80% of casualties were civilians.

A war is a fight of two countries, not two armies. Not that I like it, but just look at the facts. Ukraine is fighting back as a country, hence their incredible toughness and fortitude.

FrenchAmerican··on As Tech Tries to Hack Love, It May Be Killing It Instead
"At the end of the day, humans act in their best interest".

This point requires a demonstration. In fact, many studies conducted by experimental psychologists have proven this could not be taken for granted. People have many reasons not to act only in their best interest ; altruism is only one of them and much more common that expected.

That idea of self-interest is entrenched into the core of the field of micro-economics. From there, it has conquered the minds as a self-evident axiom.

It's also a cultural bias: it's widely accepted as true by most Americans - but it is so much not in many other countries.

FrenchAmerican··on Firefox now only available via snap on Ubuntu
As long as LibreWolf isn't snap-only... so we should contribute to their effort by funding them, if we want them to last.

"Pay your maintainers" should become the norm to all users of FLOSS. We must lobby our bosses to make regular donations to maintainers of the FOSS software used by the company. That's a purely rational business decision, not an ideological one.

FrenchAmerican··on Higher-income people are worried about the economy
They are totally aware of the stakes, but they don't care. In our world, the richer you get, the more you can escape the consequences that the poor, popular and middle classes have to endure.

The higher income class is de facto in power in our democracies. No conspiracy here, just a class phenomenon. The poor don't vote ; the popular and middle classes tend to elect people from the higher income class. Their economic success give them credits for handling things.

The higher income class doesn't care about 1/ the health of people 2/ if the wages are enough to have a modest but at leat descent life 3/ the environment

They care about 1/ their own wealth, health 2/ having no social constraints whatsoever (in the name of freedom, which is a right for all but they are the ones who have the means to act as free persons) 3/ order: they want a super policed society. So the poor are over-repressed by the police but they escape the law (connections, bribery, very good lawyers).

On climate disruption and biodiversity annihilation, our "elite" reveals that they don't even care for their grandchildren. The 0.1%, the top of the income elite, do care and buy large pieces of land in New Zealand with 100% self-sustainable houses and food production. And armed security and heliports.

FrenchAmerican··on A new tool for finding dark matter digs up nothing
I heard a podcast with top scientists about this (in French, still available online) about this: it's indeed a nickname for the phenomenon - but the scientists using it know that, of course.

However, this nickname is not absurd, in the sense that the gravity equations for the movement of stars in galaxies don't match the observation.

In order for the stars to move inside their galaxies at their observed speed, these galaxies should have much larger mass.

Hence the "dark matter".

Scientists do not all agree that there is an "invisible" matter to be found. Many think that Einstein's relativity has a more limited domain of validity than we thought.

But then the issue is as dark (in the sense of mysterious), since many of Einstein's predictions - based on his equations - have been observed in experimentations. The gravitational waves (LIGO experiment and other replications) appear to prove that the relativity equations are right. The precision of this instruments are extraordinary.

It's a terrible situation for Physics as a discipline: the equations are confirmed in all know situations, except this case (well, as far as I understood).

There are plenty of theories for explaining the phenomenon, but they lack an feasible experiment to see if their predictions match the observation.

Today, all the theories with feasible experiments have proven to be false. Physicists are stuck.

Many think that we need a new Einstein or a new Newton, meaning a genius among the geniuses, capable of think a whole new paradigm for gravity.

Gravity is a "law" and not a "force". It's as well the nickname for a phenomenon ; that phenomenon is sensible in the domain of validity of Newton, e.g. in our daily life.

The planets in the solar system move all accordingly with Newton's equations, except Mercury. Einstein had to totally put upside down the way we represent the world we live in, from a 3D world with a totally independent time to a 4D world, where everything and everyone live in its own spacetime.

Let's imagine two atomic clock set next to each other and synchronized. If we elevate one by 1 cm, then the clocks have a super slight desynchronizarion. And the tiny tiny difference match Einstein's equations.

Newton and Einstein are a few centuries apart. When will such genius reveal itself? Some physicists point that both were outsiders in their times. Nowadays, the knowledge is so vast that it takes ten years to master a fraction of it: by that time, a brain is so entrenched in the current representations that it's difficult to break the paradigm.

Others think likely that one of the theories already published is right but we'll need to wait a very long time, if ever, before being able to make the experiment that will prove it.

Maybe we will have to accept not being able to explain our universe. After all, since Gödel, mathematicians have kept going despite his proof that the mathematics are based on a quite fragile foundation.

I never quite understood that Gödel thing. Anyone to try and explain us that "dark" theorem?

FrenchAmerican··on Ukraine’s President Is in over His Head
This is pure Putin's propaganda.
FrenchAmerican··on Bacteria could be key to letting humans breathe on Mars
Hum. Being able to produce oxygen at very large is one thing, but creating an atmosphere is another.

There are reasons why Mars can't retain its atmosphere, even if those reasons are still a matter of scientific research. A search on the web will give you numerous papers on the issue, many from NASA.

There is no point sending humans into space, except to get the hundreds of billions of budget it requires.

NASA and SpaceX are manipulating the public opinion to fuel the dream of humans in space - despite no scientific gain.

We already know that humans are really not doing well in space.

Of course, the space industry will give the tautological argument that this is exactly why we must going on, to find solutions in the long term.

If the point is to understand the universe and make progress in all fields of Physics, robots are 10 times less expensive and more reliable.

See the rovers and the helicopter on Mars, the James Webb telescope and so many other examples.

The International Space Station has cost an gargantuan amount of money for the scientific results it produced - except about humans in space.

And precisely, these results say humans do poorly, and much more so than advertised. There is no conspiracy here, just the lack of interest of journalists to make that clear to the public. And the space industry is clever enough to fuel the dream of the public so that elected officials give them the dollars.

Source: I personally know one of the MD in charge of the medical conditions of astronauts in Europe. And my father is a space engineer and my aunt an astronomer, so I can say that this is common knowledge in the space industry and academia.

FrenchAmerican··on There's a new longest suspension bridge
Erdogan has turned into a despot, but that's a fact, not a prejudice.

According to its Wikipedia page, this bridge has been designed by a Danish firm and was built by a consortium of Korean and Turkish firms.

Let's all give up the whole notion of "national pride". It only leads to wars in the end. Many Russians are blinded by their national pride.

"I know it's a lie when I hear that the Russian army is bombing civilians in Ukraine: because it's just impossible" said a nice old Russian lady when interviewed. :-(

I'm both French and American, and majored in History. Nothing to be proud of, if you subtract all the massacres, imperial wars, torture, colonization, slavery, etc from the achievements.

Humans Rights are under duress in both countries (Guantanamo, police violence) ; the democracy is under attack in both - even if their respective political situations are totally different.

This bridge symbolizes in my opinion the great achievements made possible when humans choose to cooperate rather than compete in the zero-sum game of national prides.

So, a great bridge, the longest of its kind! Well done, everybody, impressive!

FrenchAmerican··on Photography is not Objective, Art is a Set of Choices
I'll extent that widely: bathroom decoration is art.

Marcel Duchamp famously made scandal with his "Fountain", which is precisely a bathroom element.

What he meant is that the gesture of declaring that a readymade object is art is art by itself.

So pure intent is art.

Some may find it ridiculous, but please try and reconsider: the scandal it provoked and the questioning about what art is - that was the intent of Duchamp when he declared that urinal (that he put upsidedown and signed) a piece of art.

And truly that gesture is still considered today as an important moment of the History of Art.

https://www.tate.org.uk/visit/tate-modern/display/materials-...

Paradoxically, some crafts by non-artists are considered ad art, despite being without any intent of art.

It's called "art brut" which translated from French would mean something like "raw art". Some guys do their thing for their own but their artistic value is difficult to miss.

https://www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/a/art-brut

So execution without intent can be art.

So what about bathroom decoration? Well, some people can turn their bathroom into a piece of art. They may be artists or common people.

But saying that doesn't mean that everything is art, just that we should pay attention and notice art when it appears to you, even in an unexpected place.

When you wrote "execution", you meant the material result produced. But the act of making art ... is also art.

Jackson Pollock is a famous painter but he's mainly remembered for the videos of him painting. Watching him is fascinating. The paintings themselves, well, not much so (some will disagree, and they are right to, more on this later).

I never saw a Pollock's painting in a museum without a video next to him showing him painting. He never asked that. But it's no mystery that he wanted to be filmed.

So the act of creation is art by itself.

But many disagree on the artistic value of most of modern and contemporary art, usually saying that their infant or a monkey could do it, or themselves.

So what is the place of judgment in art? In fact, it's a non-question. A piece of art doesn't exist if nobody look at it and/or experience it.

A book exists not because it's written but because someone reads it. The vast majority of the production of artists, writers, painters, sculptors is forgotten. Most of books that receive literary prizes are considered piece of xxx 50 years later. To the point where it's difficult to apprehend why it was considered as art... So we are right back at the beginning, right?

Well, no: experiencing a piece of art is not passive. The watcher or the reader is active. Phenomenology as well as scientific experiences have demonstrated that our senses are not passive. We build what we see and what we read. For example, when reading a novel, we build in our imagination a representation of the characters, the places etc. That's why watching a movie based on a novel is almost always disappointed. What we see on-screen doesn't match with our representation.

So the audience is a co-creator of a piece of art. Artists are absolutely divided on this: some consider that the audience is passive and the art is totally theirs. But that's just untrue, it's nothing but an ego issue. And nobody care about their opinion on this. If a writer dislike how a character is understood by its readers, well, what can he do about it? Once produced, a piece of art totally escapes from the artist's hands. Other artists go totally on the opposite side, saying plainly: 100% of what you feel and understand from my work is yours.

So the question if something is art or not is ... a non-question. In the end, what matters is what you, as someone of the audience, experience from it, in an active way since each if us - actively even if often unconsciously, co-creates the art.

What you feel, what your emotions are, the questions that arise in you, that is the only thing that matters. Art doesn't need validation. Nor fom any authorities like museums, neither a social consensus.

A proof of that? Go to a museum and look at paintings from, let's say, the XVIIIth century. The craft is often amazing. It's obvious that all those guys were super skilled. But do you feel something?

Well, some do, but I rarely. I appreciate the craft but most of the time I'm bored. Quite often I go to an exhibition and ... I'm disappointed. Because I didn't feel anything.

That's also true for super famous artists. The Sixtine Chapel from Michaelangelo? I stayed quite a while but couldn't see it. So it's not art? Obviously it is, but my art education is insufficient to apprehend it. It's like classical music. You need to learn it. And once again learning is not gulling data. It's an active process where you train your mind to see the world differently. It's also having the basic keys to decrypt what's in front of you.

I was raised in Brazil and frankly, classical music is hard. I have started my own modest education, just by listening the whole symphonies of the melodies everybody knows and likes. Little by little, I learn to appreciate. I haven't go far but well, it's getting enjoyable while I'm still totally uninterested by the Sixtine Chapel.

Too bad for me, and who cares if I consider art or not. I could say it's just a church "decoration".

So the whole debate of deciding if it's art or not is ... pointless. The only one interested are of 2 kinds:

- those making money with art. It's art if it has a financial value. As if a book was judged by the $21 you pay for it. Ridiculous but price depends from rarity, so it's important to them to build a totally arbitrary wall between what is art and what is not. Most of the museums are also in the same logic, hence their incapacity in general to display the art of our time.

- those who need social validation to make their own judgment. The mastery in painting reality as it appears to us, as if it was the true thing, is a socially constructed norm to design art. Why? Because it only reveals the mastery of crafting. As if being able to write verses that rhymes makes you a poet. It doesn't, does it? :-)

Consider music. When you dislike it, do you question it as being music? 99% of the time I don't. I just don't feel anything or I plainly dislike it.

So finally, art is a continuum, with no segmentation. From the intent (Duchamp) to the execution (Pollock painting) to the "piece of art" (which can be anything, like a graffiti or the soup cans of Warhol, e.g. simple industrial reproduction of a picture) to the active work from the audience grasping what they are able to from it.

Sometimes, it's easy to experience it: a great song, or the melting watches of Dali - which is a weird case because it's difficult to put the right words onto them (for me at least) but absolutely everybody remembers that picture once they have seen it. Many people don't know it's by Dali but somehow they can't help not remembering it.

Art is where you feel it. I remember some bathrooms. Many people decorate them without any limit, as if everything was permitted just in that place because it's for poo anyway, right? You can let your inner craziness express itself because this is a place where nobody is supposed to judge you on. It's for poo! The decoration of your living room is the exact opposite, the place where you display were you belong in the social hierarchy. It has a view on the skyline or not. It's leather or a basic fabric. It's a basic stuff from IKEA or an stylish leather couch.

Bathrooms are definitely the place where there is "art brut" to discover, and to discover that your friend has an artistic sense that he refrains to express elsewhere. Maybe they paint but they are reluctant to show you. Well, it's too soon, my production is shitty still... And back to the bathroom we are!

FrenchAmerican··on H.264 is Magic (2016)
I have read that both Chrome and Firefox now support it if one enable the proper option in the about:config page (and its Chrome equivalent, but I avoid Chrome by principle).

It's in my to do-list in the coming weeks, I have not verified this yet.

FrenchAmerican··on CIA black site detainee served as training prop to teach torture techniques
Indeed. The inefficiency of torture has been demonstrated many, many times.

It has also been recognized as such by many, many torturers.

People think torture works because they think that the guilty deserve it. In other words, they want to avenge.

Hence the never-ending rationalization of torture. People want the bad guys to suffer for what they have done.

A long torture represents the worse punishment possible. If the act is bad enough (like 9/11 or rape of a child), many people find it appropriate, and more so if they don't have to do it themselves.

The perpetrators of torture like it. They just need a narrative that justifies it, a narrative they believe in. In that case, quite a large part of us can become torturers if the circumstances put them in the situation.

Many people think that the average Joe would never torture, in any circumstances. It is just untrue. A human just need to be embedded in a group of people which values legitimate violence or torture.

If we have a social support to make it legitimate, most people can do terrible things.

Hence the mobs lynching a suspect - like that guy who was killed in Boston because an online mob pointed him as the perpetrator of the marathon bombs.

Hence the common soldiers of the German Wehrmacht on the eastern front, who participated in the killing of many Jews. The idea that only fanatic Nazis like the Waffen SS or the Einsatzgruppen were involved are just untrue. Many German - who have no issues recognizing their country's responsibilities and atrocities - still can't believe that the average soldier directly participated in the genocide. They did - as historians have demonstrated.

The genocide in Rwanda has also shown that. Most of Hutus' men participated in the genocide of the Tutsis, and most of women either supported it or acted in it.

In a given society in normal circumstances, there will always be people who want violence for itself. Efficiency to solve what the society consider punishable offers the perfect rationalization for their own need to be violent.

If you have an urge to be violent, one can become a cop or join a drug gang. Not that all cops are violent but many are. Many wives of cops or soldiers are beaten by their husband. Sorry to tell harsh truths.

But that can be different. The German police is nowadays known for its specific values. In France, were I live, cops are getting always more violent without any reason for it, just a slow radicalization to far-right ideas and values. More than 60% in the police force now vote for the far-right. This is known through their actual vote when they elect their unions' representatives.

Violence is the norm in most "force institutions" (police, army, intelligence services) in most countries, including democracies. Torture is merely the exacerbation of it in special circumstances where the crime is considered so bad that the uttermost violence is legitimized.

In average, during the XXth century, 90% of casualties during the war were civilians.

When fighting the Germans and the Japanese during WWII, the "good" countries like the USA and the UK went at length to use terror against the civilians - sharing with Hitler the idea that if the people is demoralized by intense bombings, it will force their military to stop the war. Dresden and Tokyo were both bombed with incendiary devices. In Dresden, 130 000 casualties during a sole night, 95% being civilians.

Humans are nor violent nor peaceful by nature. They are social animals who behave according to the current social norms of their social group.

Obama was a splendid President, very respectful of the Constitution - and I gladly voted for him. But he went along with the drone war in Afghanistan, with a large number of collateral casualties. Basically, 5 year-old children of djihadists can legitimately be killed if they happen to be nearby their father when a drone located him. Collateral damages, necessary for the greater good.

The Obamas have become very close to George Bush Jr. They can't stop saying how much a nice guy he is. Except that this guy should be trialed by the International Court of Justice if not by the American legal system for invading and occupying Iraq on fabricated grounds.

How can these super cultivated people and so decent people like the Obamas befriend GWBb Jr? Well, they have been in power as well and that experience has immerged them into the social norms of Washington. Very few are the one capable of keeping a true moral compass while embedded in a specific social class.

I'm no exception to this. I try to be a good guy but I identify myself as the guy in the Star Wars movie who wonders: Are we the baddies?

FrenchAmerican··on Cyber attack in Israel prompts declaration of emergency state
Isn't it the second time only that a whole country goes on emergency alert for a cyber attack? The first was Estonia in 2007.

Others cases I forgot?

Israel has super good cyber capacities, so that attack must be massive and/or highly effective.

This is the main information: such attacks are possible, not irrational fear or fruit of imagination.

On Twitter, everybody is pointing the finger to Iran - because Iranians have motive - but without any proof.

Has Iran developed such cyber attack capacities? Always possible, let's not prejudice taint our judgment. But that would be news. Iran (or another enemy of Israel) could also have recruited "cyber mercenaries". Or are those a myth?

I'm no expert but my understanding is that very few countries have developed such an high level: the USA and China. I would have added Russia but we haven't seen obvious cyber victories over Ukraine yet, so... One explanation could be that Russia is on the defensive mode on the cyber front, being attacked by many black and white hat groups, plus Ukrainians of course.

North Korea has shown real capacity, like the steal of 190 M$ from the central bank of Bangladesh. The BBC made an amazing 8-hour podcast about this heist. A super tiny detail led to an early blocking of the money transfer, otherwise the theft would have amounted to almost 1 B$!

But the podcast explained that their "cyberwarriors" have for main mission to steal money in foreign currencies, so that NK can circumvent the sanctions and import what they need the most.

China making a point to the USA by attacking one of its closest ally? This attack happens the day when US and Chinese meet in Rome to discuss China's position on Putin's invasion of Ukraine.

Well, let's wait and see if Israel denounce a culprit. But if it is China, for example, Israel may attribute the responsibility to Iran, since it would provide justification for the future.

I'm just thinking aloud here, for the sake of mind play. What do you imagine possible?

FrenchAmerican··on What is so ancient only an Internet veteran can remember?
Knowing Louis Pouzin's work and role in the birth of the internet.

I'm not a veteran by far but I had - with very little merit - the honor to talk with him about that period.

Such a nice person. He knew had how important his work had been but as well that he was one among the tens of people who were keys to this collective achievement.

In respect to his own modesty, there is a link to the Internet pioneers' Wikipedia page - where his role is explained among all the other pioneers: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_pioneers

FrenchAmerican··on “Zero To Production In Rust” is complete
I'm tired tonight and my brain read the title as "Zero to production in Russia". :-)
FrenchAmerican··on Ask HN: How to Pay Russian Contractors?
Even if it is legal, it's still morally problematic.

The point is no about the persons you want to pay, but because you send dollars to a country that needs these dollars to sustain its war to Ukraine.

Of course, the EU sends €1B ... per day to Russia to pay for its petroleum and natural gas. As if we could not drastically cut our energy use if we wanted to.

Many will protest that it is indeed impossible but Covid has shown that confining whole countries for three weeks is possible ; it has also shown that the EU could find €1 trillion to save its economy - a sum that was said to be impossible to find to save the planet from climate dereliction and collapse of biodiversity.

If the EU stopped suddenly paying Russia, the war in Ukraine would be shortened for certain. That would imply of course to share the available energy between the EU countries ; our politicians are really fierce on helping Ukraine - except if it impacts our economies. I'm ashamed as an European, really.

NB: yes, I do realize the EU level of dependency towards Russia. Yes, that would be difficult. But that's the price to show the world that we are really to fight for democracy.

Putin thought he could invade Ukraine because of his perception of our lack of will to fight for democracy, precisely. He was not wrong: it's only the Ukrainians' incredible spirit of resistance that forced the West to really oppose it with supplies of weapons and sanctions. Had the Ukrainians not resisted that well, it would have been like Crimea.

China is watching. We must do more in the EU and close all the pipelines from Russia.

FrenchAmerican··on Hi, I’m Russian. Ukraine and Russia is a story of a divorce
It's interesting to read you. Where did you get that idea that OTAN is menacing Russia? OTAN is a defensive coalition only. If the USA had the very unlikely idea to attack Russia, do you think that most of other NATO countries, situated in Europe, will join??? You think that OTAN as an empire, and more specifically as if it was the name of the American empire. It is not.

OTAN was a coalition built to protect its members from the USSR. After 1991, it had no real use until September 11. And then it was again there without true need. Last year, the French president publicly wondered what was OTAN was for... Well, "thanks to" Putin, we all know for sure that we need OTAN to protect us from Putin's imperialism. Otherwise, this costly organization would have slowly sunk into limbs.

If Ukraine wanted to join NATO, it was for protection after Russian's grabs of parts of its territory. Ukraine was obviously right to ask to join. The NATO members were far from wanting that, because they did not want to be directly implicated in an Russia / Ukraine war.

The whole notion that Russia would need buffer countries between itself and NATO is ridiculous. Russia has had several direct frontiers with NATO (Poland, Baltic countries) for the last 30 years (!) without any threat.

The EU was build to avoid wars between its members. We don't want wars anymore, hot or cold. Russia has absolutely nothing to fear on its western frontier. Which European country would be nowadays stupid enough to try to invade Russia??? As if France or Poland would by itself try to attack Russia? Oh, the USA? Well, I can't imagine it but even so, that would not be coming from Europe. Don't think for one second that other European countries would join a common attack from the USA allied to Poland. I'm trying here to find a plausible scenario that could justify your fear to be attacked on its western frontier. None is plausible.

This "Russian fear" has no rational ground. Citing Napoleon and Hitler doesn't work either. They both failed, remember??? The one lesson from History is "do not attack Russia in any case, you will be defeated". To retain from the past that an invasion from the West is always possible is just a justification for prevention attacks TO the west. What about Germany, you could ask. Well, precisely: 9 out of 10 Nazi soldiers were killed by the Red Army. Yes, sorry John Wayne and valiant Englishmen, but most of the work was done by the USSR.

The two last arguments are just atrocious. So Ukraine has found fossil fuels and you fear competition. Poor you... France produce only 1% of its petrol and 3% natural gas'/consumption. But France GDP is the 6th or the 7th in the world and Russia is only 12th with many more people. So... get to work and stop thinking like Putin that you are all like Emiratis that are rich without working. And please stop crying about yourselves: your school system is at least as good as the French one. You are not an African country. Russia was flying in space and exploding nuclear bombs ten years before France. Your problem is Putin and his kleptocracy. It's time to stop fantasies about a nonexistent threat from the West and start a revolution: it's time for democracy in Russia, so that you can develop your economy properly. If your leaders stopped stealing hundreds of billions from the Russian people and making wars without reason, Russia's economy would grow very fast. Look at South Korea: in 50 years they went from poverty to super high way of living. Russia is today far far more advanced than South Korea in 1953 (e.g. after the Korean war). In 20 years, Russians could have the same GDP per inhabitant as France or even better (thanks to fossil fuels, huge agriculture, super good IT sector etc).

Your fear of the West is a way to hide the terrible reality: Russians are afraid of Putin and his regime. I would be too, if I was Russian, believe me. Stop deflecting your internal issues into aggressiveness towards the West.

And, by the way, Russia has the nuclear bomb! Well, more exactly about 4,000 nuclear heads (like the USA more or less). And you need Ukraine to protect your territory? This is so ridiculous in all cases because there is absolutely no military threat from European countries. The only threatening power to your territory is ... China.

Do you still think the USA is interested in invading Russia? What for? California alone as the same GDP as France. They have plenty of petrol and natural gas, plenty of land. Nothing to gain. The USA is in competition with China in the middle term. Yesterday, Russia asked China for military assistance... meaning that the invasion of Ukraine is:

1/ a military failure already (Russia may win the battles but its military weakness has been proven: 17 days into thr war and you don't own the air yet? Nobody could have imagined Russia army being so little operational, and today everybody knows.

2/ OTAN is revived for the next 50 years and will probably enlarge to Sweden and Finland. And also Ukraine when Russian troops will finally retreat, having totally erased all Ukraine's cities, making Kiyv and Karkhiv look like Grozny or Alepo, a large cemetery of concrete. You'll call that a victory, because you'll keep some parts of it (maybe) but without seeing the contradiction of calling Ukrainians your own blood and killing a few tens or hundred of thousands of them - and erasing from Earth some of the most beautiful cities in the world. But victory it is, yeah.

3/ Russia will become a vassal of China or... will lose the Ukrainian war. Because that war is going to last not months but years, simply because the Ukrainian people won't submit and that the West will provide them with weapons and money. Like we did in Afghanistan. Like the USSR and China did in Vietnam to defeat the US army. No army can defeat a people that won't submit. That's one of the few things that History teaches.

So China will become your first client for petrol and natural gas, and agriculture etc. And everything you'll want to import from the West will have to come through China. And as China is more and more on an imperialist path, you'll have to fight along them in wars that are no direct concern to you.

So keep on fantasizing on the western threat and keep lying to yourselves that you are your own enemy. Putin and his regime are of course responsible for this war. I don't think that the Russian people wanted this war, even if I have doubt's after reading you, really. In all cases, at the end, one people is responsible for not revolting against its dictators. Democracy is a never-ending process. Historians say that the French Revolution started in 1789 but really reached its goal, a parliamentary democracy, in 1875. So start organizing and demonstrating in the streets of Moscow. We French are still very regularly demonstrating against our government. The USA's democracy is in a poor state, with a very polarized society - and yes, Trump almost succeeded in its coup, and he will try again, with Russian money once again (and Chinese in 2024 for sure).

Democracy is not a well of petrol you find one day. A political regime is possible only when democratic values are really deeply integrated in a people way of thinking. The Maidan protest had shown that Ukrainians are globally a democratic people ; whatever happens in this war won't change that because it takes tens of years. That's why the USA failed very predictably in trying to impose democracy to Iraq. The Iraqis are not a democratic people yet. We thought that Russia was on its way, then Putin came to power.

So no, Russia and Ukraine is not a "divorce", that is stupid, but finding rationality to Ukraine's invasion in security reasons and petrol & water reasons is just ... I don't have words, really. My point is not to vex you by using bad words - just to try and make you understand that your perception of reality is very difficult to understand for a French American living in France for most of his life.

To tell you the truth, I'm ashamed by my own French president, the young and bright and good-looking Macron. To me, he is not a true democrat. He has not defended democracy in the French political system but has rather diminished it - making it much more like a presidential regime than a parliamentary regime. More like the USA except that the Congress has much much more power in the USA that the French Congress (meaning House + Senate). The police in France has turned violent, racist. About two-third of the police force vote for the far-right. Democracy is not going that well in France either.

You have to fight for democracy in Russia. You should let Ukrainians decide for themselves what is good for them, even if you don't like it: that's the basis of democracy. And I have to fight for democracy both in France and in the USA - by democratic means of course.

To each his own fight. Stop deflecting your collective weakness towards Putin's regime into fear and aggressiveness to Central and Western Europe - and even the USA (which military hubris is a problem, I reckon). Do your "homework". Leave other countries, especially infant democracy like Ukraine alone. Most of European countries have no issues with the Russian people. Really. Well, there is resentment in Central Europe that was jailed by the Soviet Iron Curtain, of course. But time goes by. Look at us, French and German: there is no resentment anymore. It has taken 40 years after WWII.

History teaches the lessons you decide to retain from it.

FrenchAmerican··on Climate change won’t wait for future innovation – we need action now
"anti-civilization agenda": well, no, but I see what you mean (I think). Most ecologists do promote another civilization, since they believe - rightly or not - that our current civilization will lead to an environmental collapse.

Deep ecologists have decided once and for all that technology and science won't provide the solution, hence what you call their " anti-civilization agenda".

Let's take a step back and look at things calmly. You want not to be restrained in your way of life. But a better efficiency enable to do the same with less energy. So you'd be not restrained in any way. Therefore there is no reason to want to use "more energy" as a goal by itself.

Better efficiency implies batter technologies and better Science. This is where too many ecologists get it wrong.

However, we can also say that technologies don't mechanically provide a better world.

Biotechnology has resulted in a massive use of pesticides that kills biodiversity while the agro-tech business make people fat through over-processed food and ingredients bad for health.

Technology also enable us to do industrial wonders but they also pollute (rare metal extraction for example).

Eating food bad for your health and living within high level of pollution don't look to me as great civilizational achievements, do they?

Last point: we need "clean energy", not "cleaner". Science has demonstrated how fast climate changes and biodiversity plummets. In the short term, the cleaner, the better - but that can last only during a rather short transition time to really clean energy.

Many countries have at last got out of endemic poverty. Many African countries before the Covid were growing their GDP by 3 to 5% per year. It's great but that means their use of energy is rising fast.

So to stop the climate change, we really need to transition much faster. Many ecologists don't see that transition even starting ; neither do they see science and technology provide the solution on the coming years. Hence their agenda of rationing.

I can't see that agenda being politically feasible. I personally conclude that we will hit a wall collectively. When climate will be so bad and the collapse of biodiversity will directly hit our way or life, then we will take the hard decisions.

I don't believe in a civilization collapse. Books by true historians have debunked every claim of a civilization collapse due to overuse of the natural resources. And even so, we are super resilient animals, super efficient as organizing and adapting when necessary.

But, as you rightly pointed out, we are not equal in this world. The huge costs when hitting the wall will not be fairly splitted. The wealthier you are in a wealthier country you are, the less you are likely to suffer from it.

Since you don't want any change in your way of life, you should aim to belong to the 1%. Because 99% of us will have to change.

And even so, being part of the 1% doesn't protect you totally, far from it. Driving a Bugatti won't matter much if a tree fall onto you because of a big storm. And you won't escape a pandemic either.

Some people prefer to be super rich and live in fear all the time of being attacked. I prefer a system where every job provides a decent way of life so streets are safe.

That is the same for climate. Some will prefer living in huge mansions with underground self-sufficient bunkers. I prefer that everyone gets to live in a super energy efficient place so that we don't need bunkers against tornadoes. Because when the tornado arrives, you'll making an errand 30 miles away and your children will be 10 miles from that bunker as well.

The solution is collective. Hence my pessimism: we will change our way of life only when it will have become unbearable. Nature will be deep into the already current 6th extinction, meaning that it will restart despite us. But that takes thousands of years. So we will have to change our way of life starting from a low point rather than starting now.

So the ecologists' agenda is not irrational. That may hurt your wanting to keep your way of life. Maybe you will be able to. But your children and your grandchildren will have quite different conditions.

Except if Science and technology provides a way out. Many bet on it. That's not irrational either but the time is the issue. We need to capture huge amounts of CO2 and methane in the next 20 years to maintain our way of life. Is this a reasonable bet?

Well, if we collectively invested trillions of dollars to reach that goal, I may take the bet. For now, we prefer bail-out the wealthier of us ; and some lunatics leaders around the world will force us to spend that money on the military.

"Good night and good luck".

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →