HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JaumeGreen

617 karma · joined April 14, 2016

submissionscomments
JaumeGreen··on RFCs: Blueprints of the Internet
What I dislike of RFCs is that some are accepted, but still referred as RFC, for no apparent reason.

I specially dislike when some people try to do the same with internal documentation and still call "RFC 2029 Project Lifecycle" when it has been accepted by all the appropriate parties. It makes it harder to look for than needed, and it's not clear, by the name, if it has been passed or not.

JaumeGreen··on Four-year wedding crasher mystery solved
FYI naming it Catalan Spanish would be akin to naming Welsh as Welsh English. Catalan and Spanish (also known as Castilian) are two different languages, like French and Italian.

So it's normal that you didn't understand much, as even it having some words that are similar the tonalities and some of the constructs are very different.

And they might have been speaking in Balearic, which is a Catalan dialect, and that's sometimes even harder to understand.

JaumeGreen··on Programming languages should have a tree traversal primitive
One of the projects that I have only in my mind space is an Iversonian language with more data structures and the tools to easily navigate an traverse them. Trees, graphs, ... the sky is the limit. And with the power of notation as a tool of thought, and a pen interface, it would be fun to do whiteboard sessions that produced real code that could be executed as is.

OTOH I read/heard that the beauty of array languages is that they have few data types, but they can be easily worked on. So maybe the answer is not easier tree traversal primitives, but better literature/training on how to transform it in a more manageable data type.

Sometimes the answer is to adapt our vision to our world, sometimes the answer is to adapt the world to our vision.

JaumeGreen··on Widespread power outage in Spain and Portugal
I love in Spain and in my zone I didn't have Internet access until after 22:00, and it was sloppy at best.

0:49 and light came back, and woke us for a moment.

So yeah, you need local first POS applications.

JaumeGreen··on Glamorous Toolkit
It's the other way around. Python notebooks fall short compared to this because they don't have the same kind of interactivity with the data as GT has.

A single tool in the toolkit is already equivalent to notebooks, at least from what I glimpsed at the introductory video. Then you have the rest of the tools, how it can easily inspect the objects, and probably manipulate them.

This is probably one of the future ways in which we will work in programming in the future, when someone creates some similar tool, around a mainstream language, that can easily interact with LLMs, APIs, and data visualization tools.

JaumeGreen··on Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it to generate it
But I'm sure there would be some people that given the following question would not be able to produce any code by themselves:

"Let's implement a function to return us the Nth fibonnaci number.To get a fib (fibonacci) number you add the two previous numbers, so fib(N)=fib(N-1)+fib(N+2). The starting points are fib(0)=1 and fib(1)=1. Let's assume the N is never too big (no bigger than 20)."

And that's a problem if they can't solve it.

OTOH about 15 years ago I heard from a friend that interviewed candidates that some people couldn't even count all the instances of 'a' in a string. So in fact not much has changed, except that it's harder to spot these kind of people.

JaumeGreen··on I tasted Honda's spicy rodent-repelling tape and I will do it again (2021)
A couple of years back I had a problem with a package that didn't reach me, and it was marked as delivered. The only point of contact that responded in any way was Twitter, the shipping company did not have other functioning way to connect to them.

This was in Spain, so no, not only USA. I have not deleted my X user, even though I never use it, just in case I need to ever go in and contact some company that I can't contact otherwise.

JaumeGreen··on A liar who always lies says "All my hats are green."
By the way, if the phrase is "X exists and all X are Y" then we wouldn't know if X really existed.

We only would know that either X doesn't exists or, if it exists, not all X are Y.

JaumeGreen··on A liar who always lies says "All my hats are green."
In the solution they explain why they have to conclude that there should be at least one. Let me try again with a bit more explanation.

1. The liar stating something must mean that the phrase is not true. They cannot state anything that is not false.

2. "All X are Y" is the phrase.

Now, if we assume there is no X the phrases "All X are Y" and "Not all X are Y" are both true and false.

All X are Y - True. Yes, there is no X that is not Y.

All X are Y - False. Yes, there is no X that is Y.

Not all X are Y - True. Yes, there are no X, so none is not Y.

Not all X are Y - False. Yes, there are no X, so none is Y.

All these statements are (according to the article) vacuous if there is no X. A liar then cannot make them, as they are not false.

So from here you can deduce that either the phrase "All X are Y" stated by a liar indicates the existence of X or that I'm a liar :)

JaumeGreen··on Spotify has shut down several API endpoints
Spotify is quite frustrating sometimes.

I live in Spain, so it suggests Spanish podcasts to me, even though I only listen to podcasts in English or Catalan.

Music the same, I mostly listen to music in either Catalan or English, with a couple of Spanish songs in my lists. But lots of his suggestions are for music in Spanish. Heck, I just see that one of his recommendations is new things in Flamenco, even though it's a musical genre I haven't listened a single song of (nothing against it per se, only that I don't like it).

As I'm using it more to listen to podcasts now I find it hard to listen to music, because if I leave a podcast mid reproduction and play some music I have to remember which podcast it was, search for it, and then I can listen to the rest. Two separate modes, one for music, one for podcasts, would be good. Maybe a mixed one for people who do both mixed.

I will not add on how most of the music it suggests (when not suggesting things that I like) are things I already have in my lists, not good things that I could add to them.

It needs some work.

JaumeGreen··on Ask HN: Would you pay 500 USD for a "Deep Work" phone?
For phones I guess the extremes are some sweet spots.

* The ones that want their phone to be a more portable laptop get a flagship.

* The ones that through clumsiness or hard work destroy their phones want rugged ones.

* The ones that travel a lot want their phones to last.

* The ones who play music on the subway want the speakers to be loud so you can also hear it.

* The ones that don't want distractions get a dumbphone.

...

If you have several needs then you try to maximise in all the directions that you need. And this is why not everyone needs the same phone.

Work, what is work? Answering emails/messages from clients? Going into pages to enter some shipment data? Trying apps while being tied to a desk? Having it for emergencies while breaking rocks with a sledgehammer? Taking pictures for insurance claims? All of these have different needs.

Choose a target, one that is well defined, then sell them the phone. Otherwise people who are not the target will not like the phone, and people that are the target might not know that they are.

JaumeGreen··on Study: Playing D&D helps autistic players in social interactions
It also gives people a framework in where to learn how to communicate. They can try different approaches, the stakes are low (in real life terms) if they fail, their companions and the DM will not only serve an example but give hints on how to do that better.

Anyone with problems in social communication could make use of it as a great resource.

JaumeGreen··on A Weekend at the Immersion Larp Festival
If anyone likes the idea feel free to steal it.

One of the projects I have on my endless things to do is to create a computer RPG (maybe dabbling in the action RPG genre) in where the characters are dressed up and playing in a LARP.

Weapons are foam weapons. Confetti or water balloons for area effect spells, serpentine or other similar effects for line attacks, ... . NPCs are also people dressed, and maybe some cardboard cutouts for goblins, kids, and other things that could be big in numbers or shouldn't take part in a larp.

I don't know what things go in the back, such as, should some NPCs just be GMs doing the rolls and acting on the scenery? It probably would be easier to make it straight, but it would be less "fun".

JaumeGreen··on A Weekend at the Immersion Larp Festival
Really interesting kind of live roleplaying, never knew it could get so serious.

Is there any similar view on sword and sorcery larp scene? One of my projects wants to drink from that, but I have little real knowledge about it and wouldn't like to disrespect larping.

JaumeGreen··on Clojure Desktop UI Framework
That's because you are more familiar with whatever style of code you are used to.

Don't confuse familiarity with readability.

JaumeGreen··on Just Enough Software Architecture (2010)
People would care at a personal level, but the show must go on.

I had to take a sudden leave the week before, and my coworkers, and boss cared at a personal level. And while most of my tasks were taken care of by them some weren't, and I had to rush Monday morning when I got back.

This talk is not about personal feelings, even though it could include "do a memorial for the lost person", but it's about all the needed work that must go on on any scenario.

You should understand that people should keep going on their lifes once you are not there, and that is good. If they think kindly of you after your passing depends on your relationship during life, not on any company preparation scenario.

JaumeGreen··on McDonald's and other big brands warn that low-income consumers starting to crack
Your comparison is really strange, and I didn't say that the salary increase was too be equal to the price increase.

I was not going against capitalism and increasing benefits in that comment, just for some equality. After all if no one can pay the increased prices the system crashes too.

JaumeGreen··on McDonald's and other big brands warn that low-income consumers starting to crack
The problem with inflation in prizes is that some companies do not follow it with inflation in salaries.
JaumeGreen··on How might software development have unfolded if CPU speeds were 20x slower?
> Might the overall greater pressure for performance have kept us writing lower-level code with more bugs while shipping less features?

Are you living in the same world as the rest of us? Nowadays programs are shipped with plenty of bugs, mostly because patching them afterwards is "cheap". In the old days that wasn't as cheap.

So having lower powered computers would have made us write programs with less features, but also less bugs. Formal coding would be up, and instead of moving fast and break things most serious business would be writing coq or idris tests for their programs.

Bootcamps also wouldn't be a thing, unless they were at least a couple of years long. We'd need people knowing about complexity, big O, defensive programming, and plenty of other things.

And plenty of things we take for granted would be far away. Starting with LLMs and maybe even most forms of autocomplete and automatic tooling.

JaumeGreen··on Using AI to teach how to code, remember you still need to think for yourself
I wrote it wrong here, but I used the right wording there.

What I was exemplifying was that it had limits on the complexities in the instructions. And that anything with directions (left right...) can be hard for it.

These are not minor issues to evaluate the end result. It's good, but still lacking on some fronts.

BTW the level for witchcraft is too low for me, but to each their own.

JaumeGreen··on Using AI to teach how to code, remember you still need to think for yourself
That's not good enough for me. It doesn't listen to all of the instructions.
JaumeGreen··on Using AI to teach how to code, remember you still need to think for yourself
One of my dogs is white with black spots over her body, with very curious facial features. Her right eye is surrounded by a big black spot, her right ear is heavily spotted but still quite white. Her left ear has a black spot centered on its base that covers the whole ear, her right eye has white all around.

I've not managed to make Dall-E to draw her.

I wanted it to draw 2 people with certain characteristics with two generic dogs with certain colours (nothing complex on the dog side). Up to the two people and a dog it more or less managed. Adding the last dog and the location made it mangle everything.

All through the chat interface.

For me it's still lacking on some things.

JaumeGreen··on Inner Speech
I can have thoughts without inner speech or text. Why? Probably it helps that I'm multilingual, I can use several languages (3) more or less indistinctively.

So when I have something to talk about I have the idea in my head, then I have to translate it to written or oral medium. Sometimes it's faulty and I use a different language for certain words, because they convey a more nuanced meaning that better corresponds to my idea, and I have a hard time finding the right word or phrase in the language I need to express myself with.

Inside my head I sometimes have inner speech, sometimes I just have a vivid imagination, sometimes it's concepts, and sometimes it's a mix of it all. For example, my first two paragraphs were translation from concepts, while the first line of this one came more from inner speech (half in Catalan, half in English), and this phrase has started as a mix of concept and inner speech.

Not using inner speech as my main medium also means that sometimes I find hard to understand puns that derive from pronunciation, if they come in the written form. When I read I don't imagine the sounds in my head, so I don't "hear" the words and the puns are missed.

JaumeGreen··on Google Cuts Jobs in Engineering and Other Divisions
> Is a google employee in US somehow more competent than the one in India?

It depends.

There are people in India that are brighter and more hard-working than most people in the USA, just by statistical chance. But there is something that can happen there that I don't know what it is and affects some.

In another job our company had a site in India and I remotely supported them. Most people I interacted with wanted step by step instructions and hand-holding. One day someone news enters, bright and full of energy, so we could give him the documentation, point him in the right direction and he did the job. Until he didn't and also wanted step by step directions and hand-holding.

To this day I don't know what prompted the change. My only guess is that there's something cultural going on that can make people tone themselves down and not be proactive.

Just my 2 cents.

JaumeGreen··on Origins of J
Talked about this in other times (through other links):

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8533843 [2014]

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28491562 [2021]

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25902615 [2021]

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34050715 [2022]

A commentary about the code https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22831931 [2020]

JaumeGreen··on Show HN: I built an open source web calendar inspired by the Google calendar
On Google Calendar clicking on an event you see the information of that event, clicking on a white space let's you create a new event at that time.

Having some white space that pertains to the day, but not to an event, let's you create a new event at the same time of an existing one without having to modify the start hour.

At least that's how I use it.

JaumeGreen··on I am the fold (2015)
Google Ads is barely usable on my wife's 14' screen. I do have a bigger screen, but she doesn't. So yeah, some people are not conscious at all of other people's limitations.
JaumeGreen··on Game-icons.net: Free icons for your games
Not me, because I can't yet, but I can shed some light.

That comment brings nothing to the table. An upvote would have given the same meaning. This is not reddit, and some of us would prefer it to remain different. Low effort comments tend to be downvoted, and interesting ones upvoted.

So uplift your comments, say why you are thankful, what will be your use case, where you wouldn't use the OPs icons, ... give some information, not just noise.

Here [0] is some more information about downvotes.

[0] https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented#downvo...

JaumeGreen··on OpenAI Begins Tackling ChatGPT Data Leak Vulnerability
It also doesn't want to write programs. I had to waste 2 or 3 questions just to make it write a simple script.

At the beginning I was using please and thanks a lot, now I'm using fuck much more.

JaumeGreen··on Painting is Terribly Difficult
He might have been able to do that directly at the end, but first he learned to do it by substracting.

https://drawpaintacademy.com/the-bull/

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →