HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JohnMakin

10,733 karma · joined March 3, 2023

DevOps/Systems Engineer/SRE

Reluctant Terraform Wizard, Passionate about privacy

the pen is mightier than the sword. - Marcus Brody, indiana jones and the last crudade

submissionscomments
JohnMakin··on Lobbying is corruption
lol it’s this and can only be this
JohnMakin··on No Man Is an Island
> The programming language is an implementation detail the humans no longer have to care about.

If you believe this, you're in for a wild ride someday.

JohnMakin··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
I guess what I’m saying, failure to produce evidence to against a positive claim does not validate the positive claim.
JohnMakin··on I think we might lose public key cryptography
Here ya go:

https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013...

JohnMakin··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
> It's on the side making any specific claim.

That isn’t how this kind of debate works.

I make a positive claim - “there is a god.”

Counterclaim says “No it doesn’t.”

The second claim cannot be made to produce contrary evidence to the first claim. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

JohnMakin··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
The burden of proof does not lie there, this is a popular fallacy people love to reflexively respond with.

If you don't know that much about human brains, then how on earth can you make the claim that these possess human intelligence? The burden of proof doesn't lie on the "prove it's NOT as intelligent as a human" side.

Thinking about this for 5 seconds reveals how silly this line of thinking is, sorry, and this exact comment is made 500 times a day here.

JohnMakin··on Meta’s Muse is an adorable privacy and security dumpster fire
> Caveat emptor. Don’t be an idiot. Grow up. Make informed decisions regarding your use of these products and take responsibility for those decisions.

Feigned outrage, indeed. I don't think it's unreasonable to point out that Meta has been consistently predatory, reckless, and creepy with user data before, and that this is a very aggressive expansion of that.

The old facebook booster retort of "if you don't like it, don't use it, take responsibility" or whatever is nonsense. You're in their system whether you use their product or not. Even if you somehow avoid their pervasive web-wide tracking, a single contact you know installing this thing and gobbling up all your correspondence with them can compromise your privacy choices, and that's well beyond your control, unless you seriously suggest I audit every single one of my contact's devices and browbeat them into using the privacy choices I prefer.

Get real.

JohnMakin··on JetBrains reported a net financial loss first time in its tracked history
terminal and vim work completely fine
JohnMakin··on Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces felony charge
>I feel like if people understood what these things actually are there'd be way less of this AI psychosis and similar stuff.

There are people with education here that don't fare much better, so I don't know.

JohnMakin··on Tell HN: Uceprotect is extorting website owners
Their lists are definitely used, which is the only way I knew about them - some years ago one major email provider was not receiving email from my DO hosted site at all, completely blackholed. I knew enough of what I was doing to know this was practically impossible, spent over a week running every kind of configuration scan and test I could think of, and finally narrowed it down to this organization in particular blacklisting all of DO IP space. Needless to say I was shocked and annoyed at such an unprofessional looking and sounding website wielding such control over the operation of my site (which, lest it needs to be said, was a completely legitimate site).
JohnMakin··on Tell HN: Uceprotect is extorting website owners
Why DigitalOcean in particular though? Why not Cloudflare? A significant percentage of malicious and spam traffic is hosted on or routed through cloudflare services. Why not AWS? Same thing. It's a personal grudge, and they aren't quite big enough or have powerful enough lawyers to cause a widespread problem if put on a list, so, the big players are left alone.

All that aside, the website and their communication around this over the years is extraordinarily unprofessional and it's astounding to me they wield such power.

JohnMakin··on Tell HN: Uceprotect is extorting website owners
DigitalOcean has been on their list for a while, they say something like “if you don’t want to be flagged as spam, dont host on a site that hosts spammers” which is pretty ridiculous given every cloud platform does
JohnMakin··on Mike Tomlin spent 12 years building a Minecraft city
I think so too, but also in the way of like, he chose it as a creative outlet that was for him and maybe a few other people in his life. no desire for material gain, just the relaxation of creation. he didn’t care if anyone saw it or not.
JohnMakin··on Mike Tomlin spent 12 years building a Minecraft city
He didn't even want to share it, his kid kind of forced him to.
JohnMakin··on GPT-6 Astra plays World of Warcraft for the first time with agent-wow
Guess what, we created an AI to play the video game for you, so now you don't have to! Awesome!

Without the /s, WoW has been successfully automated without AI as a completely solved problem for like, 20 years.

JohnMakin··on AI Makes Me Sad
I'd go easy on them, they're a student with what is almost certainly a very bizarre view of the world from that POV right now.

It doesn't sound very different from when I was in undergrad an eon ago, except substitute "AI" with "blatant and rampant cheating" and "openAI offer" with "google" or "facebook"

JohnMakin··on AI Makes Me Sad
> But I don't want to do that. I don't want to prompt Codex for a living, or Claude for that matter.

I mean for me at least, this is not at all what it feels like. About 50% of my working time is split on architecting, planning, designing, testing, automating, reviewing. 20% on meetings and I guess the rest "prompting" but a lot is automated. I don't really mind other than the second order effects of slop grenades hitting my team by less diligent or shitty engineers.

Basically a lot more time spent on "how should this work?" vs before a lot more time spent on "how can this work?"

JohnMakin··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
It's a nice idea, but couldn't it also be explained easily by the invaders enslaving or killing most of the population? Existing structural decline and instability makes this a lot easier to do for an invading force.
JohnMakin··on GLM-5.3 and the spread of advanced cyber capabilities
There's also no effective way to ban these models?
JohnMakin··on GLM-5.3 and the spread of advanced cyber capabilities
This is a completely disingenuous comparison and strawman argument I refuse to be sucked into. The National Rifle Association is a gun lobby. I am a person on the internet, and someone tasked often with defensive security, making the completely non-analogous argument that cybersecurity capabilities should not only be provided to a gatekeeper with dubious intentions.

I don't really need to expand further. What are you proposing to do, enforce bans on every open weight model all over the world? Monitor every user's computer that has a network connection? What are you proposing, exactly, and how much Anthropic stock do you own?

JohnMakin··on GLM-5.3 and the spread of advanced cyber capabilities
It is so transparently obvious and harmful what they are doing here.

You making the argument that these models exist and are dangerous (plausible, true, likely) but then removing the cyber capabilities of your own frontier models out of 'safety' is a complete nonsense argument. You're stripping defenders' ability to defend whilst knowing stuff like this is out there, and only giving access to your gatekept super cool kids' (or rich kids) club, and then to top it off, using this as an excuse for government intervention/regulation of models that are threats to you competitively.

Just gross all around.

JohnMakin··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
Whole word reading has been a disaster.
JohnMakin··on The Test
They're never going to let you into the club, dude
JohnMakin··on Suspension of the de minimis administrative exemption for imports $800 or less
weird title change.
JohnMakin··on The first new cat species discovered in 100 years
I think you’re confusing species with genetic variation within a species.
JohnMakin··on My temporary PHP fix from 2014 has nearly 20M installs. Today I'm deprecating it
is-even implementation:

> 'use strict';

> var isOdd = require('is-odd');

> module.exports = function isEven(i) {

> return !isOdd(i);

> };

JohnMakin··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
> Is this really any different to how humans learn

yes.

JohnMakin··on There's a 100% Chance AI Agents Are Ruining the Internet
> The new one is built behind walls of 402 payment required. Visitors have to pay their freight else the servers get overwhelmed.

This is similar faulty logic the Elon era X/Twitter used to try to "stop" bots - forcing them to pay $Y dollars a month to use the platform. To a botter, that is a dream - you mean I can just pay to get past your defenses, and once I'm in, it's assumed my traffic is good? Sign me up, instantly.

There is no dollar amount using this structure that genuine users are willing to pay that will also stop botting.

JohnMakin··on Claude is a Contrarian
It's definitely worse and getting worse. I'm curious, do they not know this is happening, or not care? I struggle to believe people prefer the way it writes, which is becoming drastically different than its competitors.
JohnMakin··on LG denies TV spying claims, says tracking and snooping concerns 'not true'
Wolf claims they are utterly interested in eating sheep, news at 11
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →