HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JsonDemWitOster

139 karma · joined May 26, 2026

submissionscomments
JsonDemWitOster··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
And if yomomma had balls, she'd be yopoppa.

Puh-lease. Unity's "hara-kiri" was in 2023 by which time Godot was NINE years old. Hara-kiri or no hara-kiri Godot has shown longevity and relevance. Anything gained from Unity's own-goals is just cherry on top.

JsonDemWitOster··on The Doorman's Fallacy in action
All fair points. I did not consider inventory tracking but yeah it's not likely to be the killer feature that would tide restaurant owners for one form factor or the other.

That said, I have a _feeling_ (I cannot emphasize this enough) that some restaurants might actually relish telling some of their patrons that the _special_ item is no longer available. Makes it seem even more exclusive when there's more demand than supply. I'm not talking about Mc Donald's sundae ice cream but rather Sea Urchin Ceviche from Dorsia's. It's only ever happened to me once, so anecdotal.

JsonDemWitOster··on The Doorman's Fallacy in action
It's cringey because it's thoughtless contrarian points. Like, really, how do digital menus provide more details? The lack of detail is not a problem of analog vs digital but from whoever decided on what goes in the menu in the first place.

> QR codes work across a conference room (personal experience) how old is your phone, exactly?

See, here we go. Of course a conference room with good (if not necessarily aesthetic) lighting is conducive to scanning QR codes. I bet said QR code was also printed large or even projected. A _restaurant_ on the other hand, more often than not has (a) small QR code print-outs---remember these are put on a table!---and (b) often has mood diffuse lighting which makes getting a good exposure on an already small print-out more complicated. If someone had the genius idea to print it out on reflective glossy paper that complicates things. However, if someone lacked the foresight and printed it on normal matte paper, you might find it stained with three-week old sauce.

(EDIT: For the record, other than the aforementioned Pixels, my current phone is a Sony XPeria 1 V1, but IDK I can't even handle JSON files, maybe I'm also holding my phone doofusly.)

> QR codes have gotten easier to use over the past ten-ish years, I've seen it.

I'm not disputing this and yet they are still at a point where it's a PITA. They've plateaued. Soooo...Tesla FSD before or after it's a PITA no more?

My point isn't that you haven't scanned QR codes before; it's that it seems you haven't scanned QR codes to get a restaurant menu while eating out with a large group ever. Hence, (⸝⸝⸝>﹏<⸝⸝⸝) .

JsonDemWitOster··on The Boeing 747 begins its final descent
But if $DAYJOB actually keeps you from your dying kid's bedside, is it still there to "sustain" it? Or is it just leeching into your life?
JsonDemWitOster··on The Doorman's Fallacy in action
> Once people get used to QR code menus we will see its benefits over traditional menus.

Au contraire, mon ami. Once people see the benefits of anything they will keep using it and naturally get used to it. Not the other way around.

Really enough HN now. Goodness, the discussion here is ridiculous.

JsonDemWitOster··on The Doorman's Fallacy in action
You make some good points but some are, excuse me, cringey-wrong.

> physical menus are hard to update

How often does a restaurant update a menu? Those that need to update frequently already solved that by having a chalk board.

> physical menus are often too simple, requiring asking the server questions they've answered a dozen times before already, hurting their efficiency...

How does a digital menu solve this? All online menus I've used have basically the same amount of information as a printed menu, with some being marginally better. The marginally better ones are the online menus for food delivery because they have a bit more flavor text, pun intended. This is however offset by restaurant-owners' tendency to put unrepresentative stock photo to go with the item and they just put a disclaimer about the photos somewhere.

> physical menus aren't cleaned between uses, so you're touching everything the server touched, and the three people before you.

Ok but please wash your hands after you order at the earliest and before you touch your food at the latest.

> physical menus aren't searchable.

Fair but only thanks to `Ctrl + F`, the best menu search interface by a mile.

> Difficulty scanning the QR code will get better over time, obviously.

I'm starting a prediction market if this will happen before or after Tesla FSD.

> it ignores how QR codes work (you don't have to be that close)

Uhhh...what? The farthest I could scan a QR code is about two handspans away. This was from the original Google Pixel! It was remarkably good at catching QR codes, I have no idea why. I thought it was the moment scanning a QR code has finally gotten better(!) so imagine my disappointment when my subsequent phones (even one Google Pixel 3a) couldn't live up to it. The 3a was still better than others. Even with flagship models, you gotta be pretty close to scan QRs not to mention wait for the exposure and focus to adjust.

(Whoever tells me "cameras can zoom now dummy" has never actually scanned a QR code from afar with the camera zoom lens. When you zoom, the exposure changes AND it becomes _super_ motion sensitive which is, obviously, not great for scanning things.)

> Does the author really think getting the server to split the bill is easier?

I am not the author but yes I do think so. Server has the table's bill in front of him and a calculator, each tells him what they had and pay in turn. Et voila.

Splitting the bill inconveniences comes down to a couple of factors IME:

1. the customers know what they had but don't know the price so they have to leaf through the menu again to calculate.

2. the table is provided with only one copy of the bill so the group has to scramble over one measly piece of paper, talking over each other, to compute their share.

Both can be solved by centralizing all that complexity on the waiter.

To be fair, I think the author's bad experience was due to wanting to keep the apple crumble gesture a secret. That is such a bizarre complaint, bro. It doesn't make sense to me either! You're all in a restaurant, everyone knows all the food will be paid for by someone! Why keep it a secret that you paid for the apple crumble?

That's enough HN for the rest of the week.

JsonDemWitOster··on How Quake Ruined Id Software
> Wasnt it pretty well documented Romero was fired from ID for playing Doom

> Afaik Carmack's forcing everyone into single room was a direct result of frustration over people playing multiplayer Doom instead of working on the next game.

It's been ages since I read "Masters of Doom" but the impression I got from its coverage of this era was that the rest of the team was "blocked" by Carmack's exacting vision that every release should feature an advancement in technology.

I mean, I don't intend to make excuses for one John or the other. There was definitely some hubris involved on both sides and, had I been in Romero's shoes, the decent thing to do would be to help out Carmack or de-scope Quake, scale back ambitions. I.e., that project needed better adult supervision. I just think that their organizational dynamics (considering their partnership's history) made Carmack the de-facto "engine developer" and Romero the de-facto "game designer/developer". When the going got tough, Carmack felt (rightly) slighted by the loose role definitions but Romero was too busy having fun.

Again, more maturity would've helped, either from a neutral third party or if they talked it out openly amongst themselves.

Also, FWIW, Romero is still credited as a programmer in Quake. So at least it's not like he left/was fired without putting anything of credit into Quake.

> Daikatana failed to make us Romero's bitches

Fair. And I'm still waiting for the big thing from Romero's Irish studio. That said, Romero has had an undeniably prolific career in games. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Romero#Games . This guy just loves making games.

JsonDemWitOster··on In memory of the man who put red and green squiggles under words
This gonna blow your mind: https://aesthetics.fandom.com/wiki/Skeuomorphism
JsonDemWitOster··on Mark Zuckerberg directed Meta to create a prediction markets app
Cliché cynic's comment: the end users they are concerned about are the companies they sell ads to. If you're not that, tough luck.
JsonDemWitOster··on Mark Zuckerberg directed Meta to create a prediction markets app
I don't think he meant you ate Christians, more that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Christians_in_t...
JsonDemWitOster··on Mark Zuckerberg directed Meta to create a prediction markets app
> Many people I see underestimate what it takes to build a business. It is the classic “I could have built that in a weekend” critique.

My dude, no one in your reply thread is making that claim. We bristling at the claim that "Social networks didn't really exist before The Facebook". Unless you're saying FB's innovation is its business model and is what made it dominate, well, your original statement just didn't substantiate that.

IMO, the only thing I'd credit Zuck for is sticking (at least at the start) to his singular vision of what a social network should be; first it was just open for .edu emails, then when it was released more broadly their product roadmap stuck to fostering a social environment online.

And then he lost that vision. I'd say it was circa Cambridge Analytica when engagement---often ragebait because it gave them more and stronger of that sweet sweet monetizable ad signals---replaced fostering an online social environment. Others would say it's the algorithmic news feed. Either way, losing that vision started FB's demise.

IME, FB was best when it was a supplement and not a replacement for real life. FB had value to me because we could plan parties there and even keep in touch after, get that social buzz going for a little while longer. But it was _never_ the party.

But their recent efforts---Metaverse, all the AI crap---has all the hallmakrs of trying to replace real life. They now want to be the party but good luck with that. Judging by the blowback and lack of adoption consumers see what they're up to a mile away. Zuck has no idea how to stay relevant so now we have a platform more concerned with its market cap than having actual utility.

JsonDemWitOster··on Sixty percent of US consumers say 'AI' in brand messaging is a turnoff
I've recently come to the thought that the reason why I find AI so snake-oily is because it isn't solving the bottlenecks of the use-cases it is being applied to.

The problem with customer service was never the frontline support agents but rather that these frontline agents are not empowered to solve the problems they encounter. I once had a human agent admit to me I was wrongly charged but they could not refund me on the spot because of protocol. Replace that agent with the smartest model and it still wouldn't have improved that interaction! (Of course, the business saves money if the AI costs a fraction of a human agent's salary.)

I'll take a shot in the dark and bet there was always an obscure/poorly documented way to solve your problem and that the AI could just find it in its playbook faster; it's search after all! It's also not inconceivable to go as far as to wager that a _human agent_ would just have been as effective; maybe the protocol to do it wasn't some obscure procedure for customer support.

----

That said, this is why I'm in disbelief that AI is bringing in as much value to the table as claimed. I realized that in software, it was never shipping the code that was the bottleneck to profit. I could be the mythical 10x productive engineer but all my output is still gonna be gated by things like testing of all sorts, customer acquisition, product development and design. Testing and product dev you could maybe automate but only after putting in considerable legwork yourself.

And of course, shipping 10x more features does not mean you'll get 10x more profit, not even that you'll get 10x more customers.

I have a friend working for an international law firm which has recently made a big push for responsible AI use. (I won't say which firm but the first partner name has to do with croissants and they recently organized an internal AI congress in Spain.) So, they are paying for AI subscriptions but I sincerely wonder if that's adding to their bottom line since their profit is bottlenecked by (a) how much billable hours they can account for and (b) the judicial process which famously moves at a glacial pace.

It's just a pattern I repeatedly notice when I look closer into things. And of course, as we all know, the cost of AI services today is still heavily subsidized by VC money. When that money is gone, I worry we'll be stuck with _expensive_ AI-centric workflows that's not really adding value to the business.

JsonDemWitOster··on Ask HN: Are most corporate SWE jobs performative?
I have a fraught relationship with 1:1s. Some days I curse the MBA who came up with this. Some days I'm rather ambivalent. Doesn't help that I'm naturally introverted and 1:1s is just a leech on my limited social battery. It's rather telling that IME 1:1s are the first meetings to be cancelled when the schedule tightens up.

I'm not outright saying they are useless but 1:1s won't make a bad manager good and they're a nice bonus when your manager is competent. In the latter I actually get career and professional guidance.

JsonDemWitOster··on GitHub Is Down
I care but I can't move out because it's Orders from Up High which migrated us to Github. We haven't been here a year and it's not worth my neck to mirror our code in some kind of skunkworks forge instance. Woe. Woe is me.
JsonDemWitOster··on GitHub Is Down
The Google SRE book offers the following as one of the reasons to not gun for 100% reliability (emphasis added):

> users typically don’t notice the difference between high reliability and extreme reliability in a service, because the user experience is dominated by less reliable components like the cellular network or the device they are working with. Put simply, a user on a 99% reliable smartphone cannot tell the difference between 99.99% and 99.999% service reliability!

I've been on a shaky relationship with my ISP of late. What brought me to this thread today is that I couldn't push to Github. Notably this isn't covered by their downtime report so, going by the available facts, it's _probably_ not Github's fault I couldn't push; and I've just been on my daily stand-up call and I got disconnected so frequently.

But looking beyond today's available facts, odds are there's a bigger problem GH is not mentioning in their status page. They say the current incident has to do with "unauthorized users" and I wonder if pushing a commit from my IDE client counts as an operation from an "unauthorized user" as I still have to authorize with my SSH key.

It's just insane I can't decide which between Github or German o2 should be the more reliable service!

JsonDemWitOster··on GitHub Is Down
Well thankfully it's Monday so they've only been down for the _first_ time this week!
JsonDemWitOster··on Please don't spam people looking for employment. It's just cruel
Ilia, first of all, from what you've written today, you come across to me like a decent principled person and that's rare nowadays. I admire that.

That said, if I may offer you my $0.02: systems exist for us to fallback on. You might know yourself and your situation best but sometimes the best way to not drown is to take a lifeline even if you know how to swim. I completely understand not wanting to take-up the space of someone in greater need but let the bureaucrats make that call.

I'm not very smooth with words but what I'm saying is, I encourage you to apply for social support systems nonetheless. That's not just specifically the asylum process but I'm sure there are other programs in the EU (for instance) where you might qualify. It wouldn't hurt your situation, let the bureaucrats make the call, I don't think anyone will take it against you.

Best of luck.

JsonDemWitOster··on Please don't spam people looking for employment. It's just cruel
I've yet to experience OP's anecdote but I've had analogous experiences with employers. I don't do the HN threads so this is all from my Github with considerable side project activity albeit nothing serious; I don't even have the stars to show for it. Their template is

"Dear <name derived from GH profile>,

I've seen your recent activity on <project which does indeed have a lot of recent activity> and it has caught my interest. I am a bigwig at a company specializing on developer-experience for the Go toolchain..."

It's all downhill from there. At that point, I would either realize that, hey, the project you mentioned doesn't use Go. Heck I don't use Go. Or, if the second sentence was still relevant, the next few sentences is nothing but either a thinly-veiled attempt to make me use their product or answer a survey. I really wouldn't have been opposed to this if only it was actually relevant to me; unfortunately I don't think you can come up with a boolean search query that better qualifies your leads.

Ten-ish years ago when I got cold emails because of my GH activity, it was at least a lot more relevant to me.

As OP said, it's not really a big deal but it compounds. My worse was three such spam in a week and it made me contemplate taking the project private.

JsonDemWitOster··on Please don't spam people looking for employment. It's just cruel
Based on Ilia's post on the "Who's wants to be hired?" thread, he's currently based in Portugal.
JsonDemWitOster··on To have a moral stance on AI is to be an outcast, and it sucks
Wow. Palantirians (or whatever tf they call themselves) have no reply other than downvotes? Couldn't even get ChatGPT to astroturf an advocacy?
JsonDemWitOster··on SF startup is testing robots in Airbnbs, and trashing them, lawsuit claims
Move fast and break things is an ethos borne out of the assumption that fixing things is relatively cheap. Hence it made sense in software where experimentation is dirt cheap. But even then, the idea is quite a stretch: ask anyone who worked in a startup who had to sell to even just SMEs, not to mention big conglomerates. The idea hits a hard wall and starts to crack when the business hits a customer who can't fix things for cheap. Even Zuck, father and posterboy of the idea, had to eventually pivot messaging to "Move fast with stable infra".

And the more "software eats the world", the less this paradigm is gonna be a feasible market strategy. I've harbored these thoughts from way back and hence I was (and continue to be) skeptical of unregulated start-ups/new tech ideas who interface with the real world: Hyperloop, Tesla self-driving, and Theranos come to mind. An interesting case study in my view is _Github_ who in theory, having software engineers for customers, should be pretty well-insulated from the expensive repair costs of the real world. And yet we'd all agree they need a GINORMOUS dose of that sweet sweet "stable infra".

JsonDemWitOster··on I am not a black belt
You are not the first person to make that connection: https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.00485
JsonDemWitOster··on GitHub Actions down again today
About an hour ago I was having trouble browsing repo files in the browser and I thought "A disturbance in the force, is Github down?" Refreshed HN and loaded up their status site. Nada.

(Ofc, in a sensible universe, we just brush that off to a JS/Firefox glitch or my ISP.)

And yet, here I am. My code is not compiling, my AI isn't vibing, nonetheless I can't work! Two more hours before I can get off!

JsonDemWitOster··on Incident with Actions and Pages
Sorry guys it might be me.

I vibe coded a script that interacts with both Gitlab and Github via their APIs and I've been using it pretty heavily since this morning. I crossed the streams! Goodness, I didn't know it would be _this_ bad!

← PreviousPage 3 of 3