HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JohnFen

36,061 karma · joined December 10, 2018

submissionscomments
JohnFen··on "The only intuitive interface is the nipple" (2012)
We get dangerously close to a semantic difference here, but this is how I learned the categories generally work. This is not my field, so I could be wrong, of course.

Generally, you can break things down to three categories.

There are reflexes, which are when your body reacts to something without your brain needing to be involved. The latching reflex in babies, for example, or the patellar reflex (tapping the knee to make the leg jerk).

Then there are instincts. Instincts involve the brain, and so generally don't appear in human infants immediately. Instincts are like pre-written scripts encoded in us, but require a level of development before those scripts can be executed.

Then there are learned behaviors. Things that are "intuitive" fall into this category. Something is intuitive if a behavior you already know well can be applied the activity.

Reproduction is instinctive (and it's an instinct that, in humans, doesn't really show up until much closer to sexual maturity). It's not intuitive. If you've never been exposed to or taught how to have sex, you'll still feel the desire and be able to do it. Maybe not well, but you can get the job done.

JohnFen··on Advertising Is Shit Now
I mean, this is true. But it's more true for some things than others.

I remember a day when computer-related advertising wasn't generally shit. It was certainly trying to be persuasive, but it focused on the actual details of the products on offer rather than the feel-good or lifestyle pitches that they are now.

You really could get an idea of if a product would help you or not from the ads. These days, you simply can't.

JohnFen··on "The only intuitive interface is the nipple" (2012)
What's "intuitive" really just boils down to "what you're used to".

An intuitive user interface is one that leverages patterns the user has already internalized. That's why there is no single user interface that is intuitive for everybody.

JohnFen··on "The only intuitive interface is the nipple" (2012)
Babies have a reflex (not even an instinct) to do it, but that reflex only works well if conditions are pretty close to ideal. Outside of the sweet spot, there can be all sorts of difficulties. That's the nature of reflexes.

Using a nipple isn't really intuitive. It's learned.

JohnFen··on Do not build the LLM torture factory
> You can think it’s wrong to torture LLMs for the same reason that installing a bunch of realistic torture video game mods is wrong: not because video game characters are real, just because that’s a messed up thing to do.

I think this is mixing up two different things that overlap in the Venn diagram. Something being distasteful (even extremely distasteful) is not the same thing as it being wrong in some ethical or moral sense. It's easy to come up with examples of things that are in one set but not the other.

JohnFen··on Trump's AI rebrand causes 'unprecedented' demand for Slovenian website names
This adds an easy signal to help detect bootlickers.
JohnFen··on Florida county discovers mysterious Flock cameras with no obvious owner
Or 3D print a shell: https://www.printables.com/model/1794129-flock-falcon-survei...
JohnFen··on We're Missing a Key Reason Why Americans Hate AI
> It has completely revolutionized a handful of fields and is increasingly doing so in others.

It's also good to remember that "revolutionizing" or "disrupting" a thing does not necessarily mean (or imply, outside of SV) that the results will be better.

JohnFen··on We're Missing a Key Reason Why Americans Hate AI
> You're increasingly pushed to use AI by every online service, and every interaction with retail pushes AI in your face, and importantly, ALL OF THEM ARE JUST TERRIBLE.

I think there's much truth to this.

Personally, the only impacts I have personally witnessed or experienced from these technologies have been, on the whole, negative. I mean, I have seen some upside in fairly niche areas, but they are dwarfed by the downsides. At least so far.

I think a rather large part of the reason (but certainly not the only reason) why this technology is generally viewed in a negative light is because the downsides are actually real and being felt by a very large percentage of people, but the upsides remain mostly in the realm of aspirational statements.

JohnFen··on Decades After Watergate, Justice Department Reviews Whether Nixon Got a Raw Deal
It's cute how the justice department seems to think they still have credibility.
JohnFen··on Consumer AI Fatigue Is Overwhelming, Local Businesses Should Reconsider Use
> It's similar to using CGI instead of practical effects in movies

The use of CGI in movies led to a dramatic reduction in my willingness to see movies. Weirdly, there was a relatively short period of time where its use wasn't largely problematic, but over the last decade or so its use has become irritating enough to me that I factor it into my movie-seeing decisions.

JohnFen··on Women Don't Want Us in a Room That's Why the Manosphere Exists
I'm in the US, and it comes off the same way to me. Delusional.
JohnFen··on Is AI Just a Fad?
The provided link is to Google's awful redirect.

The actual link is https://www.quora.com/Is-AI-just-a-trend-that-will-fade

JohnFen··on Returning from vacation? The government can search your phone without a warrant
I'm genuinely surprised that Mr. Kennedy took his real phone with him in the first place. I wouldn't dare do such a thing, and I'm not even a person who would naturally be of special interest to the current administration. Mr. Kennedy is.

I mean, yes, it shouldn't be necessary to take such defensive measures. It's a travesty that it is. But the need to do it is real and apparent.

JohnFen··on Claude Says
Honestly, I would very much prefer that to people just copypasting genAI reponses.
JohnFen··on Claude Says
> relaying Claude's final answer is not inherently the wrong thing to do.

But it's very poor communication, and (to a whole lot of people) comes off as dismissive and unhelpful. It's better to hear from the subject-matter expert than from genAI directly.

JohnFen··on RFK Jr outlines expansive vision for collecting US health data at Maha event
Not just no, but hell no. Getting health care in the US is already more than fraught enough.

If this sort of thing actually happens, hopefully underground "off-grid" health care will be available so there will at least be some sort of way to get health care without making ourselves even more vulnerable.

JohnFen··on Travis Kalanick is back: How Uber's ousted founder went from pariah to hero
If SV really does welcome him back and regard him as a hero figure rather than the villain that he is, it's just another piece of evidence demonstrating the extreme moral and ethical bankruptcy of SV culture.
JohnFen··on The new Firefox design is here
> so as long as Firefox doesn’t break extensions for power users

You mean, as long as they don't break them any more than they did a few years back? Yes, I'm still salty about that loss.

But to your point, I agree with you. The native Firefox UI hasn't been one I loved for many years, and isn't getting any better. But I am still able to (mostly) massage it into something I'm OK with. As long as I can do that, then I'm fine with them doing whatever they need to do with the default look-and-feel.

JohnFen··on Anthropic is "destructively scanning" books. Should you care?
Should doesn't enter into it. I care a lot, for a lot of reasons.

It is also a potent physical symbol of what these companies are doing to society overall. I suspect that most people who react poorly to the practice are really reacting to this aspect.

JohnFen··on Singer: The Downfall of a Great American Manufacturer
Lots of people still buy good quality clothing and repair it. Not as many as there used to be, but the market exists. Five of my friends own and use sewing machines for this purpose.
JohnFen··on I switched to Brave
> Using it despite that, IS a political statement, that not everyone will make.

Not necessarily. Some of us just really don't like using Chromium-based browsers due to usability issues and want to use one that works better for them.

JohnFen··on You're Paying Meta and Google for Your Online Medication
This kind of stuff is among the many reasons why I won't use any telehealth services, including buying medication online.
JohnFen··on Think of Motivation as Something You Earn
If that's how I thought about motivation, I'd never be motivated to do anything at all. What would be my motivation to "earn" motivation?
JohnFen··on Controversial Sydney data centre project pulled amid community anger
I'm not at all convinced that the new buildouts are necessary at this pace and scale.
JohnFen··on The way we talk to bots matters even if they aren't conscious
I cannot bring myself to treat a machine with the same deference as a human.

Particularly a machine that is designed to trick me.

JohnFen··on "The refrigerator is dead": Samsung's AI fridges shut down after update
They've been making refrigerators since 1974, far longer than they've been making RAM and SSDs.
JohnFen··on "The refrigerator is dead": Samsung's AI fridges shut down after update
Refrigerators aren't (yet, anyway) one of those appliances where there's no choice.
JohnFen··on Flock seeks to have security researchers' map of Flock cameras taken down
FTA:

> A security researcher discovered a vulnerability in Flock’s website that gave him an access token without needing login credentials. The researcher used the information gleaned to build a map of Flock cameras and share it on a website he named the Flock Surveillance Map, which now lists the location of 335,701 cameras. Flock has now issued a trademark infringement complaint with the goal of having the researcher close the website.

If it's really just a trademark infringement lawsuit, then it's not a serious risk to the website. Worst case, all they have to do is stop using whatever trademark Flock is complaining about.

JohnFen··on Ask HN: Does your team still have humans review and understand code?
Yes
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →