HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

John_KZ

166 karma · joined February 10, 2018

submissionscomments
John_KZ··on Nvidia Unveils Quadro RTX, a Raytracing GPU
Fake video is happening regardless (and a lot better) with generative neural network architectures. Also fake video was already possible, we just see its usage ""democratized"", in a way.

Empowering everyone to be able to make Hollywood-grade feature films with like $10k in hardware has a lot of negative side-effects, but also a lot positive. The only problem is that video is no longer hard evidence for justice. It's a huge loss, but it happened already.

John_KZ··on Nvidia Unveils Quadro RTX, a Raytracing GPU
The fact that will have reasonably priced, real-time unbiased global scene rendering within 5-10 years really blows my mind. I knew this was coming for a long time, but seeing it actually happen is so odd.

After seeing the bright potential of an AI-powered future turn into a sad totalitarian reality it's nice to see a "futuristic" technology materialize with little potential for malevolent use.

John_KZ··on Shrinking Machine Learning Models for Offline Use
Is there really a need to shrink models?

As far as I know, most machine learning models can be very compact, often well under 1 GB. Even high-res vision CNNs aren't anywhere close to being fully-connected. They might have millions of weights, but that's just in the MegaByte range.

My understanding in the the real problem is obfuscating the machine learning model. If they decide to put their model on the local memory, they'd be giving away their well-guarded trade secret. Also they'd be giving away their justification for collecting all user data.

Is anyone around here working of production ML software? Am I really wrong?

John_KZ··on How can you treat someone who doesn’t accept they are ill?
This "I know better than you" disease needs treatment. We need to force AOT on all those individuals who are unable to understand how their actions are dangerous to society by enabling forced treatment. We need to enforce treatment on those individuals to stop the looming danger of forced treatment as a political control tool.
John_KZ··on Google’s DeepMind to Create Product to Spot Eye Disease
"Google to acquire thousands of retina scans in exchange for subpar diagnostic services"
John_KZ··on ICE Whistleblower interview with CBS interrupted by government agents
Was he send to the Gulag or not?
John_KZ··on Ask HN: How do Google's iOS apps track your identity even after reinstalling?
Please come back with an update after trying this. There are also ways to identify you without using local storage (ie browser/device/network fingerprinting) but I doubt they use it officially.
John_KZ··on Rewards of Up to $500K Offered for FreeBSD, OpenBSD, NetBSD, Linux Zero-Days
Can we fix this kind of behavior without spiraling down to a money-spending competition? (Which the open source community clearly cannot win?)

With open-source developers being badly paid, large numbers of relatively unknown contributors with little to lose (ie no reputation, no criminal charges, no repercussions whatsoever), and major corporations not caring enough about Uncle Sam to spend $$ to shield open source software they use, who will stop this kind of decay?

It used to be that the stakes were low, the developing community was small, and the amount of software was manageable. If someone introduced a zero-day, sooner or later would be caught and kicked out. Few people cared about breaking into this software so some donated personal effort was adequate to shield against those intruders.

Now if you can remotely compromise Debian or Ubuntu you have millions of servers in your hands and potentially hundreds of millions worth of private data. I don't see how this can be stopped.

John_KZ··on Facial Recognition Cameras Do Not Belong in Schools
I've never been in the US and stories like this make me imagine it as a bizarre authoritarian dystopia.

How are the parents not reacting to this? How is there no law protecting the privacy of workers and children? Why is this not in the front page of a major newspaper?

Please do something about this. By the time those technologies trickle down to smaller countries there's very little we can do to counter the external pressure to implement similar "solutions".

John_KZ··on All Amazon Prime members can now try clothes before they buy
So I guess they'll be reselling used clothes as new from now on? Or do the amazon prime members pay for the depreciation in value of the clothes they can "try on" for days?
John_KZ··on Ugandan wins Africa prize for bloodless malaria test
It is. I'm afraid I'll have to side with the cynics until further info is give on it's principles of operation.

The Plasmodium parasite doesn't seem to have any special characteristics (ie size, spectral response) that would make it detectable by such a device. You can skip the sample size issue by assuming the diagnostic will run for hours or days, but I don't see any theoretical foundation this device could be based on.

Also the obsession of the website with the smartphone interface is kind of sketchy and makes it look (more) like a scam to me.

Edit: I looked further into it, the price is given by the royal academy of engineering. Taken from their website [1]:

" Gitta wins the first prize of UK £25,000 (124 million Ugandan shillings). At an awards ceremony in Nairobi, Kenya on 13 June 2018, four finalists from across sub-Saharan Africa delivered presentations, before Africa Prize judges and a live audience voted for the most promising engineering innovation."

Which means that a live audience of non-technical people were involved in the choice, and, to my opinion, from the rest of the content, this is a feel-good kind of competition with soft goals like promoting innovation and training young people, not the kind of competition that awards working ideas.

[1] https://www.raeng.org.uk/news/news-releases/2018/june/uganda...

John_KZ··on Survivorship bias and startup hype
The massive amount of failed startups is caused by people who think this is a fun popular way to make money out of thin air.

If you're level-headed and sensible, you can do your analysis, make a business plan and figure out if your idea is marketable or not. Then, there's the business-doing portion, which is extremely complex, different from your technical work, and will make or break your company. But that only works if you have a financially viable, novel idea. Unless you intend to scam bad investors, you can't have a startup without real innovation, period.

The startups were meant to be a way for experts in some field to materialize an (actually) innovative idea with economic potential, and generally an idea that doesn't require absurd amounts of capital. This could be done in a typical corporate environment, but when the innovation originates from a single individual, the startup model allows him/her to better protect his interests and grow his business faster.

When running a startup became a trend (in many areas of Europe it did, I don't know about the Americas) there was a huge influx of people with no technical expertise, all of whom simple wanted to be a startup owner for the sake of it, with no plans or targets, just to be managers. These people fail over and over, sucking up EU and local government resources with them, and dragging the name of real startups in mud. Many of them are just the kids of wealthy individuals with connections. They leverage these connections to get investments and loans and waste 100s of thousands to millions on repeated failed attempts to materialize some retarded idea, like solar freaking highways or the 10,000th taxi hailing application on the market.

Survivorship bias is bad, but this situation would persist even without it.

John_KZ··on Long-term health risks after having adenoids or tonsils removed in childhood
A lot of those ENT problems are related to allergies and irritants. The problem is that very often it's extremely hard to figure out what is causing the reaction and if it's an external element of the environment that can be modified. But the consensus of the medical community that formed in the last decade is that removing adenoids and tonsils should be a last-line of defense for chronic cases that affect your life significantly. That's because the solution is almost never permanent.
John_KZ··on Through-Wall Human Pose Estimation Using Radio Signals
Build an electronic warfare device that makes it look like hundreds of people are inside, all pointing guns outwards.
John_KZ··on Through-Wall Human Pose Estimation Using Radio Signals
This. It's quite possible that if it looks like you're holding something, they'll just shoot through the wall before even entering.
John_KZ··on Researchers suggest that R.E.M. sleep serves to warm the brain
It's weird they don't mention the much more obvious fact that an air-breathing mammal might need to maintain some level of alertness when sleeping in water.
John_KZ··on Why do CNNs generalize so poorly to small image transformations?
Let me save you some time on why:

>While VGG16 has 5 pooling operations in its 16 layers, Resnet50 has only one pooling operation among its 50 intermediate layers and InceptionResnetV2 has only 5 among its intermediate 134 layers.

Aka being computationally cheap with pooling causes weird sampling issues.

The paper has a terrible pompous title that's just wrong. Modern CNNs generalize wonderfully on small translations. They just managed to break a couple of old CNNs and go on to claim they broke AI research or something.

John_KZ··on Researchers suggest that R.E.M. sleep serves to warm the brain
To me this looks like evidence that seals don't enjoy sleeping in water very much. Not much else. Also sleep-deprived rats seem to consume more calories. Wow.
John_KZ··on DeepMind: First major AI patent filings revealed
They can't be, unless Google decides to enforce them. It's not the first time they crowd-source massive amounts of specialized effort, only to steal all the data, close them off and get away with it.

Panoramio is the biggest one I know. They essentially stole 10 years worth of effort from a community collecting carefully positioning millions of geo-tagged photos.

Then you have Youtube. It's not completely closed off, but you can't query the video database, you can't discover any of the old content, and they "delete" (hide from the public) all issues they consider controversial or against their political beliefs.

Now it's possible they used the good old 3Es to stimulate academic research relevant to their targets, use it to create useful products, and then patent everything to choke out the competition. Of course they have better ways to kill competitors (imagine the massive potential for undercutting they have, and how nobody cares about undercutting in the online world).

John_KZ··on Nearly 80% of Japan’s Airbnbs removed in response to new home-share law
There's no point in denying that the majority of cab drivers were more rude and scammy 10 years ago. They were, and in some places they still are.

But in my opinion, Uber was not even close to the top reason for the improvement you see. It was mobile navigation, more organized taxi companies, including internal rating systems and more often inspections, and job insecurity. Uber definitely helped with job insecurity. Personally I'd rather have a somewhat annoying driver that talks on hands-free the entire ride over a smiling quiet driver that can't make ends meet and his livelihood depends on a couple of ratings. There's a good compromise somewhere between the two ends but it's not like we weren't in the former end for a long time. Taxi licenses were extremely expensive, fares were extortionate and you got scammed immediately if you looked out of place.

John_KZ··on Nearly 80% of Japan’s Airbnbs removed in response to new home-share law
That's a great example that clearly demonstrates that local law can be enforced, even on companies like AirBnb. I hear lots of arguments on "You can't enforce the ban", but it's simpler than ever to just do that.
John_KZ··on Fortran is still a thing (2017)
>Fortran is simple enough for domain specialist to write bad code and achieve good results with it.

I don't understand the idea behind this statement. Nobody but the specialist can produce efficient algorithms to solve a domain-specific problems, and Fortran isn't any simpler than C.

If the writer argues that the implementation of the algorithm is bad when written by non-programmers, then you might be surprised to find out that it's usually the opposite.

Computers are still incredibly simple in their basic design, so unless you hire a hardware-specialist programmer (like an x86 or CUDA/OpenCL specialist with background knowledge of the chips you'll use), knowing basic latencies in RAM operation, L-cache sizes and the ticks required for executing basic operations like floating point additions and XORs, is enough for the specialist to write better code, because he understand the algorithm, he can tailor it the hardware, and he actually cares, unlike most programmers/software engineers.

Knowing how to use hundreds of libraries might be helpful when you're writing long "consumer" applications, but this kind of expertise has nothing to do with scientific and high-performance programming.

John_KZ··on Steam store to sell VR porn video games
It's both about the extreme difference in immersiveness, the feedback loop (you're the one that's conditioned to choose to rape for more points for example) and the age of the target group.

Movies and books present a story. I haven't seen any movies or series portraying rape as desirable rape lately, but even if they do, you don't have to identify with the protagonist. In VR, you are the protagonist, always, and actions are presented as if they're actually yours, trying their best to trick your mind into thinking they are.

So yeah, many differences, nothing good about them.

John_KZ··on Steam store to sell VR porn video games
If you can't see how games and movies changed an entire generation in the last 20-30 years, you're blind. Morally, ethically, every aspect of their lives is different because of those influences, and in most cases not in a good way.

I would never allow my kid browse that kind of shit, even if they're 17. VR schoolgirl rape? Seriously? Why are people defending this. How can this be good for you psyche? Not to mention the more depraved shit that are going to arrive.

John_KZ··on A Costly, Deadly Obsession with Coal
I don't get why you're downvoted so much. Coal certainly has a place, even nuclear does in a country as big as the US. Going on a "monofuel" energy production (which would be gas, for now) has a lot of hidden costs on top of the obvious ones (gas is significantly more expensive than coal on industrial scales for energy production, but still far cheaper than nuclear or solar).

Not to mention that using coal extends the deadline on your country's gas reserves, reduces the much-hated fracking etc.

John_KZ··on US government to use facial recognition technology at Mexico border crossing
Exactly. Facial recognition already happens, but it's it's "natural", analog form. The border guard will make sure your documents are valid and the face in the document matches that of your face. That's more than adequate. If it's important to visa conditions, the date of entry/exit can be recorded, or for the sake of security, the date can be recorded in an offline log to be opened only by due process.

Photographing and storing data on millions of people without probably cause, sharing them with third parties (like Amazon) and keeping them forever, that's not just unnecessary, but also dangerous.

John_KZ··on NASA Finds Ancient Organic Material, Mysterious Methane on Mars
Here's a better source [1]. They found some organic goop, like kerogen. Might actually be organic (as in microbial) in origin.

However methane and organic matter gets discovered every 2 weeks. Perhaps next week they'll rediscover water for the 10,000th time. I get the excitement for the few that weren't aware of it, but it's getting really tiring for the rest of us.

http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/06/nasa-rover-hits-organ...

John_KZ··on Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buildings
Did this article just presented prefabricated housing as an innovative and novel way of building, and a solution to the housing crisis? Am I really reading NYtimes?
John_KZ··on AI at Google: our principles
If Google renews defense contracts, I'm going to simply pull the plug, and I suspect many more will follow. Changing your email address is hard, but the bulk of the task will be over in a few hours.

If financial sense is the only reason, then still yes. Why? Google works for the military, gets a bad rep, usage plummets. It's not unheard of before.

Of course they might renew the contracts secretly (and I'm afraid they might) but secret work is more expensive and hard to keep secret for long at large scales.

Also, looking at the very long term: Making killbots creates instability which creates war which damages the purchase power of their users which creates less profits for the shareholders.

John_KZ··on Rooftop solar power may be flooding the grid
Solar panels mix well with heat pumps in hot and dry climates indeed, because of the happy coincidence that peak solar radiation=peak demand for cooling. In that case it's not a bad combo, especially if you have mild winters without temps deep in the freezing (which ruins the COP for heat pumps, assuming you use them for heating too).
← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →