HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JamesMcMinn

1,830 karma · joined November 8, 2012

submissionscomments
JamesMcMinn··on Welcome to Web 3.0
So far I've yet to see a convincing argument for what "Web 3" is and can offer that we can't currently do without the use of a Blockchain. It all seems to boil down to "it'll cost something to do something", which isn't exactly a convincing argument on its own.

The responses to this story read rather like Facebook comments on controversial news articles - there's a bunch of comments claiming the website is a bunch of nonsense without actually articulating why that is the case, presumably by people who believe (or are invested in) crypto or "Web 3".

Can anyone give a reasoned argument to the actual benefits of Web 3, in contrast to what is currently not possible without the use of a Blockchain?

JamesMcMinn··on Some tiny personal programs I've written
I did, yes. I set it up with some specific conditions that sent him an alert whenever a house similar to ours became available. In the end, he got the house directly next to ours and very similar in design.

Our garages actually share a wall.

JamesMcMinn··on Some tiny personal programs I've written
I own the house I currently live in because of a script I wrote.

We had been looking for a new build for some time and had settled on a development and specific house we wanted to buy, but it was still months away from being released. We were told they released houses in person first, then listed them online later that day, but I was bored and wanted to see when new houses were listed, so I wrote a scraper to alert me whenever a new house became available.

One day, we got a call from the property developer telling us the house we were interested in would be available in person from 10am the next day. Because we wanted to be certain to get it, we appeared at 8am, only to find that 3 other people were already waiting. Houses are released in batches of 2 or 3, so whilst we weren't hopeful, we joined the queue and waited.

At 9am, while waiting in line, I got an alert telling me that the house had been released online, so I open their website on my phone and paid the deposit.

At 10am, when the sales office opened, all hell broke loose as the person first in line (waiting since 5am...) discovered the house they wanted had already been reserved online. I'd effectively stolen his house. It was awkward to say the least as all of us were crammed into a tiny portacabin while this unfolded.

In truth, I felt awful for depriving him of the house he and his family wanted, but relieved that we had reserved the house we wanted after a 5 month wait. A few weeks later the developer got in touch to say that they had changed their policy nationwide and would only be releasing houses online in the future because of "the incident"...

Whilst I wasn't willing to give up our reservation, I worked with the person who had wanted our house so that they were alerted whenever a similar house in the same development became available. He got one, there's no hard feelings, and him and his family are now my next door neighbours.

JamesMcMinn··on Thank You, Valve
I've used Linux as my daily driver for near enough 20 years at this point. I'm not arguing that people wont use Linux because Microsoft have bought some studios, I'm arguing that they might not use Linux on a device designed specifically for gaming if they can't play games using services that they've already paid for.
JamesMcMinn··on Thank You, Valve
I'm not arguing that people wont buy the console, I'm arguing that if they buy a console that has support for a different operating system, one which plays all of the same games and more, and also enables them to use services that they already pay for, then they're going to install that other operating system.

A relatively small number of people are buying the steam deck to use Linux, most are buying it to play games on.

JamesMcMinn··on Thank You, Valve
I am very excited by the Steam Deck and have paid for my place in the queue (hopefully some time this year). I am a long time desktop Linux user, however I also game and have either had to dual boot, or more recently, game inside a Windows VM because of DRM and unsupported games.

The biggest issue I can can see with the Steam Deck, or more specifically, Linux on the Steam Deck, is Microsoft's Game Pass. It simply will not work on Linux, and at the moment, I spend more time playing game via Game Pass than I do via Steam. Microsoft have a very clear direction with their recent purchases of publishers and studios, and I worry that the lack of any sort of Game Pass support (without installing Windows) will hamper the Steam Deck.

Of course, Valve are probably hoping that the Steam Deck will discourage Game Pass subscriptions since it eats into their market, but as long as Microsoft are also willing to sell games on Steam, I think having both options is the healthiest for PC gaming overall.

JamesMcMinn··on UK schools receive 300k CO2 monitors in gov initiative to reduce COVID19 spread
Very few schools in the UK have a HVAC system. Some of the more modern ones perhaps, but the majority of schools in the UK are likely older than the students grandparents.
JamesMcMinn··on UK schools receive 300k CO2 monitors in gov initiative to reduce COVID19 spread
This is my understanding having spoken to a couple of teachers. The only real option they have to increase ventilation is to open windows, however when it's below freezing outside and windy, this isn't a good solution and doesn't actually help all that much in most instances.

A more robust air purification and ventilation system is what's actually needed, but good luck getting the Government to fund that, especially with the age and general run-down state of many of the UKs schools.

For what it's worth, you're probably being down-voted because you presented no evidence or context, rather than for the message itself.

JamesMcMinn··on Tokyo police lose 2 floppy disks containing info on public housing applicants
From the 4th paragraph of the article

> 38 men in their 20s to 80s

JamesMcMinn··on When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’s Vision Gets Lost
His Dark Materials has a highly rated (and ongoing) TV series from HBO & the BBC: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5607976/
JamesMcMinn··on Jsquery: A PostgreSQL extension for searching nested jsonb objects and arrays
Whilst this looks interesting (particularly to anyone running PostgreSQL 11 or earlier) it's worth noting that PostgreSQL has support for SQL/JSON Path [1] as of version 12 and provides similar functionality without the use of an extension.

[1] https://www.postgresql.org/docs/14/functions-json.html

JamesMcMinn··on Show HN: Unclack – a macOS app that mutes your microphone while you type
After seeing this and being a bit disappointed it was for Mac only, I wrote a very quick and dirty script for Linux that does something similar [1].

Probably has lots of bugs and missed edge cases (although it should handle not unmuting you if you mute yourself), but was fun to write none the less and might be useful.

If you want to play it, please have a read before using it (it has to capture key presses using xinput but does nothing with actual key values) and I won't accept any responsibility if it mutes / unmutes you at an inopportune time, etc.

[1] https://pastebin.com/CRuLWjzr

JamesMcMinn··on Apple changes default MacBook charging behavior to improve battery health
I'm not certain that's a valid argument - if anything it's rather "apologist".

They are annoyed because the phone is unusable for a period even when connected to a charger. Every Android phone I have ever used will work immediately after being plugged into a charger (even without a battery). This has nothing to do with "saving" them from having no phone (in fact, it effectively leaves them with no phone at all for a period of time), and everything to do with the phones inability to power itself directly from a charger.

Tough to make something for customers? Perhaps, but seemingly every other phone manufacturer gets this right.

JamesMcMinn··on Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones
Sony XM3, Bose QC 35 or Bose 700 - try them all and pick whatever is most comfortable. Noise cancelling in all 3 is good enough that you're unlikely to be able to tell the difference.
JamesMcMinn··on AMD's Upcoming Ryzen 9 3900 Listed with 12 Zen 2 Cores at 65W
140W is considerably closer to the stated 105W TDP value of the 3900X than a "95W" 9900k which can easily pull down 180W. Whilst I agree that TDP shouldn't be taken as gospel, at least in AMDs case, it can be a useful approximation the amount of heat generated (and thus power draw).

If you then compare the actual performance per watt, a 12 core CPU at 3.1 base / 4.2 boost pulling down approximately 65W is very impressive. Something similar from Intel (in terms of number of cores at even just the 3.1 base frequency) would likely have a TDP of at least 120W.

JamesMcMinn··on AMD's Upcoming Ryzen 9 3900 Listed with 12 Zen 2 Cores at 65W
Intel measure the TDP based on the base clock, yes. However AMD seem to measure it based on what the CPU is likely to draw with boost clocks over a sustained period of time, so their TDP numbers are quite accurate.
JamesMcMinn··on Amazon can be held liable for third-party seller products: U.S. appeals court
Nope. I am still down £209 and have gotten no further. I have:

- Sent them a video of me opening the 2nd delivery to find playing cards (Literally from opening the Amazon box through to finding the playing cards inside the Samsung SSD box)

- Reported the matter to my local police, who phoned Action Fraud on my behalf. I've got me a crime reference number from Action Fraud.

- Signed 2 affidavits declaring what I did / did not receive

I've phoned them numerous times, and twice now that has involved speaking to someone, being put on hold, and then redirected to my own voice mail.

If I was the only person to have received card and a deck of playing cards I could understand their reaction, however they've removed the item from sale because a number of other people in recent days have received the same things [1].

When I spoke to my local police they were extremely confused by Amazon's behaviour. I gave Amazon the details of the officer I spoke to and the crime reference number, but that got me nowhere other that the same boilerplate email.

At this stage, I fear I'm going to end up taking Amazon to the small claims court here in the UK just to get my money back.

[1] https://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B07MBQPQ62/ref=cm_c...

JamesMcMinn··on Amazon can be held liable for third-party seller products: U.S. appeals court
Meanwhile, I can't ever get Amazon to accept liability for the 3 bits of cardboard and a deck of playing cards I received instead of a £209 SSD that was sold by Amazon directly: https://twitter.com/JamesMcMinn/status/1144537350602678273
JamesMcMinn··on Apple's Proprietary Software Locks Kill Independent Repair on New MacBook Pros
In the UK at least, all XPS devices come with on-site repair included in the warranty.
JamesMcMinn··on Academic Torrents – Making 27TB of research data available
As far as I could tell, none of them actually contain tweets (e.g. any JSON), just IDs, and mostly user IDs at that.
JamesMcMinn··on Academic Torrents – Making 27TB of research data available
On a quick pass of the Twitter datasets, they all seem to conform to Twitter's developer Terms.
JamesMcMinn··on Ditching Windows: 2 Weeks with Ubuntu Linux on the Dell XPS
Sounds like you got a lemon of a paste job. My XPS 15 is able to run with a full load on all cores for hours at a time. Similarly, gaming on it doesn't seem to cause any issues.

It's possible that external factors are the issue (such as ambient temperatures), however I'd wager that a proper repaste of both the CPU and GPU would improve cooling.

By default the XPS (and actually most Dell laptops) seem to come set to RAID rather than AHCI, which is likely the BIOS change you're referring to.

JamesMcMinn··on This is what happens when you Google the word “idiot” (not Bing/DuckDuckGo)
The reason that Bing and DuckDuckGo have such similar results is that DDG uses Bing's search API, so the comparison here is only really between Bing and Google.
JamesMcMinn··on Art technicians: The industry’s dirty secret, or all part of the process?
> It's exactly what's being discussed here.

No, it's not. There is no training being given. These are not apprentices learning how to create art, they are skilled professionals carrying out work that the artist themselves is often incapable of. An apprentice learns their skills from their master and could be seen as a creation of the master, art technicians are simply there to do the work.

> Are you morally outraged that Marc Jacobs does not personally cut and sew every garment bearing his name? Are you shocked to learn that many pop stars are entirely unable to write, produce or play music?

No, and I never said I was outraged at the art technicians not getting credit, since they themselves are certainly don't seem to be. However there the public perception is that the artist who gets the credit is the one who did the majority of the work when this if often not the case.

JamesMcMinn··on Art technicians: The industry’s dirty secret, or all part of the process?
Except that's not even remotely the issue being discussed here.

This is about artists going to people who are already experts in their field and having them construct the art, but taking (or being given) all of the credit for it.

JamesMcMinn··on Researchers Unmask Anonymous Twitter Accounts With 97% Accuracy Using ML
You may not be aware, but Twitter's share price took a rather large hit yesterday specifically because they banned 10s of millions of bot accounts.

They have no issues letting the public know how many accounts they are removing.

Having said that, their developer ToS are quite clear that they don't want researchers or developers to:

> aggregate Twitter user metrics such as total number of active users, accounts, total number of Periscope Broadcast views, user engagements or account engagements.

JamesMcMinn··on Researchers Unmask Anonymous Twitter Accounts With 97% Accuracy Using ML
This is a terrible title and should be changed. The story has nothing to do with unmasking anonymous Twitter accounts, rather it is about using metadata to identify posts by the same user from a dataset which has had specific user IDs removed.
JamesMcMinn··on Researchers Unmask Anonymous Twitter Accounts With 97% Accuracy Using ML
They do address this fact in the paper, and in fact note that a simple KNN approach using only the account creation time gives 99.98% accuracy.
JamesMcMinn··on Apple Engineers Its Own Downfall with the Macbook Pro Keyboard
Samsung's Galaxy S range of phones have been getting slightly thicker every generation since the S6. The S6 was 6.8mm thick, the S9 is 8.5mm, with small but progressive increases along the way.

The S9 still feels like it could break easy due to the all glass finish, but I think that has much more to do with avoiding plastic whilst still enabling wireless charging.

JamesMcMinn··on Lobotomizing Gnome
The author wants to remove JavaScript from their desktop and does this by disabling all extensions in the hope that it will also disable Gnomes JavaScript engine. What the author does not appear to understand is that extensions are written in JavaScript because Gnome shell is written in JavaScript.

Gnome works very well for my workflow, and I find much of the "bloat" to be quite useful in day to day usage, but can understand the desire to remove things like maps and Tracker if you don't use them. My single biggest issue with Gnome stems from the performance of Gnome-shell which lags and stutters its way through animations leading to a desktop which often feels like it's struggling even on powerful hardware.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →