HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

JustLurking2022

663 karma · joined March 13, 2022

submissionscomments
JustLurking2022··on Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
Yes, and if you ask an AI to reimplement functionally for which it has previously seen an exact implementation, it will likely spit out something that looks heavily influenced, if not identical, to the original. That's the thing about ML - it's still just trying to make the result match the query and doesn't really "care" about the originality of the response.
JustLurking2022··on Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
Other humans could but, if they did so in violation of the terms of the license, I could sue them. Microsoft acknowledged that copilot ignores the license altogether.
JustLurking2022··on Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
True to some extent although I can see some reasonable arguments as to why. For one, I don't expect AI art to ever replace humans for higher end creative expression - quite simply, part of the value of art is the time put in by a skilled craftsman, like the way a hand made Rolex is worth more watches that are more accurate but mad produced. Similar to Pixar and animation, I believe AI may change the style of art but not the fundamental demand for it.

Coding is far more utilitarian - so if an AI is taking others' original ideas and effectively passing them off as it's own, companies become less likely to feel they need to employ the originator.

JustLurking2022··on Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
It'll be interesting to see the legal battles around this considering, for humans, a clean room approach is often used to reimplementing an API, as it becomes an easy case for infringement (even if accidental) if you've seen the original implementation. If you ask ChatGPT to reimplement an API from a project it's indexed, seems it will likely infringe to some extent every time
JustLurking2022··on Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
No, it's not learning like a human, it's fitting parameters to a function. AI will never conduct a science experiment to determine the veracity of the data it's indexing, or have an emotional reaction to it.
JustLurking2022··on How transportation technologies shaped empires
No, it suggests that there was an optimal path around the world in 80 days. The geography of many regions would have made them more remote than the optimal path.
JustLurking2022··on Investigation on the effect of oral breathing on cognitive activity (2021)
You probably should dismiss the results if they publish the study of 22 people rather than doing that larger follow-up.
JustLurking2022··on WeWork’s once robust cash reserves have dwindled, raising chances of default
No one cares. Autocorrect does its thing, sometimes for good, sometimes not.
JustLurking2022··on Jugaad takes agile to the extreme (2020)
I never said anything about the type of apps, and the issues had little or nothing to do with dependency obsolescence.
JustLurking2022··on A Sign That Tuition Is Too High: Some Colleges Are Slashing It in Half
s/Cakes/values/
JustLurking2022··on A Sign That Tuition Is Too High: Some Colleges Are Slashing It in Half
Oh, I know people who share your views, including a few relatives. I'm just not into cults.

Either you've taught your kids cakes that will stand up in the face of scrutiny and alternative belief systems, or you're peddling junk and hoping that with enough brainwashing and avoiding reality, they won't figure it out.

JustLurking2022··on ChatGPT is a ‘code red’ for Google’s search business
Unlikely. Walled gardens already use their own search so what does Google care if they change the technology behind it. They've also made the conscious decision to be walled gardens so I don't see a federation play. Also, distributed search = incredibly slow search. Having to reach out to dozens or hundreds of backends for each query creates all kinds of problems (latency, reliability).

So that leaves us back at each walled garden needing to index web content in order to offer it alongside their own results. Large scale indexing is something Google definitely has a significant lead in, which would take many years to overcome.

JustLurking2022··on Southwest cancels 5,400 flights in less than 48 hours
Seems they only linger for Southwest, as they made up 90% of all flight cancellations today.
JustLurking2022··on Southwest cancels 5,400 flights in less than 48 hours
Cloud doesn't solve badly designed processes or poorly written software, which seem to be at play with Southwest. Yes, it can help provide more stable infrastructure and there are some (but by no means all) black swan events that can be mitigated simply by throwing more kit at the problem during a surge but it's no silver bullet.
JustLurking2022··on How tech’s defiance of economic gravity came to an abrupt end
Even in PACE, I don't think it means commoditization. That said, over time I've found anyone really technical pays absolutely zero attention to Gartner. With no judgement implied, they generally seem to target non-technical people who just want some jargon and product names that will help them sound like they know what they're talking about. They also get paid by the companies they are evaluating which means they'll almost never tell you about smaller players/startups who don't have the budget. HN or Reddit are probably both better for getting a read on who's actually doing innovative stuff.
JustLurking2022··on How tech’s defiance of economic gravity came to an abrupt end
There are also many companies making "unique" chips that are sold as COTS - it's a false dichotomy. Aside from a few initiatives like RISC-V, I'd venture to say most are proprietary.
JustLurking2022··on Ask HN: Google useless for shopping / product reviews?
It's a Catch-22 - Any service trusted by consumers will inevitably be targeted by malicious actors. The ones cited as potentially "better" are generally too small to matter, hence they have not yet been targeted in a significant way.
JustLurking2022··on How tech’s defiance of economic gravity came to an abrupt end
Is this a ChatGPT experiment? The comment uses a few seemingly relevant terms but almost entirely incorrectly. "System of Record" had nothing to do with being commoditized.
JustLurking2022··on ChatGPT is a ‘code red’ for Google’s search business
Well, the PageRank paper laid out the fundamentals of Google's algorithm in 1999 and products like Solr or ElasticSearch have offered pretty solid full text indexing/search for over a decade. Microsoft has been working on Bing since at least 2009, so I would say it could still take competitors quite a while to put together a compelling offering.
JustLurking2022··on How the McMurtry Electric Fan Car Clocked a 7.9-Second Quarter-Mile
Anthony that causes the car to behave in a way the driver isn't expecting (collision avoidance) would probably lead to less safety rather than more. Besides, even Tesla autopilot can be fooled and certainly isn't designed for cars driving inches apart.

The air bags have been covered in other comments but similarly would probably reduce safety, not increase it. The cars are very much designed for safety, and to absorb impacts, which is why they are so much heavier than previous generations.

JustLurking2022··on A Sign That Tuition Is Too High: Some Colleges Are Slashing It in Half
What century is this? Most people would probably think it a bit ridiculous to spend $40-50k a year trying to prevent kids from being "of the world" or "ending up silly". Even as someone who went to a private university, these are not good reasons to do so.

I'd also be interested in any evidence in the supposed downturn among elite universities - last I saw they are still quite effective at putting graduates into the highest echelons of government and industry. Even the supposedly more iconoclast industries like tech are largely inhabited by graduates of top schools.

JustLurking2022··on Jugaad takes agile to the extreme (2020)
Having worked in companies with a variety of skill levels, I find the higher skill you go, the less hacked together things get. While I honestly don't think Agile has to stand in opposition to good design principles, most treat it as though it does in practice. Whereas in less Agile orgs, I've worked with 20 year old systems that are still maintainable and fulfill their purpose well, in Agile orgs it feels like every system more than a couple years old has become spaghetti.

I can't 100% vouch for causality - as I said, the skill differences between the average developer in some of these orgs are immense, but it says something to me that all the more talented companies I've worked in tended not to go down the "fast and hacky is fine if you iterate" path.

JustLurking2022··on WeWork’s once robust cash reserves have dwindled, raising chances of default
Interest rates can change everything. This is a logical extreme but think of it this way - when you can get a 0% loan, does anything have a cost? Sure, there's a price tag but if you can finance it without any interest, you're only paying principle. Now, if you can continue finding more 0% financing to cover those principle payments, any profit the business makes at all is a good return since you put nothing into it.

While we weren't quite to that situation, the last decade of near zero interest rates put VCs precariously close to it.

JustLurking2022··on “Eeny, meeny, miny, mo” and the ambiguous history of counting-out rhymes (2015)
Not really, unlike the other examples the words differ by more than just the vowel sound.
JustLurking2022··on Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move
Counterpoint - Google employees get a large portion of their compensation in stock, particularly in upper management, and consequently have incentive enough to keep the share price high on their own.
JustLurking2022··on A Forth Apologia (1988)
It's been around for decades and has virtually zero traction, which is to say, Stop trying to make Forth happen.
JustLurking2022··on Habits of Highly Overrated People (2013)
I might believe that to some extent except that not all development jobs lend themselves equally to cranking out commits. Sure, if you're working on a well defined feature with all dependencies already built, you can really crank stuff out. However, those also tend to be the easiest jobs filled by junior developers. Solving the less well understood/defined problems often generated fewer commits per day but often generates more value.
JustLurking2022··on FTX Collapse takes toll on the Bahamas
Did they elect that government?
JustLurking2022··on Kite is saying farewell and open-sourcing its code
That code is wretched... Why have serializer logic embedded in a data object, especially when .NET provides generic discrete serializers?
JustLurking2022··on FTX collapse, Tether operations have links to online-poker cheating scandals
Tether has similarly been caught in the past using the funds behind their supposedly "fully backed" tokens for highly speculative investment. So far it's just such a big scam that no one has been able to create a large enough run to topple it... so far.
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →