HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

George83728

544 karma · joined April 27, 2023

submissionscomments
George83728··on Reddit CEO tells employees that subreddit blackout ‘will pass’
If they don't need reddit, then they should stop using it to demonstrate that point.

> "I'm not addicted, I can quit anytime I want."

> "Okay then, prove it and quit today."

> "....No."

George83728··on the US Government Warned Ukraine Not to Attack NordStream 3 Months Before Attack
I warned my mother that my brother was eying up the cookie jar, days before taking all those cookies for myself. Just saying.
George83728··on Apollo’s Christian Selig explains his fight with Reddit – and why users revolted
> Considering the amount of media attention this has gotten from even mainstream sources including places like the BBC

Reddit moderators are uniquely privileged when it comes to making their opinions heard on reddit. The shuttering of subreddits is sensational and splashy enough to get media attention, but in itself says little about how most reddit users feel. A moderator revolt is like a strike of middle managers, revolting against upper management. They can lock the doors and keep all the common workers out, but that isn't evidence that the common workers have much investment in the strike. I think this whole thing probably follows the 90-9-1 rule; the 9 are mods and powerusers flipping out against the 1, while the 90 are probably oblivious or simply indifferent.

George83728··on Apollo’s Christian Selig explains his fight with Reddit – and why users revolted
Those bots also shit up the S/N and generally disrupt conversations with useless replies nobody asked for. They're a big part of the reason I stopped using reddit.

Related: https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/002/054/961/748...

George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
The word you're looking for is lying.
George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
> Also, the Washington Naval Treaty was a complete failure? It set the stage for japan to build more resentment which led to ww2.

1. Attributing the whole of Japan's imperial ambition to the Washington Naval Treaty is farcical.

2. This chart of battleship displacement by date of construction plainly reveals that the Washington Navy Treaty was a massive success. Yes, treaty-breaking ships were constructed, but you cannot look at this graph and conclude that the treaty did not succeed in substantially disrupting the arms escalation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Naval_Treaty#/media...

FWIW, I agree with you that the development and research into chemical and biological weapons never stopped. However it is likely that most countries no longer maintain up-to-date stockpiles of these weapons. Research continues for game theory reasons, but the treaties (and moreover the general public sentiment against such weapons, particularly the sentiment that use of those weapons would constitute the use of "WMDs" to which a nuclear response would be warranted) had the effect of greatly reducing the risk that such weapons would be used en masse. To this point; these sort of weapons have not yet been used in Russia's invasion of Ukraine, despite most late-cold war analysts believing that the Soviet Union would use chemical weapons during their anticipated war with NATO.

George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
Unsurprisingly, Americans generally evaluate American media by American standards.
George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
Well since you've responded sarcastically, it must be debunked.
George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
[Not] incidentally, around the world it's easy to find people who know more about American politics than their own local politics. I'm friends online with several Brazilians; they spend as much if not more time talking about Trump than Bolsonaro. Why is that?

I think this is for a few reasons; America is a [the?] global hegemon; so American domestic politics have some earnest global relevance. But more than that; reporting one country's news is more efficient than reporting N countries' news. Fewer stories means fewer writers to pay, less research and investigation to do, etc. Furthermore people have an appetite for news, but a finite appetite; sate people with news about America and you'll have them thinking less about local issues. Therefore, news organizations in other countries have both an economic and political incentive to report American news instead of local news. What's more, America encourages this because for America it is a form of soft power to live rent-free in the minds of everybody else.

Point is: when a narrative becomes taboo in American media, that's likely to rub off on the rest of the world. Particularly so in countries where a sizeable portion of the population consume at least some English-language media, participate on English-language forums, etc.

George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
> A lot of dog whistling with sentiments like "I'm criticizing the Chinese government, not the Chinese people." (spoiler alert: it was both)

'Dog-whistling', meaning they don't overtly say it and you infer that they mean it. If they make it overt such that it doesn't need to be inferred, they're not longer dog whistling.

How do you know your inference is correct and that is their intent? How can you be sure that wasn't just an impression given to you by [social] media? The CCP has a vested interest in conflating any criticism of itself or the PRC generally with racist criticism of all Asians. They also say that criticism of their Uyghur genocide is dog whistling anti-Asian racism. The CCP say this of anything that criticizes them, and their narratives do not stop dead at their borders. I've heard it echoed by some of my coworkers, PRC nationals working in America, and even western media that might not endorse such narratives will still give voice to consideration of those narratives.

Now allow me to be frank; during the supposed surge of anti-Asian hatred ostensibly motivated by Trump and perpetrated by white nationalists, much of anti-Asian crimes that were being reported had been perpetrated by African Americans. It was probably crime motivated by class/social/economic inequality, and insofar as it disproportionately targeted Asian Americans at all (rather than selective reporting merely creating that appearance) it probably had nothing to do with any politician's covid rhetoric and was instead was an artifact of geographic proximity and inequality in policing (Asian American neighborhoods receive less protection from the police, making Asian Americans an easier target for crime.) In this last regard, you can easily show that racism against Asian Americans played a role, but such inequalities in policing are problems that go back many generations and have little if anything to do with covid.

George83728··on VP of Bitwarden fired for using ‘Assigned By God’ as pronoun sues employer
A man has a right to be offended by somebody asking him if he is a man. (Woman too, for that matter.)

Asking everybody their pronouns by default is an overtly political act, meant to re-engineer society to be more accommodating to people who's preferred pronouns do not match their visual appearance. The idea is that if everybody lists their pronouns, those people who's pronoun doesn't match their appearance will seem less conspicuous when they specify their preference. Since this listing of pronounces is a fundamentally a political act, you shouldn't be surprised when you encounter people who don't wish to participate in this sort of political action. Furthermore it is clearly inappropriate for employers to coerce workers to participating in such activism.

George83728··on VP of Bitwarden fired for using ‘Assigned By God’ as pronoun sues employer
If a gender-fluid pansexual wants to identify their sex as "Yes please", who are you to say they can't? Hmmm.
George83728··on VP of Bitwarden fired for using ‘Assigned By God’ as pronoun sues employer
Today, you can say that people who think themselves kittens aren't sane and most people won't disagree with you. 20 years ago you could say that men who think themselves women aren't sane, and most people wouldn't disagree with you. Who can say what the future will hold in store for our culture. I know it seems unlikely now, even farcical like an argument being made in bad faith, but that's how it always is.
George83728··on New York City will charge drivers going downtown
> Nobody wants to ban your cotton bag.

Really? Well that's good to hear. Because earlier it seemed like you were agitating against cotton bags with remarks about their 10000x CO2 emissions and remarks like "god forbid reusable cotton bags". So you see, I get a little defense of my bags.

I know your anti-cotton remarks are not themselves proposals for legislative bans, but online agitation about an idea is how many such bans start. E.g. the plastic straw bans started as people making a big deal online about turtles getting straws stuck in them. So please understand, when you start using such strong rhetoric against cotton bags, I see fit to defend them.

George83728··on VP of Bitwarden fired for using ‘Assigned By God’ as pronoun sues employer
My friend doesn't proselytize. He knew I was an atheist the first day we met and not once has he ever proselytized to me. He conceals the very fact that he is a catholic at work because he has reason to believe (well founded reason, I think) that he would face discrimination should that simple fact become known around his office.
George83728··on Inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid
> [...] infectious biological weapons because they are near impossible to control.

You mean contagious, not infectious. Biological weapons which are infectious but not particularly contagious, such as anthrax, are much easier to control and have been the focus of most biological weapons research. Biological weapons are banned and aren't, used not because they don't work, but because other things work better and with less political fallout.

And FWIW, very contagious pathogens could be used as weapons for strategic effect if you had reason to believe they would hurt your economy less than your enemy's. For instance, if you believe your authoritarian government will allow you to flatten the curve but liberal governments will have a disordered response that precludes this. I'm not saying they did it, but the possibility isn't patently absurd.

George83728··on VP of Bitwarden fired for using ‘Assigned By God’ as pronoun sues employer
> The lawsuit further mentions that two employees in Bitwarden’s human resources department complained of feeling harassed by Scharf’s religious statements.

I am an atheist but my best friend from college is a devout catholic and he tells me similar things about having to keep his religion under wraps at work because he'll get coworkers going on a vendetta against him otherwise. I believe him. Others have confided all manner of discriminatory and hateful remarks aimed at the religious to me, knowing that I am an atheist and therefore believing that I sympathize with their anti-theist bigotry (I do not; being an atheist is not synonymous with being an anti-theist.)

This industry has a real problem with tolerance. It's all sunshine and roses if you fit the mold, but if you dare to be a little different all the knives come out.

George83728··on New York City will charge drivers going downtown
Pros and cons for cotton bags:

Pros: Never spills my groceries onto the sidewalk when I'm walking home. Looks nice.

Cons: The CO2 emissions of producing... one square yard of cotton cloth. (Btw, how many pairs of pants do you own? Probably more than you need, I bet.)

Yeah, looks like I'll be sticking with my cotton bag.

George83728··on Ted Kaczynski has died
What are some good Nero quotes? Wikiquotes only has two; one of which is "I wish I could not write." which seems a bit ironic since it seems most of his writings are now gone.
George83728··on The computer graphics industry got started at the university of Utah
> The situation isn’t being shifted

Really? Then what male researchers were hanging posters of Lena in classrooms?

George83728··on Palantir CEO Rejects Calls to Pause AI Development
Libertarians love government contracting. The less the government does themselves, and contract out to corporations instead, the happier libertarians are. Many libertarians even want to abolish the US Postal System so that even that work can be contracted out to corporations.

These kind of libertarians are all about "economic liberty", e.g. unfettering and deregulating corporations. They care little for individual liberties; a surveillance police state administered by corporations is right up their alley. In their view, the problem with the Stasi is the Stasi wasn't a for-profit corporation, and was consequently inefficient at what they did.

George83728··on Palantir CEO Rejects Calls to Pause AI Development
Palantir's AI calculated this comment to be the ideal way to derail this conversation.

1. This article has nothing to do with climate change, so why is such a comment the top reply?

2. "nobody says we should stop anything [to address climate change]" is a flagrant lie. You guys are being baited.

George83728··on Peter Singer on utilitarianism, influence, and controversial ideas
Better to have the rules and sometimes find very compelling reasons to break them, than to never have the rules at all. The rules raise the activation energy. A rule against murder may be overridden when presented with an extreme circumstance, but utilitarianism without such a rule at all will permit (or even require) murder for very marginal theoretical gain. Under such systems you have the government going around murdering farmers so their property can be collectivized for the greater good, and then millions of people starve to death which was never factored into the equation but oops, too late now. Better to live in a society which generally respects deontological principles (and sometimes breaks them) than to live in a utilitarian society with no such compunctions.
George83728··on Peter Singer on utilitarianism, influence, and controversial ideas
> It mostly boils down to what they personally feel comfortable with emotionally (and that’s fine, but not something you can apply in law for all people).

Every democratic country has laws which are motivated by the way people feel emotionally. Check out this map: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_Europe#/media/File...

12 weeks in Germany, 24 weeks in the UK. Why is there such a difference? Because these laws are based on how people feel.

George83728··on Peter Singer on utilitarianism, influence, and controversial ideas
Yes, it's amusing that the simplest way (for atheists such as myself) to justify deontology is with a utilitarian argument; having deontology principles is good because those principles produce good outcomes. But I think my point stands, that utilitarianism without any deontological safety rails is a recipe for mass murder.
George83728··on Peter Singer on utilitarianism, influence, and controversial ideas
Utilitarianism and consequentialism are very dangerous; they make it too easy for people to justify murder by doing a little moral arithmetic and (consciously or subconsciously) putting their finger on the scale by selectively considering or ignoring some outcomes. Peter Singer has demonstrated this himself, having seen fit to justify the murder of children for the greater good. This is why good moral philosophies have a deontological core of simple principles such as "Don't murder people."
George83728··on Cosmic luck: NASA’s Apollo 11 moon quarantine broke down
> The surface of the moon is 100 m thick blanket of impact debris that has been pulverized over billions of years. Nothing in kind of structure could survive that treatment, regardless of whether it is silicon or carbon based.

Impacts would destroy any conceivable microbes in the immediate vicinity of the impact. But unless an impact was strong enough to sterilize the entire moon all at once, microbes outside the kill radius could subsequently reclaim the impact site. Like plants reclaiming land after a lava flow destroys everything previously living in that spot.

I agree with your other arguments, and believe the moon is sterile.

George83728··on Jared Diamond: A Reply to His Critics
Across Eurasia you had about 2000 years where people were riding around on chariots with strong spoked wheels, but farms didn't have even primitive wheelbarrows to move rocks off their fields. Moving rocks off fields is back breaking work and even a primitive improvised wheel barrow gives you an order of magnitude advantage. The prerequisite technology, conditions, demand, etc were there, but it took thousands of years for somebody to have the idea. Therefore, I think it's safe to conclude that very few people who've never seen or heard of a wheelbarrow would ever have the idea to invent one, even if they were already familiar with wheels in other contexts. The idea itself is the rare thing, not the prerequisite technological/social conditions. The idea can go unhad for thousands of years after all the other pieces were in place.

> You aren't even addressing Diamond's argument.

I think Jared Diamond could be correct, but I would still say that his argument is lame because he failed to establish a high likelihood of prompt invention once prerequisite conditions are met before concluding what those supposedly missing prerequisites were. I'm not addressing his argument because he failed to convince me that his argument addresses a real question in the first place. Supposing hypothetically that ancient Mexico had pack animals, it still might have been thousands of years before pack animals and wheels were put together.

> Going from [rollers] to the wheel doesn't seem like a huge leap of insight.

I really think it was. There's a big conceptual gap between rolling something on logs, and making the rollers captive through the use of an axle. The roller goes from being a tool used to move a thing to being an integral part of the thing. Wheels may have been invented more than twice, but there's not much evidence for that. And in any case, it certainly did take a very long time for some seemingly simple applications of wheels to be considered after wheels were popularized for more sophisticated and demanding purposes.

George83728··on Cosmic luck: NASA’s Apollo 11 moon quarantine broke down
From what I understand, there are quite a lot of cosmic rays coming to Earth at 10 TeV and even much higher, so the black hole thing never made any sense to me. Shouldn't cosmic rays have already created an earth-destroying blackhole, if such a thing were possible?

Apparently the whole controversy was started by the Scientific American magazine publishing the letters of some crank botanist. Pop science journalism is shameless.

George83728··on Cosmic luck: NASA’s Apollo 11 moon quarantine broke down
> North america was pretty isolated from europe but bad things still happened.

I don't think this and the hypothetical moon pathogen are comparable. In the case of smallpox in North America, the native Amerindian population had no acquired immunity to smallpox but smallpox had already evolved to be very effective at spreading through human populations. But in the case of lunar pathogens, both the pathogen and humans would be new to each other. The lunar pathogen would not be evolved to spread in humans.

← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →