HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Johnjonjoan

274 karma · joined March 13, 2020

submissionscomments
Johnjonjoan··on Assange, Manning and Snowden Nominated for the 2020 Nobel Peace Prize
I did think of that before I posted. I think though long term (once we are out of this) we will now take threats to humanity much more seriously.

I can only speak for myself:

Personally I've always seen myself as an observer to humanity. I know what's right and I'd like to make it happen but there's so many people trying to get ahead there's no point. The cards are stacked against me and I was scared to fail.

Covid for all its badness has made me realise I can't just observe. Whilst there are people who don't want what's best in power we are in this precarious position where humanity could fail. My hope however optimistic it is, is that people who are good will also realise they have to act and they can't just watch.

As the old saying goes all it takes for evil to prevail is for good men to do nothing.

That saying has always meant a lot to me and I've always stood by the fact I would stand up and be counted when I was needed; this coronavirus made me realise I was needed right now.

Johnjonjoan··on Assange, Manning and Snowden Nominated for the 2020 Nobel Peace Prize
Can we give it to the coronavirus instead? I feel like a reminder of the human races mortality is just what world peace needed.
Johnjonjoan··on Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang
Cheers, I now understand why it's not such a clear case. I fear I may have many more harder to answer questions now though - Thanks none the less!
Johnjonjoan··on Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang
Objects far apart may be traveling faster than the speed of light but once the universe reaches equilibrium won't there be intermediate masses that gravity will be able to travel through?

I was also under the impression that an expansion of space would just reduce the gradient of the gravity along that space and not inhibit its propagation.

If like a bubble space has some form of surface tension then would there be a point that it can no longer expand? Gravity could then become dominant and force the contraction. -edit-> I guess that wouldn't contract the space though just the matter?

I promise I'm not being pedantic or contrarian for the sake of it but to further my knowledge, thanks for your input!

Johnjonjoan··on Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang
They're both variations on information theory.
Johnjonjoan··on Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang
You're right of course but I find the cyclic version so much more intuitive.

The force from the big bang was imparted in an instant yet gravity is a constant force. IANAP but surely at some point the accumulative force of billions/trillions/... of years of gravity overcomes the force imparted by the big bang and the universe compresses into a singularity again?

I'd really appreciate someone explaining why this isn't obviously the case.

Johnjonjoan··on I had Covid-19, and these are the things nobody tells you
"The loss of smell that can accompany coronavirus is unique and different from that experienced by someone with a bad cold or flu, say European researchers who have studied the experiences of patients.

...

Another thing that sets them apart is their "true" loss of taste.

It's not that their taste is somewhat impaired because their sense of smell is out of action, say the researchers in the journal Rhinology. Coronavirus patients with loss of taste really cannot tell the difference between bitter or sweet.

Experts suspect this is because the pandemic virus attacks nerve cells directly involved with smell and taste sensation."

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-53810610

Johnjonjoan··on Humanly Traversable Wormholes
Would we not be able to infer their existence by finding a white hole? I do see how calling that a detection could be a stretch.
Johnjonjoan··on Popular seafood species in sharp decline around the world
I'm not sure we can make this conclusion. Certainly the effect you're mentioning does extreme damage but it is localised. Acidification is nowhere near as localised, therefore whilst it doesn't affect individual areas as strongly it is much more widespread. When looking at the accumulative effects the question of which one is worse is up for debate and non trivial to answer.
Johnjonjoan··on Ask HN: Finding the Australian Aboriginal flag in all artworks
The closest flag I could find in the ten minutes of Google searching I could allot is the flag of the kingdom of Württemberg (1805 - 1918). It's just missing the yellow circle. Coincidentally the coat of arms involves a yellow oval and would often be placed in the centre of the flag.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_W%C3%BCrttemberg

Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
That's absolutely not what I said.

Catastrophic for 2100 is not the same as catastrophic climate change. Catastrophic climate change is much worse than even the worst case scenarios for the change between now and 2100.

What I was saying is if we get to a point where we are facing real catastrophic climate change then off course we will do whatever to stop it and it will be easy because we can stop the energy before it enters the system. Ocean acidification is a direct result of our carbon dioxide entering the ocean, unlike climate where sunlight is the primary input the carbon dioxide is the primary input. This is why it will be so much harder to stop catastrophic effects of ocean acidification compared to those of climate change once enough carbon dioxide has been emitted to make them happen.

Obviously we should still lower emissions. The thought I was saying we shouldn't is ridiculous. In fact what I'm arguing is we should be doing it far more aggressively because of the effects it has on ocean acidification and the difficulty in reversing those effects.

Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
We don't need to block all of it or anywhere near. We have hundreds of years to do this, why wouldn't we make them in space?

If you read my comment you would realise I didn't say we could use it to address climate change but that climate change would never become catastrophic (read runaway greenhouse effect) because we could do it as a last resort.

Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
It's hyperbole not alarmism and are you kidding? The ocean is currently acidifying at a rate 100x anything in the last 20 million years. Oceanography may be a relatively young science but we certainly know this kind of change is outside of what would be preferred.
Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
The best way to get the data would be to measure how much energy the planet absorbs vs how much it emits. The earth just wants to be in equilibrium so if these amounts aren't equal the climate is changing and the difference can tell you to what degree (excuse the pun).

The problem is that the earth transfers energy between many of its systems (think Ocean conveyor belt) and it's incredibly difficult to keep track of the energy. So any measurements of the earth directly that don't measure all the systems are likely to be inaccurate.

Edit: yes there is a global average surface temperature but due to the reasons above it's not a great indicator.

Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
As far as many marine organisms are concerned we are doing just that though. I said it for effect and I stand by its use.

The way I see it when talking about our oceans they are systems rather than a liquid. The system has a preferred pH range and therefore can become acidic regardless of whether it's <7.

Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
Ocean acidification involves a shift towards pH-neutral conditions rather than a transition to acidic conditions.
Johnjonjoan··on Greenland ice has shrunk beyond return, study finds
The way I see it climate change could be awful but it's never going to be catastrophic as long as we're alive. All we have to do is send up hella reflectors to block the sun and we can be cool again.

The real risk IMO is making the oceans acidic with all this co2. That has the potential to be really really catastrophic.

Johnjonjoan··on Trump: 'A lot of people' think Edward Snowden 'not being treated fairly'
Perhaps he expects the Russians will execute him if he's pardoned. Wouldn't surprise me given their track record.
Johnjonjoan··on Epic Games releases "Nineteen Eighty-Fortnite" ad
Interesting. Does your ability to download past updates mean you'll be able to download future ones though?

There's no doubt in my mind epic are using the they are stopping you playing argument - they literally say in the advert it's been blocked from a billion devices.

I mean if that statement is technically not true then don't you think it's propoganda?

Edit: I shouldn't have said technically not true but that they are being very economical with the truth.

Johnjonjoan··on Epic Games releases "Nineteen Eighty-Fortnite" ad
Until there's an update.
Johnjonjoan··on Epic Games releases "Nineteen Eighty-Fortnite" ad
Do the ends justify the means? The way I see it Apple will be rightfully scrutinised but only because a giant corporation used propoganda on its users. The lowest common denominator: "they're stopping you playing the game!!!"
Johnjonjoan··on Wellbeing levels fell with the pandemic but improved under lockdown, data shows
Why not also tropical rainforest? (I'm assuming you're saying we are meant to live how we did at our inception)

IMO using the word meant implies a purpose and I don't think there is one here.

Johnjonjoan··on Planet Ceres is an 'ocean world' with sea water beneath surface, mission finds
This is so non esoteric. I can't remember who said it but I'm reminded of the old saying: "if you can't explain something to a high school student then you don't understand it". You certainly understand it and I certainly appreciate you sharing your understanding in such an accessible way, thanks.
Johnjonjoan··on Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai arrested under national security law
Yes this is one line of thinking. However integrated air defence systems (IADS) have not shown themselves to be effective so far.

We've only really seen Russian systems in action and they've mostly failed, however it's very easy to argue this is due to poor training. One notable (alleged) engagement in Syria involved a Russian operated s400 battery (the latest and greatest) attempting to shoot down some of the 70+ tomahawks trump launched. Whilst some didn't make it to their targets there's no evidence the s400 hit them rather than them operationally failing. It's unlikely anyone would be better trained than the Russian military itself so if this indeed did happen it is damning for currently fielded IADS's.

Another reason for the apparent ineffectiveness of IADS's could be the west's proficiency at dealing with them:

Jets like the EA-18 growler are designed purely to entice systems to reveal their position (switching on their radar) so another jet can launch an anti-radiation air to ground missile (AGM) at it.

It's very likely the B2, f35 and f22 can't even be targeted by any IADS due to their low radar cross section.

Stand off weapons give the ability to destroy targets without being inside the range of any IADS. These could be used to strike important targets before the IADS is down or to pick the IADS apart itself (if you know where its assets are).

Given all this information I still can't say an anti aircraft system wouldn't be effective.. but I think the fact China is investing heavily into its air force implies that they have the same concerns about IADS effectiveness that I do.

Sorry that was so long, had a Pringles moment!

Johnjonjoan··on Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai arrested under national security law
There's no excuse for killing civilians in war but there's a definite difference between doing that and putting people in concentration camps because of their religion.
Johnjonjoan··on Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai arrested under national security law
Airplanes are so expensive and non survivable these days that IMO the next war will be a massive air battle with whoever loses unable to replenish and therefore forced to surrender or be picked apart from the air or escalate. America currently has 10x the aircraft China has and the logistics to back them up (China is catching up). A 2m man army will likely be irrelevant except for fighting regionally, if their enemy has air superiority they will not be very effective.
Johnjonjoan··on Revolution in Belarus People are demanding Lukashenko to go home
So Russia could well be supporting the opposition (who I imagine will become closer to the EU if in power) so they then have a reason for Russia to take Belarus?
Johnjonjoan··on Low-cost measurement of facemask efficacy for filtering expelled droplets
Yes we should not have taken masks that would go to the NHS but don't forget those masks should have been in government stockpiles well out of reach. How can we blame and punish the publics self control (or lack of it) when it's a government failure that caused the issue. Had we all bought masks and the state made them instead of redundant hospitals perhaps we would be in a much better place (less NHS casualties and physical/mental suffering).

All in all it just doesn't sit right with me to justify the government's decision without mentioning they were the ones that put us in the position where it had to be made.

Johnjonjoan··on Wheat yield potential in controlled-environment vertical farms
Appreciate this info. Thanks.
Johnjonjoan··on Wheat yield potential in controlled-environment vertical farms
If cost is the only issue we should be subsidising it and turning farmland into succession forest.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →