HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JamesMcMinn

1,830 karma · joined November 8, 2012

submissionscomments
JamesMcMinn··on Tesla's Model S fails to ace some tests in IIHS evaluation
Model S "only" gets second highest rating in a single test.

The headline is not only wrong (it aced all but one test, so didn't fall to ace "some tests"), but seems designed to make it sound much worse than the report actually suggests.

JamesMcMinn··on Why Some Men Don't Work: Video Games Have Gotten Really Good
The whole argument is built on ignoring the question "why aren't employers hiring young men" and asking the very presumptuous question "Why don't young men want to work?"

I can't get access to the full paper without paying $5, which I'm not going to do, however the abstract doesn't sound very convincing either, making the argument that video games take up a larger percentage of men's leisure time, and younger men have more leisure time than older men, so video games must be stopping men from working.

It's not a very convincing argument, and the converse could just as well be true: older men would prefer to spend more time working than enjoying leisure time.

JamesMcMinn··on Pop-up bike lanes show that demand exists
The "miles per day" would suggest 9.35miles each way, so ~40 minutes each way, which seems more likely.
JamesMcMinn··on Best Linux Distros for Gaming in 2017
Solus[1] has a good reputation for gaming in my experience.

[1] https://solus-project.com

JamesMcMinn··on US considers banning laptops on flights from UK airports
(Edit: it seems it's all of Europe, not just the UK) So you fly to Amsterdam or Dublin, then onto the US instead.

This isn't going to protect anyone, it's just stupid and inconvenient to its very core.

I'm already apprehensive about potentially having to visit the US because of everything from asking for social media accounts to copying data off of phones. All this is doing is making sure that I'm not going to travel to the US for business or pleasure.

JamesMcMinn··on Ask HN: What are pros and cons of PostgreSQL and MySQL?
You seem to imply that Postgres isn't stable when in the fact the very opposite is true. Postgres is one of, if not the, most safe and stable relation database systems to ever exist. The fact that they keep adding or improving features does not take away from this, it only means that you have the option to upgrade if you want the new features.
JamesMcMinn··on New APIs to power customer engagement in Direct Messages
As someone who uses Twitter's APIs heavily, this is both encouraging, and slightly terrifying.

We draw down a lot of data from Twitter. Obviously, we always want more data, so we got in contact with GNIP to see what we could afford (which, in itself took a long time). As it turns out its incredibly expensive, and as a very early startup, we couldn't afford any of their plans. We had no option but to fall back to their standard, free APIs and make do.

There are plenty of people who would happily pay good amounts of money for access to more Twitter data - there really are a million uses for it - however Twitter's current prices are far too high for anything other than a VC funded Silicon Valley startup to afford. I hate to think how many potential startups and cool projects have been killed off instantly simply because Twitter's prices are insane. You can get real-time global stock market tick data for a year for less than Twitter charge per month for access to the decahose.

So, I'm glad to see Twitter being more open about their future plans, and really happy to see they're moving towards a more self-service paid API for those than want and can afford it. I just hope they make it affordable and don't kill off too much in the process. The last thing they need is to upset a lot of developers, again.

Twitter's API has always been something they've not leveraged enough. All they had to do was keep it open, find a way of serving adds through 3rd party clients, and I suspect there would have been an explosion of good clients that could have made Twitter much easier to use for people who just can't figure Twitter out. Twitter shouldn't be complicated, but it is, and by trying to hold onto the brand as tightly as they have, they've prevented good developers from making easy to use clients that could have brought in users.

I really want Twitter to succeed. I hope this is the start of a turnaround for Twitter.

JamesMcMinn··on Building the Future of the Twitter API Platform
As someone who uses Twitter's APIs heavily, this is both encouraging, and slightly terrifying.

We draw down a lot of data from Twitter. Obviously, we always want more data, so we got in contact with GNIP to see what we could afford (which, in itself took a long time). As it turns out its incredibly expensive, and as a very early startup, we couldn't afford any of their plans. We had no option but to fall back to their standard, free APIs and make do.

There are plenty of people who would happily pay good amounts of money for access to more Twitter data - there really are a million uses for it - however Twitter's current prices are far too high for anything other than a VC funded Silicon Valley startup to afford. I hate to think how many potential startups and cool projects have been killed off instantly simply because Twitter's prices are insane. You can get real-time global stock market tick data for a year for less than Twitter charge per month for access to the decahose.

So, I'm glad to see Twitter being more open about their future plans, and really happy to see they're moving towards a more self-service paid API for those than want and can afford it. I just hope they make it affordable and don't kill off too much in the process. The last thing they need is to upset a lot of developers, again.

Twitter's API has always been something they've not leveraged enough. All they had to do was keep it open, find a way of serving adds through 3rd party clients, and I suspect there would have been an explosion of good clients that could have made Twitter much easier to use for people who just can't figure Twitter out. Twitter shouldn't be complicated, but it is, and by trying to hold onto the brand as tightly as they have, they've prevented good developers from making easy to use clients that could have brought in users.

I really want Twitter to succeed. I hope this is the start of a turnaround for Twitter.

JamesMcMinn··on Python coding interview challenges
How often have you had to code up solutions to any of these challenges in the last two decades?

These sort of challenges are great for learning some of the theory behind computer science and getting you thinking, but they're not a useful part of the interview process imo.

JamesMcMinn··on Python coding interview challenges
Honestly, I think you'd learn more about a potential hire that way than by presenting them with these sort of challenges.
JamesMcMinn··on Python coding interview challenges
Not really. If anything it just makes coding challenges useless for distinguishing between people who can think, and people who can regurgitate.

It's one thing to "know" how to balance a binary tree because you've read up on and practiced the most common challenges - it's something else entirely to actually think through and understand a problem, then come up with a solution.

I'd much rather have someone who can describe the edge cases and the complexity of a problem but get the final solution slightly wrong (but hey, the know the edge cases so can write tests for it, right?), than someone who can regurgitate code they've written before without really understanding it.

JamesMcMinn··on Ask HN: What do you want to see in Ubuntu 17.10?
I can't find much information, but things like scrolling, switching work spaces etc. worked out of the box for me when I was testing Fedora 25 a month or so ago.
JamesMcMinn··on Ask HN: What do you want to see in Ubuntu 17.10?
Fedora with Gnome shell on Wayland already handles both 1 and 2, although power managements is about the same as Ubuntu and Wayland comes with its own set of issues.
JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
...yes, it is. So what?

Vegetables don't just magically appear in minutes - they take weeks or months to grow, so bad winter has an effect which can last for most of the year.

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
With a bit of luck, Scotland might offer you someone to escape to, although the weather wont be as nice as France.
JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Empirical evidence justifies or disproves a claim. A single point of data does not justify the claim that vegetables from Mexico are cheaper than vegetables from the EU - all you have done is state that you once found a vegetable from one source country for cheaper than the same vegetable from another country - you haven't provided any evidence what-so-ever (the name of the supermarket, the prices, the volumes, the different brands), just made a claim.

Empirical evidence in this case would be a large scale survey of the prices of comparable vegetables across multiple supermarkets, over a long period (several years to cover seasonal variance in prices).

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
> anecdotal: not necessarily true or reliable, because based on personal accounts rather than facts or research.

By definition, it is anecdotal. A single piece of price data observed only by you with no evidence is not proof that EU grown vegetables are more expensive than those from Mexico.

To say that someones supermarket bill going up is somehow more anecdotal than "I found asparagus from Spain that cost more than asparagus from Mexico" is absurd.

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
> Except "the experts" were predicting terrible things immediately, not later on - remember the punishment budget necessity?

As a matter of fact, I do remember the "punishment budget", the one which was mocked up for 2019-20 [1], around the time that the UK would actually leave the EU.

No one expected the UK economy to crash the day of the referendum. The projections are all projections for AFTER we have left the EU, not before. The reason exports get that title is because they know enough to at least make their projections from when the changes actually happen.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jun/15/revolt-of-6...

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
The risks are most certainly not only economic. The EU influences almost every aspect of the UK in one way or another.

Immigration and travel are both affected. The ability to travel and work in any country in the EU is a massive benefit which will likely be much more difficult. Visiting family in friends outside of the UK could become much more difficult.

Our laws are affected - there will be nothing to stop the UK Government from bringing in even more draconian and invasive spying laws [1] or scrapping the Human Rights Act as they have desired to do for so long.

The wonderful thing about the EU is that it has for the most part done nothing but protect people, and I worry what will happen when we leave.

[1] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/snoopers-chart...

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
> No trade negotiations until we leave?

No trade negotiations until we official notify the EU that we are leaving, which makes nothing but sense from the EUs perspective.

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Given that Spain is still recovering from flooding, cold weather and a bunch of other issues [1] that have made growing vegetables impossible in many areas, that's not really a surprise.

[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-38666752

JamesMcMinn··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
You haven't been affected by the changes because nothing has happened yet. This is the start of the negotiations to decide what those changes will be.

And when I say nothing has happened yet, I mean apart from the massive drop in the value of sterling and inflation massively outstripping wage increases.

I assume you're based in London, which means you're fairly isolated from the social changes that have happened across the UK in recent years. London is very pro-EU and immigration friendly. The statistics do show a massive increase in race related hate crimes in the UK since the referendum, so even if the vote wasn't racist, it has given racists a confidence boost.

JamesMcMinn··on DeepMind in “very early stage” talks with National Grid to reduce UK energy use
The image has been used in a number of articles, the oldest of which I was able to find was from 2013 - I would assume the image is older than that even.
JamesMcMinn··on Facebook will never take responsibility for fake news
The Onion is listed as a Media/news company on Facebook. For those that know what the Onion is, it's entertainment masquerading as news, but for those who don't know, it certainly looks a lot like news.
JamesMcMinn··on Facebook will never take responsibility for fake news
The problem with having to provide a source is that the majority of "fake news" type stories, even the ones that are true, come from anonymous sources "close to X" or "within Y". It also means every Onion story will be capped.

Something at a publisher level, where the publisher themselves is given a fake news rating, rather than individual stories, might work, but even that is full of difficult to solve issues.

JamesMcMinn··on Facebook will never take responsibility for fake news
I'm not sure that they should take responsibility for it, but I do believe they should make tools available for people to fight it, although I don't think even that is an easy task. Facebook enables fake news by offering a platform where fake news can spread, but it spreads because a lot of people really do believe what is being reported, not because they necessarily want to spread fake news.

Fake news, or lies as we should really be calling them, is very much a social problem. We've had "fake news" in the form of parody websites like the Onion for a long time, and whilst a large number of people fell for their stories, they often didn't make the same mistake twice. People are looking for new sources of news, and the combination of this with easily shareable and difficult to verify stories means that the lies spread quickly.

Part of this has been caused by the attack on mainstream media (MSM) - people no longer trust the MSM because they're being told not to by politicians, and the fact that they're often caught misreporting stories doesn't help this. So, people turn to smaller more focused sources - often ones which they've never heard of before, and which they haven't been told not to trust. How does Facebook solve this? I'm not sure. Flagging stories as "this hasn't been reported elsewhere", or by filtering new sources of news might be a start, but it wouldn't be a solution. I'm not sure people would trust Facebook to manually moderate content, and it would simply give fake news and politicians the ammunition they needed to target Facebook as being against them. The very nature of news is that its unexpected and mostly unpredictable, so training algorithms to detect fake news reliably, without hiding real news, is a very difficult task.

Facebook can't take responsibility for fake news, society needs to do that.

JamesMcMinn··on Orion Ubuntu Laptop Review: The Powerful MacBook Pro Alternative
Plenty of places still only have VGA connections for projectors - I have to use a TB3 to VGA dongle at least once a week.
JamesMcMinn··on Orion Ubuntu Laptop Review: The Powerful MacBook Pro Alternative
I'm all for laptops that come with Linux as an option, but calling this a MacBook Pro alternative is a big stretch. People either buy the MBP for the build quality and materials, or for macOS, neither of which this seems to have - I'd give that title to Dell's XPS range at the moment.

Having said that - this Orion does seem like a decent laptop for the money, and I'm sure there are plenty of people who want a decent Linux machine without the price premium of Dell's XPS range who will happily go for something like this.

JamesMcMinn··on Scotland to seek second independence referendum
They're doing better now as a party than before Brexit, but not for the reasons you might think.

The Labour party have traditionally been very strong in Scotland - the Labour party was a party for life, and many people only every voted Labour. However, this has all changed over the past year, as they have effectively self-imploded to the point of uselessness. I cannot overstate how much of a breakdown there has been within the Labour party, and people who had previously only ever voted Labour are now voting differently.

I'd argue that much of the Conservative party's gains have come from people who will simply no longer vote for Labour, rather than a move towards the Conservatives themselves.

JamesMcMinn··on Scotland to seek second independence referendum
It's probably worth noting that the Scotsman has historically backed the Union and their audience are very pro-union, and generally pro conservative.

As I understand it, the poll which they based that article on didn't even ask the same question for each of the leaders, so the final results can't be seriously compared.

← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →