2,840 karma · joined January 8, 2011
There's no people involved except for the token character, which the author uses for the reader to understand.
The counterarguments can be simpler than you think;
Senator, would you prefer ineffectively blocking child pornography that paedophiles can work around or allowing children the chance to innovate and communicate freely for their future?
Senator, would you prefer ineffectively blocking occasional terrorism that will piss off terrorists or allowing political discussions freely?
Senator, would you prefer blocking piracy or allowing anyone to share their content freely? DMCA cracks down on this; a catch-22 that the creator must sell it to claim damages against DMCA notice abusers unless the police charge them with perjury. Not to mention that the notice is scary not only to creator but to other people wishing to re-share. The DMCA does not discriminate against non-commercial sharing.
Here's a good history of anti-Internet measures by USA: http://www.rense.com/general85/net.htm
Here's Australia's version: http://libertus.net/moreinfo.html
Probably because they recently got an UK court to allow USA to extradite a webmaster for linking to infringing content.
CNET <- CBS Interactive [1]. CBS Interactive <- CBS [2].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_organizations_that_sup...
"Hey, a lot of people don't want more Internet controls. So lets get them involved in the Internet control discussion by playing on their hopes of less Internet control. Their supporters will lose momentum as people say 'discussions are ongoing'. We can then easily pass more anti-Internet stuff when we can as we have done in the past. It's brilliant."
"This is something we looked at and thought we could make some narrow and relatively easy changes to our Autocomplete algorithm that could make a positive difference, Cano added."
They believe in filtering broad innocent terms in them as a solution to copyright infringement rather than saying "No no, we can't filter broad terms, especially innocent uses of it. Not only does the language evolve, but the infringers can adopt innocent names like congress:<link to song>. We need to intelligently handle copyright infringement without hurting access to legitimate websites."
It looks like part of doing SEO now is to be aware of avoiding broad innocent terms. I hope the unaware people don't get caught in Google's broad autocomplete filter.
Linux Distro excuse comes to mind.
A cynical person might say that the intent would also further kill free content creators, restricting the supply of content; consumers then see only paid content.
[0] http://dvcs.w3.org/hg/webdriver/raw-file/515b648d58ff/webdri...
Alternatively, if a person suffered monetary damages (current and future), they can sue the abuser for damages. This is what protects big companies from potential DMCA abusers because they have a lot to lose.
Since free content creators can't sue for damages but only counternotice and accept liability if they're not scared from the notice; but people sharing the content will be more afraid of the legalese in counternotices. The bill's intent was to stop freely infringing copyright content, it also consequently kills free content sharing due to the unchecked abuse. It's brilliant bill for the anti-Internet activists.
MPAA are anti-Internet activists by the way.
If they won't stop demanding control of Internet, then we have to demand Internet Freedom bills. Those Internet Freedom bills are to replace SOPA in outlawing the opposite; outlawing attempts to seize domain names without judgement being passed.
Edit: The general aim of the bill is to make initial seizures illegal. It can be argued that it's hard to run off with the domain name during court case for example.
At the moment, they can initially seize pseudo-legally. Then it's a question of being illegal since they can't hold it without cause.
I believe they will run it by the legal team anyway.
Speaking of, I wonder how many children there are in the world.
It would also show that there's a technologically advanced audience here that has great concerns of the anti-Internet attempts.
If they wish to block child abuse, they basically admitted to wishing to kill the future of children just to hide evidence of abuse.
The ball's in their court.
Of course, we can educate the populace. That's why I'm trying to educate the population that there are anti-Internet attempts that affect their Internet usage. That they should demand protection from anti-Internet attempts. :D
As for constitutional, the EFF and anti-SOPA groups say it violates 1st amendment. But the anti-Internet supporters counter in it's perfectly legal [0]. I don't know about you, but I'm not going to let it pass and wait around for the supreme courts to interpret it as unconstitutional.
Until the populace understands the importance of Internet (beyond thinking it's just Facebook, etc), Internet Freedom bills will go a long way in stopping anti-Internet attempts by not only researching and discussing Internet Freedom but also preventing anti-Internet attempts.
For the anti-Internet attempts like bills, there's a lot of Door In Face [1] that's allowing compromises leading to more Internet control. Look at the history of the anti-Internet attempts. They are relentless, demanding a mile, and getting an inch every time as 'compromise'.
It should be the opposite for Internet Freedom bill attempts, otherwise we're continuing to slip down the anti-Internet road.
[0] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/11/at-web-censo...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique
Edit: I want to also mention that for whatever reason, USA government seems to be cracking down on Internet Freedom in the world (Ref: Spain). Internet Freedom advocates in government should counter this subterfuge.
Analogy: It's like bombing a town because one house is harbouring terrorists.
Domain analogy: It's like taking down youtube.com because one channel is harbouring terrorist videos.
They tried one tactic with SOPA to fool people in thinking it was delayed until next year: http://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/nfrru/sopa_has_n...
There had been many anti-Internet attempts implemented and proposed: SOPA, DMCA, PROTECT-IP, COICA, CEST, OPENA, ACTA and more.
PLEASE. Demand Internet Freedom bills in place of such bills. Protect not only current and future Internet businesses, but also the future of children's access to knowledge and ability to share (Some people think the anti-SOPA are just Internet companies).
For example, making it illegal for government or corporations to shut down domains without due process. There's more potential in the SOPA by simply re-wording it to be pro-Internet Freedom.
Bonus: It'll make such Internet Freedom bills a template for pushing Internet Freedom on other countries! Especially UK and Australia.
If they won't stop outlawing/controlling parts of the Internet, then we need to fight back in outlawing anti-Internet attempts.
The war against the Internet will continue after SOPA.
Edit: I sent a message to reddit admins again (several attempts already in past). If you know any of the reddit admins, please pass on this Internet Freedom message quickly!
2nd Edit: hueypriest acknowledges the message: "We are well aware that the fight will continue long after SOPA/PIPA, and that this is just the first battle."
In Australia, the mandatory Internet Filter failed. But conspicuously, the government is throwing money at ISPs who voluntarily filter. Now most biggest ISPs are adopting it. I predict when companies adopt NBN to leave the one digit megabit era, they'll have to have "appropriate criminal content filters in place" in order to be eligible (Taking a note from UK's internet censorship).
tl;dr: The government can use capitalism to kill freedom of choice. Slower, silent yet deadly.
Edit: The government could make an Internet User Owns Device Act that dictates that the hardware bought can not be sold with such remote access to removing content on the device. The user has to specifically opt-in for the remote removal service. Essentially, people can own their own devices they bought.