HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Herval_freire

97 karma · joined March 30, 2023

https://linktr.ee/herval

Contact info:

Address: 6363 Christie Ave, APT 2302, Emeryville, CA 94608

Phone: (917) 704-0699

email: hervalfreire@gmail.com

Media relations: Michelle Veronese

(https://www.linkedin.com/in/michelleveronese)

submissionscomments
Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
I think there just isn't enough mathematical data. English language data is magnitudes more and longer then mathematical data so there is a correlation here.

The more data the better the LLM can formulate a realistic model. If it has less data then the resulting output is more of a statistical guess.

There is an argument that can be made here that the more data the more things chatgpt can copy and regurgitate but given how vast the solution space is I think data at best covers less then 1 percent.

Basically I think that if your data covers say 2 percent of the solution space you can generate a better model then if the data covered 1 percent.

Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
Gotta look at the actual numbers for jobs in photography. These numbers say a lot more then a "few" data points.
Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
No there is reasoning in LLMs. This is actually proven through several scientific papers.

I can't say whether it's using reasoning for specific answers. I'm sure many times it just regurgitates something that is known... But saying that LLMs in general can and do reason is categorically true. LLMs do attempt to extract actual mental models of the subject of the text.

See here:

- GPT style language models try to build a model of the world: https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.13382

- GPT style language models end up internally implementing a mini "neural network training algorithm" (gradient descent fine-tuning for given examples): https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10559

For your specific case, given the conditions, another explanation that fits as well is that the LLM simply needs more data to build a more complete model for elixir. Once it does that I'm sure it can respond with completely novel elixir code as it already does with python.

Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
Unlikely. GPT-4 wasn't as game changing as chatGPT. People are less hyped up and have a more realistic expectation of what they should see out of an LLM.

The extreme positive reaction to gpt4 is imo not driven by hype fuel.

In fact, if you recall the hype fuel surrounding the initial chatGPT was in both parts positive and negative. There were equal portions of people praising it and people vehemently dismissing it as a stochastic parrot. That's not what I see here.

Herval_freire··on Nim 2.0.0 RC2
You're just using the tacked on features as syntactic sugar. You haven't "bought in" at all.

I was traditionally trained like you under OOP and procedural methodologies.

After encounter FP I fully bought in and developed two mental models. The fp model lives side by side with the the oop/imperative model.

With equal knowledge in both one can make a more unbiased judgement. The fp model is actually superior imo.

I largely have the opposite strategy now when programming. My mental model is largely fp, and I occasionally cheat and sprinkle in procedural or oop syntax here and there as syntactic sugar.

The basic realization here should be that mutating shared state should be avoided and segregated as much as possible.

Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
You're a good manager. But not everyone/company is like this.
Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
The evolution of comments here on HN are telling.

1 month ago people were saying there was no way AI could do their job and many were telling everyone to calm down as nothing would happen.

Now one month later this entire thread is about how chatGPT is an integral part of the development process. There are people even saying it replaces junior developers completely.

Can anyone venture to guess what the thread will look like in 1 more year?

"chatGPT can do the work of an entire team!"

And one more year after that?

"chatGPT can manage a team!"

Herval_freire··on AI-enhanced development makes me more ambitious with my projects
>To use a relatively modern analogy, AI-enhanced development is to developers what Photoshop is to photographers.

Photography as a job has been hit heavily by modern smart phone advances. Heavily. It's now very hard to get paid a living wage as a photographer. With mid journey it's now even harder. Photographers weren't completely replaced. I would say they were mostly replaced because now every Tom dick and Jane can take photos as good as any professional photographer.

>AI [in its current iteration] cannot do that.

All these changes happened within 6 months of progress. The technology has not stabilized. The current "iteration" will be obsolete very, very, very soon..

>As developers, our jobs are safe. Jobs will not be lost at a massive scale; only those unwilling to learn a new tool will be replaced.

Only for the current iteration of AI. Can you say the same for the next several iterations of chatGPT? No. Given the trendline, if it keeps continuing finding a job in software will be like finding a job in photography.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4