HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

George83728

544 karma · joined April 27, 2023

submissionscomments
George83728··on US urged to reveal UFO evidence after claim that it has intact alien vehicles
> if such a thing was possible, why would it be restricted to "UFOs"?

Who said it is? Tons of people report seeing all manner of nonsense.

George83728··on Russia’s population nightmare is going to get even worse
They tried that, they are/were giving away tracts of Siberia for free to anybody willing to live on that land, but I doubt there were many takers.
George83728··on Ancient Carthaginians did sacrifice their children (2014)
Why do you think the Carthaginians didn't sacrifice children? One one hand you have various accounts from different people claiming they did; maybe they were all mistaken or lying or repeating rumors.. nothing solid but claims nonetheless. There's a little bit of archeological evidence to back it up too.

On the other hand you have... what? Are there any surviving ancient claims of the Carthaginians being wrongly slandered with this claim? What is your reason for assuming they did not? Innocent until proven guilty? It's not a court, and by that standard you might as well declare any infamous ancient person innocent since the hard evidence is long gone and none of the claimed witnesses can be cross examined. A modern court couldn't convict Genghis Khan of mass murder and war crimes in absentia, all the remaining evidence against that man is hearsay at best, but I don't think that's a reason to assume he was innocent.

Maybe it's an appeal to the fundamental goodness of human nature? That the Carthaginians are assumed to be innocent because what they're accused of goes against intrinsic human nature? Surely not; human nature includes the capacity for all manner of brutality; proven in the modern era.

George83728··on US urged to reveal UFO evidence after claim that it has intact alien vehicles
Also anonymous pranksters, deliberately tricking people using balloons, kites, drones, etc.
George83728··on US SEC sues Coinbase, one day after suing Binance
> Coinbase issuing public statements to SEC “tell us what is a security” were basically a ploy or the lawyers involved were extremely inexperienced.

I take it as a stunt intended shift the layman's perception of Coinbase's legal responsibilities onto the SEC. They're counting on cryptobros using this "SEC won't tell us what's legal" talking point to affect favorable political / legislative change.

But newsflash: government regulators aren't obliged to act as your legal council.

George83728··on Chrome still hasn't changed its opinion about dropping JPEG XL support
> Photoshop still can't open webp files,

Why is Adobe so bad at their job? GIMP added webp support about 5 years ago. Paint.NET added it 4 years ago.

> many websites still don't support uploading webp files.

4chan is the only such site I've heard of, and 4chan is notoriously bad at this sort of thing ever since they lost moot. It took them years to permit uploading of vp9/opus webms, for no good reason. 4chan's present administrators are incompetent, but 4chan is barely profitable (if at all) so that's not really unexpected.

But Adobe rakes in huge piles of cash, so what is Adobe's excuse?

George83728··on Phishing Darknet Users for Bitcoins
You're correct and the other responses you've got miss the mark. While stealing for thieves might be morally or ethically defensible (in some moral or ethical frameworks), it IS still illegal. You can go to prison for it. Your PSA is warranted.

For your comment to be not just downvoted but also flagged for saying something true is a farce.

George83728··on Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread protests
> made up [...] ragebait stories [...] are pretty harmless in itself.

Strong disagree, reading such things habitually is corrosive to the mind and turns people bitter. For reddit to recommend and promote ragebait subreddits to their user is deeply unethical. And to create fraudulent ragebait content, to make people vicariously mad about something that didn't even happen, is evil on par with being a tobacco advertiser.

George83728··on Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread protests
"He cleared the subreddits with a whiff of grapeshot."
George83728··on Demo: Fully P2P and open source Reddit alternative
Is it true that Lemmy censors casual profanity like "bitch"? I first heard of Lemmy a few days ago, in the context of somebody dismissing it because it allegedly performs such censorship.
George83728··on Demo: Fully P2P and open source Reddit alternative
The number of third party domains this site needs to hit to even load any posts on the front page is insane. I'm looking at a list of domains like "etherscan", ipfs gateways, pokt... all kinds of shady sounding bullshit and it isn't at all clear to me what I would need to whitelist to get this site to work: http://0x0.st/Hbkj.jpg

Yes I know this is "my fault" for being a weirdo who doesn't blindly let his browser hit any server a website pleases. But I use this to judge the quality of a website, the care and professionalism that was put into it. This plebbit site is awful by this metric even compared to new reddit; with new reddit merely whitelisting *.reddit.com is sufficient to view a list of posts, and whitelisting 3 more domains (all clearly reddit-affiliated: redd.it, redditmedia.com and redditstatic.com) is enough to make the site behave as it should.

George83728··on Demo: Fully P2P and open source Reddit alternative
Old reddit had a compact design that filled the page. New reddit and plebbit both have huge margins on the side, tons of white space between boxes, etc. It's got nothing to do with server-side rendering.
George83728··on Apple Vision Pro: Apple’s first spatial computer
cmdrtaco is wrongly mocked for his reaction to the original ipod. The original ipod flopped hard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod#/media/File:Ipod_sales_pe...

It didn't catch on until several years and hardware iterations later.

George83728··on Major Reddit communities will go dark to protest threat to third-party apps
> there are not really any good alternatives to reddit.

Sure there is, you can simply stop using reddit. You don't have to replace it with something new. Take whatever other hobbies and activities you already have and extend the time you devote to them into the time-slot formerly occupied by reddit.

George83728··on Thousands of early-career NIH researchers forming union for first time
Most early-career researchers are not working on their own individual "widget". Rather, they're working under another more senior researcher on a widget they have relatively little personal stake in.
George83728··on OpenAI boss ‘heartened’ by talks with world leaders over will to contain AI risk
So your objection to LLMs being called AI is a non sequitur and has nothing to do with your objection to LLMs being regulated? That's not the impression I got from either of your comments.
George83728··on OpenAI boss ‘heartened’ by talks with world leaders over will to contain AI risk
People delegate their decision making to other systems all the time, whether or not those systems are termed to be AI.

There is no empirical test for whether or not a system is AGI, and 'AI' is a term which has been applied to all manner of mundane systems for decades already. It is not important that we restrict the term AI to only mean AGI (whatever it is that AGI even means!) The 'CPU' players in Mario Kart 64 were frequently called AI, and there was no problem with that. Anybody who gets bent out of shape over the casual use of the term AI is placing way too much importance on the term.

George83728··on OpenAI boss ‘heartened’ by talks with world leaders over will to contain AI risk
You aren't answering my question. I asked about the relationship between 'is it dangerous?' and 'is it AI?' Some relationship between these questions was suggested by you in the comment I responded to above:

> "The current generation of work is not AI. [THEREFORE?] The risks it poses are minimal. You cannot hurt me with an LLM."

and again suggested by this remark:

> "we are no where close to artificial intelligence (current generation is content generation, no logic, no truth) and [THEREFORE?] it poses no risk."

You seems to be claiming that LLMs aren't dangerous because they aren't AI. Does the set of dangerous things belong to the set of AI? Pipe bombs and pit vipers aren't AI, so does that mean they aren't dangerous? They are, therefore the set of all dangerous things does not belong to the set of AI. Why then is "The current generation of work is not AI" thought to support the assertion that LLMs cannot be dangerous?

I think it could be reasonable for you to assert that LLMs have not yet been demonstrated to be dangerous enough to warrant regulation. But that's not what was asserted above; you asserted that LLMs cannot hurt people, and the supporting argument seems to be 'because they aren't real AI'. That is simply illogical. Whether or not LLMs are sci-fi tier AI is irrelevant; it has absolutely no bearing on whether or not LLMs are dangerous.

tl;dr: Rattlesnakes aren't AI, therefore rattlesnakes can't hurt me.

George83728··on OpenAI boss ‘heartened’ by talks with world leaders over will to contain AI risk
Isn't it the opposite? People who are willing to say that a simple ELIZA bot is a form of AI think that something being AI isn't very important; it's a low bar to clear and doesn't imply much about the usefulness of the thing. To these people, AI is not intrinsically important. A chess bot is AI, it has very limited utility and just isn't important at all in any domain other than chess.

On the other hand, people who say that AI is an as-of-yet unobtained far-future technology are saying that AI is intrinsically very sophisticated and useful; so much so that nobody has succeeded in creating one yet. These people think that AI is intrinsically important. They think the term AI is so important that it must not be applied to systems with limited mundane usefulness.

George83728··on OpenAI boss ‘heartened’ by talks with world leaders over will to contain AI risk
> The current generation of work is not AI. The risks it poses are minimal. You cannot hurt me with an LLM.

Can you please clarify this point? Are you asserting "not AI, therefore it cannot hurt me", or "It can't hurt me, therefore not AI"?

What precisely is the relationship between something being AI and something being capable of harm?

George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
You haven't posted anything but hyperbolic FUD. "reasoned arguments" my ass, you're asserting that a telecom company charging more for service to a military in a warzone is "essentially robbery" and you ignore every comment that points out the practical difficulty and risk inherent to providing such a service. Pathetic.
George83728··on Major Reddit communities will go dark to protest threat to third-party apps
> Do you have a source for “a large portion of reddit contributors use 3rd party apps”?

Most top-level reddit posts come from bots reposting old content. Those bots aren't using the first party app...

George83728··on Major Reddit communities will go dark to protest threat to third-party apps
The same official experience? So they're going to take away user choice in which subreddits to read too?

Probably not. It's about money, not enforcing a uniform experience.

George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
> "essentially robbery"

There you go, with your 'creative' use of language again. You seem strangely upset about Ukraine having internet access, because you're throwing up all sorts of FUD about it throughout this discussion (16 comments from you so far; 21% of posts in this discussion), all with a negative tone and hyperbolic abuse of language. Why are you so keen on getting people to be upset about Starlink's use in Ukraine?

George83728··on MSI reveals first USB4 expansion card, delivering 100W through USB-C
Within about 5 meters of me I have devices with sockets or cables for USB 2 Type A and Type B, USB 2 Mini (not sure if Type A, B, or AB...), USB 2 Micro (Type AB?), USB 3 Type A, USB 3 Micro (Type B? not sure...) and finally USB 3 Type C.

That's seven at least by my count. I probably have some USB 1.1 Type A peripherals in my closet but those might be USB 2, they look the same so I'm not sure. The only devices I counted were: phone, kindle, laptop, PC, mouse/keyboard, printer, portable HDD, and a GPS nav unit. Maybe I'm weird for still using the last one, but otherwise I don't think any of this is particularly unusual.

George83728··on MSI reveals first USB4 expansion card, delivering 100W through USB-C
>USB4 uses USB-C

That's a relief I guess, I was afraid we were getting a new connector again. How do normal people keep all this USB crap straight? I consider myself something of a nerd but I find all of this cable/port diversity utterly bewildering.

George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
You're overloading your definitions of "grift", to simultaneously mean dishonest scamming and standard profiteering.

SpaceX is a regular for-profit defense contractor. They aren't scamming the government. For anybody aligned with America's foreign policy interests, both of these are a good thing. (And for those who aren't, it's an unmitigated disaster.)

George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
Musk "got cold feet" when Ukraine started using Starlink to create long-range weapon systems that could in principle strike targets deep in Russia. The US Government has thus far refrained from giving such weapon systems to Ukraine, or made them promise not to use weapons that could in that way. So in this regard, Starlink and the US government are aligned in not wanting to overtly enable such an escalation. Probably the US government are the ones who made this apparent decision from Starlink.
George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
Yes, this is the core idea behind the Space Development Agency's NDSA / PWSA (Proliferated Warfighter Space Architecture.) To this end, the SDA has already contracted SpaceX to launch large dual-use Starlink satellites (called Starshield) specialized for military use.
George83728··on Pentagon contracting Starlink to provide satellite communications for Ukraine
My 'favorite' were the shrill comments saying that the defense industry was foolish to use Starlink because Musk might pick up SpaceX and relocate it to another country. As though he would be permitted to do that, even if he were so inclined? Lmao.

I dislike Musk for many of his business practices, which I view as unethical and often outright illegal, but the hate train has really made some people lose their minds and suggest all sorts of outlandish nonsense. I wonder how much of it is provoked by foreign nations upset about Starlink astroturfing any discussion about it.

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →