HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Gatsky

6,216 karma · joined December 17, 2009

After 13 or so years, I quit HN on a bad day in a moment of supreme frustration. Password randomized and a dead email.

Kageroya Tsuka yori soto ni Sumu bakari

submissionscomments
Gatsky··on Write simply (2021)
One new reason to ignore this advice: so people know you are not chatGPT.
Gatsky··on Instagram’s co-founders are back with Artifact, a kind of TikTok for text
Bryan Caplan’s advice:

“Stop paying attention to things that aggravate you unless (a) they concretely affect your life AND (b) you can realistically do something about them. Start by ceasing to follow national and world news.”

Gatsky··on Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal
And for only 5 minutes?
Gatsky··on Could ultrasound replace the stethoscope?
Frankly, the average diagnostic performance of the stethoscope doesn’t justify this approach [1]. The real world performance will be even worse.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7192898/

Gatsky··on Brief structured respiration enhances mood and reduces physiological arousal
Mindfulness in this study:

> Participants were informed they should sit down in a chair or, if they preferred, to lie down, and then to set a timer for 5 min. Then they were told to close their eyes and to start breathing while focusing their mental attention on their forehead region between their two eyes. They were told that if their focus drifted from that location to re-recenter their attention by focusing back first on their breath and then on the forehead region between their eyes. They were told that as thoughts arise, to recognize that as normal, refocus their attention back to their forehead region and to continue the practice until time has elapsed.

Is this a legit expression of mindfulness meditation? It lacks any sort of breath modification.

Gatsky··on Could ultrasound replace the stethoscope?
All good points, but you would surely agree that despite that it is better than the stethoscope? Particularly in ambulatory care rather than ED, where there isn’t a CT scanner down the corridor. ED docs are forever trying to diagnose aortic dissection for some reason…

I thought POCUS was useful for pleural effusion and consolidation, but you’d know better than I do.

Gatsky··on Could ultrasound replace the stethoscope?
TLDR: Yes.

An inordinate amount of time is spent teaching auscultation (using a stethoscope) to doctors. The diagnostic performance isn’t that great even under ideal conditions. Having bedside ultrasound would really improve things for patients, and save money on unnecessary tests and treatments.

Gatsky··on Why Tipping Is Impossible to Get Rid of in America
Could include a default 15-20% gratuity that gets tacked onto the bill at the end? I’ve been to places outside of the US that do this. It’s ‘opt-out’ tipping.
Gatsky··on I've procrastinated working on my thesis for more than a year
A bit of self-knowledge goes a long way. If you are prone to procrastination, tend to have grandiose visions of what you’re going to do, like to avoid conflict, reach for various ad hoc rationalisations when you underperform, like to really perfect your work, prefer to work by yourself, get easily derailed when you hit a snag… then guess what, you’re going to suffer a lot working on very open ended projects like a PhD (myself included). The trick is to acknowledge your own proclivities from the start and either don’t do a PhD or accept that every single day you must fight to the death with your own torpor.
Gatsky··on ChatGPT listed as author on research papers: many scientists disapprove
Obvious that these authors listed ChatGPT to get attention. The papers themselves are very short. The medxriv preprint [1] should be a blogpost. The paper in Oncoscience is nonsense [2]. It was submitted on Dec 14th and accepted on Dec 15th 2022, apparently contravening the journal’s stated peer review policy (find me an article anywhere that gets peer reviewed in under 24 hours). The journal presumably realised the clickbait value and rushed it through.

Suffice to say, the authors’ cheap strategy has worked. The medrxiv preprint has an impressive view and retweet count. Expect a flood of ChatGPT authored papers.

[1] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.12.19.22283643v...

[2] https://www.oncoscience.us/article/571/text/

Gatsky··on In the past, I've had students call my problem sets “emotionally trying”
You're getting some flack for this comment, but others have said similar things: https://www.google.com.au/books/edition/_/__CnDwAAQBAJ?hl=en...

"I took six undergraduate mathematics courses. Until my junior year I encountered no one who seemed to have a greater aptitude for mathematics than mine. It had always been my easiest subject in high school, and I had been chided there by a classmate for writing my final exam with a fountain pen. Before I discovered physics, trigonometry and differential and integral calculus were my greatest intellectual pleasures. But my final mathematics course as an undergraduate was differential equations and the instructor gave me only a B. I'm sure he recognized that I was competent — I had worked every problem in the book — but he had to give the A's to the obviously brilliant students, who were now closing in on me. If I had decided to become a professional mathematician, as I easily could have, I would have made the traumatic discovery that there were many people my age who were far more talented mathematically than I could ever be.

The world of mathematics and theoretical physics is hierarchical. That was my first exposure to it. There's a limit beyond which one cannot progress. The differences between the limiting abilities of those on successively higher steps of the pyramid are enormous. I have not seen described anywhere the shock a talented man experiences when he finds, late in his academic life, that there are others enormously more talented than he. I have personally seen more tears shed by grown men and women over this discovery than I would have believed possible. Most of those men and women shift to fields where they can compete on more equal terms. The few who choose not to face reality have a difficult time."

Adventures of a Physicist, Luis W Alvarez

Gatsky··on U.S. cancer death rate has dropped by a third since 1991
Yes, tailored screening is one aspect. Prophylactic surgery is another option. There are also pharmacological measures eg tamoxifen to reduce risk of breast cancer in BRCA1/2 carriers. Then there are clinical trials of preventative interventions eg denosumab in BRCA carriers.
Gatsky··on Two research teams reverse signs of aging in mice
The Sinclair study is pretty contrived work frankly, as the commentary points out. We use cancer treatments in humans which can induce the same sort of DNA damage, and those people don’t seem to exhibit dramatically accelerated ageing.

This article is much more interesting and well developed IMHO: https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(22)01530-6

It finds that activation of endogenous retroviruses induces cell senescence and is associated with ageing phenotypes. It also affords a more tractable therapeutic approach eg antivirals or vaccines.

Gatsky··on U.S. cancer death rate has dropped by a third since 1991
Ashkenazim have relatively high rates of inherited BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations. These are associated with high lifetime risk of breast and ovarian cancer, but also prostate and pancreatic cancer. If someone with Ashkenazi heritage gets one of these cancers, they are reflexively tested for BRCA1/2 mutations. There are various mitigating strategies, so it is worth finding out I think, but the right way to go about it is to see a genetic counsellor.

About the AA, it seems to be herbal supplements that are the primary concern (see https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cms_ia/importalert_141.html). Normal ginger is fine, wild ginger is the problem. Wild ginger isn’t used in cooking as I understand it.

Gatsky··on U.S. cancer death rate has dropped by a third since 1991
There are not really any lifestyle interventions with good quality evidence for preventing cancer. This is my list:

Definitely worth doing:

- Don't smoke anything that burns or chew tobacco.

- Depending on your age and sexual experience, get the HPV vaccine.

- Investigate your family history of cancer. If there are multiple people on one side of the family getting cancer (particularly breast + ovarian + pancreatic, or colon + gastric) then consider getting genetic testing/discuss with a doctor.

- If you have certain ethnicity, just get a genetic test, pay for it if you have to (Mainly for Ashkenazim)

- Avoid consuming herbs/plants which contain aristocholic acid.

Probably worth doing:

- Reduce red meat consumption (observational data and plausible mechanism)

- Reduce or eliminate alcohol (observational data and plausible mechanism)

- Eat highly processed meats rarely (charcuterie etc)

- Make sure to get sufficient fruit and vegetables and fibre. This may offset the risk of red meat consumption.

- Take vitamin D, particularly if your levels are low or you live far from the equator. Don't take intermittent megadoses, take some every day. This seems less useful if you are overweight.

- If you are female, then have children and breast feed if possible. Longer durations of breastfeeding are more effective. Having more children is also more effective. (One may balk at this, but there is a lot of supportive data about long term breast cancer risk)

- Exercise. There is only (a ton of) observational data, but exercise is so universally beneficial. Going from nothing to a bit of exercise has a bigger impact than going from a bit of exercise to a lot. Most people over do it. Do cardio and resistance training. Try to do something every day.

- Avoid supplements designed to have antioxidant properties (based on data suggesting harm from controlled trials, and no clear benefits).

Maybe:

- Move closer to the equator.

- Avoid obesity (note this is complicated... obesity itself may not be the problem. Obesity is protective for some cancers, and this varies by age).

- Get checked for Hepatitis B and C, particularly if you have risk factors or were born/grew up in an endemic country.

- If you get chronic reflux or heartburn, consider pushing for your doctor to investigate further (usually a gastroscope) and do an H pylori test. This is particularly if you were born/grew up somewhere with a higher chance of exposure. If you have it, take the eradication therapy.

- Try to maintain metabolic health. This is highly personal and hard to give general advice around. Eg. South east asian/Subcontinental people can be metabolically ill despite not being overweight. Investigations here could vary from checking for insulin resistance (eg HOMA-IR calculation from a blood test), gettinga DEXA scan to look for visceral fat, or in the extreme case continuous glucose monitoring to look for foods which really spike your blood glucose. The interventions are exercise, sleeping well, and potentially avoiding foods which spike your sugar (or scheduling exercise after eating such foods). Soon we will have a better idea if certain personalised dietary interventions may be beneficial.

Gatsky··on U.S. cancer death rate has dropped by a third since 1991
This is great progress.

Important to note this is not an average effect across all cancers. Some cancers still have terrible outcomes eg pancreatic cancer, GBM, small cell lung cancer, stomach and esophageal cancer, certain types of breast cancer. Advanced colorectal cancer also not great.

The other aspect of this is that death can often be replaced with multiple years of a highly medicalised and sallow existence while receiving cancer therapy.

Point being, we don’t want to lose site of the ultimate goal, which is preventing cancer as much as possible.

Gatsky··on The end of the high school essay
Perhaps there is a role for those writing tools which record everything you write as you go including edits, revisions etc. Faking this reliably will be pretty tedious. It'll be like showing how you arrived at the answer in maths. You submit the finished work and your recorded writing process. Not sure why this isn't already used, since it would stop people paying someone to write the essay for them as well.
Gatsky··on The Future Dominance of Solar and Wind Energy
South Australia is an interesting example. It is a big state, but 77% of the 1.8mil population live in the capital city. The average population density of the whole state is 1.7 persons per sqkm. It has a temperate climate, and gets quite a lot of sun overall. They’ve done a good job lately with their energy mix but important to bear in mind their specific circumstances when extrapolating to other places with less pleasant weather, less space, more distributed populations and more difficult grid arrangements.
Gatsky··on Researchers identify protein that helps skin cancer spread
I see a reasonable number of these University press releases on HN. This was a preclinical lab study. There are literally hundreds of thousands of these studies, and yet as you may readily observe, cancer is still killing lots of people. The signal to noise ratio is very low for such preclinical results. They are also inferior information sources versus the actual paper. As someone who works in the oncology field, my opinion is that these press release submissions are generally of low quality.

Makes me wonder why they are posted. I can see the user who submitted this has had 35 submissions in the last 6 days. 3 or 4 of these are university PR pieces about cancer, Alzheimers and some other bioscience things, along with many other disparate fields. Not sure what to make of this, and I won't guess at the motivation. I accept that some people have omnivorous interests. I guess I should just not click on such articles.

Gatsky··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
I would disagree with this statement. The core teachings, and canonical status of the bible, is very consistent across the major denominations. Perhaps if you could provide a more specific example it would be more enlightening as to your point.

If you are arguing that the way Christians behave today is very removed from how the original Christians behaved, well that is a different point to make, albeit much more difficult to evaluate. This is in a sense nothing new, just look at the opprobium Jesus lays down at the beginning of the book of Revelation.

Gatsky··on Tell HN: Crypto/web3 grifters are Now AI/ML grifters
“What are you drinking, the water or the wave?”

The Magus, by John Fowles

Gatsky··on ‘Breakthrough’ obesity drugs that have stunned researchers
Incorrect. They controlled for changes in weight, it is not confounded by weight loss. RCT >> cross sectional analyses.
Gatsky··on ‘Breakthrough’ obesity drugs that have stunned researchers
I have a theory that the Nature group, ostensibly a bunch of academic journals, actually wants to become the NYTimes. They have chosen a custom font, they publish increasingly editorialised political content, and they produce these hype train news pieces which really lack objectivism or scientific rigour. Scientists should consider carefully what is appearing alongside their research, and the ultimate result of an unassailable, centralised academic publisher with opaque editorial practices.
Gatsky··on ‘Breakthrough’ obesity drugs that have stunned researchers
There are randomised controlled trials of diets (without caloric restriction). They show that some diets are better than others for real clinical endpoints, eg mediterranean vs low fat diet for secondary prevention of cardiac events [1]. The effect size in that example is not small, it is large, despite most participants already being on a statin. This data shows that diets are biologically active and significantly impact health. Therefore, the philosophy you espouse cannot be correct, or at least needs to be heavily modified.

[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

Gatsky··on Higher-order organization of multivariate time series
Old explainer thread on twitter from one of the authors: https://twitter.com/lordgrilo/status/1506294750621716482
Gatsky··on Practice typing by retyping entire novels
Hey, that’s a good idea! Keyboard Karaoke!
Gatsky··on “Why We Sleep” is riddled with scientific and factual errors (2019)
I find this comment strange and wrongheaded. The world is better off for having this criticism out there, and we should thank Guzey for making the effort. Unlike Walker, he doesn’t get paid to do it.
Gatsky··on Tesla stock falls again, toward longest losing streak in more than 4 years
Could be another dotcom era Cisco, which still hasn’t regained it’s peak [1]. Cisco had the biggest market cap in the world for a while. Tesla could be an even worse investment if it ends up being just an overvalued car company. It also has the biggest ‘bus factor’ of any company in SP500 ie. if Musk quits/falls ill the price will likely dive severely.

[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/heres-much-investing-1-000-12...

Gatsky··on Ask HN: What are your best and safest investment options?
Follow the advice of the hedge fund people in other comments.

Richer, Wiser, Happier by William Green was a good book.

It talks about investing longterm. Having a very long time horizon as you do is a considerable advantage.

The other main message I got was that (successful) stock pickers expend a stupendous amount of effort to understand and select stocks. And I will never be able to come close to this effort. So either I just don’t, or if I really want to have a few discretionary stock picks, copy what they do (eg https://whalewisdom.com).

Gatsky··on The antimicrobial resistance crisis needs action now
Not sure I agree. Take a look at recently developed antimicrobials. It’s not like there haven’t been any new ones. The problem is this: they are very expensive compared to older antimicrobials (so don’t get used at all except in wealthy healthcare systems) and they are tightly held in reserve for only the most resistant cases (so very small market). The latter point is particularly insurmountable, since widespread use will make the new antimicrobial less useful. It isn’t really worth it for a drug maker. The article talks about this, indicating that public-private partnerships are the way forward.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →