HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

K0SM0S

1,642 karma · joined September 9, 2016

submissionscomments
K0SM0S··on Embodiment is indispensable for AGI
Exactly.

The baseline assumption in modern neurology is that meaning, for living things, is derived from their physical experience of the world. In short that no paper definition can ever substitute for experiencing first-hand what the "effect" of something is, what it does to you or to the world and what that entails for your body, your life. That is what "knowing" and "meaning" ultimately are.

These experiences are the basis for associations in our constant cognitive (and emotional, instinctive, sensory, symbolic, etc) modelling of the world. Associations beget complexity (dimensionality, modalities) of the model. Hence, "finely tuned" or "high definition" i.e. ever more "advanced" intelligences.

Given the overall crudeness and extreme simplicity of a CPU (or any man-made machine) compared to any living organism, I'm actually willing to bet that should CPU-based AI's "feel" something, it's on the order of 1/100th of what a shrimp feels, and they'd develop real-world intelligence at that level. Infinitely smarter than a potato, yet infinitely dumber than a fish. You don't run ape software on amoeba hardware.

K0SM0S··on Embodiment is indispensable for AGI
There's no asking, let alone answering this question beyond mere speculations, until we've defined "subjective experience" in objective terms — i.e. positively provable, measurable in some unambiguous way (not merely inferred). That is the hard problem. Solving it might require reframing the problem such that this dichotomy isn't even relevant anymore (like say electromagnetic information isn't "opposed" or "dual" or "exclusive" to a gravitational field but merely concurrent) if we are to unify somehow the general field of "theory of mind".
K0SM0S··on The saga of Apple’s troubled mixed reality headset
We're hordes waiting for a usable product, but that iconic/pop moment isn't about to come, the tech just isn't there yet.

Think late 2020s at best, and probably well into the 30s for the kind of refined VR we all know possible. It's like we had nice and functional pocket computers since the 1990s (PDAs etc), but it would take a solid decade for the iPhone to be made under the vision of a statistically rare product genius (means we can wait ±5~10 yrs for things to emerge as commercially successful tech). Or how video games took about 20 years to move from whatever came before the current "modern" era/paradigm (say late 1990s) that lives on to this day in terms of UI/UX. Same with the "desktop" metaphor for PCs, etc.

We have yet to nail the hardware for VR, let alone the OS code (core libs etc) whose precision and intuitiveness will feel tremendously "corporeal" in the case of VR, visceral, much more than any TV/monitor + vibrating thing could ever do (let alone keyboard/mouse). If you've ever did the timing for an action-paced fast video game, you know the kind of intricate subtleties I'm talking about, where one frame can make or break some experiences.

Then will come the time to nail killer metaphors, high-level GUI/GUX, killer apps.

We're not quite there yet.

K0SM0S··on The saga of Apple’s troubled mixed reality headset
Literally "proof of stake" as measured by headcount.

Is it a bad relapse of LOC metrics? ツ

K0SM0S··on The saga of Apple’s troubled mixed reality headset
Allow me to summarize this perspective as the future of "cognitive ergonomics" of sorts and second entirely the idea that it's the biggest promise of VR from an experience standpoint. Literally immersion in a wider context, not deliberate focus that by very definition a narrow viewport already covers quite well. Conversely to physical displays, contextual ergonomics is where VR must shine.

The way you expressed it actually reminds me of Iain McGilchrist's "left brain" versus "right brain" thinking model, wherein the narrow-ish "task-focused" approach is typical left-brain concern (essentialist, to a fault), whereas the wider "contextual" approach is typical right-brain associative concerns ("everything is complex/connected"). I'd never noticed this ergonomics question (should I say dichotomy) could be neurologically framed that way, thanks for the insight.

K0SM0S··on A Linux Command Got My Twitter Account Locked for Abuse and Violation
The short answer is because his proposed "solution" isn't solving the fundamental issue of fairness in public communication, nor does it guarantee any meaningful improvement thereof. Case in point: Elon is perfect, makes Twitter the best, then dies the next day and we're back to square one because the will of one man is not an institution (explicitly defined in this context as "surviving those who man it").

The long, IMHO, is that eventually the only solution is a truly decentralized system, much like DNS, that no actor alone can enable nor stop as long as other actors refuse to "fork" the namespace for a more restricted one.

That's what "freeing the code" ultimately means, and that comes down to a protocol at a basic level. Anyone (company, individual…) being free to implement whatever interface they want to it.

Then we'd likely move to observing and participating in this unimpeded common "mother / raw / source" stream of messages, through what I imagine would look like more-or-less-biased portals of sorts, culturally flavored aggregators, but ultimately unable to lie about true raw numbers.

Until we all agree about reality, there's no discussing it. That's why we need dumb pipes, neutral transport, much like the air is dumb in transmitting sight and sound. That's why we make protocols (as in RFC's), and every single internet-facing machine holds its little piece of HTTP land, of IRC land, tomorrow of <some Twitter-like land> (I know, it's Mastodon, but it's also not in reality as we speak. Ask your sales people about adoption rates and network effects).

Thus follows, IMHO, the answer to your question: Elon claims a lot of things but none guarantee such a free and fair space for communication that de facto puts him out of the loop as a necessary gatekeeper (notice how Mr. Musk's moral fairness or even good intents, as a "benevolent dictator" is Montesquieu's words IIRC, is actually irrelevant to the core question). Elon does not suggest that he would "protocolize" Twitter's operations such that the company would act as a central but ultimately _optional_ hub for the sake of a mission —and literally operation— bigger than itself: free and fair human communication (by which point who cares about their code since everyone else can check the raw data stream in countless replicas and redundant streams over the web). Twitter (Inc.) as the steward and creator of this protocol would actually become valuable over the very long term (think: E/P ratio, employer prestige, etc) because hosting a fair and free human communication is one hell of an important job that few institutions —ever in history, private or public— would ethically be able to manage. But it's now become military-grade or hospital-grade important to a free society. As I was saying in another thread, it's about time we manage some deontological framework for the field of information technology and its practice at large.

[PS: Not that I hold my breath for one second that Twitter as we know it is in any way willing let alone able to undertake such an ethical mission, nor do I dream for one minute that Elon would buy Twitter instead of going from scratch, were the above goals his. The true disruption will likely be menial at first and come from left of field.]

K0SM0S··on Building a Budget Homelab NAS Server
Side note, since it's probably a niche use-case, but using NVMe's in Z1 was both pretty effective with VMs and cheap enough on usable capacity (4×1TB for ~3TB usable).

I feel SSDs are in a totally different category that makes Z1 an actual option, whereas I don't trust it for spinners. Key difference being that a failed SSD can usually be read (only) whereas a failed spinner is usually as good as bricked.

K0SM0S··on Study claims Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft work to derail data rules
> User concerns are mostly ignored.

Indeed and I don't see how that changes _structurally_ when people "in the know" are always going to be a tiny minority — they say that about 3% of the population has the profile to work in tech, and I tend to agree anecdotally.

I feel it's comparable to the inception of medicine for instance, and the solution was auto-regulation of the field by itself through the application of a loud (public and transparent) set of deontological rules of practice ("Primum non nocere", etc).

Awareness of society about these issues re. privacy and information sanctity in a democracy will not come naturally, structurally as time goes by. Just like they don't really know how doctors make life-or-death decisions on the spot. Nevertheless, the right principles should eventually exist, be known, and abode to, by those who work in the field. It should be loud and clear that we all have ethics (rules, implementing guiding principles), and which exactly.

A deontology of information technology and its practice in relation to human beings is one big "TODO" of this century, and it should concern anyone even remotely skilled to understand the problem.

K0SM0S··on Ask HN: How to learn math from zero for adults?
Side-related note: You'll get there (actual DL), because your "want" is close enough to determination (as opposed to mere motivation, i.e. conscious decision versus mere fleeting feelings).

On academia and grades: yes, it's a "dark time" (as in "Dark Ages" for what we mean by it, regardless of the veracity of that historical perception). I often summarize all those collective F-ups by remarking that most people, either individually or collectively as institutions, have lost their purpose, they "have no mission in life" so to speak. Thus, we lose sight of the endgame, of the actual purpose of education for instance.

That's not about to change if the now widespread intuition that most institutions have been rotting too much for too long is true, so the solution might be some historical disruption of the domain — I think Khan was an early ripple in those foundations.

K0SM0S··on Ask HN: If Apple buys EA, how would this affect indie game developers?
I can't tell you about the specifics in this case, but if you want the general framework to understand economic concentration and the relationship between major groups and the independent scene in media / entertainment, read The Master Switch by Tim Yu.

Video games so far fit perfectly the evolution that radio, movies, TV — a couple cycle thereof — especially as they became commoditized (most notably in mobile form) alongside other forms of digital entertainment (music, video streaming, etc).

K0SM0S··on Libaws: A simpler way to declare AWS infrastructure
The worst offense is perhaps that we've evolved quite intuitive languages that would impeccably serve most con/prosumer needs as far as "mostly static but smartly architected" configurations are concerned.

Python, Go, even Scratch (for a 100% GUX)… And among the many pros, error handling is enough to warrant the change from markup.

But IMHO here's the one barrier: people need to stop thinking of an Information System (IS) as a collection of machines, and move one level of abstraction above to consider said IS as the unit, and machines as subs of sort (subsystems, components, modules, call it what you want). Conceptually, your "main" space is the IS, everything else is modules down the namespace hierarchy. We need to think of machines as we used to think of programs, and think of IS's as we used to think of machines. In the UNIX philosophy, any application is a collection of programs, just as an IS-as-code is a collection of machines-as-software-modules (basically feature libraries for "main" to use).

When that paradigm comes, you'll be able to simply "import" some subsystem (say Elastic Search, whatever machines in the IS) and add that (as a class, method, whatever) to all your existing objects, because the concept of "interfaces" (quite literally the basis of interoperability, dating back forever in computing) will be _native_ to your IS model in a Turing-complete paradigm.

Not sure my wording made sense to non-programmers (cue: "quotes" are technical terms, not general meaning), but I'm too lazy to write a layman expose.

K0SM0S··on Windows 11, Amazon, and Uncomfortable Questions
Frankly this, as a developer. I call them "showstoppers" and if there is a god of programming, they are the ultimate sin. Things like

- breaking a user's multiboot

- deleting user data

Even if these are not bugs and merely the result of bad UX (lack of warnings and security for the user).

Deletion of all user data upon upgrade was a common 'problem' with earlier versions of Windows (I remember having such problems into the XP era, and I hear it happened to people on W10). Breaking other installs by MS is a common theme too in dual boot setups (whereas Linux bootloaders are more likely to pick up the Win install and offer access to it).

I remember vividly the last time it happened to me. I had been dual-booting Linux for some time (on a personal laptop dedicated to work). It was my first Linux OS, I was a newbie (precisely learning bash, programming for servers, etc). After some update, Win10 broke my dual boot. I was livid. It took me the better part of a weekend to fix it and avoid loosing all my work of several months (a lot of it was in the form of system files all over the place, I had no idea how to retrieve all that without ad hoc commands etc, and I had no idea what e.g. chroot was at the time. I learned, the hard way, haha — btw thx to the Arch Wiki for that weekend. It was a life saver).

The very next thing when I got access back to my Linux OS was to backup all my data, format everything and reinstall Linux fresh.

And that was it.

I've never used Windows ever since as my primary driver, only for testing purposes in VMs. That was 2016 iirc.

There are such things as showstoppers that make you instantly drop a product, never to look back. Microsoft's Windows desktop team never learned that, I don't know how they still pretend to be for "professionals". You don't do that to people who make a living with their computer (i.e. the vast majority of businesses nowadays).

K0SM0S··on Jack Dorsey is attempting to sell his first tweet as an NFT
Thing is, "value is in the eye of the beholder". It might be material in a strictly biological setting, or idealistic (subjective) in a post-scarcity environment. We're somewhere in-between with the digital world, the value of the superfluous (e.g. collectibles) is able to rise as material needs are more easily covered (using an ever-smaller fraction of resources).

To put it simply to the point of absurdity, if we were a "magical" (in Arthur C. Clarke's word) civilization without any outstanding needs, we could still play some for-profit economic game and spend quadrillions buying autographs, because it wouldn't lessen anything of importance. Conversely, if you're barely eating enough, you won't spend resources on anything else than getting more food, because that would lessen your chances of survival.

The degree of perceived insanity, I think, thus entirely depends on who you are as a beholder of value, where you fit in the material ⇾ idealistic spectrum. Pretty sure Africans with $1/day feel this is perfectly stupid, but your average billionaire might find it a funny hobby, like collecting some cards of the digital era. There will be a market for that, I think crypto-manias proved as much.

It's all relative to an observer, IMHO.

K0SM0S··on Facebook announces policy changes ahead of 2020 elections
World Wide Web (www or W³): (between 1992 and 2042) Technological economic subsystem designed to monetize the intelligence of a few to produce ignorance in many more others. Internet is a fertile space for baseless or futile controversies (see "nihilistic relativism"), bad faith arguments (see "trolls") and personal attacks (see "DOTA 2"); it's been shown to warm up populations to authoritarianism and speech control (see "Xiism"), and to generate the cannibalistic stock-splosions of the early 21st century. It was eventually replaced in 2042 by radioweb, a quantum mesh network which ultimately spanned forty-eight thousand stars centered on the Sun by the year 4000. The only remnant of the World Wide Web in use today is Javascript. Replicas of the W³ circa 2020 are commonly used in airgap VR settings, to train soldiers to resist torture, or as horror depiction in movies. Psycho-history estimates that the human race would have gone extinct by 2145 at the latest if the W³ "experiment" hadn't been shut down prematurely by the Pixies.
K0SM0S··on California sets Covid-19 daily record, Bay Area cumulative total passes 20k
There is a popular expression in French that explicits a worthy distinction: “Politique politicienne”.

It literally means politician politics, or politicians' politics (a politician is a political figure, like an elected official), and it very derogatorily qualifies all the noise, the blablabla, the unimportant chatter in politics — Wherein politics speaks of egos, not ideas; the part that seldom leads to actual or worthwhile "policy".

When a leader is said to be making “de la politique politicienne”, it basically means that's degree zero of intelligent discourse, and solely aimed at tackling political opponents. Cue false claims, supporting opinions you provably don't believe yourself (but party line prevails), etc.

It's an old expression, before my time (1980s). It's fallen out of flavor. Probably because 99% of politics has now become de la politique politicienne...

K0SM0S··on Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?
> Science, these days, seems to have become a faith based system

> That (and bad science, like this study) is a shame.

Tangential, but this has indeed been a slow drift since the 1970s roughly. We are witnessing the consequences of that, now that entire generations of academics have been molded as such.

I think we need a vocal and principled reaffirmation of Positivism in science, to meaningfully move away from all the faith-based and broadly political conduct of scientific affairs at large (and the reporting thereof).

K0SM0S··on Twitter, Reddit support challenge of visa applicant social media requirement
Just to poke your brain, or anyone's, suppose we shared concerns and views on all topics. Now let's consider a spectrum of "how well are are individual rights upheld in practice?", with all the nuances.

What's your short list of particularly good/best places in SE Asia/Oceania (that you'd be comfortable travelling to, but even work with, invest in? (Coming from the north Atlantic)

I'm down to:

- Australia + NZ

- Taiwan (sadly HK seems 'compromised')

- Singapore

Pretty much in that order. That's the shortest this list has even been in my lifetime. What am I not seeing?

K0SM0S··on Facebook executives shut down efforts to make the site less divisive
Honestly a truly well-made ad targeting on me, something that really ticked all the right boxes... gosh I'd spend 3-4× more, easily. Because ordinarily I just don't lose time on shopping websites, but I'm kinda of a spender when I do find things that I like. And I'm a sucker for good deals, I'm a patient prey hunter, I can wait months in ambush for the right deal.

Anecdotally of course, as one of those tech-folks who's got nothing against good and relevant ads.

K0SM0S··on Breathing habits are related to physical and mental health
Indeed and yet, paradoxically, living longer is quite literally what's killing you¹...

1: Cells have two ultimate fates: they either fail to resist cancer or, if they succeed, eventually die of doing it, sort of wear-and-tear, i.e. "ageing" as we call it. Lookup telomeres and cancer. Therein lies the recent hype/hope of increasing human life expectancy by a lot, perhaps orders of magnitude.

K0SM0S··on What Is Nix?
It's a true wonder but much like the AUR (read: Archlinux User Repo), it's great 80% of the time when projects have reasonable popularity or committed (even 'niche') support.

It's honestly a treat for personal use if you have the mind of a tinkerer, but it's a difficult proposition to sustain in business (you basically end up vendoring yourself if big enough).

Nix has a very different proposition that solves from the "inside" a problem that is currently usually solved from the "outside" using e.g. Ansible in ops/infra, or Vagrant in dev.

In my perspective, the outside/black-box solution is ultimately brute-force, plain and simple. It works because it scales well, because copying data is cheap enough (re. deduplication, delta sync, etc) You hit limits when systems grow older and complexity creeps in no matter what however, it's an approach that requires a blank slate every now and then.

But the inside package approach is elegant in that it's absolute, it's not conjuring a black box that "should just work" if Ubuntu18.04-387lts-32-1.989-2a and my_fav_package.1.1.1.9.3.5-f work fine together, this time around. Sure, there is testing but we're back to the popularity/support limit.

In the end, in a world where some of the stack is basically nailed and can be modularized with clear forever-true expectations of I/O (the content, not the hardware), then Nix eventually prevails— but we really have to evolve "LTS" for what it means (like we'd do in construction, electricity, plumbing...), and not a half-trendy windmill / rat race. But we have to think of those systems that could transfer almost-as-is well from now to 2050 or more, not 2025-2030. It's not impossible, it's what COBOL did, does as we speak.

I think something like Nix could help shift perception in the right direction, but I expect mindsets to take a good part of the decade to change deeply, if it happens.

K0SM0S··on Linux touchpad: preliminary project funding, survey results
That's a lot to take in, let me get back to you a bit later.

Extremely interesting, I must say at first glance. You're definitely technically stronger than me in most of these topics, I'll have to work on it a bit to clarify some of these concepts.

Thanks for an insightful and candid thinking out loud. Much appreciated. I wish other people would chime in as well to further the discussion, I'm afraid I won't be able to elaborate much technically but rather speak high-level UX concepts. What's interesting is that your general approach seems to answer an essential problem (and opportunity!) in systems whose complexity far exceeds human cognition (that's what I get from the 'lens', not what's on Google about it but the object in your head you call as such; it is sometimes hard to explain such things in a word, rather takes a book chapter).

Thanks again, I'll revisit this WE.

K0SM0S··on Linux touchpad: preliminary project funding, survey results
OK, I'll bite that sandwich.

Can you expand some of these points? I fail to understand (I need an ELI5, first principles)

I think I get the premise, EMACs/Jupyter hybrid with ext. prog. lang. (+1 for typed).

> By keeping the specification of the components as abstract as possible, one could reinterpret the same code to give a completely different and customizable user experience.

Custom UX is my pet peeve, has been forever since the 1990s. I have intuitions but no clear understanding of what you mean here. Does that essentially mean decoupling model/view, a more modular or stateless metaphor?

> Probably with a lens based GUI toolkit for interactive widgets.

lens? (impossibly hard for me to Google what that generic word refers to, I just tried)

————

I'd like to 'get' to the essence of the paradigm you're suggesting. What the 'magic' is, its endgame, what it 'feels' or looks like.

K0SM0S··on Second-Guessing the Modern Web
Probably because "more people" are not trained to "use WebComponents as a light weight alternative to React/Vue/Angular", let alone lead a team in that direction (and assume responsibility for a thing that has no market value on their resume... it's the situation 80% of tech workers find themselves in).

Momentum is a b#%~~ I mean, momentum is hard to ignore.

The sad reality is that trendy will always be driving behaviors for as long as recruiters attach value to buzz-words and -names.

Meanwhile, I guess a few will take the risk to do good engineering and damn the name of techs used, hopefully to rise to decision-making positions. Hopefully. Oh who am I kidding.

K0SM0S··on Second-Guessing the Modern Web
It's my personal philosophy in many things, but I like to insist that it's far from being the end-all be-all of good engineering in general. Perhap so I don't fall prey to the usual weaknesses of a hacker.
K0SM0S··on Finding new physics will require a new particle collider
Finding new physics will require removing a lot of dust on the politics of that field, and a vast re-evaluation of why and how people get funded. How important the is science versus everything else in the matter.

It's not going to happen overnight, but it's good that people are opening their eyes. Let's reevaluate in 2040 and see if we've moved the needle in fundamental physics even just a little compared to what was achieved in the first half of the 20th century.

K0SM0S··on Ask HN: How to stop anxiety from too many choices?
Personally:

- see the first step, the very next step, and that's it. You don't need to know what step 2,748 is about let alone how to solve it to take the next door. (formally: no premature optimization). All you need is the end-goal (general direction) and the next step to move forward, at all times. This considerably narrows the magnitude of freedom/choice locally, which feels comforting.

- Anxiety is "nostalgia about the future". Let that sink in for a minute. It's a "FOMO" regarding a desirable state that you have not yet encountered. There's a word for a more positive take of a slightly different thing: "saudade". In this I find there's a middle ground of acceptance and longing that strikes the right balance to keep a positive mind about the future.

- Make a decision, and stick to it. In other words, be quick to decide but slow to change. The trick in life is not to "do what you love" (or make the decisions you think are right: spoiler, you'll be wrong 50% of the time). The trick is to "love what you do", to learn that mindset, which is how we give a real chance to the paths we take (not half-ass it, not work actively against your own success). If you learn to love all that you do, then suddenly the stakes are very different, and good/bad decisions are more complex, more shaded. That's good, like increasing resolution to better "see". It becomes easier to navigate, like your vessel has a better map.

- Every single decision you made in life, you did your best at the time with the information you had. Nobody tries to fail on purpose, nobody wants to make the wrong decision. Therefore, 1. there is no point in regret, only in learning lessons; 2. Hindsight is 20/20 but has no practical purpose except implemented as action in the present (to solve a real current problem).

Now this is how I "tame" my own mind, when thinking of those things. Stoicism was my entry point into such self-control, self-knowledge to begin with.

K0SM0S··on My blog is now generated by Google Docs
I'm more of a Markdown, maybe LaTeX guy myself, but 100% down with the author's approach.

The simplest "CI/CD", and closest to the material (plain text files), is usually the best in practice, especially for a one-man operation.

Iterate into complexity on a need-to-basis.

K0SM0S··on Intel's flagship 10th-gen desktop CPU has 10 cores, reaches 5.3GHz
My understanding is that Nvidia can't produce enough GPU to saturate their pro market, the demand is huge as we speak and only increasing for now (looking at you, ML).

So AMD (or rather, their RTG division specifically) would be remiss not to align their price/perf with Nvidia to maximize profit.

A reason why they'll probably stay 'cheaper' to some extent for some time (perhaps long) is that they don't compete against CUDA, Nvidia's silver bullet. And don't just think “muh fancy library”, think hordes of engineers that Nvidia has the financial muscle to deploy in the field, 'lending' them to customers who need ad hoc driver work, custom implementations, general help, and what-have-you.

CUDA is a war machine, because that's how Nvidia operates its strategy.

It's how they owned the video game market back then, and I'm pretty sure they do the same with CUDA / ML / compute (why wouldn't they).

I thought that OpenCL would eventually be to CUDA what Vulkan is becoming to DirectX (btw: thank you, Linux); but it seems to me that OpenCL is going the way of the dodo? (still very little support in all ML/compute software I encounter, anecdotally).

AMD can sell a ton of GPU at good price, and they should, but they're lagging behind because optimized software libraries support (CUDA, the whole commercial hammer it represents) is where it's at.

Fortunately or not for them, Intel's graphics efforts seem to be... hype, more than a truly organized effort (insiders leaks speak of a terrible, terrible political / manegerial / organization situation at Intel's). It's fortunate for AMD's graphics market share, but it's unfortunate in that Intel would be a major support for OpenCL (last I checked, at least) and Intel's rise on that market could have taken AMD's hardware along with it in a tsunami of competition for CUDA.

But that's not happening soon, apparently.

K0SM0S··on Tmux for Mere Mortals
Thank you, so much, for this. Flawed-ISO-keybros!

Different kinds of layouts for spanish language is asinine. But hey, this reminds me, Quebec and France also have different layouts. Why keep it simple, when you can complicate everyone's life?

A toast to ANSI and your smart employer!

K0SM0S··on Tmux for Mere Mortals
I was born in France, so grew up with one of the weirdest ISO layout: "AZERTY".[1]

The worst offense is not even A-Z but rather symbols — take the key "ù" for instance: it's a non-mod key that is used for 1 single word in the entire French language. Literally, ONE WORD in the dictionary. And you need to Shift that 'ù' key to get '%'. How stupid is that...

I won't even comment on the weird 'M' position, which shortens the bottom row (index hits no letter, it's a symbol...) Like WTF, seriously.

Also, top row requires Shift for numbers... (no modifier yields symbols...) What a strange, impractical decision. Every number requires pressing a modifier, but underscore or '&' do not... Sure, yeah, OK.

Should we talk about period '.' requiring a Shift, but not ';' No, no we shouldn't. It's not like a period is common in language...

I thus call it 'weirdest', because it's as far as it gets from ANSI, and it has to be the worst ISO I've ever tried altogether. The question is, why do it so differently? Why not change as little as necessary based on ANSI? Was it a misguided sense of cultural appropriation? Did they like torturing typists and programmers alike?

So one day, as I was learning programming, I decided to stop fighting my keyboard, to preserve my sanity (and limit RSI).

QWERTY US (ANSI) is simply the best for tech (IT, prog). Not necessarily inherently (although it's very good for language), but because of the chicken-and-the-egg: most software is designed by/for US companies and programmers, so symbols like e.g. []{}|/ are used in programming, bash, tools, because they are easy to use on a QWERTY keyboard. And I vastly prefer the 1-row wide Enter to the inverted-L shaped ISO style (less RSI-inducing on the right pinky).

For non-US programmers, there's life before, and after switching to ANSI-US. I'm not even kidding, it's a life-changer in simplicity, comfort (ergonomics) and generally intuition— e.g. there's a reason why ()[]{} are close by. And it lets one buy keyboards anywhere (you'll always find QWERTY, but good luck finding ISO-XX in country YY.

Thank you to anyone who read this. I hope you feel the pain. Now revel in the fact that you weren't born in France and did not have to suffer the computer illiteracy and impractical engineering design of an entire generation before you.

/rant

I don't know if French AZERTY is funny or appalling, I'll let you be the judge of that; I just need to vent 25 years of frustration every now and then, even 10+ years later.

____

[1]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b9/KB_Franc...

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →