HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Gatsky

6,216 karma · joined December 17, 2009

After 13 or so years, I quit HN on a bad day in a moment of supreme frustration. Password randomized and a dead email.

Kageroya Tsuka yori soto ni Sumu bakari

submissionscomments
Gatsky··on State of the Sanderson 2022
My question was genuine. Thank you for the suggestion.
Gatsky··on State of the Sanderson 2022
So… are the books any good? Or is that irrelevant now?
Gatsky··on Against All Applications
Things get even worse where the application process is completely unaccountable to the future success of the applicant. When you hire someone for a job, you get some feedback on how that person does at said job. In Medicine for example, this is not the case. Whether the person you admit to your university or residency program ends up being fantastic or a psychopathic murder is not even considered.
Gatsky··on Are super-rich people just better at making money?
Well… except that many super rich had failed businesses, went bankrupt etc?

I used to kinda think along the lines of this post. However, when examining the performance of top investors for example (eg Buffet, Templeton, Marks etc) it is clear it isn’t mainly luck.

Gatsky··on Cormac McCarthy loves a good diner
Ugh, reminds me of my writing when I was in high school, not in a good way.
Gatsky··on People took some potassium and lost some weight
After seeing this proposal a month ago, I contacted the authors of the large SSaSS randomized trial [1] (n ~ 21,000) which compared a potassium salt substitute (75% sodium, 25% potassium) to normal salt. There was no reduction in BMI in the potassium group.

Now the amount of potassium consumed was not directly measured, but assumed to be 20g salt substitute per day which equates to 5g KCL or about 2.5g potassium. This was enough to have other biological effects like reducing stroke risk, and was more than most people took in the slimemold study.

[1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa2105675

Gatsky··on What happened to the first cryogenically frozen humans?
Really interesting discussion! Reminds me of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie
Gatsky··on What happened to the first cryogenically frozen humans?
Perhaps, I guess it depends on how much of the data we generate (tweets, video, blogs, text messages etc) survives into the future.
Gatsky··on What happened to the first cryogenically frozen humans?
So what I think is the most likely outcome is that we realise there are better ways to preserve the dead for reanimation, and nobody will ever bother working on how to salvage the crudely frozen/vitrified.

I personally think the way forward is to derive the neural connectivity and transcriptional state map of the brain on a single cell level. This can be done today, albeit at great expense, on tissue that is chemically fixed. Maybe this will be enough to reanimate someone in a new substrate. Maybe more data will be required, but eventually we’ll get there, accepting that human consciousness is subject to the laws of physics.

Gatsky··on Should I step down as head of Twitter? I will abide by the results of this poll
I can scarcely believe you are holding up Murdoch as a paragon of impartiality. His newspapers are notoriously biased and scurrilous, and actively try to influence political outcomes. He doesn’t have to intervene much because he makes sure to hire people who will enact his will.
Gatsky··on Paul Graham is leaving Twitter for now
Sigh these ‘What is Elon Musk thinking?’ discussions are so tiresome, devoid of any useful content. Do we really need 600+ comments about this issue? Is everyone really so upset about some guy they don’t know?
Gatsky··on Show HN: A highly opinionated, fully functional Obsidian vault
This isn’t necessarily the case if you are back linking blocks.
Gatsky··on Ask HN: What is the best advice you received in 2022?
“I’ve given a lot of thought to the optimal use of my time, and I simply do best operating by myself.”

Just hearing someone extremely successful with effectively limitless resources say this, hearing that this is OK.

Gatsky··on Ask HN: How do you protect your children from internet addiction?
I think in general parents overestimate how much what they do matters, and underestimate genetic effects. I worry that a lot of the advice here isn’t reproducible.

My advice is to look at your own life first. If you (or the other parent) have trouble with getting addicted to things, obsessive behaviours, body dysmorphism etc you might want to take a more judicious approach with your kids.

I think there are also some things that go without saying:

- Don’t let kids sacrifice sleep, so no devices in the bedroom at night.

- Be extremely careful with tween+ girls and visual social media. Restrict usage, educate and discuss a lot, and beyond that make a special effort to give them attention, do fun stuff, let them know they are special and important and valued during the vulnerable years.

- Boys and pornography. Need to talk to them about it. I don’t know how to approach this, I’ve got about a decade to work it out.

Gatsky··on John Carmack Leaves Meta
He has the quality of being unformidable. The guests are very relaxed on his show I find. Tim Ferris is similar. Contrast to say Sam Harris, who although very erudite, perspicacious and articulate, asks paragraph long multipart questions and spends around 50% of his air time talking. Tyler Cowen is a better example of a formidable interviewer, who keeps things quite short and punchy and is always a little lighthearted.
Gatsky··on Request for Startups: Climate Tech
Be that as it may, I think this initiative by YC is mainly because they noticed a lot of talented founders were starting Climate Tech companies. pg had a tweet about this a while ago.
Gatsky··on Boom takes the wraps off its supersonic Symphony engine design
Yeah it seems a bit of a downer, but it’s mostly just noise. How many of us would actually invest money in Boom right now? Basically none. How many of us would short it if we could? Basically none.

The fact that Boom exists at all suggests sufficient optimism about new technology is out there somewhere.

Gatsky··on New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations
The bill says that sale of smoked tobacco products will be prohibited if the recipient was born after 2009-01-01. Just giving them a smoked tobacco product is also illegal if it occurs in a public place.
Gatsky··on US Department of Energy: Fusion Ignition Achieved
Good things often have dubious or downright evil origins (which would never be justifiable a priori).

A relatively recent example: development of cancer chemotherapy began with the incidental finding that the chemical warfare agent nitrogen mustard reduced the white cell count of affected soldiers.

We make progress building on the shoulders of giants, but those giants are often standing in dung.

Gatsky··on New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations
Agreed, but the OP is obviously unconvinced by the moral observation that Big Tobacco hack people’s brains for profit while externalising the costs to society.
Gatsky··on New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations
Ah well sure but when the smoking rates drop low enough, smoking related healthcare costs greatly exceed the cigarette tax receipts. NZ is a small country and needs to contain the costs of its socialised healthcare. Is there a fundamental ‘right to give money to Tobacco companies’? Buying cigarettes is banned, smoking isn’t.
Gatsky··on The father of all secrets: John le Carré’s daddy issues
Can highly recommend A Perfect Spy, one of the best books I've read, a bleak masterpiece.
Gatsky··on EU-wide maximum limit of €10K for cash payments
I would characterise it differently. The aspect of financial repression that hurts the middle classes the most is letting inflation run. This is because they tend to have cash assets and their way of life is in many ways predicated on the idea that working hard ensures a certain buying capacity. It is also hard for them to move to Panama, for many obvious reasons. It is more that in the current world, there are many options for moving money around, so it harder for a government to ensure they have a captive audience for financial repression in terms of cash reserves.

I am not critiquing financial repression. It is probably the only feasible way to reduce government debt compared to say austerity measures. We would all be better off if economic growth could overcome government debt, but the Eurozone lacks the demographics to make this happen. Italy in particular is a basket case in that regard. One point to make however, is that the severe degree of inflation in Europe seems at least partly due to asinine energy policy. If that had been better handled, then the pain wouldn't be so great. Europeans may therefore be less happy to accept inflation denuding their lifestyles as an 'inevitable' condition of living in social welfare states.

Gatsky··on EU-wide maximum limit of €10K for cash payments
Capital controls are one of the elements of financial repression.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_repression

Gatsky··on The price of ‘sugar free’: are sweeteners as harmless as we thought?
Some comments here seem ignorant of the key study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35987213/

It’s very compelling - some sweeteners have adverse metabolic effects and it is mediated by the microbiome [1]. Aspartame and stevia seem better than sucralose and saccharin. In theory, thaumatin should also be fine.

[1] As always this varies between individuals.

Gatsky··on I liberate the ending to Minecraft from Microsoft and give it to you
Yes, also a good example, although he seems more delusional than merely deranged.
Gatsky··on I liberate the ending to Minecraft from Microsoft and give it to you
Well I enjoyed the piece. But it evinces a kind of derangement unique to modern life. Minecraft became so popular, and worth so much money, that the author couldn’t get over it.

Another example is that guy who threw away a hard drive with his bitcoin wallet on it, now worth $200 million or something like that. He can’t move on. Last I heard he was trying to finance a plan to exhume an acre of landfill and sort through it all by hand.

Gatsky··on Organ donations, transplants increase on days of largest motorcycle rallies
If you were designing a vehicle to help harvest organs, you would want a high chance of causing blunt head trauma but avoid major organ damage. You would also want the victim to be thrown well clear of the vehicle to enable quick access for resuscitation, and to avoid smoke inhalation or conflagration. You would also want this vehicle to be highly attractive to fit and healthy young people. Namely, a motorcycle.
Gatsky··on Caterpillar offers phone with built-in FLIR camera
How much do these go for?
Gatsky··on FTX Contagion
Saying that Temasek has annual returns of 14% and that the EV of burning money is zero are logically inconsistent. The EV of burning $275million is actually about negative $1 billion over 10 years, offset by tax savings.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →