HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

FridgeSeal

7,095 karma · joined March 20, 2017

Opinions are my own etc etc etc
submissionscomments
FridgeSeal··on pg_flo – Stream, transform, and re-route PostgreSQL data in real-time
> how it first must copy the whole CDC state to kafka

There’s a setting that controls whether it will do a snapshot first. Turn it off and it will just start sending through new cdc entries.

> you must set the kafka retention time to infinity

Is this a new retirement? I’ve never had to do this.

FridgeSeal··on Get me out of data hell
Once again. Because clearly this needs to be said loudly and repeatedly.

That is a _technical solution_ to a fundamentally _social_ problem.

FridgeSeal··on Prisma Postgres – Runs on bare metal and unikernels
Nice, this is very cool.

Very much of the opinion that the Unikernel stuff (and especially what UniKraft are offering) is being massively slept on.

FridgeSeal··on Ink: React for interactive CLI apps
Rudy, Haskell, Ocaml are obvious examples.
FridgeSeal··on Pushing the frontiers of audio generation
Yes but many people have jobs in their fields, which benefits their personal and/or public creative endeavours.

I’ve learnt things and been exposed to ideas developing software for work that I simply wouldn’t have if I was only doing it in my spare time.

FridgeSeal··on Debian’s “secret” sauce
> but "in Debian, we like to improve things" by "applying our own judgment" to the code.

Mmhhmm, yes I’m sure you Know Better™ but maybe don’t complain when you do this to yourself, and then it makes your life hard?

FridgeSeal··on Optimizers need a rethink
How would this model handle code that needs to be as fast as possible, at the cost of debugging? E.g. all hot-loop code, all high performance numerical code, all latency sensitive and instruction sensitive code?

> If your optimization is that situation specific, it should stay stuck in "experimental".

Yeah, I have a feeling that there’s low-key lots of applications for whom many compiler optimisations that you’re branding “experimental” are in fact run-of-the-mill and would just enable “experimental” mode so frequently it’d just be synonymous with “actually release mode”.

> And through all of this, the compiler should also eject files that carry enough information to allow debuggers to make sense of the compiled code, unwind the optimizations when the users asks, and present a coherent version of what is going on.

This is a pretty cool idea, semi-related, you should check out some of the work around E-Graphs, which attempt to enable the same level of optimisations but also preserve more original context. It’d be neat to have the equivalent of source-maps for highly optimised code, but I’m not sure how we’d manage them without them becoming enormous. After things like inlining, constant-folding, desugaring, rearrangement operations, etc all take place I suspect you’d be left with code that bears only the merest passing resemblance to its original form.

FridgeSeal··on The global surveillance free-for-all in mobile ad data
To add to your points:

> Could people read terms of service…

Even if they do read licences and such, companies have a vested interest in making them as complicated, obtuse and self-serving that you have close to no recourse. It’s weasel-worded to the nth degree. They also change them largely at their leisure, and if the new terms are bad, again, there’s often very little you can do.

“If consumers don’t like it, they wouldn’t buy it” is the other lie that’s successfully kept itself alive. Consumers are kept time and spare-resource poor, and are largely presented with a predefined set of options to choose from that the companies at play feel like presenting us with. Rarely is there an _actual_ varied choice. Only the illusion. Combine that with scenarios in other industries like enterprise sales where the “customer” is an exec and the user just gets lumped with some garbage software.

FridgeSeal··on Perplexity AI's new tool for researching the stock market
Tbf, I’ve had friends in finance describe the Millennium fund (now Medallion fund I think?) as operating in a very, very specific niche of the market. Probably helps that it’s limited to a very select group. Its extraordinary impressive for sure, but I don’t think it is widely applicable or comparable.
FridgeSeal··on Perplexity AI's new tool for researching the stock market
You think the people with the stuff that even “sort of works” are likely to be giving up that edge?
FridgeSeal··on The IPv6 Transition
Yeah exactly.

I have a friend who works in the networking division of a telco in my country, their team had to spend significant time and effort educating a PM who was dead-to-rights convinced that IPv6 was “less secure” and seemed to think that IPv6 didn’t have subnets and that NAT’s were the same as firewalls and refused to be convinced otherwise.

People like that make any forward progress extremely difficult.

FridgeSeal··on Skeptical of rewriting JavaScript tools in "faster" languages
Bit rich to complain about that when all the major browsers have just as significant differences, and that’s before we bring node into the equation, let alone talking about a good 30% of websites I visit with any quantity of JS in them are either perpetually broken in some way, or so jank as to be effectively broken.
FridgeSeal··on Skeptical of rewriting JavaScript tools in "faster" languages
Presumably because, apart from Python (see Ruff, uv, etc) most languages aren’t running into such major issues with their own “self hosted” tooling that it’s worthwhile to rewrite several of them in a completely different language.
FridgeSeal··on Skeptical of rewriting JavaScript tools in "faster" languages
Well curious as to what some of these ideas might be.

NPM has done a pretty great job of showing everyone else what to avoid doing.

The mere mention of “web pack” sends most of the FE devs I’ve met into borderline trauma flashbacks.

There’s seemingly half a dozen package managements tools, some of which also seem to be compilers? There’s also bundlers, but again some of these seem integrated. Half of the frameworks seem to ship their own tools?

FridgeSeal··on Skeptical of rewriting JavaScript tools in "faster" languages
I swear some JS devs will go out of their way to avoid learning anything else, whilst simultaneously and breathlessly espousing that we rewrite everything else in JS.
FridgeSeal··on The IPv6 Transition
Whilst I agree with you, I rather depressingly suspect a lot of people equate NAT with “security”.
FridgeSeal··on QUIC is not quick enough over fast internet
Because Google puts whatever they want in their browser for you to beta test and you’ll be pleased about it, peasant /s.
FridgeSeal··on QUIC is not quick enough over fast internet
QUIC isn’t HTTP, QUIC is a protocol that operates at a similar level to UDP and TCP.

HTTP/3 is HTTP over QUIC. HTTP protocols v2 and onwards use binary headers. QUIC, by design, does 0-RTT handshakes.

> Yes, in theory UDP is faster than TCP but only when you completely abandon integrity

The point of QUIC, is that it enables application/userspace level reconstruction with UDP levels of performance. There’s no integrity being abandoned here: packets are free to arrive out of order, across independent sub-streams, and the protocol machinery puts them back together. QUIC also supports full bidirectional streams, so HTTP/3 also benefits from this directly. QUIC/HTTP3 also supports multiple streams per client with backpressure per substream.

Web-sockets are a pretty limited special case, built on-top of HTTP and TCP. You literally form the http connection and then upgrade it to web-sockets, it’s still TCP underneath.

Tl;Dr: your gripes are legitimate, but they refer to HTTP/1.1 at most, QUIC and HTTP/3 are far more sophisticated and performant protocols.

FridgeSeal··on Show HN: Vortex – a high-performance columnar file format
I mean, you can have it you’ve just got to be happy to bear the cost of rewriting the file every time you mutate a row.
FridgeSeal··on How I Experience Web Today (2021)
Don’t forget finally landing on the page and having the focus immediately stolen by some “LOG IN WITH GOOGLE” pop up that you didn’t ask for, and don’t want.
FridgeSeal··on Splitting engineering teams into defense and offense
Whilst I very much agree with you, actually doing this properly and pulling this off requires PM’s and/or Account Managers who are willing and capable of _actually managing_ customers.

Many, many people I’ve dealt with in these roles don’t or can’t, and seem to think their sole task is to mainline customer needs into dev teams. The PM’s I’ve had who _actually_ do manage back properly had happier dev teams, and ultimately happier clients, it’s not a mystery, but for some reason it’s a rare skill.

FridgeSeal··on Splitting engineering teams into defense and offense
> For example, sending us unfinished designs and requirements that haven’t been fully thought through

Oh man. Once had a founder who did this to the dev team: blurry, pixelated screenshots with 2 or 3 arrows and vague “do something like <massively under specified statement>”.

The team _requested_ that we have a bit more detail and clarity in the designs, because it was causing us significant slowdown and we were told “be quiet, stop complaining, it’s a ‘team effort’ so you’re just as at fault too”.

Unsurprisingly, morale was low and all the good people left quickly.

FridgeSeal··on Embedded Rust in Production?
> For being a relatively new language, there are almost no "entry level" positions.

Isn’t this a fairly well-known phenomenon though?

- new language makes waves. The people who picked it up early do some impressive stuff.

- early early adopter companies either snap them, or internally make the choice to learn it too. In turn, they do some stuff with it.

- gets a reputation for being the hot new thing. Other companies “want in on it”- they want to be able to do the fancy cool things the other places did, but they don’t have the patience, time or culture to grow it themselves so they aim to hire out seniors and everyone with lots of prior experience. <——- many orgs are here.

- proliferates enough that it’s well and truly mainstream. Also known as the “hire 1000 Java devs and throw bodies at stuff” stage of hiring and availability. Python, Node, Java, PHP, etc are here.

FridgeSeal··on Embedded Rust in Production?
100% this. Well put.

The Rust codebase I’ve built on run faster, don’t crash, are more correct, and take only marginally longer than the first python version. They’re easier to maintain, they’re easier to upgrade their dependencies, I’m more confident about asserting guarantees from the codebase, and it’s an easier time onboarding people and having them meaningfully contribute. There’s no more death-by-a-thousand-cuts that I experienced with Python codebases. I don’t have to worry about my Rust codebases blowing up at 2am because of some random exception.

I am defs not going back.

FridgeSeal··on Embedded Rust in Production?
God I feel like I’m taking crazy pills when I read these threads.

Can I hire 1000 Rust devs at the drop of a hat off the street? Well, no. Have I ever struggled to find competent Rust devs, or high level people who were happy to learn? Nope.

I would absolutely not be afraid to use it because of “hiring concerns”. If your current devs can’t or won’t learn anything new, they’re not very good at their job. If you can’t or won’t hire because you can’t find a super-senior at the drop of a hat, well, your hiring process is broken and no language will really help there.

FridgeSeal··on Diffusion for World Modeling
Gosh can you imagine how frustrating a game would be when you can _barely_ do anything reliably?

Wanted to jump on the platform? Wow too bad, model had a little day-dream and now you’re floating somewhere. Wanted to peak a corner? Oops too bad, model had a moment and now the wall curves differently. Trying to pick a shot-well you’d definitely hit the other player if the model wasn’t making physics go out the window. Inconsistently.

FridgeSeal··on Diffusion for World Modeling
Gosh I’m so excited for AAA games to get _even more garbage_ once this gets good enough for investor-driven studios to start slinging out AI driven, hyper-derivative, low-effort slop with even less effort.

We all thought Sports-Game $CURRENT_YEAR or CoD/MW MicroTransaction-Garbage was bottom of the barrel, a whole new world of fresh hell awaits us!

FridgeSeal··on FLUX is fast and it's open source
“I have successfully destabilised many countries with only a few tanks”.
FridgeSeal··on Io_uring and seccomp (2022)
Surely this is a seccomp shortcoming, or kernel auth shortcoming, rather than an io_uring problem?

That is, seccomp is (apparently? I’ve never used it myself) capable of intercepting direct calls. Obviously, that design isn’t going to be able to handle “indirect” calls in its default implementation.

Either seccomp needs a way to act on the buffer or intercept io_uring calls, or there’s a need for a new auth mechanism that’s capable of handling io_uring style API’s.

Torpedoing the whole api (a la gcp) feels like throwing the baby out with the bath water.

FridgeSeal··on How to make Product give a shit about your architecture proposal
Your comment has big “you’re just ticket monkeys” energy.

> A plumber isn’t going to refuse adding another bathroom to your house, they’re going to tell you how it can be done and tell you the cost

Let me know how the plumber reacts when you then tell him said bathroom needs to be freestanding 300m in the air, and the plumbing needs to be made out painted twigs and twine (because your housemate thinks they look pretty), and you also want heated stone floors and you have a budget of $250 and an ice-cream wrapper.

In the miraculous case said plumber accepts the job, make sure to change specs halfway through.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →