HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Jtsummers

29,848 karma · joined October 6, 2009

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jtsummers; my proof: https://keybase.io/jtsummers/sigs/2v_NBwmgy9lrspxf8k7DN4UwIi-73h22Wxr_7kF01RM ]
submissionscomments
Jtsummers··on Why We're Banning AI
> Obviously the WSJ staff shouldn't be using it in the final output

It was an op-ed, it's inappropriate to edit those heavily. So they either had to accept it more or less as submitted (with the usual basic editing around grammar, clarity, and typos), or not accept it. If they'd rewritten it, it would not have been an op-ed by Druckenmiller anymore, but someone else's interpretation of his submission.

Jtsummers··on C++26 Contracts: Introduction to Preconditions and Postconditions
> You can't use them for safety checks, because you must assume they won't be run.

This is also true of assert, though. It can be compiled out so shouldn't be used for anything that must run.

Jtsummers··on Ask HN: Apple HomeView. What problem is Apple Home solving?
> They are solving a problem that was already solved.

Exactly, that's why they never made music players or cellphones...

A solved problem doesn't mean it's solved within their ecosystem and making them money. You can go out and buy a Google or Amazon device to do many (or even all) of the same functions, but that's not making Apple money, and they rarely integrate well with Apple's other devices and accounts. This isn't confusing.

Jtsummers··on Ask HN: Apple HomeView. What problem is Apple Home solving?
Why does Apple sell desktops when they can sell laptops instead? Why does Apple sell their Apple TV when people can use a video cable from their laptops? Because there's a market for the device, as demonstrated by Amazon and Google and others over the past decade+, and this is the same thing but within the Apple ecosystem.
Jtsummers··on The United Kingdom generates less electricity per person than in the 1970s
> I was formed to work in an office, to go have a career and make money, and absolutely useless at any domestic task, such as cooking, cleaning, personal finance.

Your parents never taught you how to balance a checkbook? That's just basic arithmetic, are you sure you were "formed to work in an office" when you can't even manage your own finances? Sounds like you weren't formed for anything, not even basic self-care.

Jtsummers··on The United Kingdom generates less electricity per person than in the 1970s
Every washer, even basic ones, I've owned that were made post-2000 had a delay start function. Even my most basic one that just had dials to select options, it had a 2/4/6/8-hour delay dial. I figured it was a common feature by now.
Jtsummers··on The United Kingdom generates less electricity per person than in the 1970s
> There don't seem to be any comments on this thread referring to rationing.

Trivially falsifiable statement, just read the comments in this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50076266

>> But their great idea to deal with the shortage is intermittent availability of power.

In other words: rationing.

Jtsummers··on Cyberattack halts construction of tunnel between Denmark and Germany
As long as they can avoid loss of life (or significant loss of life) and direct attribution, but the rumors are still that it's Russia, this is a way to reduce popular support for Ukraine. The attacks aren't severe enough to make people want to support Ukraine to spite Russia, and it makes it apparent that there is a cost for the current support.
Jtsummers··on Push ifs up and fors down: The idiom, its algebra, and its limits
https://godbolt.org/z/rz8MxhdGd

Just a simple example, but the conditional branch occurs on line 14 of the generated assembly. It does a comparison (line 13) and then a conditional jump (jl, line 14).

Jtsummers··on The Early History of Smalltalk (1993)
Some prior discussions on this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31062369 - April 20, 2022 (45 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25012425 - Nov 7, 2020 (28 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17913668 - Sept 4, 2018 (69 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9907556 - July 18, 2015 (5 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9588316 - May 22, 2015 (5 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7926141 - June 21, 2014 (10 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1311282 - May 1, 2010 (17 comments)

Jtsummers··on AI is now capable of developing its own inference hardware
If it's an ASI and so beyond humans, why would it even care to do what humans ask it and not do its own thing? If I held your beliefs, the fact of its existence dooms us, not the risk that someone might ask it to do something. It wouldn't care about the requester.
Jtsummers··on OpenTPU – An open-source AI accelerator, developed by AI
Is your belief then that ASI is going to be producing computronium or something, then? And what's the need for this apparent hyper optimization task the ASI is going to embark on?
Jtsummers··on AI is now capable of developing its own inference hardware
What's your basis for assuming that ASI would need the same resources as biological life, or that it would be incapable of sharing the resources needed in common?
Jtsummers··on The Early History of Smalltalk (1993)
> it was the older brother of Logo

Logo predated Smalltalk, so Smalltalk is more like an evolution on the idea and a younger brother.

EDIT: Looked up the dates. Logo was made in 1967, Smalltalk started development in 1969.

Jtsummers··on AI is now capable of developing its own inference hardware
> unbounded goals consuming unbounded resources

What resources are unbounded? There are limits to growth in the real world, how are these ASIs going to escape physical reality?

Jtsummers··on OpenTPU – An open-source AI accelerator, developed by AI
> I don't care if ASI progress stalls after it's already killed all biological life

What's your basis for thinking ASI will kill all biological life, and how do you think it's going to happen?

Jtsummers··on Why Common Lisp is now the best programming language
CL already has strong types, it's static typing that it lacks. Though some compilers do make use of the information present to varying degrees, they'll emit warnings typically, not errors, for things like

  (+ 1 "hello") ;; SBCL should emit a warning, but will let this run and you'll get a runtime type error
If it was not strongly typed then you'd be able to do the silly things you can do in JS and Perl like:

  (+ 1 "1") => "2" ;; hypothetical, doesn't happen in CL
Jtsummers··on Why Common Lisp is now the best programming language
In fairness to the LLMs, many professionals do the same. And since it's trained on the source code of amateurs and professionals, it's not surprising when garbage in becomes garbage out.
Jtsummers··on Why Common Lisp is now the best programming language
Why wouldn't you have code backing the image? Sane people do. The main exception is when you are working on code you know is meant to be thrown away (testing out a library for instance, but not building your actual application).
Jtsummers··on Why Common Lisp is now the best programming language
In CL, this works with compiled code.
Jtsummers··on US closely monitoring case of lab worker who possibly died of plague in Siberia
She put it in her book on Area 51, apparently, and had one source for the claim, no other evidence.
Jtsummers··on US closely monitoring case of lab worker who possibly died of plague in Siberia
> Jacobsen is also the author who claimed that the Roswell event was a Soviet plot to sow panic with an actual Nazi flying saucer piloted by genetically-engineered midgets

And people take her seriously?

Jtsummers··on US closely monitoring case of lab worker who possibly died of plague in Siberia
And like I said in my comments, if this was a serious attempt by the CIA to disrupt midterms, they started too late. And COVID was a worse pandemic than this non-pandemic (presently) and we still held our national elections. It's an extremely absurd theory.
Jtsummers··on US closely monitoring case of lab worker who possibly died of plague in Siberia
I did read it. It was an idiotic hypothetical. Your hypothetical is hinged on something not based in reality.

2020 with COVID was far worse than something that's still literally thousands of miles from the US and we still held elections in the US. Midterm elections have already started, so even if this was some bizarre CIA plot, it'd be the least effective way to achieve their goals. They failed before they began because, again, the elections are already happening.

Jtsummers··on Senator Cotton is Blocking the Change to Permanent DST
https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/interactive/2024/no-da...

Gift link: https://wapo.st/4yAZVXM

A useful map that lets you hover over each county to see the effect of the three policies (current, permanent DST, no DST).

Jtsummers··on US closely monitoring case of lab worker who possibly died of plague in Siberia
This disease is generally highly treatable. Your conspiracy theory hinges on a belief that a treatable disease in a foreign country will be used to do something with the ongoing (ballots are already going out) US midterm elections, when in 2020 the US still held regular elections despite the ongoing, and far less treatable at the time, COVID pandemic.

Your hypothetical is not based in reality.

Jtsummers··on RacketCon Is Saturday
A closure, specifically, because closures are a poor man's object.

https://wiki.c2.com/?ClosuresAndObjectsAreEquivalent

Jtsummers··on RacketCon Is Saturday
It's a common way to implement OO in Lisp-y languages, and it fits if you're taking Smalltalk as an inspiration. SICP has an example in chapter 3 (IIRC) of doing the same, but the selector had to be quoted as in:

  (my-account 'balance)
  (my-account 'withdraw 10)
Jtsummers··on RacketCon Is Saturday
> What to do?

Flag the twits that bring it up in every thread. They're trolling at this point, not actually trying to have a conversation.

Jtsummers··on The top secret URSALA, RAQUEL, and FARRAH satellites (2025)
It was accidentally revealed in 1973 (though known since 1971, just not acknowledged), and officially declassified in 1992. It's been around for 66 years now, so more than half its existence was declassified, and realistically it's been known for 55 of its 66 years.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →