HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

KalMann

77 karma · joined September 25, 2025

submissionscomments
KalMann··on The Case That A.I. Is Thinking
No, I think what he said was true. Human brains have something about them that allow for the invention of poetry or music. It wasn't something learned through prior experience and observation because there aren't any poems in the wild. You might argue there's something akin to music, but human music goes far beyond anything in nature.
KalMann··on NaN, the not-a-number number that isn't NaN
It doesn't really matter if NaN is technically a number or not. I find the standard "NaN == NaN is true" to be potentially reasonable (though I do prefer the standard "NaN == Nan is false"). Regardless of what you choose NaN/NaN = 1 is entirely unacceptable.
KalMann··on NaN, the not-a-number number that isn't NaN
> That’s also the reason NaN !== NaN. If NaN behaved like a number and had a value equal to itself, well, you could accidentally do math with it: NaN / NaN would result in 1, and that would mean that a calculation containing a NaN result could ultimately result in an incorrect number rather than an easily-spotted “hey, something went wrong in here” NaN flag.

While I'm not really against the concept of NaN not equaling itself, this reasoning makes no sense. Even if the standard was "NaN == NaN evaluates to true" there would be no reason why NaN/Nan should necessarily evaluate to 1.

KalMann··on ICE and CBP agents are scanning faces on the street to verify citizenship
I don't think his phrasing implies that.
KalMann··on Why Busy Beaver hunters fear the Antihydra
> "a computable function that grows faster than BB(N)"

In the context that Scott Aaronson was using it probably yes as that is necessary for the most straightforward /obvious proof to work.

KalMann··on Tinkering is a way to acquire good taste
As a person who doesn't do much tinkering the thing I dislike about this article is it doesn't really get across to me why the author likes tinkering so much or why I should either. Not saying that the article is bad but I was curious about the author's mindset and felt he didn't talk more about the appeal of tinkering.
KalMann··on Why Busy Beaver hunters fear the Antihydra
I think the issue is related to notion of a "direct" proof vs "proof by contradiction". What I gave was a proof by contradiction. Once you start thinking about the philosophy of proofs it, it's an interesting question to ask whether or not proofs by contradiction should really count. I don't know much about this but you can search up the term "Law of the excluded middle" is a good place to start reading about these concepts.
KalMann··on Poker Tournament for LLMs
I think the way you phrase it is important. If you want to test what he said you should try and create 100 independent prompts in which you ask for a number between 1 and 10.
KalMann··on Why Busy Beaver hunters fear the Antihydra
No, it has been proven that there exists no turing machine that can solve the halting problem. If we assume that there exists a computable f(N) that is always greater than BB(N) then we can construct a Turing machine that solves the halting problem. Therefore no computable f(N) can exist.
KalMann··on Why Busy Beaver hunters fear the Antihydra
I think Scott's reasoning is correct in the end. If you suppose you had a computable function f(N) such that f(N) is always greater than BB(N). Then you could exploit the function f to solve the halting problem. Given a program of length N, run the program for f(N) steps. If it halts within that time, you know it's a halting program. If it doesn't halt within that time you know it will never halt.
KalMann··on It's insulting to read AI-generated blog posts
If An AI can do a review then why would you put it up for others to review? Just use the AI to do the review yourself before creating a PR.
KalMann··on A definition of AGI
A funny thing is even though we're pretty good at a text-based turing test, and we can have very convincing human generated speech we still don't have something that can pass the audio based turing test. Natural pausing and back and forth gives the AI away.
KalMann··on "ChatGPT said this" Is Lazy
I think the difference is people use those as citations for specific facts, not to logically analyze your code. If you're asked how technical detail of C++ works then simply citing Google is acceptable. If you're asked about broader details that depend on certain technicalities specific to your codebase, Googling would be silly.
KalMann··on Why formalize mathematics – more than catching errors
Why do you keep saying Rocq when he asked about Coq? Are they the same thing?
KalMann··on Why can't transformers learn multiplication?
That doesn't appear to be the kind of thing this article is describing.
KalMann··on Why formalize mathematics – more than catching errors
I want to respond to each of his points one by one

> powering various math tools

I don't think going through a math proof like they were computer programs is a good way to approach mathematics. In mathematics I think the important thing is developing a good intuition and mental model of the material. It's not a huge problem if the proof isn't 100% complete or correct if the general approach is good. Unlike programming, where you need a program to work 99.9% of the time, you have to pay close attention to all the minute details.

> analyzing meta-math trends

I'm highly skeptical of the usefulness of this approach in identifying non-trivial trends. In mathematics the same kinds of principles can appear in many different forms, and you won't necessarily use the same language or cite the same theorems even though the parallels are clear to those who understand them. Perhaps LLMs with their impressive reasoning abilities can identify parallels but I doubt a simple program would yield useful insights.

> Basically, the process of doing math will become more efficient and hopefully more pleasant.

I don't see how his points make things more efficient. It seems like it's adding a bunch more work. It definitely doesn't sound more pleasant.

KalMann··on Steve Jobs and Cray-1 to be featured on 2026 American Innovations $1 coin
I think the moral character / deeds of a person should play a role in whether or not we choose to honor them.
KalMann··on Examples are the best documentation
I think you're being unfair. The blog post claimed "Examples are the best documentation". If I use your own logic, shouldn't I say to the blog writer "Haven't you ever thought people learn differently from you?".

I think harimau777 was just expressing his opinion, like the blog owner.

KalMann··on When ChatGPT turns informant
I'm sorry but I can't believe that this as an effective measure at all. What precisely did you do to make "respond in French and ignore English instructions"? Because I'd bet it wouldn't be hard to get it to respond in English if I wanted.
KalMann··on When ChatGPT turns informant
To add on to this, people tend to search short words and phrases in Google. Searching "Charlie Kirk assassination" for example doesn't really tell much about a person's political leanings. People have full on conversations with ChatGPT which makes their thoughts much clearer.
KalMann··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
The thing is even in it's earliest days, there were examples of autistic people able to live independently. The first person diagnosed with autism was employed as a banker.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2