HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

J-dawg

2,993 karma · joined November 3, 2014

submissionscomments
J-dawg··on First person receives Pfizer Covid-19 vaccine in UK
The UK government has already stated that pregnant women won't be getting the vaccine. (https://inews.co.uk/news/health/covid-vaccine-pregnant-women...)

This seems at odds with the gung-ho "it's 100% safe" rhetoric of our politicians.

I am by no means an anti-vaxxer, but I'm already finding it creepy the way any concerns are simply being dismissed. It's also just bad policy: it means that any unexpected side-effects that do emerge (even if very rare / not serious) will look much worse and immediately stink of a cover-up.

What's wrong with saying: "We are confident, to a reasonable degree of certainty, that the risk of taking this vaccine is lower than the risk of contracting Covid"? Not "This vaccine is definitely safe". I am sick of politicians treating the electorate as if they are morons who can't understand the slightest bit of nuance.

As you mention, vaccines can cause harm and have done in the past. Some degree of caution might be warranted.

J-dawg··on Boeing's upgraded 737 Max completes first flight with media onboard
Thanks for that explanation. I think this was misreported at the time (or I just wasn't paying attention!).

In a way what you described is worse: a known bug that they decided not to fix.

I'm surprised that displaying the sensor value wouldn't be a standard feature.

J-dawg··on Boeing's upgraded 737 Max completes first flight with media onboard
In the original design, wasn't there an optional safety feature that added a second AoA sensor? It seems unbelievable, and is possibly one of the most ridiculous things about this whole story.

Presumably as part of the update, this optional feature has become standard?

I'd also like to see a list of all the airlines that chose not to spec the additional sensor in their initial order of the aircraft. It probably says a lot about their safety culture.

J-dawg··on Pfizer Covid vaccine approved for use next week in UK
> The maths says that we need about 70% of the population to take the vaccine in order for it to no longer be a threat

...to no longer be a threat to an unvaccinated person.

This isn't like the childhood vaccines, where we need herd immunity to protect the children who are too young to be vaccinated.

Provided that everyone who wants the vaccine can get it, I don't see the problem with letting everyone else make their own decision.

The current priority list of people is nowhere near 70% of the population anyway. Most people under 50 won't have the opportunity to be vaccinated for months. So this absolutely is a theoretical problem, at least for now.

Given that Covid is such a mild disease for most young people, I predict that by the time the elderly and vulnerable have been vaccinated, this will be a non-issue anyway.

J-dawg··on Pfizer Covid vaccine approved for use next week in UK
Conversely, I am finding the reaction to anti-vaccine sentiment from some politicians to be pretty creepy. Already there is talk of compulsory vaccination or "vaccine passports". Labour (the UK opposition party) were even calling for spreading "misinformation" online to be illegal.

I find this ridiculous considering the massive challenge we have ahead of us just to get the vaccine to the millions of people who desperately want it.

Sure, if we get to the point where everyone who wants the vaccine has had it, and there are still people dying from COVID, then we can discuss illiberal measures to increase vaccine take-up. (I'd still be opposed to them).

Getting worked up about this stuff when not a single person (outside of the trial groups) has been vaccinated yet just demonstrates our politicians' (on all sides) tendency towards authoritarianism.

J-dawg··on Why do I care the open web is dying?
I think there's an argument for breaking up Facebook for antitrust reasons.

I used to be fine with the "Just don't use Facebook" argument. I quit it myself several years ago.

But recently I've found myself being genuinely inconvenienced by not being on Facebook. My gym for example, uses a Facebook group as its main forum. Several sports clubs and businesses I use now have a Facebook page as their main "web site". Friends tell me that Facebook marketplace is overtaking Gumtree as the best place to buy and sell. I am missing out on participating in all of these groups.

I don't blame any of these organisations for opting to use Facebook. They're all too small to employ anyone to maintain a website. Facebook no doubt gives them a great CMS and makes everything easy.

But it seems completely wrong that I have to submit to Facebook, with its real name policy and abuse of my data, to participate in these groups.

The markets for startups in any of these areas must be hugely stifled by Facebook's monopoly. Who would be brave enough to start a business building a CMS for gyms at this point?

I'm not a lawyer, but I don't see how this is different from Microsoft bundling a browser with an OS. In many ways it's worse.

J-dawg··on “Accentism” is real, but impossible to end
Why stop at accent bias training? We also need:

Facial symmetry bias training

Height bias training

Big 5 personality trait bias training

Parental upbringing bias training

Intelligence bias training

Competency bias training

Maybe then we'll reach the brave new world where everyone is exactly equal

J-dawg··on “Accentism” is real, but impossible to end
Stuff like this highlights (one of many reasons) why identity politics is such a bad idea.

Every one of us can be sliced up a hundred ways into things that might be a "privilege" or a disadvantage: accent, height, attractiveness, personality traits.

J-dawg··on World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)
It has often surprised me how many people don't understand this part of the egg industry.

I eat eggs, so I'm definitely not making any moral judgements, but the process is brutal. I would definitely buy no-kill eggs when they come to the UK.

J-dawg··on Danish study finds face masks provide limited protection to wearer
> There's plenty of evidence mask campaigns slow transmission

By how much do they slow transmission?

> It's not fun but I see it as a minuscule sacrifice for me to wear a mask to the grocery store if it saves even one person a trip to the hospital

People go to hospital with flu every year. You or I might have unknowingly spread it around and caused someone to go to hospital before. Will you wear a mask every flu season, forever? It's worth it if it saves even one person a trip to the hospital, right?

J-dawg··on Danish study finds face masks provide limited protection to wearer
This might make you even more surprised about my existence, but I'm not entirely unsympathetic to the "ideological" types.

Let me put it another way: why weren't you wearing a mask during flu season every year? Or, given that Covid will probably exist in some form for many years to come (even with a vaccine), when will you stop wearing one?

Because you could make a case for mandatory mask wearing at all times, forever, using the same logic that's currently being employed: "it's only a minor inconvenience and if it saves even one life, it's worth it".

Presumably you won't wear a mask forever: you'll make a personal decision, based on data or gut feeling, that the "effect size" of mask wearing is no longer worth the inconvenience. You were already making that calculation, implicitly, when you chose not to wear a mask during flu season last year.

That calculation will be different for every individual. Which is why I don't think any of us is really in a position to judge another person when the parameters of the calculation are different for them. Ultimately, the differing parameters of that calculation are what we call "ideology".

To return to my original point, it's also why we vitally need an open discussion on the "effect size" of wearing a mask. If it's large (I suspect it is not), then it gives more weight to the idea that all the Karens should just shut up and wear one. If it's small, there's a lot more room for personal choice.

J-dawg··on Danish study finds face masks provide limited protection to wearer
That is an absolutely horrible idea, and is exactly what fuels widespread mistrust of public health initiatives.

Tell the damn truth. If something is uncertain, tell the damn truth about how uncertain it is.

J-dawg··on Danish study finds face masks provide limited protection to wearer
I guess I could say I'm "mask skeptical" even though I do wear one to conform to social pressure.

I wish the conversation would move on from "do masks work?" to "do they work well enough to be worth the cost?"

Because I think the costs are being significantly underestimated. We are social creatures. All of the joy has been taken out of routine daily activities. Putting on a mask at the supermarket entrance as if you're about to enter some contaminated danger zone. Being unable to give a friendly smile to people as you pass them. I am 100% sure it's affecting my mental health, and I can't be the only one. In online discussion, these concerns get brushed aside as if they are the complaints of a spoiled child: "stop being a Karen and put a damn mask on..."

I'm not some science denier. It seems logical that a barrier over the mouth and nose must limit how far droplets can travel. As I understand it, empirical evidence also supports this (when the mask is worn by an infected person). There may be some (weak) evidence that masks also protect a non-infected wearer, despite this study.

But the size of the effect can't be that big. Here in the UK mask compliance is high, yet we're well into our second wave. So in the real world, masks can't be doing all that much. (Or, most of the infections are happening in mask-free places such as between family members in the home).

So maybe I'm just another "Karen", but I want more evidence that I'm enduring the costs of mask-wearing for a good reason.

In the meantime, I'll keep wearing my mask because it seems to keep everyone else happy, but I'm continually disappointed by the lack of nuanced discussion about this.

J-dawg··on Ask HN: I'm missing travelling in pandemic. How do you satisfy your wanderlust?
It's just a shame the UK is so densely populated / overpopulated.

When the rules were relaxed in the summer, it seemed like every outdoor place I normally go to was overrun with people. Makes you realise how many people we export to other places in a normal summer.

J-dawg··on Never Pay for Online Dating (2010)
Absolutely, it's a horrible thing to contemplate. As a single man who is not very successful with women, I'm equally afraid of this outcome as I am of being alone forever. Perhaps even more.

I would love to find a way of coming to terms with this that doesn't involve adopting the full red pill attitude of "never get married, all women are like that" etc

J-dawg··on Never Pay for Online Dating (2010)
One of the rather bleak theories that has come out of the Red Pill / men's rights movements is that women develop this sense of entitlement because:

1. Attractive / high value men are happy to sleep with less attractive women they wouldn't consider as 'relationship material'.

2. Women are generally more sexually liberated so there's an increasing chance they will have had several of these encounters, and therefore believe they are entitled to men of the same level (also known as becoming an 'alpha widow').

Like most of these theories it's pretty depressing to contemplate, but I'm yet to see a convincing refutation of it.

J-dawg··on Ask HN: Talked about my fave cereals now I see ads for the exact cereals. How?
As soon as you learn about this phenomenon you start seeing it everywhere
J-dawg··on Ask HN: Talked about my fave cereals now I see ads for the exact cereals. How?
Almost all of these "OMG Google/Facebook is listening to me" happenings can be explained by this mechanism
J-dawg··on Over 80% of Covid-19 patients in a hospital study have Vitamin D deficiency
Recently I keep seeing references to protecting oneself by wearing a mask.

When did the narrative shift from "wear a mask to limit transmission to others in case you might be infected and asymptomatic" to "wear a mask to protect yourself"?

Assuming we are talking about the usual surgical / cloth masks here (not N95 etc), is there any evidence that they protect the wearer?

We all know that mask wearing and the science (or lack of it) to support it has become ridiculously politicised, but I'm curious if there's any evidence behind this particular shift.

J-dawg··on The ‘Caspian Sea Monster’ rises from the grave
Every time these things are mentioned, I always wonder about that. Now that someone is building a modern equivalent (https://www.wigetworks.com), I wonder what they are doing about avoiding collisions.

Normal aircraft typically spend long periods in autopilot, whereas these things would presumably require a constantly vigilant pilot. And not just to avoid big ships, there are plenty of things floating in the ocean that could destroy one of these things: small boats, buoys, debris. The mast of a small sailing dinghy would be enough to cause a catastrophic crash.

I like the idea of this kind of craft, but I can't see it working at scale.

J-dawg··on My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too
Around the peak of chatbot hype, someone described them as "an obfuscated command line".

In my experience that's exactly what they are; you end up second-guessing the machine and thinking "what do I need to type to get where I need to be". It's like playing one of those old text based adventure games.

I can't remember a single encounter with a chatbot where a good search interface wouldn't have got me there faster.

J-dawg··on Coinbase offers exit package for employees not comfortable with its mission
> Good God, your firm exists to facilitate trading in speculative assets peddled by libertarian internet millionaires and that just so happen to be exceptionally useful for laundering money - enabling a whole online industry of shadow markets that were thought impossible a decade ago

This is a fantastic sentence. One of those times when I wish I could upvote more than once.

Arguably even more puzzling are the social activists at Facebook etc. They work for a platform that has interfered with democracy, has been proven to cause or exacerbate mental health problems, tramples over privacy, and at the very least is deliberately designed to be addictive and waste a lot of people's time.

It is strange that people can (claim to) care so deeply about the welfare of certain identity groups, yet work for a company that shows contempt for humanity as a whole.

J-dawg··on Journalists aren’t the enemy of the people. But we’re not your friends either
> When was the last time you read a news article about a topic where you are an expert, and walked away from it thinking that it would help laymen better understand the topic?

You don't even need to be an expert. I recall reading about someone who was on trial for downloading terrorism related material, or something like that. The article talked about him using "encryption so powerful that even experts from GCHQ couldn't crack it". I know very little about cryptography, but I do understand the whole point is that nobody can crack it.

I think this kind of low-level misinformation is particularly damaging. It's not even an incorrect statement, technically. But it has the effect of making the guy seem like much more of a mastermind than he really was, and spreading fear about this terrifying "encryption" thing that we all use every day, whether we realise it or not.

And then we all turn the page and read the next story...

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-ge...

J-dawg··on At 31, I have just weeks to live. Here's what I want to pass on
I'm curious about the point you're making here. Clearly the quote you selected is pretty objectionable by modern standards.

Is this intended to invalidate the quote in the parent comment? Does "cancel culture" apply to long-dead philosophers now?

Perhaps I'm reading too much into it!

J-dawg··on Most “mandatory requirements” in corporations are imaginary
It's interesting that in tech there is this expectation that every available thing should be done to make the employee as happy and relaxed as possible. If an employer refuses to do these things it's met with "does not compute", as in this example.

Granted, it does seem to make sense that your employees are as happy and relaxed as possible, but this attitude doesn't seem to exist in other industries to the same degree.

For example, I have a friend who works in finance. He was allowed to work from home for the bare minimum amount of time during the pandemic, his company requested him to return to the office almost as soon as the government permitted it (despite his job being possible to do 100% remotely). He also wears formal clothes every day (another thing that is frequently viewed as ridiculous in tech). But, he makes probably 3-4 times what I do per year!

It seems that in tech people expect to be "looked after" by their employer more than in other industries, yet simultaneously undervalue themselves.

Caveat: this is a perspective from the UK where finance salaries are high, and tech salaries are (as far as I can tell) much lower than the USA.

J-dawg··on Levandowski sentenced to 18 months in prison as new lawsuit against Uber filed
This seems like good advice. Amateur diagnosis of mental syndromes seems to happen a lot these days.

It raises an interesting question though. Every time narcissism / NPD comes up, the general advice seems to be that you should stay they hell away from these people. There seems to be plenty of evidence that they can wreak havoc on the lives of people around them, particularly anyone in an intimate relationship with them.

So it's arguably a good idea to learn how to "diagnose" these people, at least for self-preservation.

J-dawg··on The greatest privilege we never talk about: beauty
This is a good example of how the modern philosophy of identity politics falls apart when you seriously examine it.

Think of all the ways that people are innately privileged (or not): intelligence, height, beauty, upbringing, parental wealth, personality profile.

Any combination of the above can have a vastly greater impact on a person's life outcomes than race, gender, sexuality etc.

J-dawg··on The greatest privilege we never talk about: beauty
Being tall is a huge privilege for a man. It's a large component of male attractiveness.

Many women make it clear on dating sites that they won't consider anyone below a certain height, or at least taller than they are.

J-dawg··on France to introduce controversial age verification system for adult websites
I think you've got cause and effect backwards.

Men are withdrawing because they are not being selected by women. Freed from social pressures that used to act as a brake on hypergamy, women are following their natural instinct to pursue the top 10-20% of men.

Unfortunately, taken to its natural conclusion this leaves a huge chunk of people unhappy. Lower status men are sexless and unloved, and most women are unsatisfied because there aren't enough high status men to go around.

Excessive porn use is a symptom of this, not the cause.

J-dawg··on Ask HN: I want to quit coding professionally but keep it as hobby. What now?
> This can lead to impostor syndrome which is often mistaken for burnout, but just takes time to get through.

Man, I feel this. I feel burnt out basically all the time. Maybe it is imposter syndrome, maybe I'm still overcoming the learning curve, or maybe there's a third option: I just don't have much aptitude for programming, and never will.

I identified a lot with the OP's question. I still feel like a complete beginner, even though I've got a few years of experience under my belt now. I guess what I actually have is one year of experience, a few times over. I think I've actually reduced productivity in all the teams I've been part of.

It's so tough to know whether to cut my losses and get into a different career, or keep plugging away and hoping I somehow become competent one day. Feeling so useless really knocks your confidence in other areas of life. Maybe the OP should actually cut his losses and get out now, and maybe I should too.

This industry has a habit of labelling anyone who is struggling as having "imposter syndrome". It's well intentioned, but misses an obvious truth. Programming is really hard, and most people don't have the intellect for it. Are we doing people a disservice by encouraging them to stay in a career they have little aptitude for?

← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →