1,063 karma · joined May 3, 2010
Ah. I misread the following...
>>This is actually what I expected to read:
as agreement ("This is actually what I expected to read."). My mistake.
>Unfortunately, rather more science takes place in the second domain than the first.
As I said to Homunculiheaded, this is because of the relative utility of the models, which we understand--and even those that do not understand it do not make the tool's use invalid.
What are we bemoaning, here, but actual misunderstanding itself?
And really, what's the point of that?
Something I never contested.
From Glyptodon:
>>"This is std dev. This is how you compute it. Make sure you put it your tables and report."
>>it wasn't always a sensible thing to be asked to calculate but was instead just an instinctive requirement.
I hate to break it to you, but this is how rote mathematics is taught. You can't communicate concepts purely, and hammering instinctive math is better than no math at all.
To reiterate, there's nothing wrong with the normal distribution. We're not about to retire addition or subtraction just because there are "plenty of people who don't really realize" there's more to math.
>You seem to be having some trouble reading what I'm writing, rather than what you think I should be writing.
Sure whatever, same to you.
Realization by who? If you understand the normal distribution you had damn well better know that there are other probability distributions.
>The problem of course is that the Cauchy distribution is pathological in that it doesn't have a mean or variance, you can calculate similar properties for it (location and scale), but it doesn't obey the central limit theorem so in practice it can be very strange to work with.
In other words, we're using the normal distribution as the workhorse because considering other distributions is, well, inefficient/unproductive.
> However a great amount of future progress is going to come from wrestling with more challenging distributions, and paying more attention to when assumptions of normality need to be questioned
What exactly is it that you think physicists have been doing for the past half century? The error accounting for CERN's experiments requires actual millions of PhD-hours.
This topic's conversation is at some bizarre intersection of good intentions, concrete knowledge, and woeful ignorance. I guess I tar myself with that brush.
But... it doesn't. You ever hear about the hypothetical possibility of your atoms lining up and falling through the floor?
It's hypothetical in the sense that it's really ridiculously unlikely, but there is no bound preventing it.
Now the central point about different probability curves stands, but that's not what Taleb was talking about--he seems to think that it's the tool's fault if people are using it wrong--and it's also not what Homunculiheaded argued.
Perhaps I am less critical of Paul as much as I am the crude politics of it all--thus critical of Paul by extension.
(Before you think I am directly calling Paul a hypocrite, what I mean is that the toxic flame wars are, by their nature, hypocritical, and it takes care to interact with them without appearing hypocritical yourself--care that I do not think Paul managed.)
:D
Dude actually wrote: 'by pointing out the degree to which women run things at YC it's closer to saying "I'm not racist! I'm black."'
Comedy gold. You just don't say stuff like that.
I mean, maybe he's got some semblance of a good point in there somewhere, but you can't hear it over the kneejerk outrage.
And maybe that's where I have a problem with this. PG ignores the flamewar unless by touching it he can get something he wants--the appropriate reputation amongst moderates. And he can't (and won't) get away scott free.
>This piece, seen as a consequentialist act, would be a gambit played to calm a possible negative tide in feminist circles toward YC, that might have resulted in YC getting fewer (qualified!) female applicants... which would be bad for business.
Precisely, with a possible qualifier on 'feminist circles'--moderate, maybe even conservative feminist circles.
By which I mean to say, he's pointedly ignoring the feminist concerns outside of the most mainstream: even those that have a point.
Which is why this isn't a conversation! There is no interchange of ideas happening here, only the inevitable flame war spawned by a HN gender topic.
This piece does nothing but puff up YC in an effort to distance YC from the tech sector's sexism, which will only work to a point.
The target audience is the section of moderate feminists that are inherently sympathetic to YC; the concerns of those outside that layer, even the valid ones, are simply not important to PG.
To reiterate: this is a posturing move, in the most neutral sense possible.
The rhetorical arc of the piece is public self-exoneration. I don't think you can reasonably argue otherwise.
PG isn't required to give a deposition of his thoughts on the matter. He could remain silent and continue working on what's important to him.
Or more interestingly, he could launch YC initiatives to get girls coding, shift resources towards some meaningful contribution, something more tangible. Possibly he's done that, and combined with aforementioned silence he might be cruising quite comfortably.
Instead he writes a piece designed to keep the 'more moderate people' from thinking YC sexist, a piece that changes nothing (the flame war abounds) except public perception.
See above, "working on what's important to him," with a certain wry taste.
The nature of this kind of discussion is always going to be hyperbolic and emotionally charged, which is why gender discussions here get nuked.
That's what I find so amusing about PG's foray today: PG could write the most innocuous treatise imaginable, and he'd still be getting into trouble, and deservedly so.
Ask yourself: what happens after this? Is YC going to be the shining light that brings sexual equality to the Valley?
Or does YC culture get to pat itself on the back for being less sexist than the other parts of tech culture and continue its general status quo?
This essay doesn't heal any divide; it just stirs the pot a bit more. It's about reputation, not solutions--which is somewhat a shame, because the second half of the essay (which essentially is a restatement of PG's initial comment) is pretty thoughtful and reasonable.
I mean that ('posture piece') as neutrally, perhaps, as it is possible to mean it.
>come away with the idea that YC is somehow sexist.
And you can say, with a straight face, that YC is not sexist? That it's just the tech environment, and you're on the 'right side'?
Again, this is about your reputation--controlling the narrative.
(Though I share your ^_^)
He asked for real criticism, guys. His post is really high on imagination and low on delivery, and if you don't see that you should probably think about how many people have created our programming languages and contemplate doing better.
This person isn't having conversations with them.
Am I rude for requiring him to step up to his talk?
Edit:
>>In other words, I think this might be the killer feature that allows one programming language to outcompete most others.
This sentence alone is flagrant ignorance.
What exactly do you think you're on to? Insight has built all of the things that you're hoping to replace. So what are you bringing to the table?
>(I am surely not the first person to have this insight, but it's WAY ahead of being mainstream).
Great. Maybe you can actually bring it into the mainstream. With code.
Imagination is fun, but you're not doing more than imagining.
... for Christ's sake. Give it a rest, he's not a mustache-twiddling dastardly capitalist and the banking system is not trying to keep Bitcoin down.
The banking system is ignoring you.
I'm not talking about Winklevii clowns or a few comments from a few figures or a Senate hearing.
I'm talking about the corporations for whom 8 billion ('market cap' for Bitcoin) is pennies. Chase has 2.5 trillion in assets. It does not care about Bitcoin.
More importantly, no one in Bitcoinland seems to realize that Bitcoin is re-implementing our financial system, and doing it badly--perhaps because when they do, they realize how silly it all is.
The discussion has reached a place of little common ground--a sign, perhaps, that maybe soon the universe will actually hand down a ruling and we can put down our HN accounts and go home.
All of the debates on this issue have happened already. There's nothing left but vitriol and broken dreams.
If I were to step aside and look at the current ground in context, I think we're seeing the effects of China's rebuff, and I think we're seeing Bitcoin fail on the global stage.
There's only so much cheap faith in the world, and every time Bitcoin lets people down that rich resource is depleted. We've seen Bitcoin build up attention in the tech world (initial crash way back in the day), in the financial world (the most ludicrous crash, back in the spring), and now in China.
What's left?
The obnoxious thing--to me--about this play money trend isn't that people are giving it serious attention and thought, it's the shiny ideals in the eyes of the greedy.
It provokes a reaction in me: how dare any Bitcoin advocate take moral ground against a system that, whatever its flaws, protects its community from the disasters Bitcoin repeatedly faces?
Greed. Greed greed greed.
Unsurprisingly, PG takes Bitcoin seriously.
This is a perfect example of the entitlement people feel to be free from others' ire or criticism.
This back-pedaling is where you begin to lose steam.
> Nobody tries to tell a cancer patient how to treat their cancer, yet so many people feel obliged to opine about mental illness.
Including the psychiatrists who admit to 'more art than science.'
>You pretty much need to start with the medication, then work from there to figure out which group they're in, and adapt their treatment accordingly (i.e. stick with meds or drop them but help them learn how to manage it).
Sounds essentially like just guessing.
Now let's look at your first statement.
>While I'm sure you mean no harm, you are - quite simply - wrong.
While I'm sure psychiatrists mean no harm, that doesn't mean they're right.