HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Guid_NewGuid

622 karma · joined June 7, 2021

submissionscomments
Guid_NewGuid··on On over-engineering; finding the right balance
As someone who has been operating in hacky mode for years there's another situation where

> we might not be here tomorrow

Is true and increasingly common which is the recurring rounds of layoffs we all seem to be experiencing. It's in the individual developer's interest to bodge something in if it makes them appear productive in time for the next layoff. Certainly not a healthy incentive for building good software but it is what it is.

Guid_NewGuid··on Weight-loss drugs are causing people to spend less at the grocery store: study
This is positive news, I wasn't aware of this research.

Nevertheless the point remains that the food industry having a free hand to craft the most addictive possible products and then advertising them to kids is also a problem we should address in parallel with getting these drugs to the people who need them now. We should do both.

Guid_NewGuid··on Why America fell behind in drones, and how to catch up again
One wonders to what extent the management of these companies having a background in actual engineering, as opposed to financial engineering, gives them an edge over US companies:

- DJI: MPhil in Electronic and Computer Engineering

- BYD: Chemistry Graduate

- CATL: PhD in Physics

- Huawei: engineering

Maybe a generation of companies who followed the Jack Welch school of management rather than valuing people who used to make stuff, also contributes to the US falling behind across the board?

Guid_NewGuid··on Weight-loss drugs are causing people to spend less at the grocery store: study
I think there is absolutely a moral issue with these drugs but it's not the usual "personal responsibility" nonsense.

The problem is it makes it far less likely we'll address our poisonous food system. The US subsidises (crops including those that produce) HFCS to the tune of billions. Fresh fruit and vegetables aren't subsided. Advertising has been shown to impact consumer behaviour in other countries.

These drugs are, provisionally, miracle drugs. But they must be paired with regulation otherwise whatever addictive poison the industry comes up with next will repeat the cycle until everyone on earth is on them.

Guid_NewGuid··on Ask HN: How do you keep up with the ever-changing tech stack?
Wait 5 years. After 5 years of the hype cycle the rough edges are sanded off, or the concept has ceased to be relevant.

You could have built most (web) things in the past 20 years with Java and a SQL database. It's worth keeping an open mind to what useful things might come out of a new trend but give it some time to avoid chasing fads like Web3, NFTs, NoSQL, Microservices or LLMs.

(This is not to say any of these are entirely useless in every scenario but the useful parts will have stood the test of time and the rest is for 'thought leaders' and con artists)

Guid_NewGuid··on More disabled Americans are employed, thanks to remote work
I think -- on the basis of this same argument playing out for years at this point -- it's because the 2 views are talking past each other.

Sure, in office works better for some people and remote makes them miserable. They're real people.

But the side suffering economic compulsion is the remote preferred people being forced back to the office against their will.

If everyone can work how they prefer then great. But that's not the world we live in and to draw a false equivalence between the dominant (at exec level) RTO view and remote workers forced into unpaid commutes and time away from families gets our hackles way up.

Guid_NewGuid··on Ask HN: What would you spend your time working on if you didn't need money?
I hadn't, that's super interesting thanks for the pointer.
Guid_NewGuid··on Ask HN: What would you spend your time working on if you didn't need money?
In an ideal world I would go back to chemistry.

Since the option in the world we have is working 60 hours sub minimum wage trying to get through a PhD followed by bouncing round on 2 year short term contracts as a postdoc (still barely on minimum wage) while University administrators make your life hell I took the only rational route.

I switched to software and make people's lives and the climate worse for a paycheck that still isn't enough to live where I want to live.

But ideally I'd use my brain to research some of the fundamental challenges we face, battery chemistry, plastic recycling, industrial catalysts, etc, etc.

Guid_NewGuid··on Wegovy could be covered for at least 3.6M people under new Medicare rules
But (inserting my own narrative), isn't the point that some deeper societal problem is being masked by this?

> Snack companies take advantage.

I'm uncomfortable with these new drugs but they seem to be a net positive so this is a good thing. But we should also look into legislating junk food companies that hijack people's appetite for a quick buck.

Chile banned sugary food TV advertising to children and saw a roughly 10% drop in purchases high in sugar. An unleashed free market in food has been shown to be harmful and the drugs alone are insufficient. Regulation is necessary.

https://healthpolicy-watch.news/chiles-comprehensive-food-po...

Guid_NewGuid··on How Would You Turn This Dial to Make the Freezer Colder?
Yes! This is the root of the confusion. Certain dual button flushes have the small button to combine with the larger one to make the complete flush but on others the small button does the small flush.

At what point does the small button cross over from meaning big flush to small flush!? I swear on most toilets where small means small you need steady hands of a surgeon to hit it!

Guid_NewGuid··on How to keep engineers out of meeting hell
Counterpoint. Engineers created meeting hell.

You know what's a bad meeting? Any Scrum meeting or status 'sync'. Meetings are invaluable. Get together frequently to talk about what you're actually trying to build with the stakeholders and you don't need process, you barely even need tickets.

But you have to be present, involved and responsive to jump on a quick call.

Instead engineers whine about context switching and how the business context of their work is irrelevant "just put it in a ticket". So now we have micromanagement up the wazoo with execrable Scrum type meetings.

I love meetings and feel a lot of anger to the type of engineer who thinks it's beneath them. Equally I detest all 'ceremonies', absolute time wasting dregs.

Guid_NewGuid··on Htmx changes license to Zero-Clause BSD
I don't understand the view that MIT and Apache 2.0 make it possible for corporations to somehow destroy or enclose the commons. Code is code. It can't be destroyed, its cost of duplication is effectively zero. If I take some open source code, add my changes and distribute a paid, closed-source, version, nothing has been removed/lost.

Certainly they make it hard/impossible to build a business from Open Source code. Unfortunately in an economic system designed to maximise the reward for value capture at the cost of value creators this is a common problem. But I believe the answer to that is more communism, not more licenses with more convoluted requirements creating jobs for legal departments for shared code.

Guid_NewGuid··on Software engineering salaries come from one of three budgets
Maybe someone who knows more about this stuff can enlighten me. From what I've heard there are actually only 2, opex and capex.

If I recall correctly capex is better for the business because of how it gets treated in the accounting stuff. This naturally gives rise to the feature factory style work of a lot of dev jobs. Some reason like they can record capex spend as an asset with depreciation. Is this true?

Guid_NewGuid··on Ask HN: What's the fastest programming language with a large standard library?
Not with Rider anymore as far as I know. I'm still on Visual Studio but colleagues report Rider is as-good or better.
Guid_NewGuid··on Ask HN: What's the fastest programming language with a large standard library?
C#/.NET in my opinion. Extremely extensive and high quality standard library and it keeps getting faster every release.

Though it's kind of a difficult question to answer, what do you need the standard library to actually do?

Guid_NewGuid··on What Is OIDC?
I played around with consuming a few different OIDC providers as close to the raw APIs as possible (not component libraries or client SDKs) just to try and understand the flow.

Each provider implemented the spec subtly differently and caused a massive headache to get working even for just a basic auth code with PKCE flow.

I'm still none the wiser on why you'd even want OIDC for most apps. Granted if you have much more complex SSO needs with external IDP integrations and OAuth API stuff etc it can make sense. I don't see why it is preferable over basic forms auth with a cookie.

The default answer seems to be to support mobile apps but I'm also none the wiser on why a JWT auth token is preferable to store on device and send with every request vs a cookie. They're both just 'keys' that need to accompany every API request and need to be stored securely. OIDC-by-default seems like overengineering but I appreciate I'm probably missing a critical reason.

Guid_NewGuid··on Hard-to-swallow truths they won't tell you about software engineer job
You've obviously hit a sore spot for some people.

The system is built to capture value (not create it) while externalising as much damage and cost as possible.

The sooner one accepts that the less deluded one needs to be. There's no company 'mission'. The only mission is try to find a way to survive and prosper under hegemonic capitalism.

Guid_NewGuid··on Personal aviation is about to get interesting
I think this kind of belief in free markets should be treated as equivalent to beliefs in Santa or fairies at the bottom of the garden.

'Consumers don't want to die in plane crashes so if they are killed in a plane crash they will simply avoid doing business with that company in future' is certainly... A take and I guess actually correct taken literally but uhhh, nobody listen to free market maniacs please.

Guid_NewGuid··on Moq – Privacy issues with SponsorLink, starting from version 4.20
Yeah I've been following the thread but feeling a bit queasy because there's a real person on the end of all this vitriol.

I think a lot of people's anger and waving the GDPR stuff around is excessive. It's understandably annoying but at the end of the day this is just the implicit cost you pay for not having a commercial agreement in place. Maintainers can go rogue, make stupid decisions and disappear and frankly your comeback is 'fork it and do it yourself'. Not bombard the maintainer with invective and legal threats.

I wouldn't use Moq (or other libraries by this maintainer) again in light of their current behavior but the fork button is literally right there at the top of the page. If I want to use the code going forward I'd have to take ownership.

I think this also shows how nonsense the default security posture is for a lot of places. Dependabot has atrophied organisation's security sense. You almost never want to upgrade and sit at the bleeding edge, that's asking for zero days, supply chain attacks and bugs. Number goes up is not a sensible way of managing software. There's nothing wrong with a 2 year old dependency running in your solution if there are no reported security issues.

Guid_NewGuid··on Companies Requiring Full-Time In-Office Are Struggling to Recruit New Employees
Not to mention, some of us have to frikkin crap too!

It's kinda a daft reason but for people with irritable bowels or other conditions work from home is an absolute godsend. No more terrible cramped toilet stalls with attendant embarrassment.

I suffered in literal intense pain the first 6 years of my career, I don't know I could go back to that, ever.

Guid_NewGuid··on 45% of people have 20 browser tabs open at a time
This is still like chaotic neutral at best.

I refuse to believe computers can stay on overnight (spot the Windows user). I shut my computer down completely every afternoon so it can have a rest and start up refreshed tomorrow.*

*What actually happens is some bug in MySQL on Docker irreversibly corrupts my database every week or so. (Again, spot the Windows user).

Guid_NewGuid··on libjpeg-turbo 3.0 has been released, and why there may never be a 3.1
This is confusing to me.

Rather than one or two good, open, reference implementations everyone uses you'd rather have multiple proprietary solutions? That seems worse for people who want to learn from a commons of knowledge and hugely inefficient and a waste of time.

I can see an argument for copyleft style licenses for this stuff (though I fundamentally disagree with them, freedom based on copyright that requires police and courts to enforce isn't free) but you appear to be arguing for completely closed solutions, though I assume I'm misunderstanding?

Guid_NewGuid··on Scaling up the Prime Video audio/video monitoring service and reducing costs
To be fair it is somewhat a punching bag example but I think what people are reacting to, but maybe not articulating well, is the presumption for microservices by the powers-that-be.

Of course the only rational take on monoliths versus microservices is "use the right tool for the job".

But systems design interviews, FAANG, 'thought leaders', etc basically ignore this nuance in favour of something like the following.

Question: design pastebin (edit, I of course mean a URL shortener not pastebin)

Rational first pass but wrong Answer: Have a monolith that chucks the URL in the database.

Whereas the only winning answer is going to have a bunch of services, separate persistence and caching, a CDN, load balancing, replicas, probably a DNS and a service mesh chucked in for good measure.

I think this article shows that this is training and producing people who can't even think of the obvious first answer they have been so thoroughly indoctrinated.

Guid_NewGuid··on Scaling up the Prime Video audio/video monitoring service and reducing costs
I feel like it's a semantics thing. To me the meaning of microservices has undergone semantic drift to the antipattern in the article where every little component or database table is its own service with an associated "pizza team".

It's fine to just have plain "services" to do things like this where you need to leverage another OS/framework/whatever and just hive off something like PDF conversion while your core application remains a monolith.

Guid_NewGuid··on Methane may not warm the Earth quite as much as previously thought
On here?

Nothing will change from the chorus of "well I get all my meat from this local quaint little butcher who knows all the cows by name and they're raised on grassland that cannot sustain arable farming so it's fine, actually", completely ignoring what happens when 8 billion people need to go to that butcher...

Guid_NewGuid··on Stop whining about “The EU Cookie Policy” and improve your ways
No one likes these consent modals, not the EU, not the companies, not the end users.

But they're good.

They're making the negative externality visible. We had developed an ecosystem where as soon as you clicked on a webpage it would spaff your personal data to third party brokers and infest you with tracking across the entire internet. All driven by marketing and sales departments. All driven by a capitalist free market.

The regulations changed nothing other than to make people annoyed by this. Good. Take that anger and direct it against the god damn companies building this stuff, many of the employees of which are on this site. Stop whining about the EU, they're just holding up a mirror to the abject horror of tech.

Guid_NewGuid··on Animal Sex Determination Is Weirder Than You Think
Yeah the culture war seems to be seeping in everywhere and particularly badly on these topics as the bulk of comments on this article seem to show.

At the boundaries even in humans this stuff gets really fuzzy and has real world implications for people who get barred from their careers or forced to undergo medical procedures to be more easily categorised[0][1].

While it might be a rare scenario (between 0.08% and 1% seems to be Wikipedia's intersex estimates depending on definition) a system is only as good as its protection for the minority case.

And from an intellectual curiosity standpoint this is kinda cool and interesting right? Like this breaks our lazy categorization and shows that the world is so much more intriguing than our dumb models.

And instead of 'intellectual' and 'curious' discussion we get the equivalent of a Tennessee GOP rally about school bathrooms...

[0]: https://apnews.com/article/europe-cape-town-africa-south-afr...

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testosterone_regulations_in_...

Guid_NewGuid··on Arrest made in SF killing of Bob Lee – alleged killer also worked in tech
Just to reinforce what you say here

> I think we all live in our own bubbles, because I see so much discussion of SF crime.

As a European on this platform it's ceaseless whinging about the state of SF and how the "woke mob" are ruining San Francisco and the state of the Tenderloin versus Mission or Market or whatever and I don't particularly care to know.

Like I've started to learn the parts of a city I have no particular interest in visiting from repeated stories about how someone shouted and pooped in the street because of boogeyman de jour.

Definitely feels like maybe YC could make a "local HN" to save the rest of us from these circular discussions.

Guid_NewGuid··on Saying Goodbye to GitHub
My thoughts on the co-pilot thing remain as vague as ever but I made something of a connection reading this:

> GPL violations by soulless corporations stealing the hard work of independent programmers and assimilating it into their own proprietary software

"stealing"? Where's it gone? It vanished!? It's been erased from the internet?

Why do we play these semantic artificial scarcity games with code that has deliberately been made publicly accessible? If I read your code and copy it to a file on my computer it hasn't been destroyed, it hasn't gone anywhere. If my computer reads the code it hasn't vanished into the ether.

I don't pirate films/games/TV/books but I think open source code is an entirely different beast to the former.

Guid_NewGuid··on Montrealer found guilty of hate against Jews after Daily Stormer post
I'd agree here and I think there's a big flaw in how this period of history is taught to people in the 'victorious' powers.

Generally a high-school level of history (assuming you're paying the normal level of attention) leaves you with the impression that Germans got sad and mad and poor because of the Treaty of Versailles, hyperinflation and the 'German martial spirit' or something and then Hitler appeared out of nowhere to do bad stuff.

Reading "The Coming of the Third Reich" by Richard J. Evans was eye-opening in this regard. The Nazis did nothing more than tie together several existing culturally accepted themes more successfully than other fringe groups in Weimar politics. The swastika as a far-right symbol wasn't even 'invented' by them.

The Nazis to some extent were incidental, or didn't represent a step-change from the thoughts, politics and speech that were already circulating broadly in pre-Nazi society. This is what free-speech primacists seem to neglect. The Nazi ideology didn't arise from nowhere, death camps weren't the start, they were the end of 30 plus years of increasing acceptability and propagation of far-right ideas (stab in the back myths, casual and scientific anti-Semitism, anti-communist and anti-left propaganda, mainstream scientific eugenics, etc).

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →