270 karma · joined December 10, 2022
ChatGPT is not a human. If a news site was to publish some information on their website without attribution, this would be a problem. ChatGPT is more analogous to a news site then some person you have a conversation with.
Models are _not_ human beings, and should _not_ be treated as such! Not in ethical, normative, or legal fashions.
> If there is ever to be venal economic exchange for AI produce, levy it upon model outputs
Every output should be considered a derivative work of the input, and models should be required to license their inputs accordingly. To do otherwise is a massive devaluation of real human labour and ingenuity.
And no, this is not equivalent to human beings training and learning on their own experiences and consumption. Moreover, the scale of investing inputs and delivering outputs far outstrips any human capacity.
If human learning is equivalent to ML training; it’s up to the ML advocates to actually prove that! Until then, kindly stop using human comparisons as an excuse for rampant theft.
The thing is, we relied on the novelty of something like covid to enforce lockdowns in the first place. Without that overblown fear, voluntary compliance simply won’t be there.
And any government that wants to impose lockdowns will be forced to implement a military response, akin to what China did during covid. That kind of response + hindsight to how useless it is won’t go well.
In the same vein, most fantasy fans will also have some opinion on Harry Potter. Or pop music fans will have something to say about Taylor Swift these days.
Moreover, cyclists don’t cause congestion; motorists do. The congestion + noise + safety issues mean motorists are causing orders of magnitudes more negative externalities than any other transportation methods.
That’s not to say it’s impossible, of course, but just much harder. Your professional social network is much smaller remotely. You have to work with someone remotely for months to form the same relationship you could have in an afternoon in-person.
Hybrid work is a good compromise.
Losing my job wouldn’t put my social life at risk - as work relationships don’t and shouldn’t fill that role for me. Again, you seem to be conflating personal and professional relationships.
I might pick up a hobby and make some friends there - these friends are going to linked to my personal life, not my professional one.
I cannot ask this hobby friend for a referral for a job in the future. I cannot ask this hobby friend for some help if I’m dealing with a difficult boss or a challenging technical problem.
I might ask this friend to come skiing with me or come to the bar with me though. That’s nice, but it’s not a work relationship and I can’t fulfill work relationship needs through it.
That said, I think you’re completely out of touch with how 18 year olds choose universities. It can be as simple as a friend of theirs is also attending, or the school is close to a parent’s home, or they were actually in a liberal arts program before they switched into CS.
Sometimes as you implied, it’s their parents making that decision for them.
There’s no point in holding the cost of a student’s education over them, especially as you don’t know even how much they paid.
Just about everything within 10 minutes drive is a total fantasy in my experience. Whether you’re in the suburbs driving or walking in the urban centre. The only difference is that walking is much more pleasant.
That said, if you expand your time radius to 15 minutes, and allow the use of bikes and/or a good subway system, “just about everything” becomes very realistic.
I can’t speak to the interior US and how lovely it was or wasn’t.
I grew up in a car based suburb. It didn’t really have much for people to do. My grandma went and left because she couldn’t drive and was bored. I couldn’t afford my own car until I was 25, and I left shortly after anyway.
I could easily see my dad being very lonely while I was young. Everyday he went to work and then spent the rest of the evening ferrying everyone around.
He’s now doing social things like playing badminton etc. That will probably stop once he gets too old to drive.
Doesn’t that actually prove the op’s point? People are not moving away from the metros in which their families are, so of course the largest metros would grow larger.
Personally I am very very hesitant to move cities for an economic opportunity. And that is entirely for financial reasons; if something happens to me, at least I can easily move back in with my parents.