HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

J-dawg

2,993 karma · joined November 3, 2014

submissionscomments
J-dawg··on Auto-Antonyms
A couple of others that baffle this British English speaker:

- "I could care less" meaning "I couldn't care less"

- "Entrée" meaning a main dish rather than a starter

J-dawg··on United Kingdom Budget Visualization
Tax credits deserve some scrutiny. A significant portion of tax revenue is effectively being paid as a subsidy to businesses allowing them to systematically underpay their staff.
J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
Yep, that's why I was careful to say 'a chance'.

I remember this being a key point of the 2014 referendum - the 'Yes' side seemed to be overly optimistic about the process of joining the EU.

However if Scotland has already been dragged out of the EU against the will of most of its people, it changes the terms of that debate quite a bit. A chance of joining the EU seems better than being part of a country that likely won't rejoin for many years (if ever).

J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
Sadly that's my feeling too. He's already publicly said he would rather 'die in a ditch' than ask for the extension
J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
Any UK citizen can move there while it's still part of the UK. Do you think there would be minimum residency requirements for citizenship?

It's a bizarre thought that we may be seeing English illegal migrants being deported from Scotland in the not-too-distant future.

Also, how quickly could Scotland join the EU? I remember that being one of the sticking points of the first independence referendum.

J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
Except that under the Benn act, the PM is legally obliged to seek an extension from the EU if a deal isn't agreed.
J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
Related question: how would they decide who gets to be a citizen of (independent) Scotland?

I expect that millions of people would try to find a link to Scotland for a chance of regaining their EU citizenship.

J-dawg··on Ask HN: What happens after no-deal Brexit?
What I fear is the UK government (and the press that support it) continuing its policy of doing very little and blaming everything on the EU. For example:

1. UK leaves without a deal, leaving an open EU border between Ireland and NI. 2. UK refuses to do anything to enforce this border or stop the movement of goods and people across it. 3. Ireland / the EU needs to protect its borders so they put up fences and vehicle checkpoints. Perhaps even with help from other EU countries' security forces. 4. UK right wing press runs stories full of angry language about the 'invasion'

I fear we'll see this process repeated every time there's a shortage of anything - it will all be the EU's fault, and entering into any transitional agreements with the EU (if they are gracious enough to grant us any) will be 'surrender' or 'capitulation'.

This is a worst case scenario, but I fear we are heading for serious civil unrest and violence

J-dawg··on We Are All Confident Idiots (2014)
To be fair to the grandparent comment, some of the examples in the article could be interpreted as 'faking it 'til you make it'.

What's most interesting is the nuance of what 'faking it' really means. The woman making up a whole narrative about 'Tonya and the Hardings' - was she thinking 'shit, I know nothing about this band but I like the idea of being on TV so I'm going to make up some lies and hope the conversation moves on to something else'. Or did she genuinely in that moment believe that she knew of this band?

Both seem sort of unlikely, yet one of them has to be true (or a combination of them - as long as you discount the possibility of her being a shill or realising it's a joke and playing along for fun).

There's also some interesting self-selection bias going on - by standing on a street with a microphone you're only going to get people who are more extroverted. Perhaps that's linked with willingness to 'fake it'.

I just find this stuff fascinating.

J-dawg··on Catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderator
> I wonder how you look at vice-squad members?

It was a poorly formed argument, but you've hit on the absurdity that I was trying to point out. Obviously somebody has to look at this stuff.

But having low paid, poorly trained people do it all day, every day? I don't think it's crazy to suggest that shouldn't be legal.

And if Facebook can't exist in its current form without these teams, then I'm totally fine with that.

J-dawg··on Catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderator
There seems to be a fundamental hypocrisy in a legal system that considers some material is so fundamentally corrupting that it must be illegal for people to possess or see it.

If this were truly the case, it should also be illegal to compel someone to look at this same material as part of their employment.

J-dawg··on The Cult of Kubernetes
I've suspected this to be the case almost everywhere I've worked. Another reason it happens is that anyone questioning the adoption of a new tech risks looking like they don't understand it.

However going the opposite way (sticking to one reliable tech stack and refusing to change even when something better comes along) could be just as damaging to a business.

How then, do you build a culture where people are open-minded to new tech without feeling obliged to jump on every bandwagon? I don't think I've ever seen an organisation get the balance quite right.

J-dawg··on America’s DIY Phone Farmers
I know the term "fraud" is used throughout the article, but is this actually fraud in the legal sense? (I assume not).

I certainly don't see it as anything approaching fraud in the ethical sense. Advertisers are paying for clicks / "views", and that's what they're getting. If people want to game that system I see that as entirely fair game.

J-dawg··on Photographers, Instagrammers: Stop Being So Selfish and Disrespectful
For using words that make people cringe
J-dawg··on Photographers, Instagrammers: Stop Being So Selfish and Disrespectful
My sincere apologies
J-dawg··on Photographers, Instagrammers: Stop Being So Selfish and Disrespectful
Damn, I've noticed it too.

At these point I feel compelled to remember that quote from Socrates about how the kids are all rude and disrespectful these days. So maybe nothing ever changes and we're just getting old and grumpy.

But your comment definitely rings true. It's something hard to pin down but I notice it all the time.

J-dawg··on Photographers, Instagrammers: Stop Being So Selfish and Disrespectful
Absolutely. It seems to have become popular to value "experiences over things" as if that's somehow virtuous and makes you better than materialistic people who just want to accumulate stuff.

It's really just another branch of the same kind of materialism.

The mating signal thing is crazy too. I recently dabbled in dating apps (hopefully, never again). It seems virtually every woman on there is obsessed with travel (has "wanderlust", or wants to visit "30 countries before 30", or "couldn't live without my passport", along with a bunch of photos of them posing in front of familiar stock-photo tourist sites).

It's almost always like this: an obsession with travel itself, rather than a passion for a particular culture or region or language or activity that requires travel. (Which might not really be any better, but I'd identify with it a lot more easily).

What's driving this? Is it covert (or subconscious) signalling that they want a mate with the resources to fund this lifestyle? Or simply a feeling that this is expected of them to seem fun and interesting?

As you said, not nearly enough has been written. I wish a great writer with the requisite knowledge of culture and psychology would dive into this.

J-dawg··on YouTube was launched as a dating site
This is a good point. I guess it's important to remember that dating sites do actually change people's behaviour, rather than being a representation of how everyone behaves.
J-dawg··on Airlines are finally fixing the middle seat
> No passenger on such a flight should be urinating

That's a pretty weird statement. It's not really abnormal to want to go to the toilet every 1-2 hours.

J-dawg··on Airlines are finally fixing the middle seat
The offset seats also look like they create extra gaps for kids to poke their hands through and annoy people in front. Or if you're really unlucky, someone's gross feet.
J-dawg··on Airlines are finally fixing the middle seat
That's a great point. I hope they user test these things by actually simulating all parts of a flight.
J-dawg··on YouTube was launched as a dating site
> one person's lemon can be another person's peach

That's a nice way of looking at the world, and of course it's true sometimes.

But...hasn't all the data coming out of dating sites kind of proved the opposite? Especially for men, something like the top 10-20% are getting basically all the matches and messages.

J-dawg··on Hofmeister Kink
Thank you! This is exactly the kind of thing I am talking about.
J-dawg··on Hofmeister Kink
I'm not exactly sure why, but I absolutely love this type of post.

Actually I do know why, it's because I get the warm feeling of knowing I get to be a smartass and point out Hofmeister Kinks to other people all over the place.

And for anyone else thinking "that would make an awesome band name"... it seems a duo from Adelaide with 66 likes on Facebook have beaten you to it.

J-dawg··on How to parent more predictably (2018)
I bookmarked this article ages ago because the advice seems so sensible. This post just reminded me of it.

https://blog.codinghorror.com/how-to-talk-to-human-beings/

J-dawg··on Medical Reversals
I suppose if you end up reversing an established thing, you'd better have a damn good reason why you were doing that thing in the first place.

Why give any treatment that hasn't been through a randomised trial? (Unless, of course, you are giving it as part of a trial)

J-dawg··on When murderers were hanged quickly (2014)
If that referendum were to be held in simple yes/no terms it would be a mess for exactly the same reason as Brexit - all the 'yes' voters would be voting based on a different understanding of the outcome. (Note this is far from the only reason why Brexit is a mess).
J-dawg··on Medical Reversals
I am reminded of this story of a medical reversal: https://www.badscience.net/2011/03/when-ethics-committees-ki...

> This is not an abstract problem. Here is one example. For years in A&E, patients with serious head injury were often treated with steroids, in the reasonable belief that this would reduce swelling, and so reduce crushing damage to the brain, inside the fixed-volume box of your skull.

> Researchers wanted to randomise unconscious patients to receive steroids, or no steroids, instantly in A&E, to find out which was best. This was called the CRASH trial, and it was a famously hard fought battle with ethics committees, even though both treatments – steroids, or no steroids – were in widespread, routine use. Finally, when approval was granted, it turned out that steroids were killing patients.

> This was an extraordinary piece of work. At the end of the trial, where the head injuries were pretty bad (a quarter of the people died), it turned out there were two and a half extra deaths for every one hundred people treated with steroids.

J-dawg··on When murderers were hanged quickly (2014)
Assuming the predictive link goes the other way, does this mean that a referendum on the death penalty would be somewhat likely to go in favour of reinstating it?
J-dawg··on Ohmm Mining: Turn Flared Natural Gas into Bitcoin
Got to admire the creative thinking involved in this. Are there any more "practical" potential uses? Some industrial process that requires lots of power but not too much other infrastructure?
← PreviousPage 4 of 21Next →