HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Gaelan

2,595 karma · joined May 4, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/gaelan; my proof: https://keybase.io/gaelan/sigs/_8scLuddlnin3n7WEWudnzDROREeNEEYYEaN-cEvn5U ]
submissionscomments
Gaelan··on If Apple is the only organisation defending our privacy, it is time to worry
That tweet's been deleted, so it's hard to judge it exactly, but my recollection is that someone else pointed out "payment data" here is just App Store, iTunes, etc purchases. "Apple targets ads on the app store based on previous app store purchases" is, IMO, much less of a privacy invasion than "Facebook targets ads based on your friends list, messages, browsing history, real-life purchases, and other things I can't think of off the top of my head".

Apple's profile of me, I imagine, is much less detailed than Facebook's, despite Apple's capability to build just as much of one (after all, they own iMessage and my iCloud contacts) if they wanted to.

Gaelan··on Animated GIF uses over 35GB RAM in Acorn on M1 Mac, likely due to memory leak
iOS Safari seems to render it with no performance issues. Interestingly, it can’t seem to decide whether the background is black or green—it’s different each time I load the gif.
Gaelan··on Undefined behavior in C is a reading error
I was under the impression the "committee" here was the people who wrote the C standard? So the accepted interpretation by the people who wrote the document must be the intended meaning, no? If it wasn't, they'd have written something else.

(Sure, it's possible they wrote something, then only later came to understand the implications of this. But the standard has been understood as allowing nasal demons since long before the latest revision of the C standard, so I'd argue that by publishing a new version without rewording that section, they're making clear that they intend its current interpretation to be part of the standard.)

Gaelan··on Undefined behavior in C is a reading error
> and the commtitee

I'd argue that for a document like the C standard, if there's a well-known intended meaning, that is the meaning of the document - any other interpretation is purely academic.

Gaelan··on UK Rail services to come under unified state control
Can they still do that, now that the ScotRail franchise is (presumably) no more?
Gaelan··on Apple Music Announces Spatial Audio and Lossless Audio
That's what I said.
Gaelan··on Cosmopolitan Libc 1.0
Iirc, APE starts with a (Windows) PE header, which is also a valid shebang-less shell script; when invoked on Unix, the shell script replaces the beginning of the file with an ELF/Mach-O header and invokes itself.
Gaelan··on Apple Music Announces Spatial Audio and Lossless Audio
> But, and this the article does not mention, is not what Apple Music wants you to do. The formats will be proprietary with DRM.

For what it’s worth, music actually purchased on iTunes (not an Apple Music subscription) has been DRM-free for years. If this means iTunes-purchased songs are lossless now, that might be useful.

Gaelan··on Starting in August, Google will require that they sign apps, not you
That doesn't work if there's a large and possibly growing matrix of hardware/OS/whatever combinations they're trying to optimize for.
Gaelan··on Things you can’t do in Rust (and what to do instead)
I always thought of Rust's enums as simply a generalization of other languages' enum concepts, not a completely different thing.
Gaelan··on DarkSide ransomware gang quits after servers, Bitcoin stash seized
I mean it doesn’t require ASICS, it’s just inefficient not to, right? Shouldn’t it be theoretically possible to mount a 51% attack with conventional CPUs (or GPUs), just a lot more of them? I have no idea what kind of computing resources various major states have, but I wouldn’t completely write off the possibility that they have enough CPUs to throw at the problem.
Gaelan··on Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom
Has anyone attempted to find this transaction on the blockchain?
Gaelan··on Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom
The issue is that a tumbler doesn't make the dirty money go away, quite the opposite; it gives a bunch of other people little bits of dirty money. If I were a non-criminal, or even a smaller-time criminal, it wouldn't be in my best interests to use a tumbler that might give me this dirty money.
Gaelan··on Google Docs will now use canvas based rendering
While “text in a VCS” is a great option, it’s obviously far less usable than something like Google Docs, and you still don’t get real-time collaboration, which can be really nice.
Gaelan··on Google Docs will now use canvas based rendering
I assume your parent means the result of clicking inspect element in the (pre-canvas) editor.
Gaelan··on Google Docs will now use canvas based rendering
> eg. declare variable up front, not within loops

I have trouble believing modern JS engines wouldn’t optimize this to the same thing.

Gaelan··on Google Docs will now use canvas based rendering
Would anyone mind explaining/screenshotting what it does, for the benefit of those of us on phones?
Gaelan··on Apple’s AirTag trackers made it frighteningly easy to ‘stalk’ me in a test
Any reason for that, other than lack of political will?
Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
Yeah, I suppose that is what I am arguing. Apple is absolutely an abusive monopoly, but tackling them alone without simultaneously handling Facebook and co would result in a net loss for the average consumer.
Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
Citation needed?
Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
Sure, but Chromium, which is ~identical, is.
Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
The top 10 free apps on the App Store, at time of writing, are TikTok, HBO Max, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, Messenger, Snapchat, Zoom, Gmail, and Google Maps. Until Gmail, every single one of those provides access to content that can't be accessed thorough another app—a more ethical Snapchat doesn't have any of my Snapchat-using friends, and a more ethical HBO Max doesn't have the movie I want to watch. So no, in practice, the option is to get the app, wherever it's available, or decide to do without whatever it's offering.
Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
> You could very easily not install any other store

But in practice, there are apps we need to use—people who we mostly communicate with over Facebook, movies we want to want that are only on Netflix, etc. In the status quo, we can use those apps, and they're beholden to Apple's guidelines, hopefully reducing the privacy, etc abuses. I can use Facebook and still have some amount of privacy.

In the world where alternate stores exist, I have to choose between using Facebook or having some amount of privacy. Sure, I could not use Facebook, but I'm a real human living in the real world, and that means I miss out on social opportunities that I would rather not miss out on. I—and the vast majority of iOS users, who aren't particularly interested in 3rd party stores—lose a less-terrible Facebook app.

(Not that I'm too happy with Apple here either. Some of Apple's policies are bizarre and abusive, and there are apps I'd like to run that aren't allowed. But I'm not entirely sure it's worth the tradeoff.)

Gaelan··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
That's the thing: Apple's exercising market power does bring all sorts of benefits to users. Obvious examples include the new privacy rules they're imposing, in-app purchases allowing any subscriptions to be cancelled with zero hassle. If Apple allowed other app stores, Facebook would almost certainly move to one that let them produce a far more invasive app. And the vast majority of the users will just download Facebook from the new store, because most people (myself included, tbh) value convenience over any absolutist stances about the software they use—see the past several decades of the free software movement.

The net result: Apple losing their monopoly means a huge influx of user-hostile behavior in apps.

Now, you're not wrong either—Apple does, in some cases, abuse their monopoly, and probably takes more of a cut than is fair from IAPs. (Although, quite frankly, I'd be shocked if the money from cheaper IAPs went to reducing prices and not increasing profits.) So yes, Apple's behavior here is harmful in some ways, but it does good in others. Like pretty much everything in this world, it ain't black and white.

Gaelan··on Apple sued for terminating account with $25k worth of apps and videos
> there's a clause making that debt senior to any future we-terminated-your-account liabilities

How does that work? Surely that’d have to be something agreed to by both the lender and the customers?

Gaelan··on Why Lichess will always be free
I read the comment as "a city like Portland, but…"
Gaelan··on Apple’s M1 Positioning Mocks the Entire x86 Business Model
If you mean specifically an Apple Silicon game console, that's the Apple TV.
Gaelan··on Apple’s M1 Positioning Mocks the Entire x86 Business Model
I expect this will be the case with Linux on the M1 in a year or two, given the pace of marcan's work. Windows depends on Microsoft's willingness, of course.
Gaelan··on GitHub Actions update: Helping maintainers combat bad actors
Previously, PRs would automatically cause actions to be run, for all users. So users could notice and fix CI failures themselves, and maintainers could see that CI was passing they first looked at the PR. The maintainer needs to touch the PR a minimum of once: look at the code, see CI passes, merge. Now, the maintainer has to look at the code and approve, at which point they have to wait for CI to pass, then come back later and merge; or, if CI fails, come back and re-approve each time the contributor tries to fix it, so a minimum of two times, and quite possibly more if there are CI failures (which, I expect, is common for first-time contributions).
Gaelan··on Exploiting vulnerabilities in Cellebrite UFED and Physical Analyzer
Right, but Apple now has to choose between suing Cellebrite and (tacitly) condoning their behavior. Not the same as losing the copyright, for sure, but still.

Not clear which the parent was talking about. Maybe both?

← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →