HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JohnDeHope

539 karma · joined December 3, 2009

submissionscomments
JohnDeHope··on What do you visualize while programming?
I never thought about it before, but I think I visualize stack frames. Local variables are registers or just memory in the stack frame. Objects are pointers. "Where I've been" is prior frames on the stack. "Where is this going" is branch prediction guesses the CPU is making. It's like having a sort of mishmash of Von Neuman architecture and algorithms and data structures rolling around.
JohnDeHope··on NASA's SLS rocket's Mobile Launcher-2 increase from $383M to $2.7B
> 3. Creativity flows to the most basic constraint. The most basic constraint is political will to fund, so top level attention goes to managing/manipulating up.

Can you or somebody elaborate on this? Is there an idea or a terminology or something I can read more about this? I'm very interested in the idea that you can pay attention to where the "smart kids" are going, to help identify where the most basic constraint is. I'm also interested in what the word "basic" means here. I'm familiar with the theory of constraints and the idea of bottlenecks. But that doesn't seem like what this is getting after. Thanks!

JohnDeHope··on Faster CRDTs (2021)
Yeah, new rule: I don't believe anything in a published scientific paper until it has been independently verified for the third time. I don't even want to hear about it, before then, unless I read the journal the original (or second) paper was published in. What I'd really like, and would subscribe to even as a lay person, is the JOURNAL OF STUDIES WHOSE FINDINGS HAVE BEEN SUCCESSFULLY REPRODUCED FOR THE THIRD TIME. I'd pay for a subscription to that.
JohnDeHope··on CockroachDB license change
> They may be nice folks today, but who knows who will run the place in 5y when the next round of squeeze comes?

The same idea applies to political questions. A politician I like is proposing a policy I approve of. Great! Now what happens in the next election cycle, when a politician I don't like gets to use that same power to do something I don't approve of? Woops.

JohnDeHope··on CockroachDB license change
Maybe we will have to replace "open source" with "spec driven". As you point out, open source can be just as bad as closed source, given future changes in direction by the project team. But "spec driven" means that anybody can come along and compete, and you can switch to them, regardless of how the original developers feel about it.
JohnDeHope··on It's Sounding Like Boeing's Starliner May Have Failed
Agree. It'd be nice if there were some universal "just take me to the source" feature in media. I know most of what I see on YouTube is just other people reacting to, or re-reading, or generally regurgitating prior people's material.
JohnDeHope··on Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?
I use hckrnews.com. It's great!
JohnDeHope··on Is anyone interested in a better Hacker News?
I use hckrnews.com mainly because it only shows things that made it to the top page. It's an easy way to filter. If they can do that, it seems anybody could do anything with the content.
JohnDeHope··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
I'm sorry I didn't RTFA, but I wonder if there's a correlation / causation issue here. Did the "agile" projects fail because they were agile, or because their project management methodology was prescribed by management than is higher up than appropriate. Maybe they happened to choose agile because it's the flavor de jure at the moment, but it wasn't the "agile" that was the problem exactly, as much as the undue influence of the wrong layers of leadership.
JohnDeHope··on There's no need to shower every day – here's why
There's no need to ever listen to ---the BBC--- ---NPR--- state-run media.
JohnDeHope··on Show HN: Composable (as in iGoogle, but modern) privacy-friendly new tab
My current favorite here is start.me but I’ll give this a whirl.
JohnDeHope··on The Papa Johns closest to The Pentagon is far busier than usual
That's a succinct way to put it. Does anybody have any suggestions for following up on this line of thinking? I wonder what other, maybe technical scenarios, where this might also be true?

It's better for an error message to explain what the end user likely needs to know, rather than you heroically debugging it for them.

JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: Node vs. .NET Core (2024 edition)
I'm having fun jumping into this conflict. Since I'm unabashedly on one side of the argument, I feel equipped and compelled to weigh in. The work my small team does is well documented, and when we execute our plans, we can click "next next etc." and everything works quite nicely. You're absolutely correct that I do not want to have an understanding of what is happening when I click next. I have a lot of other things that I need to understand. Humans for example do not have any "next" button so I spend a lot of time wrangling us. When the computer does what I think it out to do, then you're right I am not going to dig in. That's true. Inevitably I'm sometimes surprised when the computer doesn't do what I think it ought to, and I do have to dig in. Then I am perfectly happy to debug the situation. We figure out what's going on, fix it in the near term, update the documentation to address this in the long term, and then go back to clicking "next next etc." I call this productivity. I guess you could look down on me for not wanting to know things I am not getting paid to know. I look at it as saving my limited brain cells and attention for things I am getting paid to deal with.
JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: Node vs. .NET Core (2024 edition)
I'm a full stack Microsoft tech stack web dev since the days of asp classic. It's cool that the tech industry is big enough for all of us. I am not sure what the ClickOps mentality is, but I'm pretty sure I have it. Peace.
JohnDeHope··on The Windows 11 Start Menu is comically bad
I wouldn't have to search for apps, if they'd just show a handful of the most recently used apps. This is what boggles my mind, that they don't monitor which apps are being launched, how often, and promote those to the top of the start menu interface.
JohnDeHope··on Intel One Mono
https://programmingfonts.tumblr.com/
JohnDeHope··on Intel One Mono
CommitMono is my current favorite.
JohnDeHope··on US Media Is Collapsing
> Mass layoffs are tearing through US media. To preserve a functioning media ecosystem, we need three things: immediate aid to struggling journalists, public subsidies to smaller news outlets, and eventually industry transformation into a publicly funded system.

People don't seem to want what we're selling. So the government should tax them, then give us the money to continue providing what they've demonstrated they don't want. Did I get that right?

JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: How would you go about meeting a bunch of new people IRL?
> ... social anxiety ... hundreds of new people ...

I think you should lighten up on that goal. Meeting hundreds of new people for a person without social anxiety would be difficult. Maybe just start by chatting up folks who cross your path in everyday life? You might not get to hundreds. At least you won't distract yourself with unrealistic metrics.

JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: Does procrastination advice help you?
> Does procrastination advice help you?

Yes. I listened to Mel Robbins' book "The Five Second Rule" and it did help me. https://www.melrobbins.com/5secondrule

> Is this a sign of depression or ADHD?

No, it's just that you have a particular set of skills, and you have a certain set of priorities. If you had different skills, or different priorities, then your behavior would be different.

JohnDeHope··on SN Pro Typeface
It's pretty, but small serifs on the uppercase I are a must for me.
JohnDeHope··on Peter Norvig: New Python Operators (2023)
These are cute, but this is also one of the reasons why I can never get into python. It's had too much stuff tossed into it.
JohnDeHope··on Microsoft Publisher will no longer be supported after October 2026
I'd agree if Power Apps had a programming language backing it up. Say what you want about VBA, but it's at least a programming language. The databases and UIs were often just along for the ride, in my experience. The ability to run code was what made MS Access so useful to me. Power Apps just isn't there, yet, I don't think.
JohnDeHope··on Perun2 Programming Language
I think the syntax and numerous keywords are interesting. They have keywords for every weekday, month, unit of time (singular and plural), etc. Most programming languages are proud of how few keywords they have. This means every last damn little thing you want to say has to be said with an enum, static, constant, etc.
JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: What is your go-to stack for the web?
I've moved everything to ASP.Net Core Blazor. I've been developing web apps on Microsoft's stack since Wrox's ASP 3.0 book. It's always been a pleasure.
JohnDeHope··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
Thanks for this quote. "Artificial Inanity" seems about as useful of a concept as "negative information" (from Foundation?) has been.
JohnDeHope··on The BeOS Bible (1999)
The original black and white screenshots in the book do not do justice to how jaw droppingly beautiful BeOS was at the time. It was like a work of art. Hanselman had a project where he crowd sourced people re-writing an old basic games book into modern python or somesuch. I wish there was a way to re-take all these old screenshot of a VM running the original BeOS from back then. That's the part of BeOS that I really have nostalgia for. The technical underpinnings were great, no doubt. The source code was almost as beautiful, and I don't even write C. But the GUI...
JohnDeHope··on Reddit Sans
It's only when two highly-prized priorities are pitted against each other that you can really determine which is higher up on the priority list. I guess now we know. Hating on the outgroup is a strong trait amongst humans, perhaps even stronger than font snobbery.

Does the world really need yet another font with a purely rectangular lowercase 'l'? There. I guess you can see where my priorities lie.

JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: Why do half of Internet users think we are living in a simulation?
A more pithy version of my two cents...

Facts or opinions which are to pass through the hands of so many, to be misconceived by folly in one, and ignorance in another, can hardly have much truth left. - Jane Austen (1775 - 1817), Persuasion, 1818

From http://www.quotationspage.com/quotes/Jane_Austen/

JohnDeHope··on Ask HN: Why do half of Internet users think we are living in a simulation?
Here's my systematic answer about 'questions'. First, broadly, a question is either falsifiable, or not. Even if it is hypothetically falsifiable, if it's not falsifiable in some reasonable time frame, or within some agreed upon framework for determining the "right" answer, then it's effectively not falsifiable. I think this question about if we're in a simulation is not falsifiable at the moment.

As an aside, if the question is falsifiable, then you don't want to simply ask people what they think. Asking people questions is usually a waste of time. Setting up an accurate poll is really hard. Even in good faith, anonymously, people will answer based on social norms and expectations. Knowing if you have an accurate population to poll is really hard, too. I think it's more reliable to set up a scenario where people can bet money or other another resource on the answer. You have to define how the "right" answer will be determined, and time box it. Assuming you set this up well, you might get some approximation about what people actually think about your question, and how confident they are in their assessment. It's still not foolproof, but it's meaningfully closer than just asking them.

For a question that's not falsifiable, or that you can't pin down a way to determine the "right" answer, such as if we're living in a simulation or not, there will be a small margin of people who will refuse to answer either way. A question that's not falsifiable is not a question at all. It's source material for fiction writers. This is a very small sliver of the population though. Most people will play along.

Among the remaining population (which is most people) you will get two broad groups. One doesn't think very hard about the question at all (if they did, they'd realize it was not falsifiable, and so kind of silly). These folks will split roughly along the proportion of the prevailing society at large. They're just answering whatever seems the most fun or heartwarming to them. It might be interesting to know, though. It'd tell you which way the "wind is blowing" so to speak.

The second group will actually think about the problem, and suspend their philosophical apprehensions about non-falsifiable questions, and kind of mull it over in their heads. They'll be willing to consider arguments. They might even (shudder) search the internet for articles or videos about it. The most you can ever hope for is that some of these folks have actual credentials or education in the field your question relates to, so their answers might actually even be credible. You won't know if they're credible or not though. And even if they have credentials, you probably don't have any way to judge the credibility of their credentials. But even still, they've given it some though, and are answering with a bit of investment. You'd probably like to know how this population sees the question, as it's the closest you can get to a "right" answer, given that the question is not falsifiable.

Here's the rub though. You have no way of separating the people who answer flippantly from the people who answer with some modicum of thought put into it. You can't know if somebody is trolling you, or a subject matter expert with decades of applicable scientific knowledge. And you can't judge a person's decades of scientific knowledge if (just as one example) their job depends on them answering a certain way. There are so many unknowns involved, that the proportion answering the question one way or another is basically noise. If I told you that half of people think gremlins are real, or that the God of the Bible is real, or that aliens are among us, I haven't really told you anything at all. It'd be like saying "I took this six sided die, rolled it, and it came up a 3. What does that mean?"

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →