HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Joeboy

5,497 karma · joined November 28, 2009

http://www.joebutton.co.uk/
submissionscomments
Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
Out of interest, do you identify any of the comments in this discussion as that kind of posturing? The "pro-EA" comments I see here seem (to me) to be fairly defensive in character. Whereas comments attacking EA seem pretty strident. Are you perceiving something different?
Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
(Sincerely) good luck with that, but I don't see why it means we should be against saving the lives of poor people in the immediate term. At some point we might just have to put it down to irreconcilably different mental wiring.
Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
> the silicon valley environment, the investing bubble, our entire tech culture is why Musk has the power he does, right?

For sure, not quibbling with any of that. The part I don't get is why it's EA's fault, at least more than it's many, many other people and organizations' fault. EA gets the flak because it wants to take money from rich people and use it to save poor people's lives. Not because it built the Silicon Valley environment / tech culture / investing bubble.

> Should life or death matters be up to whims like this?

Referring back to my earlier comment, can you sell me on the idea that they shouldn't? If you think aid should all come from taxes, sell me on the idea that USAID is less subject to the whims of the powerful than individual donations. Also sell me on the idea that overseas aid will naturally increase if individual donations fall. Or, sell me on the idea that the lives of the poor don't matter.

Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
> Whether you agree that someone can put money into saving lives to make up for other moral faults or issues or so on is the core issue

For me the core issue is why people are so happy to advocate for the deaths of the poor because of things like "the community has issues". Of course the withdrawal of EA donations is going to cause poor people to die. I mean yes, some funding will go elsewhere, but a lot of it's just going to go away. Sorry to vent but people are so endlessly disappointing.

> Elon musk may have wiped out most of the EA community gains by causing that defending

For sure!

> and was probably supported by the community in some sense

You sound fairly under-confident about that, presumably because you're guessing. It's wildly untrue.

Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
As per conversation elsewhere, I think you've fallen for some popular but untrue / unfair narratives about EA.

But I want to take another tack. I never see anybody make the following argument. Probably that's because other people wisely understand how repulsive people find it, but I want to try anyway, possibly because I have undiagnosed autism.

EA-style donations have saved hundreds of thousands of lives. I know there are people who will quibble about the numbers, but I don't think you can sensibly dispute that EA has saved a lot of lives. This never seems to appear in people's moral calculus, like at all. Most of those are people who are poor, distant, powerless and effectively invisible to you but nevertheless, do they not count for something?

I know I'm doing utilitarianism and people hate it, but I just don't get how these lives don't count for something. Can you sell me on the idea that we should let more poor people die of preventable diseases in exchange for a more morally unimpeachable policy to donations?

Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
Well, there are some fairly obvious answers:

EA had a fairly easy time in the media for a while which probably made its "leadership" a bit careless. The EA foundation didn't start to seriously disassociate itself from SBF until the collapse of FTX made his fraudulent activity publicly apparent.

But mostly, people (especially rich people) fucking hate it when you tell them they could be saving lives instead of buying a slightly nicer house. That (it seems to me) is why eg. MOMA / Harvard / The British Museum etc get to accept millions of dollars of drug dealer money and come out unscathed, whereas "EA took money from somebody who was subsequently convicted of fraud" gets presented as a decisive indicator of EA's moral character. It's also, I think, the reason you seem to have ended up thinking EA is anti-tax and anti-USAID.

I feel like I need to say, there's also a whole thing about EA leadership being obsessed with AI risk, which (at least at the time) most people thought was nuts. I wasn't really happy with the amount of money (especially SBF money) that went into that, but a large majority of EA money was still going into very defensible life-saving causes.

Edit: I made a few edits, sorry

Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
The work I do is / was largely funded by USAID so I'm biased, but from literally everything I've seen EA people are unanimously horrified by the gutting of USAID. And EA people are overwhelmingly pro "tax the rich".

But again, I recognize the appeal of your narrative so you're on safer ground than I am as far as HN popularity goes.

Joeboy··on A new book about the origins of Effective Altruism
Similarly, the reason comments like yours get voted to the top of discussions about EA is that they imply "It's best if rich people keep their money, because the people trying to save poor people's lives are actually bad". There's a very obvious appeal to that view, especially somewhere like HN.
Joeboy··on Show HN: I built a synth for my daughter
I don't really understand your issue sorry, but my thing basically just writes the audio output to a buffer, and the DMA and PIO "automatically" send that to the I2S output. There's also some messing about with ping ponging between two DMA buffers to avoid gaps between each buffer write audio. I guess things might be quite different on the ESP32.

Edit: Ok I glanced at your code, if I read it right it seems like you're writing sin waves into buffers at "init" time then copying the appropriate buffer at "run" time. Which is not what I'd do, but then I'm used to more luxurious devices. Maybe try using a fast sin approximation rather than the precomputed buffer table?

https://bmtechjournal.wordpress.com/2020/05/27/super-fast-qu... might be helpful there.

Joeboy··on Show HN: I built a synth for my daughter
It's not kid friendly, but in case anybody's interested I just wrote up how I made a simple "hardware" synth by bodging together a Raspberry Pi Pico 2 and I2S audio module, total cost around £10 on Amazon UK.

The hardware's very cheap and easy. The "default" synthesis is pretty simple but also pretty hackable (in Rust) if you want to customize it.

https://github.com/Joeboy/oxynth/

Joeboy··on Blender Lab
Yeah the page is currently loading very quickly and is very easy to read due to an issue with Cloudflare.

Edit: If I'm honest, I find this specific css fairly innocuous. I have a more general grudge that raw HTML is easy, free and accessible but we collectively insisted that it's not OK to use it.

Joeboy··on AWS to bare metal two years later: Answering your questions about leaving AWS
There is nothing that needs fixing? Both my link and yours give the same "primary" definition for "bare metal". Which is not unequivocally the correct definition, but it's the one I and the person I was replying to favour.

I thought my link made the point a bit better. I think maybe you've misunderstood something about how Wikipedia works, or about what I'm saying, or something. Which is OK, but maybe you could try to be a bit more polite about it? Or charitable, to use your own word?

Edit: In case this part isn't obvious, Wikipedia redirects are managed by Wikipedia editors, just like the rest of Wikipedia. Where the redirect goes is as much an indication of the collective will of Wikipedia editors as eg. a disambiguation page. I don't decide where a request for the "bare metal" page goes, that's Wikipedia.

Edit2: Unless you're suggesting I edited the redirect page? The redirect looks to have been created in 2013, and hasn't been changed since.

Joeboy··on AWS to bare metal two years later: Answering your questions about leaving AWS
Yes, but if you look up "bare metal" it goes to the page about actual bare metal (aka "bare machines" or whatever).

Can we stop this now? Please?

Joeboy··on AWS to bare metal two years later: Answering your questions about leaving AWS
I indeed deliberately pasted a link that shows what happens when you try to go to the Wikipedia page for "bare metal".
Joeboy··on AWS to bare metal two years later: Answering your questions about leaving AWS
Wikipedia still thinks it means the thing I (and presumably you) do.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bare_metal

Edit: For clarity, wikipedia does also have pages with other meanings of "bare metal", including "bare metal server". The above link is what you get if you just look up "bare metal".

I do aim to be some combination of clear, accurate and succinct, but I very often seem to end up in these HN pissing matches so I suppose I'm doing something wrong. Possibly the mistake is just commenting on HN in itself.

Joeboy··on You already have a Git server
I mean, you do need an ssh server. Basically ssh can run commands on the remote machine. Most commonly the command would be a shell, but it can also be git commands.
Joeboy··on Show HN: I built a web framework in C
A computer program written in a programming language.
Joeboy··on ‘Based on a True Story’ (2016-2019)
Years ago, a British TV show called The Comic Strip Presents... made two films called The Strike[0] and GLC: The Carnage Continues[1]. Both comedies about what would happen if Hollywood were to make films about '80s British political events like the miners' strike or the abolition of the Greater London Council. While they're both broad comedies I think watching them at an impressionable age was probably quite a good education.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-oufaMHUHw

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kBFSo4TY_r8

Joeboy··on The death of east London's most radical bookshop
People who enjoyed this may also enjoy the Blocked and Reported podcast's episode about Glasgow's Pink Peacock cafe, "the only queer Yiddish anarchist vegan pay-what-you-can café in the world". If I remember it right, it closed among similar drama, also specifically involving issues with the building's toilet.

I have to admit to finding these things hugely entertaining. But for balance I'll point out that Housmans has been open since 1945 and Freedom since 1886. It's not the inevitable fate of radical bookshops to implode like this.

Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
I think word is sometimes used as a cudgel to derail reasonable discussion. I still think it has its place and at this point, yeah I'm going to say you're unambiguously an antisemite.
Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
I don't really want to get into the A word thing, but your position makes more sense to me from a perspective of being anti-Jewish, rather than pro-Palestinian. From the latter perspective, I think it's better to challenge Israel's narratives than embolden them.
Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
You linked audio of a phone call from a Hamas terrorist, as evidence that "Palestinians don't discern Jews and Israelis". I hope you can see the irony there.

There's also, I think, an irony that antisemites and Zionists are united in their their efforts to conflate Jewishness with the actions of the Israeli state. I think it's a welcome development that Parker / Stone / Sheila Broflovski aren't going along with it.

Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
I think you're probably propagandizing rather than trying to engage coherently with the conversation, but perhaps I'm missing something.
Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
Perhaps we'll have to agree to differ, but I think American Jews being like "not in my name" sends a more politically effective message than "what are you talking about, psycho murderer?".

tbf I'm not primarily interested in what's a good look.

Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
If a country was killing thousands of people and saying it was to make people like you safer, might you not be inclined to point out it's having the opposite effect?
Joeboy··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
“There you are, Mr. Netanyahu! Just who do you think you are, killing thousands and flattening neighborhoods, then wrapping yourself in Judaism like it’s some shield from criticism? You’re making life for Jews miserable, and life for American Jews impossible!” - Jewish character on the latest South Park, a show created and run by two Jewish people.

Also ”It’s not Jews vs. Palestine, it’s Israel vs. Palestine!”

Joeboy··on 30 minutes with a stranger
I found it only slightly worse than not overriding the standard scrolling behaviour. Any time a site remains usable despite this sort of UX intervention we can consider that a win.
Joeboy··on Ask HN: Have any successful startups been made by 'vibe coding'?
In reality, when people talk about "vibe coding" they're probably either being self-deprecating (if it's their own work) or snarky (if it's somebody else's).

I've made a couple of things lately that I sometimes tell people are "vibe coded" because they were heavily facilitated by LLMs, but it's not really true in the pure, literal sense.

Joeboy··on Turn any website into an API
This is relevant to my interests[0]

Based on the website I was quite skeptical. It looks too much like an "indiehacker", minimum-almost-viable-product, fake-it-till-you-make-it, trolling-for-email-addresses kind of website.

But after a quick search on twitter, it seems like people are actually using it and reporting good results. Maybe I'll take a proper look at it at some point.

I'd still like to know more about pricing, how it deals with cloudflare challenges, non-semantic markup and other awkwardnesses.

[0] https://github.com/Joeboy/cinescrapers

Joeboy··on Ask HN: What trick of the trade took you too long to learn?
I'll add that I spent decades not learning to set up a guitar properly or acquiring the tools to do so. It turns out it's not nearly as difficult or expensive as I feared. To be fair it's a lot easier now than when I started, with youtube tutorials etc.

In particular, I now own a string height gauge, which was very cheap and makes the action assessment more empirical.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →