HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Gollapalli

479 karma · joined May 6, 2019

GitHub: https://github.com/acgollapalli
submissionscomments
Gollapalli··on Richard Stallman – The state of the Free Software movement
Belaboring the point: you should have SOME working understanding of the physics of your homes use of energy. You should be able to fix your home when something’s wrong with it, so long as it’s not something catastrophically wrong that requires professional help (such as the fire brigade).

The point: computers are different from everything else. Pre-writing man is a fundamentally different character to literate, historical man. (I do believe there’s an Egyptian dialogue on the matter.) And in the same manner, computing man is a fundamentally different character from pre-computing man. However, most people, despite their USE of computers, cannot really compute, because they can only get their computers to do what other people have told them to do, and not what they themselves have told their computers to do. In other words, to them the computer is an appliance. Now, not everyone can read Ulysses, or Durants history, and I don’t think it would be fair to expect that of people. But most people can read, and they can read the whole book if they choose. The qualitative shift of computational man finds that what he has read can be made into action, simply by it having been written, yet this does not hold true for a person who is handed Durants history of the world, or Livy’s history of Rome (before having been taught Latin, even!) and being told, you have knowledge, even though you can’t get through it all.

You start people with shorter books. Even picture books. You start them with simpler computers, with simpler software, and then more complex computers which do more complex things. And even in the professional world, of fully literate adults, you only break out the really complicated stuff for the really complicated things.

Software should be comprehensible, because it is meant to be comprehensible, it is not just execution but elocution, and is the explanation of its own intent.

Gollapalli··on Richard Stallman – The state of the Free Software movement
He built huge amounts of wealth by building rocket ships and electric cars because he's worried about the earth becoming uninhabitable and thinks we need to be an interplanetary civilization. This is a dude who's dedicated his entire life to (in his mind) save all of humanity from certain doom.

I think it's a bit disingenuous to say that it's all just exploitation.

Gollapalli··on Richard Stallman – The state of the Free Software movement
Not the poster in question, but I think some of it might just be the "big ball of mud" of long maintained software, and some of it may indeed be the managerial structures around software, which incentivizes managers to grow their teams and find problems for them to solve, regardless of the need of either the growth of team size, or the so-called problems.

And we all know bored developers will make up work for themselves and bikeshed themselves to death.

> a strategy

I don't think it's conspiratorial, so much as emergent. All structures which persist have means of ensuring their persistence. Institutions (including open ones) will push for things that further their existence, status, funding, and ultimately their power. They will make themselves indispensable, regardless of their actual value-added.

Gollapalli··on Richard Stallman – The state of the Free Software movement
>because the size and complexity of modern software is far beyond the ability of individual users to reason about it based just on the source code and without any augmentation

I feel this. You should be able to understand your computer.

Gollapalli··on Show HN: Slow Social, a social network built for friends, not influencers
ActivityPub exists, it's just niche.

Maybe Elon will let mastodon instances interact with twitter or something. It'd be unlikely, but very cool

Gollapalli··on Ask HN: How do I get over my obsession with operating systems?
Write one.

Or build distro or something. You've got an itch, might as well scratch it.

Gollapalli··on Clojure isn’t for me (2020)
>feels like marketing speak

I've been told this a couple times. I doubt I'd thrive in that world though, unless I was selling something I actually gave a damn about.

IDK, is guile a scheme? guile is it's own thing, but it's definitely a scheme. What about racket? Racket has a whole bunch of stuff that mit-scheme doesn't. But it's still kind of in the scheme family. That's the parallel I was drawing. That and the statement that Hickey made in his History of Clojure that Clojurescript _was_ clojure, not some kind of spinoff.

I'm certainly not detracting from Janet and Fennel, but they _are_ quite close to clojure proper. There is a clear lineage.

Gollapalli··on Clojure isn’t for me (2020)
Increasingly, I don't see clojure as primarily a matter of the clojure-on-jvm implementation, but as a distinct and (generally) hosted dialect of lisp. Clojurescript is a clojure. Janet is a clojure. ClojureCLR is a clojure. Fennel is a clojure. Babashka is a clojure. Ferret is (kind of) a clojure. Maybe someday we'll have a bare-metal clojure. So far as I can tell, the lisp landscape (land of lisp?) has changed from common-lisps and schemes, to common-lisps, schemes, and clojures.

IMHO. Maybe I overexaggerate. Anyway, the author, from my perspective has decided that clojure IS in fact for him, but clojure on the JVM is not, so he chooses to use a different one.

Gollapalli··on What Is at Stake in Ukraine
I don't understand your perspective. Perhaps you could share some elaborating resources?

So far as I can tell, Russia now controls some 40% of the worlds grain production which feeds much of Europe and North Africa, 70+% of neon production needed for semiconductors, the main source of nuclear material for French energy, the main source of fuel for German energy, and a great deal of raw materials and commodities besides, such as timber, palladium, etc.

They now also have avenues to trade in energy in means other than the dollar, something which was not possible before, and have experience against modern NATO weapons. They are, so far as I can tell, far from screwed.

Gollapalli··on What Is at Stake in Ukraine
>China

It’s not just the manufacture but the money laundering for the cartels. Maybe “It’s just business” but so is knocking America down a peg.

>Russian energy sanctions

This is the core problem. We in the west are under the parochial impression that most of the world will follow along with this, and that impression is incorrect. Russia has too many resources, that too much of the world is reliant upon. That is the crux of the decision that is being forced, and IMHO it is not going to be forced in our favor.

If we wanted to force such a decision, it should have been from a far stronger position, with ready alternatives for the rest of the world in place. Of course, it was the Russians who took the initiative on when that would or would not be possible.

Gollapalli··on What Is at Stake in Ukraine
I kneel.
Gollapalli··on What Is at Stake in Ukraine
I thought I wrote it rather well… was feeling stylish at the keyboard. Might delete later, idk. But hell, if I sound like a propaganda apparatchik I could probably get a job at the Economist, huh?

Re: the substance of your post.

>the Chinese are mostly neutral business people

This is naive. They remember what was done to them in the opium war, and there is a reason they manufacture the stuff.

>the same dirtbags…

When one person falls into folly, that person is a fool. When an entire society falls into folly, can you blame each man as a fool? We have an opium problem. It was fueled by large pharamceutical companies, but in 2022 there is also a geopolitical component.

Re: Russia

I have no doubt Russia would like to see America knocked on its rear. However my biggest qualm with the support of Ukraine is not “Russia right, America wrong,” but that this is a self-own. What we’ve done is force the world to make a decision, in which neutrality, once a holding pattern for the sake of good business, is now a knife’s edge slicing through one’s slipper. Moreover, the so-called “smartest people in the room,” by confiscating a substantial portion of Russia’s sovereign wealth fund, have forced a realignment in which a great portion of the world is now trading oil in terms of rubles instead of dollars, which removes the base from under our own currency. I’m sorry, our involvement in Ukraine was an overextension, and our measures in support of it were foolish and self-destructive. If I sound sympathetic to Russia, it is because I am frustrated with America and how this country is being run. The people who knew how to handle situations like this, such as the now oft-mention John Mearsheimer were ignored, in favor of weak-minded flag-wavers with complementary Lockheed caps in their closet.

Gollapalli··on What Is at Stake in Ukraine
Great power competition begins long before battle does.
Gollapalli··on Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel
They taught us the search engine operators in elementary school computer class. It’s a shame that they’ve gone away now, and the internet is so much worse than it was then.
Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
I didn’t. But I had to check that you weren’t talking out of your rear. It was a damn condescending comment. “Young people don’t agree with the established foreign policy position, it must mean they’re weak,” kinda thing.

I mean the greatest generation didn’t support ww2. Hell, the Americans of the early 1900’s didn’t support ww1. Both times presidents were elected on the promise of keeping America out of war. Could you attribute that to being “detached from war”? They fought when they were called to do so. And until congress votes for war, I’m going to keep on saying that supporting Ukraine is a poor decision and outside the interests of America. I’m a zillenial for context.

Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
This should be pinned.
Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
Which war did you fight in?
Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
>Who do you think started this violence? Did Ukraine invade Russia or did Russia invade Ukraine?

Who cares? Not our fight.

>Who do you pull for when one person attacks another? The bully or the victim?

Such infantile moralizing displays a profound case of arrested development in the moral faculties. Geopolitics is not a marvel movie.

Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
Has it occurred to you that there are many Americans who view sodomy as immoral?
Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
I get war (kind of… never fought one). But I don’t get why this war is my war. It’s a conflict between Russia and Ukraine. We have no sworn defense pact with Ukraine, except that if nuclear aggression arises from some other power, we defend them from such.

Why do I care what the Russians and Ukrainians do? Now if the American world hegemony or whatever wishes to continue to exert control over Ukraine, fine. But, I have no stakeholdership in that, and it increasingly seems that I and people like me are quite disliked by said hegemony. If they want us to support their empire, maybe they ought to cut us in on a bit more of its spoils, and give us a bit more say in its aims.

Gollapalli··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
>rule of law

We don't have that NOW.

>minority rights

I'm sorry, but the BLM riots in 2015 have made me immediately suspicious of anyone towing this line. I just don't trust you.

>Free-ish speech

We just banned Russia Today (not to mention all the issues with alt-platforms getting dehosted)... oh yeah and the Babylon Bee.

> Mostly equal application of law.

See pt. 1

Gollapalli··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
I used to just take accusations of CP at face value, but knowing how entrapment-happy and truth-ambivalent the US Government can be, I find myself wondering if the killing of usenet wasn't just a part of the "hacker crackdown" and the crackdown on piracy. Piracy in particular is not something that most people had/have any real or natural compunction against.
Gollapalli··on RaidForums gets raided, alleged admin arrested
I think that goes to the matter of leadership. Politicans aren't normal people. They're supposed to be the best people, who surround themselves with the other kinda-best people. We expect them to be better than us. We want them to be better than us. We want elites. And then we ask them to not make us feel bad about it by pretending to be the same as the rest of us. But it's pretend. It's a game we play. At the end of the day, elites are supposed to act like elites, and that means knowing what they're talking about, and making us feel like someone competent is at the wheel and everything is going to be okay.
Gollapalli··on RaidForums gets raided, alleged admin arrested
We had one running for president just a couple years back. Sadly, I don't like him much, nor do many from his home state. But it's kind of cool that he went from hacker to political candidate.
Gollapalli··on FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'
The point was "this person was attacking Rittenhouse, and is the kind of person who would attack someone". Rittenhouse was a clear cut, video-verified, and court-confirmed case of self-defense.
Gollapalli··on Ed Sheeran on creative cost of lawsuit: ‘Now I just film everything’
Utterly unrelated, but it’s fascinating how the word film has gone from “putting something on celluloid film” to “recording audiovisual data”, just like tar has gone from “tape archive” to “archive of file(s)” and car/cdr have gone from “address part of the register” and “decrement part of the register”, to first part of the cons pair and last part of the cons pair. As technology develops, words lose their meaning as mnemonics of technological underpinnings and become signifiers of the functionality of a technology.
Gollapalli··on Using Windows after 15 years on Linux
This drives me nuts and I wish I could turn it off.

To be fair, it doesn't bug me when I use stumpwm instead of the default WM, but the default WM is otherwise quite nice for most things.

Gollapalli··on The ever-increasing walled-gardeness of Twitter
I only use it on mobile, but I kind of like it, tbh.

Maybe it's a generational thing.

Gollapalli··on The ever-increasing walled-gardeness of Twitter
Imagine a world where social media companies drove controversial events just to drive engagement metrics.

Replace the word "drove" with the word "stoked" and you have the current world.

Gollapalli··on The computers used to do 3D animation for Final Fantasy VII in 1996
In a lot of ways I think the big reason the subsequent games were not as good was because square took the wrong message from the success. They didn’t go “we should release more emotionally impactful video games with extremely well-told stories” (although they did this well into the ps2 era), they went “we need to be the most technically innovative company in the world” and this mindset brought them into the the failures of crystal tools and the luminus engine, where they were pulling scenario writers off of games to work on their engine (the saga of Final Fantasy VS XIII is because of this).

They got the music part down though. That stuck around.

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →