HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JoelMcCracken

2,777 karma · joined February 27, 2009

Pittsburgh dev. Haskell mostly.

Contact me at mccracken.joel@gmail.com

If your reply to me seems unnecessarily combative, pedantic, or uncharitable, I will probably not reply. Its not worth talking with someone who appears to be intentionally misconstruing my words. Ain't nobody got time for that.

submissionscomments
JoelMcCracken··on The Next Button
Every once in a while I think about this. I want a desktop environment that lets me organize things into "activities"/tasks; sets of tabs, different editors, different apps, which are essentially isolated from each other, shut down when I want and restore state when I want.

Roughly, I would prefer if my interaction with the computer was almost "reverse-repl"; the computer is consistently prompting me, and providing me suggested tools for how to proceed. I would love this. It would make a lot of things more straightforward imo (especially for someone with ADHD, like me).

JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: What would you do if you didn't have to work?
Write. I would investigate things that interest me, especially historical/little/less known things, and bring them to a wider audience.
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: Given AI advancements, is a master’s degree in CS worthless?
So, so much of our job is not writing code, it's understanding what is going on, communicating it to non-technical people, etc. It is very clear that these tools don't have an understanding what they're doing, it is all an advanced form of pattern recognition.

Some of our jobs may be automated by AI in the next N years, but I think we are quite a ways away our jobs being truly replaced, as opposed to simply augmented.

Don't forget that also in many ways these tools may (and are likely to) spawn the need for more programmers, while decreasing the total costs of development, but we will absolutely still be needed.

Remember, a computer can't be "fired". It can't be "blamed" when the site goes down, etc etc. We work in human organizations and fill in many needs beyond simply the time we spend in emacs.

JoelMcCracken··on The empty list
I like the way scheme does it, but IMO this is one of the least significant reasons scheme choices are much preferable to cl imo. It’s just a much cleaner, friendlier language overall
JoelMcCracken··on Kilo Lisp: A Kilo Byte-Sized Lisp System
yeah as a haskeller, there is a LOT that I wish haskell had that was better... if it had taken more of the good ideas from common lisp early on in its evolution, would be in a much better place.

I'm looking forward to a replacement; Unison might be it, a lot of its choices are better oriented towards interactive development, but the jury is still out on this. Other candidates imo are lean, agda, roc, verse (this one I heavily doubt), or ghc fixing itself so this discussion is unnecessary. But there is space for a language that cuts out the historical baggage. For a while, I hoped that would be purescript, but I think that unlikely at this point.

JoelMcCracken··on Kilo Lisp: A Kilo Byte-Sized Lisp System
I don't know that its good to learn it instead of any of those, but its fantastic to learn in addition to.

It's just different. I love haskell, but also love lisp. For very different reasons, but they're both delightful expressions of thought.

JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: How to do that you need to do but not motivated at all?
yep. But the thing is, realize that you can't trick yourself. you need to be allowing yourself to actually only do that. So, instead, think of it like this: its fairly easy to collect my various tax docs, and if I can't find a specific thing, then I have something specific to investigate instead of a nebulous fear.

I think a lot of procrastination is breaking down a large, nebulous task into a loop of investigate and then resolve until the task is complete, but our brains naturally tell us to avoid this kind of thing, its riskier to go after the food that you really don't know how to acquire and takes a lot of investigation than the food that you've been able to acquire easily in the past

JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: How to do that you need to do but not motivated at all?
I came to say this, find out if you have depression/adhd; they seem to be the root causes of my procrastination issues
JoelMcCracken··on ElonJet Is Now Suspended
So he's doing the same thing twitter was doing pre-acquisition, without pre-acquisition-twitter memeing about "philosophical free speech"?
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: Are you a “lifer”? If so why?
I've always wanted to be a lifer, but I just haven't found the right place. I think my current place might be it, though.
JoelMcCracken··on Dynamic types have the potential to be more than "no static types"
The existence of this option is what actually finally convinced me to give haskell a real try, but I have to say, I haven't actually ever used it. I alwyas just use undefined to defer any type error, actually seeing each spot there is an error and comprehending how to delay the problem for later basically seems to help me comprehend the problem I need to solve.
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: How's the job hunt going? (For those laid off)
Sure, but I think the implicit question-behind-the-question-being-asked is "we're hearing about a recession and that the job market is a lot harder than it was, how are you finding it?"
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: How's the job hunt going? (For those laid off)
I’d ask in a month. It’s still early since the layoffs. I’d guess that even for people who were laid off first, started looking immediately, and found plenty of hits, few have accepted jobs.

I’m much more curious in 4-5 months. I assume VC funding is harder to get now, for example, but I don’t think that’ll make a massive impact for a little while.

JoelMcCracken··on Functional programming should be the future of software
why?
JoelMcCracken··on Homemade Heat Pump Manifesto (2009)
This is exactly why I keep coming back to this website
JoelMcCracken··on URL is also a shell script that executes some malicious(?) code
I could imagine someone embedding something like this in a much larger URL, one that was full of many different characters, to make it look innocent.
JoelMcCracken··on Functional Reactive Programming
You absolutely can. Its a great platform for this.

There may not be as wide a variety of libraries as you would hope, but that's true of any smaller language.

The main thing you need to be able to do is have the wisdom to avoid the footguns. They're quite different from the footguns in other languages. in general, using Haskell well requires a good bit of experience with it, and knowledge of who in the community are selling false solutions.

JoelMcCracken··on C23 is finished: Here is what is on the menu
Indeed; I am wondering why go does not consider traits in rust a form of ad hoc polymorphism?
JoelMcCracken··on U.S. Army Camouflage Improvement Explained (2013)
I feel like eventually they'll be back to highland plaids as being the optimal pattern.
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: Why not have reverse life insurance that rewards longevity?
What is your overall stack like? Haskell dev here, always curious about commercial use.
JoelMcCracken··on Goodbye, shitty Car extends Vehicle object-orientation tutorial (2011)
Oh, well then you are talking perhaps using a newtype to wrap another type and perhaps use deriving to get behaviors from underlying type automatically.

Or with a record you just explicitly implement typeclass methods in reference to the contained data.

If you mean doing it without doing a typeclass, well the functions need to have different names. If that’s exactly what you want. In order to have the same function name you need a typeclass.

JoelMcCracken··on Goodbye, shitty Car extends Vehicle object-orientation tutorial (2011)
This is what Haskell uses type classes for. See how Monoid typeclass delegates to semigroup with default implementation of mappend
JoelMcCracken··on Ask HN: Is your company giving you a holiday for Juneteenth?
Yes, on Monday. TVision Insights.
JoelMcCracken··on Why Rust is a great choice for startups
Yep, this is absolutely a problem. Beginner-friendliness is huge, and we need to keep working on it.
JoelMcCracken··on Why Rust is a great choice for startups
> compelling framework

Sadly no. There are contenders for this that have arisen over the years, but we don’t have a RoR for Haskell yet.

If you’re curious, here is a talk that goes into this problem. It’s very accessible IMO. https://youtu.be/fNpsgTIpODA

To be honest, the compelling reason to learn Haskell for me was so I could engage with various academic literature. I just kept running into things I didn’t understand which were tangential to the topic of the paper, and it seemed like the most straightforward way to solve this was to start with learning Haskell. Once I learned it, I realized I was wrong in my biases, and Haskell is a fantastic tool for normal programming, with some important caveats.

JoelMcCracken··on Why Rust is a great choice for startups
> now do you Depends. I like JS ok. I really like Lisps. I miss doing Ruby sometimes. I've been doing more Python lately and find it rather distasteful, all this tooling is just so so complicated for very dubious guarantees/benefit. Not all of us are a sum of tropes.

The main thing that I find frustrating is that the actual act of programming in an impure language is so much harder. Haskell is def harder to learn, like 10x at least imo. Especially for a mainstream dev. But, once you know it, there is a simplicity to what you're doing which is very easy to do. I find myself having to just think so hard when writing python. "what exacty does this function do? Oh it calls this other function, I have to go check that one." etc. And then with a myriad of control flow issues, and random syntactic "sugar" to contend with...

There are a number of haskell companies, not just Jane street, and they do pretty well. If you don't follow the space closely, it is not surprising that you don't know about it. But there are. Not nearly as many as Python or whatever, but the appeal to the popular is def problematic: mostly because, at one point python itself was a radical new thing, full of skeptics like "if its so great, why don't more people use it".

Many ideas from haskell/typed fp are slowly making their way out into the larger community. Witness Swift, Kotlin, Java, numerous features in C#, etc. People like them.

Its fine if you don't like Haskell and don't want to use it. But its not an insane choice.

Haskell community really needs to do better at making it easier to get started though. Eventually I hope to contribute to that.

JoelMcCracken··on Why Rust is a great choice for startups
You shouldn't make the job harder than it needs to be. The main danger is using tools/techniques you don't know well. Learn radical new approaches on your own time. Don't bet the farm on the latest free monad framework which has 10 downloads on hackage.
JoelMcCracken··on Glucosamine significantly reduces risk of lung cancer and lung cancer mortality
Thanks. I was hoping for something online, like a blog post/website, which is an easy way to spread the word to other people so they know how to contextualize these things.
JoelMcCracken··on Mundane chores are all the rage in gaming
When I call clean, I use the time to listen to audiobooks, podcasts, attentively to music (versus just being something in the background while focus is elsewhere), etc. And focusing on the peace/serenity I feel when my area is tidy also helps.

Hth

JoelMcCracken··on Glucosamine significantly reduces risk of lung cancer and lung cancer mortality
I wonder, does anyone know of a good guide for lay persons that explains how to understand scientific studies?

Even something that details the difference between a population study and randomized controlled trials.

← PreviousPage 6 of 24Next →