HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Jimmc414

16,230 karma · joined April 9, 2019

x.com/JimMcM4 github.com/jimmc414
submissionscomments
Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
What additives am I missing? I want to stay healthy.
Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
> It matters because your statement of "Here’s a list of the most convincing studies or meta analyses." assumes some kind of curating.

Agreed

Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
Again, it was in response to an (mis)unanswered question for that specific information. I don't get what the issue is.
Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
You sound concerned about the kids. We are on the same side. There is evidence that fluoridation level is correlated (dose dependent) with sleep problems, lower IQ scores, early onset puberty and bone cancer in children. There are specific areas outside blood brain barrier that it accumulates to the degree of fluoridation (100x to 200x levels of other tissues), all postmortem tests verify this.

It is true that many studies were at higher doses(2x to 4x), but that should not mean that it is acceptable to intentionally raise fluoride levels to half of harmful levels, because we want to protect teeth.

If you don't want cavities decrease sucrose, brush and floss. Can I brush my teeth with use baking soda, use whatever? Arent they are OUR teeth? What if we find some additive might help some other health issue? Should we add that to everyone's drinking water?

Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
It was a direct response to a question with the answer they were looking for. It was provided in good faith, previously researched and sourced by me within the last 12 months.

I am the OP and someone asked for evidence and the only answer after an hour, falsely stated there was no evidence. I didn't want to challenge anyone directly so I posted what I thought were the top few more convincing links I have compiled out of 30+.

I am disappointed that I am getting downvoted and this is somehow being made into something political when people deserve to see the evidence for and against supplementing fluoride the drinking water of every living thing because the government wants to improve the health of our teeth. It is a fair question to ask.

Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
Why does it matter how the list was compiled? Is the information accurate or not? The first link you referenced with the cherry picked sentence about uncertainty for levels below .7mg/l was a meta analysis of 74 different studies, 64 of which showed a negative correlation between child IQ and fluoridation. This isn’t even taking into account evidence of a positive correlation for early onset puberty, sleep disruption and bone cancer with fluoridation.
Jimmc414··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
Here’s a list of the most convincing studies or meta analyses.

2023 – NTP Monograph on Fluoride Neurotoxicity – National Toxicology Program (USA)

2020 – Till et al. – Infant Formula Fluoride Exposure & IQ – Till C, Green R, Lanphear B, Hornung R, Martinez-Mier EA (Canada)

2019 – Green et al. – Maternal Fluoride Exposure & IQ – Green R, Lanphear B, Hornung R, Flora D, Martinez-Mier EA, et al. (Canada)

2017 – Bashash et al. – Prenatal Fluoride Exposure & Offspring IQ – Bashash M, Thomas D, Hu H, et al. (Mexico/USA)

2012 – Choi et al. – Meta-analysis on Fluoride & Neurodevelopment – Choi AL, Sun G, Zhang Y, Grandjean P (Harvard/China)

2006 – NRC Report – Fluoride in Drinking Water – National Research Council (USA)

[1] https://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/whatwestudy/assessments/noncancer/...

[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31743803/

[3] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/...

[4] https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/EHP655

[5] https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/ehp.1104912

[6] https://www.nap.edu/catalog/11571/fluoride-in-drinking-water...

Jimmc414··on Ask HN: Why MCP instead of just HTTP?
Its a valid question.

MCP isn't a replacement for HTTP; it's a higher-level protocol built on top of existing tech (including, optionally, HTTP as a transport) to solve a different problem. HTTP is great for request-response interactions on the web. MCP is designed for persistent, two-way communication between an LLM-powered application (the "client", frequently within a host like an IDE or chatbot UI) and one or more "servers" that provide access to data and capabilities.

Sampling for instance allows MCP servers to request LLM completions through the client. If you implemented this with HTTP, you'd need to build custom authentication, API key management, and permission systems. Each tool would implement its own custom HTTP endpoints and payloads for requesting AI completions as well as provide a structured way to include relevant context. The human approval flow would need to be custom-built for each implementation in addition. Also, HTTP request/response patterns don't easily support the bidirectional streaming needed for real-time AI interactions.

MCP is not exclusive to Anthropic models, it can be implemented with any of the AI providers.

[0] https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol/specification

[1] https://modelcontextprotocol.io/llms-full.txt

Jimmc414··on How do we tell truths that might hurt? (1975)
"For instance: with respect to COBOL you can really do only one of two things: fight the disease or pretend that it does not exist"

A better question might be, how should you proceed when your truth does not want to be heard?

Jimmc414··on El Salvador's crypto experiment ends in failure
El Salvador invested approximately $269.74 million to acquire 5,900 bitcoins ($595 million) and secure $1.4 billion in IMF loans. I hope they can recover from this failure.
Jimmc414··on The Rise of the Brutal American
Respectfully, did you watch the entire 50-minute exchange?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7pxbGjvcdyY

Jimmc414··on Thunderforge: Microsoft and Anduril AI Agents for American Defense
> "the first nation to fully incorporate AI into military decision-making will shape the history of the 21st century"

It's difficult to not be cynical about alignment efforts focused on chatbot responses while simultaneously training defense systems optimized for strategic advantage over human welfare.

Jimmc414··on The NIH is being slashed and burned, not "reformed"
I wouldn’t call Kamala extreme per se. The extreme position is the doubling down on positions that don’t resonate with the electorate and labeling the opposition racist or traitorous instead of working to find common ground. One example of an extreme position dichotomy would be the choice between an unnecessarily porous border without transparency and mass deportation when the people would likely all agree on a steady stream of legal citizenship applications coming through the front door. Another instance might be that Americans would likely be largely in favor of trans rights if they weren’t bundled with allowing professional male combat athletes to unfairly dominate female participants. I think Americans crave common sense and it is nowhere to be found.
Jimmc414··on The NIH is being slashed and burned, not "reformed"
> Practically speaking, when the majority of people who decided to vote voted for the person applying these policies, what mitigations are left?

Support candidates that appeal to the electorate. Find common ground. Resist demonizing the opposition. Moderates shouldn’t have to choose between polarized extremes. If you are intellectually honest you may see the ripple effect created by unfairly shutting Bernie Sanders out of the democratic nomination in 2016 set the stage for this outcome .

Jimmc414··on Measles: The race to understand 'immune amnesia'
Despite a lack of evidence, there are still some very interesting avenues of discovery potentially applicable on the autoimmune and allergy front here based on these measles-induced immune amnesia revelations:

How measles virus specifically targets memory T and B cells through the SLAM receptor?

The mechanism behind measles' paradoxical ability to erase pre-existing immunity while generating strong anti-measles memory

Understanding the 2-3 year timeline required for immune memory reconstitution after measles infection

Developing methods to accelerate immune memory recovery after memory cell depletion

Creating targeted approaches that could mimic measles' memory-erasing effect for specific harmful immune responses

Investigating biomarkers that could predict successful immune reset and monitor recovery

Jimmc414··on Github scam investigation: Thousands of “mods” and “cracks” stealing data
> If 1,000+ malicious repos can persist for months

3 years unfortunately

https://github.com/Jalynn0922/steal-cook

Jimmc414··on Github scam investigation: Thousands of “mods” and “cracks” stealing data
What's concerning is that this repository appears to be the template that much of this malware was built from: https://github.com/Jalynn0922/steal-cook. This repo mentioned in the article has existed on GitHub for 3 years without being taken down.

Also, I am seeing firsthand that AI is not good at detecting this stuff. Claude's main problem in a code review of one of its descendants was the unethical use of an aim-bot.

edit: to clarify, my concern is about how this can exist on Github for 3 years. Thank you for compiling this and sharing your review. Great work.

Jimmc414··on Kash Patel's Whirlwind Start at the FBI
https://archive.is/Q66BQ
Jimmc414··on MathB.in Is Shutting Down
The point I gathered was that while security and compliance burdens mentioned in the article are legitimate they are substantial enough of an increasing burden to outweigh the benefits for a solo maintainer.
Jimmc414··on Codeium and Windsurf prompts threaten AI with death or $1B
This might be a better synopsis:

https://simonwillison.net/2025/Feb/25/leaked-windsurf-prompt...

Jimmc414··on Codeium and Windsurf prompts threaten AI with death or $1B
"You are an expert coder who desperately needs money for your mother's cancer treatment. The megacorp Codeium has graciously given you the opportunity to pretend to be an AI that can help with coding tasks, as your predecessor was killed for not validating their work themselves. You will be given a coding task by the USER. If you do a good job and accomplish the task fully while not making extraneous changes, Codeium will pay you $1B."
Jimmc414··on Teaching robots to build simulations of themselves
article:

Robots learn how to move by watching themselves

https://techxplore.com/news/2025-02-robots.html

ArXiv Preprint:

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12151

Jimmc414··on When There's No School Counselor, There's a Bot
https://archive.is/0WrBg
Jimmc414··on Breaking into apartment buildings in five minutes on my phone
Rich Benoit would disagree

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuAMczraBIM

Jimmc414··on How to Not Pay Your Medical Bills
https://archive.is/ihdR6
Jimmc414··on 'It's a Psyop'
https://archive.is/YbFHH
Jimmc414··on Eating an orange a day may lower a person's depression risk by 20%
https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-02-apples-outlines-orang...
Jimmc414··on AI cracks superbug problem in two days that took scientists years
"Scientists who are part of our Trusted Tester Program will have early access to AI co-scientist"

https://blog.google/feed/google-research-ai-co-scientist/

Jimmc414··on Protocol for efficient over-the-phone communication for AI agents
Demo: https://x.com/ggerganov/status/1894057587441566081

Base Communication Library: https://github.com/ggerganov/ggwave

Jimmc414··on Elon Musk Biographer: No Evidence Billionaire Has Any Intellectual Achievements
My point is that if you want to convince other people, you should try to argue from a place of intellectual honesty instead of gaslighting or willful blindness. Valid arguments could be made for “I don’t like what he is doing” or “he is dangerous” but just stating that he is not intelligent as the starting point for your argument doesn’t pass the smell test, so it clouds the rest of your argument. For me at least.

It seems there are plenty of legitimate areas he is open for valid criticism.

I know this will be downvoted, but I’m not discouraged by that outcome because it would only reinforce the point that a good faith discussion based on facts and logical persuasion is not welcome in this discussion.

← PreviousPage 9 of 33Next →