HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Herring

3,347 karma · joined February 3, 2008

submissionscomments
Herring··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
Yeah none of that fever dream is real. There's no "after" a civil war, conflicts persist for decades (Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Myanmar, Colombia, Sudan).

Check this out - https://data.worldhappiness.report/chart. The US is increasingly a miserable place to live in, and the worse it gets the more their people double down on being shitty.

Fun fact: Fit 2 lines on that data and you can extrapolate by ~2030 China will be a better place to live. That's really not that far off. Set a reminder on your phone: Chinese dream.

Herring··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
It probably depends on the society you start out with, eg a high trust culture like Finland will probably fare better here.
Herring··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
American culture actively punishes compassion, then gaslights you about it.

https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/interactive/te... Look at all the professions on the bottom right: Teachers, therapists, clergy, social workers, etc. It’s not a coincidence that cruel people take top positions.

Herring··on Bag of words, have mercy on us
Give it time. The first iPhone sucked compared to the Nokia/Blackberry flagships of the day. No 3G support, couldn't copy/paste, no apps, no GPS, crappy camera, quick price drops, negligible sales in the overall market.

https://metr.org/blog/2025-03-19-measuring-ai-ability-to-com...

Herring··on Most technical problems are people problems
Marx died in 1883. Things have moved on a little since then.

Some parts of the economy are great under state control: monetary policy, military, infrastructure, healthcare, education, safety nets, etc.

Some parts prefer a mix of public and private investment: utilities, rail, airports, R&D.

Others work best with very little direct state control (other than regulations): most retail, consumer goods, IT, etc.

Herring··on Why Speed Matters
Sometimes the perception of speed is just as important as actual speed. No I'm not bitter, why do you ask?
Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
Dude go figure it out yourself, it's not that hard. I remember discussing inequality with friends in 2014, and probably knew about it since Occupy Wall Street (2011). Or earlier. At this point if you still don't get it, with a billionaire in office, surely it's on you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupy_Wall_Street

I got what I needed from here, I'm out.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
You're not thinking at a systems level. Check this out - https://data.worldhappiness.report/chart. The US is increasingly a miserable place to live in - in large part because of pay not keeping up with housing/school/medical/etc.

Correct systems-level answer to your question "how much do I pay you" is "as much as it takes to stabilize the US curve". Happiness correlates with financial security, which we won't get if the rich get richer from those capital investments then buy up all the housing.

Fun fact: Fit 2 lines on that data and you can extrapolate by ~2030 China will be a better place to live. That's really not that far off. Set a reminder on your phone.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
As a general rule, it's unethical people who like to ignore ethical issues for their own benefit.

And there's plenty I can do. Studying the issue & preparing a move, to name two. You want to roll over cause that's your lack of ethics.

It won't work out for you. Set a reminder for 2030.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
> I own your tools therefore I own everything you do with them

Like I said, madness.

It's like slavery was technically outlawed but a lot of America strongly disagreed. And they're posting on HN.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
I'm just tired of re-litigating this issue. Discuss with your favorite frontier model. Roughly, productivity has been outpacing pay since the mid 1970s, and I wrote about this in another comment here.

There's just so much confusion here. Some people like you don't get why a world where a handful of billionaires own everything is a bad idea. Madness. I think nothing less than another depression will get through to most.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
Those economic policies were a backlash to the 1970s Civil Rights pushes. You can always count on racists to destroy themselves rather than to stop abusing others.
Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
What do you mean "we"? The rich are much much richer than they've ever been. The stock market is soaring. Companies are seeing record profits. GDP is through the roof.

http://web.archive.org/web/20200428221848/https://www.nytime...

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
It's not that I don't like it. It's more that I think you're being lied to. Inequality has been going up in the US for a very long time, which means a lot of people are not being rewarded as much as they should. But they still buy into the system that is impoverishing them.

The top 10% of income earners in the US account for 50% of consumer spending. LMK if you think that's part of the contract. https://www.marketplace.org/story/2025/02/24/higher-income-a...

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
Ok so that's 1 guy 100 years ago. How many golden parachutes and layoffs have there been since then? Cmon people put 2+2 together, it's not that hard.
Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
I might sympathize, but reality doesn't care. At the end of the day it doesn't matter why they voted for something. They did and it's here.
Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
There's never been any such contract. You guys must not have studied the Great Depression at school.

Or more to the point, productivity has consistently outpaced pay for most of the US workforce since the mid-1970s. That's ~50 years that companies have been ripping you off. It's only now you notice, because rent/mortgage/school/medical have finally become so much larger than pay.

Well now you get to live through the Great Depression and study it up close.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
What social contract? Companies have always been for shareholders. Do you people have some kind of contract with Tesla that I don't know about?

This entire discussion sounds crazy to me. If you want socialism, vote for socialism. If you want raw unfiltered capitalism, vote for the billionaire. You can't vote for the billionaire and expect safety nets. That's madness.

Herring··on The Junior Hiring Crisis
We're still in the early days. It's gonna get a lot worse, if the LLM scaling laws are to be believed.

https://metr.org/blog/2025-03-19-measuring-ai-ability-to-com...

Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
Idk man, I'm pretty sure there's more going on than that. Look at this study for example https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11109-024-10000-8

Normal people would become more liberal.

Or look at how badly teachers are treated https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/interactive/te...

Or look at the way Americans punished Democrats really hard after Obamacare https://www.quorum.us/data-driven-insights/under-obama-democ... Democrats won't make that mistake again of listening to Bernie any time soon.

Or look at how bad the coronavirus response was, for such a rich country.

Something's deeply wrong with American political culture, like from watching too much Game of Thrones or something. It’s not just being misled, it’s ingrained.

I think for many Cruelty <=> Power. Like how guns make them feel powerful. I wasn't born here originally so I don't really get it (thank god). It won't end well.

Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
> this is a deliberate choice to make labor less powerful...

To be fair, though, I don't trust modern labor either if they can't figure out how to NOT vote for a rapist pedophile real-estate billionaire. Twice. Including a pandemic and a coup.

What a mess we find ourselves in.

Herring··on Major AI conference flooded with peer reviews written by AI
That’s on you. You get to decide what “best” means when picking among the K, so you only get bs if you want bs.

I occasionally get people telling me AI is unreliable, and I tell them the same thing: the tech is nearly infinitely flexible (computing over the space of ideas!), so that says a lot more about how they’re using it.

Herring··on Major AI conference flooded with peer reviews written by AI
Don't kid yourself, all those steps have AI heavily involved in them.

And that's not necessarily a bad thing. If I set up RAG correctly, then tell the AI to generate K samples, then spend time to pick out the best one, that's still significant human input, and likely very good output too. It's just invisible what the human did.

And as models get better, the necessary K will become smaller....

Herring··on Major AI conference flooded with peer reviews written by AI
I couldn't care less tbh. I just want to know whether they're correct or not. We need something like unit testing and integration testing, but for ideas.

For the record I actually like the AI writing style. It's a huge improvement in readability over most academic writing I used to come across.

Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
We just went through a ton of layoffs, while those companies are making record profits.
Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
Yep you just rediscovered alienation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation

Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
I think that’s a bit unfair. I’d say shipping a product that solves a problem is the baseline entry fee into the market, just table stakes. Profitability is determined by the machine built around the product, like the efficiency of capital deployment, the speed of distribution, the defensibility of the business model against competition, etc. The product is just one variable in a much bigger equation.
Herring··on How good engineers write bad code at big companies
> Big companies know that treating engineers as fungible and moving them around destroys their ability to develop long-term expertise in a single codebase. That’s a deliberate tradeoff. They’re giving up some amount of expertise and software quality in order to gain the ability to rapidly deploy skilled engineers onto whatever the problem-of-the-month is.

And also to "keep the balance of power tilted away from engineers and towards tech company leadership." The author touched on that and forgot about it. You don't want key projects depending on a group of engineers that might get hit by a bus or unionize or demonstrate against Israel or something. Network effects and moats and the occasional lobbying/collusion mean the quality of your product is less important.

Herring··on Three Years from GPT-3 to Gemini 3
> Everybody should be as unhappy as me

I'm not from the US and I think that attitude is fucked up. You'll get your wish -- the US has been steadily dropping on the lists of "World's Happiest Countries"[1]. But luckily I don't need to do anything. Nature will teach you what a simple text box cannot. Eventually you guys will ruin all your important institutions & become deeply unhappy & hit rock bottom & start meditating or something.

[1] https://data.worldhappiness.report/chart -- Fit a line and you can extrapolate by ~2030 China will be a better place to live. That's really not that far away. That attitude is not "universal".

Herring··on Ilya Sutskever: We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of research
Nope, Epoch.ai thinks we have enough to scale till 2030 at least. https://epoch.ai/blog/can-ai-scaling-continue-through-2030

^

/_\

***

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →