HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Helianthus16

417 karma · joined June 30, 2010

submissionscomments
Helianthus16··on The first serious infowar is now engaged
remember the last Declaration was important, made by people with political power and influence. This is merely an idealistic essay rather than an action--it describes a movement, it does not _compel_ movement.
Helianthus16··on The Rise Of The Gentleman Hacker
A phrase _is_ a set of connotations, so I would argue that his problem is indeed with the phrase.
Helianthus16··on SecDef Gates on Wikileaks
>This classy response by Gates is but a brief glimpse of honesty from an otherwise hysterical, paranoid, and secretive government.

I think you're making a really careless characterization here, and it's taking me some time to put a finger on why.

Maybe it's that the government has _not_ acted hysterical, paranoid, or secretive in any way throughout this hubbub. It was pretty much like "Yeah, we know what's coming, we're bracing ourselves," with an additional stated position of "It is wrong to release state secrets."

I think you're conflating the media coverage, which _is_ hysterical and paranoid, with the actual government's reaction.

I think in addition, you're conflating what the loudmouths of the political process call for action with the actual government's reaction.

The loudmouths are there for us to consider extreme courses of action.

The reason this took me long to force out was that this brief glimpse of honesty really is in contrast with the reactions of the irked and probably very harassed officials who have been quoted, so I didn't disagree with some part of the statement. However, I expect this is because the government is realizing how it came off pretty well--I would not be surprised to find US policy advanced in some ways, especially Iran. The US was a victim in public world opinion.

So maybe now the government is able to communicate with the media its composure.

Helianthus16··on WikiLeaks Archive — Cables Uncloak U.S. Diplomacy
What is interesting about this is not the damage it does, which will likely be minimal as it's really just embarrassing.

What's interesting is the look into the hidden minds of countries. I didn't know, for instance, that so many Arab countries urged US intervention in Iran, or that Israel has been monitoring Iran's nuclear program so closely--as indicated by their pressing warning that 2010 specifically is a key year.

Of course, everyone here knew or suspected China's dirty hands, but it's nice that this calls them out for it.

And it's funny to know exactly how little most countries seem to think of Europe's importance.

Helianthus16··on 15-minute writing exercise closes the gender gap in university-level physics
I find it amusing that you are being downvoted for saying the same thing many others are saying, but less politely and more baldly.

We are at a point where men are starting to realize that gender imbalance works both ways, where lots of comments decry the article's inattention to the male decrease in performance.

But there's still a taboo.

Helianthus16··on 15-minute writing exercise closes the gender gap in university-level physics
If deep societal problems could be solved in fifteen minutes, they wouldn't be deep societal problems.
Helianthus16··on Macro Perspective: Is This America's Great Decline?
Yeah, and an increasingly male population, a huge disparity in actual GDP, and the general maturity level of the country rated somewhere around "early teenager" says that China isn't going to take over anytime soon.

China still _acts_ like a 19th or 20th century power. It's still pre-occupied with its "place" on the world stage, so sensitive to insult because it wants so hard to be important.

Sure, that could grow into something, but it ain't there now.

Helianthus16··on Macro Perspective: Is This America's Great Decline?
Well... it might not be bonkers, but if you're positing absolute decline then not a lot of what we say is going to matter.
Helianthus16··on Macro Perspective: Is This America's Great Decline?
"I've found a historical heuristic that might apply here."
Helianthus16··on Macro Perspective: Is This America's Great Decline?
This is debatable. They are definitely throwing their weight around and playing some Machiavellian games with world opinion, flat-out denying things that anyone can see is probably true--look at how they re-directed network traffic.
Helianthus16··on Solar Power Blowing Up in the United States
Hate to say it, but this felt... spammy. They didn't include any trending data from now, they just... kinda drew a line upwards?

Yeah, solar power is cool, it's growing and reasonable to assume it will continue doing so. Article's rather light on information, though.

Helianthus16··on Outsmart your brain by knowing when you are wrong
ha. what I've learned from reading the comments is that it's not necessarily necessary to compensate for this error. (I also guessed 400 as a lower bound.)
Helianthus16··on The Opinions of Attractive People
Correlated. Just because we can say "This person is generally more attractive because of facial symmetry, well-aligned teeth, and x,y,z" doesn't mean we have any particularly useful quotient to judge the attractiveness of a person. Such a general measure is way too broad. And you missed my point: the perception of physical attraction is not based solely on physical traits! Look at Sarah Palin--some would say she's attractive, but if you mentally recoil at the thought of a Palin presidential run I'm sure you would not think so.

Your amateur video productions _prove my point_ because the attractiveness is in the ordinary, the "just a person at home making a video." It is in the fact that the person is presumably contributing something valuable. So why would people care if models were paid to say something?

This is why Adams articles frustrate me: because it provokes discussion without moving anything forward, because he's used a terrible model to abstract attraction and as a consequence our definitions are semantic (read: fucked) to begin with.

Helianthus16··on The Opinions of Attractive People
Reading Scott Adams almost invariably just makes me irritated. A number of semi-plausible speculations coupled with intellectual smugness that's (dishonestly, in my opinion) protected by virtue of being explicitly just a guy's opinions.

It's more of the same here. Attractiveness is not universal and is often _tied_ to the opinions a person holds--so people that disagree with arguably attractive people will think them _ugly_.

The other big problem is that no one really cares about a pretty face repeating words they don't understand. Pretty faces might get famous just for being famous, but they don't get respected, only thronged.

The hell of it is, this could _work_. It wouldn't work by the mechanism he declares, though--it would work because we connect with real people, and it's fun to experience people in short snippets with no obligation. The problem is that we've just described Chatroulette, only decoupled from the present time--and sharing the present time is what makes chatroulette interesting.

Helianthus16··on Nobody Understands Probability
It sounds like he didn't get to it before running out of steam. Which is unfortunate, because that's really the reason I kept reading.
Helianthus16··on Clean People Feel Morally Superior
>You're correct in assuming that it's difficult to extract correct conclusions from a psychology experiment, just like with any other science.

In psychology it is much much more difficult to tease out "correct" conclusions than in, for example, physics. This is a result of 1) the complicated nature of human behavior, which is not subject to (in comparison) simple mathematical formula; and 2) the unethical nature of trying to measure the effects of bizarre environments on children in order to analyze development.

This is what you said right afterwards, of course.

But the fuzzy sciences face challenges that naturally make them less rigorous in the scope of their conclusions.

Helianthus16··on Why are so many people in their 20s taking so long to grow up?
Speaking as a 23-year-old who graduated a year ago...

-Because we came out into a terrible economy our professional lives are naturally chaotic.

-Because we have little regard for the 'status quo,' the 'way things are done.' We've been told all our lives that nothing is 'normal'--we grew up thinking that attitude was normal to the extent of never questioning it. See: http://xkcd.com/150/

-Disregard similarly for vaguely Western assumptions. From the article: "Sociologists traditionally define the transition to adulthood as marked by five milestones." As someone else noted, leaving home isn't a global thing.

To put a bit of Angry Young Man spin on it, why should we be concerned with "growing up?" Why should we follow your (this is directed more at the NYT than at anyone here) roadmap? It's not like you did such a great job as far as we can see. (And I know that sentence has been said in some form throughout all of history.)

Helianthus16··on Cold Calling Techniques
I wish this were actually about cold calling techniques--i.e., how to honestly approach someone and maximize the importance of the information you transfer to them--instead of how awesome cold calling is.

excuse me, how awesome 'good' cold calling is. god. "why it's good that cold calling is so difficult for most sales people"

because that makes it more exclusive. bleh. hacker news was made less worthwhile with this link.

Helianthus16··on Might Our Universe Have Been Born Inside a Black Hole?
When scientists say that an additional theory is ugly, they mean that adding the theory means ugly math. Ugly math is complicated, unsupported calculation--it's tweaking the theory to suit the data. In other words, the very reason they call it ugly is because of the things you cited. Now, it is certainly pseudo-science or wishful thinking, but cherry-picking the current knowledge base is how you create new theories.
Helianthus16··on If you believe in science you're doing it wrong
I don't particularly view it as empty, I just think it lies outside the framework of practicality.

It's like asking about the nature of hobbits. (Actually, this does have practical provenance in certain circles, but let's try to overlook that for a bit.) Hobbit qualities can be essentially whatever we want them to be, so their precise nature only matters insofar as they reflect our desires. We desire to hold true to Tolkien's vision, so we accept his details as truth and might extrapolate a bit here and there.

That doesn't mean the question has any bearing on reality.

Similarly, I could ask, why isn't there a force that could destroy our reality retroactively, eating through space and time a la the Nothing of the Never-Ending Story?

And the answer is more or less, if it happened, we would know (or rather, not know anymore) by now. The question assumes that there could be such a thing.

I suppose I view "Why doesn't the universe not exist?" in the same light.

Helianthus16··on RIAA paid its lawyers more than $16,000,000 in 2008 to recover only $391,000
No one will miss them much.

"The RIAA? Or their lawyers?"

Ohoho, ahah, I crack myself up.

edit: ALL RIGHT ALL RIGHT I'M SORRY I'M NOT FUNNY THIS LATE AT NIGHT I'LL NEVER MAKE BAD JOKES AGAIN

Helianthus16··on If you believe in science you're doing it wrong
1) There are a number of physics equations that generalize physical equations--Lagrangian mechanics. (IANAP, but I have a physicist friend.)

2) It is a misconception that physics can trace the whole history of the universe, or even any part of it. The Holy Grail Unified Theory is not a full descriptor of our universe, it is a full descriptor of the _forces_ of our universe.

3) There's something in your language that makes me feel like you're not really tackling the question completely. "Speaking purely subjectively" might be part of it--as if one can speak purely objectively.

Maybe it's just that _no_ system could ever adequately answer that question. Why anything? Why doesn't the universe not exist? The question itself is temptingly meaningful, but ultimately empty, since it itself is part of the universe. I don't even know how to begin constructing the universe's not existing in my mind.

So it's not a fault of science that it does not answer that question. It at least has the wisdom not to try.

Helianthus16··on If you believe in science you're doing it wrong
Meh. The whole question/controversy is just confusion about the word belief.

Statements in our minds can sometimes be accepted axiomatically--that is, what you believe to be true about reality. We need a way to comment on reality's qualities.

In this sense, "belief in science" can roughly be translated as, "belief that whatever science reveals is true re: our reality."

(It's actually all statistics, which means that we're only _excluding_ things from admittance into what we accept as true about our reality. Belief in science, then, is belief that only that which is detectable exists.)

So the article misses the point anyway; science doesn't _grant_ proof, it grants a process for disproof and allows us to believe in what's left over.

Helianthus16··on Love in the Age of the Pickup Artist
He said, talking about all of life. >_>
Helianthus16··on Dan Ariely on why online dating is so unsatisfying
Forgot about this post. Maybe it's not sensible to come back to it, but whatever.

There are several points of bullshit in your post. The first is that you are _absolutely_ ashamed of who you are. You don't think you'll be good enough for women! That's a wild self-degradation on your part. You'd take 1/3 of the women on dating sites? What kind of valid self-estimation is that supposed to be?

Second, no one cares about technical perfection. Technical perfection is not artistry, for one thing; artistry is about being, taking space, feeling, and embracing honesty. Things that aren't quantified because they aren't rational. This threatens to stray from the topic, so I'll cut it short for now and skip to the clearer argument, which is: there is someone better than you. The world is huge. And what will you do when you meet that person, if your ego depends on being the technical best?

For some reason you seek out visible status symbols to mark your ego's progress. Not everyone can be the President. Not everyone can program. Being the best is not a victory.

>I am never ashamed of who I am, and I will meet you face to face, give you my real name, and look you in the eye.

You just won't do that if I'm a _woman._ And if you did, you'd probably do a lot better at talking with them.

Helianthus16··on Love in the Age of the Pickup Artist
I wish he didn't try so hard to impress us, instead of writing an exercise in clear thought.

I was with him up to the "Let's show off what I've researched about the history of Love," which turned out to be, yes: there have always been pickup artists of a sort, and yes: there has always been desperate deep love. Thanks. I skimmed most of that indulgent name-dropping.

Then he tries to get clever with words and it goes downhill. Loads of those sections could be stripped out for clarity; elegance from simplicity, not pretense from complexity.

Liked the personal stories, the accounts of modern PUA. Did not like the way the research felt like name-dropping. He was trying too hard.

Nowhere is this more clear than in the stilted final sentences. "You have no choice in the matter. Love was hard enough already; it has only gotten harder. Your love will exhaust you. But it will be worth the trouble."

Helianthus16··on Love in the Age of the Pickup Artist
Without a moment of hesitation? Ha. I'm no PUA, but I doubt you fall in love at the drop of a hat. And if you do spot a girl across a crowded room, and think, By God, I'm in love!, you're not going to walk over there and tell her that on the spot.

Relationship protocols are designed around taking acceptable risks. Just because you're playing for real beating hearts doesn't mean there isn't a game.

Helianthus16··on Love in the Age of the Pickup Artist
Yes yes, this is one side of the coin; but you are willfully ignoring the other--willfully because it's presented in this topic.

If there is no art to forming deep emotional connections, then there is nothing interesting about it. The game is the protocol, the communication of what "real risk" one is taking.

PUAs always communicate that they are taking zero risk, _but_ they provide channels for women to also take zero risk. This is what makes them successful--they have mastered the shallow protocol.

But your deep emotional connections are also a game, as is your real risk. You wouldn't fall in love on a first date, would you? You've got rules of engagement, I expect? But I thought it was about the real risk of emotional agony! No.

What makes the game fun is when there is real risk, when you play for keeps. PUAs run the risk of forgetting why they got into the game to begin with.

Helianthus16··on Dan Ariely on why online dating is so unsatisfying
>I have the personality of leader,

You are entirely wrong, if you accept the rest of your post at face value.

Women like leadership.

Leadership in its most primal form is not about intelligence, decisiveness, alpha male-ness, or what-have-you. Leadership is about people believing you have any of those powers (or some several I forgot). And that's where you're going entirely wrong!

You think that such a belief is worthless. You think that people give up something when they follow a leader. A leader is just one who takes the desires and wishes of the people who follow them into his/her own heart.

You think that women are really such base operators and are upset at them for that. And that makes it impossible for you to see them as human.

If you think that making money and power will get you women, you're entirely right. You'll hit the point at which such things are so attractive that your other "defects" won't matter. Money can buy anything with a pricetag, and power can buy anything that can be intimidated.

But you won't be happy until you realize that you're on an equal level with those women whom you despise.

And that's the core of why I'm angry with you. You think you're better than women because they fall for speed seduction value elicitation bullshit, but at the same time you think you're hot shit ("personality of leader") and buy into same shit in your seeking of power. Do you think women will interest you once you can buy them?

The better framework is that yes, there are women who will fall for power and money; yes, there are women who will be seduced by "demonstration of value"; but there are a lot of women. Even speed seduction respects women's choice by taking tactics that try to influence it.

I apologize, I'm being harsh in calling you out so thoroughly. I'm a little drunk.

But fuck it, this story is about online dating in an absurdly negative light, and I've had more than a few friends succeed in online dating because they were serious about finding and evaluating someone.

Good luck in whatever sort of woman you choose to pursue.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5