HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Illniyar

4,822 karma · joined February 17, 2013

https://alonbd.com
submissionscomments
Illniyar··on Bear is now source-available
That is exactly the stance. If there are strings attached that means some people can't use it, it's not really open. (GPL has strings attached if you use it, which is bad in a different way)

I don't think anyone has a problem with the non open source licenses themselves. If you start with a closed source license or whatever, that's fine. It is switching from an open source licenses to something that is not.

A lot of the projects that later switched out of open source would have never gotten any traction if they started with the license they ended up with.

Illniyar··on New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
The article doesn't make sense to me. They mention 1900-1938 life expectancy rose by ~5 months per generation. And then say it grew from 62 years to 80. Does that mean each generation is ~2-3 years? What unit of measurement is that supposed to be?

Then for 1938-2000 they say it's 2.5 months per generation. If generation is 2-3 years we should already be at 100 year expectancy.

Also having 1900-1938 and 1938-2000 as the only points in time seem meaningless. Does the entire 1938-2000 have a single graident? What's the slope here?

They also mention that the main advancement in 1900-1938 is infant mortality. Which is really uninteresting for the old age.

Illniyar··on Essential Coding Theory [pdf]
Encoding and encrypting is often used synonymously and many times simultaneously. Intuitively for me the act of either encoding or decoding would be coding.
Illniyar··on A 2k-year-old sun hat worn by a Roman soldier in Egypt
If geopolitical stability was a precursor to technology, we would still be living in the stone age :)
Illniyar··on Bank forced to rehire workers after lying about chatbot productivity, union says
This is mentioned a lot, but it's still true - people on HN are not representative of the majority of users for customer support.

The majority of support tickets are repetitive and answered by a simple formula the representative churns without thinking. Which is likely easily replaceable by chatbots.

Illniyar··on Notion releases offline mode
I've never heard of companies using Obsidian. Notion isn't really marketed or suitable for individuals (even if their free plan says otherwise).
Illniyar··on "Privacy preserving age verification" is bullshit
My point was that adultery is no longer legally enforced was not because of concerns about government overreach. Whether it's morality or religion that changed people's mind about enforcement of Adultery is tangential
Illniyar··on "Privacy preserving age verification" is bullshit
I think that's a bit of rationalizing. I don't thinks there's much evidence that Adultery is no longer a criminal offense because people were concerned about privacy or government control.

It's that people became more secular, Adultery is considered a sin and not a crime, and modern countries instituted separation between religious and secular laws.

Illniyar··on Why We Migrated from Neon to PlanetScale
It's definitely a business model. Just like a dark pattern is a pattern :)

The counter to that argument is that it's creating an adverse effect on your most profitable customers, with an incentive to move to offerings that don't have free tiers (or where the free tiers are not considerably affecting your own costs).

If your free tier is so lucrative that you need to 25x the cost, then your free tier is too expansive and you need to tone it down until the economics make sense.

Illniyar··on A game that can be played riding the New York Subway (1980)
The game suggest - Claremont Parkway to 13 Av. Here's the map in 1964 - https://www.nycsubway.org/perl/show?/img/maps/calcagno-1967-...

I had to use google just to find Claremont Parkway on the map :) (I did find 13 av. I imagine people who this is their first time in NY would probably also be confused with 13 st)

And from the article it seems like the navigation inside the subways were also very hard - they are not intuitive even now (with some entrances only allowing one way for example, and you have to go out and back in again)

Illniyar··on Persona vectors: Monitoring and controlling character traits in language models
That's interesting! I guess the question is how did they detect or simulate a model hallucinating in that regard?

Do you have a link to that article? I can't find anything of that nature with a shallow search.

Illniyar··on Persona vectors: Monitoring and controlling character traits in language models
I can see this working with "evil" and "sycophantic" personas. These seem like traits that would be amenable to input and thus be detectable by manipulating the input.

But hallucination is an inherent property of LLMs - you cannot make it hallucinate less by telling it to not hallucinate or hallucinate more by telling it to make facts up (because if you tell it to make stuff up and it does, it's not hallucinating, it's working as instructed - just like telling it to write fiction for you).

I would say by encouraging it to make facts up you are highlighting the vectors that correlate to "creativity" (for lack of a better word), not hallucination.

Illniyar··on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short
I find it weird that people are taking the original paper to be some kind of indictment against llms. It's not like LLMs failing at doing Hanoi tower problem at higher levels is new, the paper took an existing method that was done before.

It was simply comparing the effectiveness of reasoning and non reasoning models on the same problem.

Illniyar··on Meta invests $14.3B in Scale AI to kick-start superintelligence lab
Matt Levine suggested that this was an aquihire. And the weird setup where they only buy non voting shares is to not trigger any regulatory review
Illniyar··on Meta buys Scale AI in a $14.3B deal
Matt Levine suggested that this was an aquihire. And the weird setup where they only buy non voting shares is to not trigger any regulatory review
Illniyar··on Next.js 15.1 is unusable outside of Vercel
It made it by default. It's also not much of an "opt-out". An opt-out would be called "disableStreamingMetadata". Names convey intent, and it's obvious this is intended to be the behavior for all users with maybe an exception.

The problem is that this is needed for a minuscule amount of users. This should've been an opt-in. The choice to make it opt-out is quite weird.

Illniyar··on Next.js 15.1 is unusable outside of Vercel
I think it was that if metadata requires getting data from third parties or something, it takes a long time, and it doesn't affect what the user sees.

It did say this was a problem for very few people.

Illniyar··on Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc
Oh, Apple is doing windows Aero now? Wonder how long that one'll last.
Illniyar··on Cockatoos have learned to operate drinking fountains in Australia
Perhaps it's an issue with multiple combatants? If fights are not one on one then having one crab be difficult to work with can be a problem
Illniyar··on Porn sites go dark in France over new age verification rules
>This system, referred to as “double anonymity”, means the porn site receives only a yes-or-no confirmation that the user is of legal age. The age-check provider knows who the user is, but not which sites they visit.

I don't know the specifics, but seems very reasonable if implemented matches the promise. If it's required also for some non porn sites (social media? gambling maybe), there should be no stigma attached either.

Illniyar··on OpenAI reaches agreement to buy Windsurf for $3B
Cursor purports 200m in projected yearly revenue. With some months having 40% month over month growth. The trajectory is vastly different.

Whether or not it's justified is a different matter, but for startups valuations are more about potential then current performance.

Illniyar··on Show HN: A motherfucking app (does one thing, under 300 LOC)
This is clickbait. The app does two things, there's a do nothing and a do one thing button. That's TWO things, not one. One thing would be ONE button.

0 star review. Developer should be ashamed of himself and should never ever build another thing ever again.

Illniyar··on "AI-first" is the new Return To Office
"An average LLM won't even know that Drake's favorite MIME type is application/pdf"

Is this seeding for future AI models? If I ask chatGPT a year from now what is drake's favorite Mime type would it confidently say "application/PDF"

Illniyar··on Bored of It
Right? How much more can we stand all this talk about cryptocurrency and Bitcoin.
Illniyar··on The Frontend Treadmill
I love it when people phrase this as a frontend problem. It's not a frontend problem. It's just a "it's a huge ecosystem with new players" problem.

I've seen this in Java 15 years ago when it was the front of innovation (I can name dozens of frameworks, and a half dozen build systems coming out in as many years). React 17-18 is quite a minor change then perl 5->6 or python 2->3

For backend instead of "let's use this new framework", I get the "let's use this new LANGUAGE" - the newest hottness is to rewrite something in Rust. It was Go before that, haskell, scala, F# (yes I got that too).

You think migrating your frontend code from react to svelte or whatever is troublesome, trying rewriting that VB 6 app :) (Or god forbid something like RPC where your data is in the code)

Not saying that the unstableness of engineering practices aren't a problem. It's a huge problem. Just that it's not a frontend problem.

Illniyar··on Fauna Service Winding Down
No new customers is not shutting down services you rely on. It's the exact opposite. It's making sure things you rely on continue to work until you are ok leaving it.

And SimpleDB has been deprecated for years. I don't know think there's a single service you could have picked to better highlight the point.

AWS does close services, from time to time, all companies do, but the services they choose and the way they do it instill confidence in customers. The way GCP does it instills fear

Illniyar··on Fauna Service Winding Down
Google is the exception that proves the rule. Companies are fearful of using GCP exactly because of their terrible reputation of unreliability (and lack of even basic support).

No one fears AWS or Azure is going to shut down services they rely on (even if it happens in some rare cases).

Illniyar··on Handling cookies is a minefield
Solved the problem almost completely in npm. Sure you can't search for a name of a company or a project and expect it to be related to the company or project. But there's no way to solve that.

But once you know a namespace is owned by a company or project, you can know that everything under it is legit. Which solves the vast majority of squatting and impersonation problems.

Also you know that everything under "node" for example is part of the language.

Illniyar··on Math from Three to Seven
Regarding Soviet prowess, I always considered the fact that going to higher education considerably shortened and made easier your military draft term to be a main factor.

Everyone who could went to university, because why wouldn't you? This incentive pressure and selection bias we're probably insane.

Illniyar··on This Message Does Not Exist
I was sure this was going to be a gen-ai site that is going to generate messages on the fly.
← PreviousPage 3 of 31Next →