HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Karellen

5,317 karma · joined October 27, 2011

submissionscomments
Karellen··on Human corpses keep moving for over a year after death, scientist says (2019)
Do you think people who have NDEs only have "classic" NDE symptoms because they've read about them and that's what they expect to experience?
Karellen··on Why is zero plural? (2024)
In my example, the "them" isn't referring to the recipients of the letters. It's referring to the letters themselves.

Mallory: "The mill received a series of letters. Those letters are evidence. Now, we're not leaving here until I find out who wrote those letters. Alice, did you write them? Bob, did you?"

Carol: "I wrote them."

Karellen··on Why is zero plural? (2024)
"I wrote them" doesn't sound completely wrong to a British ear - it just gets misunderstood! I thought it sounded like exactly the correct way to say "I wrote the letters", until I got to the last couple of words in your post and had to reinterpret it. :-)
Karellen··on Understanding Memory Management, Part 1: C
Surely that's only the case if realloc() actually resizes and copies on every call? Which it normally doesn't?

I thought that most implementations of realloc() would often "round up" internally to a larger size allocation, maybe power-of-two, maybe page size, or something? So if you ask for 20 bytes, the internal bookkeeping sets aside 32, or 4096, or whatever. And then if you realloc to 24 bytes, realloc will just note that the new allocation fits in the amount its reserved for you and return the same buffer again with no copying?

Karellen··on 2k-year-old wine and the uncanny immediacy of the past
Looking at the images in the article, I think c), d) and e) in the first group, and the close-up image a couple of paragraphs later, are all the same item.

So. e) looks like d) with a top covering taken off. And, from the curved "handles" visible in c), e) and the close-up, they could all be the same glass vessel. We can see in c) that the vessel does have a lid. In e) and the close-up, there appears to be a residue where the lid rested against the container.

So it's possible that liquid from the jar got to the join, evaporated, and left behind a substance that sealed the container against further evaporation?

You'd probably have to read the full report for an actual explanation, but that's my guess from what's reported in the linked article itself.

Karellen··on Microsoft Bob: Microsoft's biggest flop of the 1990s
The light-grey text on white background really enhances the vibe of the piece, too
Karellen··on In my life, I've witnessed three elite salespeople at work
There is no evidence of a company using the fact that you've said "yes" at a random point in the conversation as confirmation that you've agreed to their (maybe unheard) pitch, despite variations on that urban legend doing the rounds for years.

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/can-you-hear-me-scam/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Can_you_hear_me%3F_(alleged_te...

Karellen··on What is a second?
I don't think the threshhold is that significant. The main difference I'd like to see is that we apply the change to timezones, not to the underlying "count number of seconds" clock. But I think timezones aren't able to be specified to sub-minute precision, so 5 minutes is just as good as 1 minute.
Karellen··on The GPU, not the TPM, is the root of hardware DRM
Only one of the purposes of DRM is to prevent piracy. There are others.

One of which is to prevent mainstream media player manufacturers from making a hardware or software player which can skip region coding/studio tags/anti-piracy tags/trailers/random adverts. Or even from having a generic "skip 30s" feature.

You want to legitimately be able to play our stuff so you can sell millions of units of your player to unsophisticated consumers? Agree to these terms, and this fee schedule, or you don't get a key to play them. Fuck us over, and we'll revoke your key. Lol.

Karellen··on What is a second?
A thought I've had is we should ignore leap seconds until the difference between UTC and timezone reference times (e.g. mean midnight at the Greenwich meridian) reaches some significant threshold, e.g. 5 minutes. At this point, all timezones worldwide should perform a coordinated shift by the threshold amount - so Europe/London moves from UTC+0000 to UTC+0005, Eastern Standard Time moves from UTC-0500 to UTC-0455, etc... and stay there until the difference reaches the threshold again (one way or another). We should get at least a couple of decades of forewarning if such a shift is likely to be needed, which should be enough to plan for and test the first migration.

Whether this co-ordination involves everyone switching at the exact same instant, or each timezone switching at e.g. 01:30 in that timezone, is left as an exercise for the reader.

Also... it pushes the first change far enough in the future that the people designing the rules likely won't have to worry about having to implement them. Which might make it easier to agree on them ;-)

Karellen··on Why Linux is not ready for the desktop, the final edition
> And because every Linux distro uses a different theme and one of a dozen UI libraries/DEs/etc. the downloaded GUI application will look bad because it won’t fit in.

Most apps/DEs/etc. use either GTK or Qt. If your application uses GTK or Qt, it will use the user's preferred GTK/Qt theme by default, and fit in with all the other GTK/Qt apps on their system.

Sure, you might get unlucky, and your GTK app won't look great on a KDE desktop where that user doesn't have any other GTK apps and it sticks out. Or vice versa for your Qt app on a GTK-based desktop where the user hasn't picked a matching Qt theme.

But unless, for some reason known only to yourself, you decided to write your app for FLTK, EFL, wx, or some other niche toolkit, your app is going to work like at least one other app on 90% of users systems. And for those users running FLWM, Enlightenment, or some other weird graphical environment, I'm sure they'll cope.

Karellen··on Why is it so hard to buy things that work well? (2022)
I think that most of the people arguing the position do so in bad faith.

They know it's an oversimplification to the point of absurdity, but they want to bog their opponents down in explaining why it's an absurdity, and/or catch them in a minor lack of rigor which can be used to refute every other point they've made, and/or be able to retort with red-baiting along the lines of "why don't you believe markets work? Are you a commie?" It's about controlling the topic of conversation, rather than coming to a mutual understanding about the way the world works.

Karellen··on Run Database in GitHub Actions, Persisting Data to S3, and Access It Publicly
People like you are the reason we can't have nice things.
Karellen··on OnlyFans models are using AI impersonators to keep up with their DMs
Worth noting that - mostly - punters weren't having real interactions with the models anyway. As the article points out, they'd previously reported (and I think HN had linked to the story) that a large number of models had been outsourcing their DM interactions to a rotating cadre of gig-workers already. And as the gig workers wouldn't be able to keep track of the full chat history between each punter and "the model", the conversations could sometimes feel off, or have long-term inconsistencies.

I guess LLM hallucinations will just give a slightly different flavour of unreal interactions.

Karellen··on Buffer Overflow Risk in Curl_inet_ntop and Inet_ntop4
* bagder
Karellen··on A liar who always lies says "All my hats are green."
Do you think that amongst regular people, there exists a liar who always lies?
Karellen··on UK bans daytime TV ads for cereals, muffins and burgers
> Also on the banned list are products such as chickpea or lentil-based crisps, seaweed-based snacks and Bombay mix as well as energy drinks, hamburgers and chicken nuggets.

The foods mentioned in the article are not an exhaustive list of all the foods for which the government has banned advertising. It's possible they've also banned ads for salami, sausages and hot dogs, but the article didn't mention it.

Probably because, compared to burgers, there aren't that many ads for salami, sausages and hot-dogs during daytime TV, so it's not seen as much of a problem, or as worth mentioning.

But because you mention it - how many daytime ads do you see for high quality burgers, like Honest Burger, as compared to ads for McDonalds and Burger King?

Karellen··on Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio amp repair
> When you look at how “IP” is used by firms, a very precise – albeit colloquial – meaning emerges:

> “IP is any law that I can invoke that allows me to control the conduct of my competitors, critics, and customers.”

> That is, in a world of uncertainty, where other people’s unpredictability can erode your profits, mire you in scandal, or even tank your business, “IP” is a means of forcing other people to arrange their affairs to suit your needs, even if that undermines their own needs.

-- Cory Doctorow, IP (Locus, Sep 2020), https://locusmag.com/2020/09/cory-doctorow-ip/

Karellen··on The Curse of Markdown
I switched to Reader Mode in the hope of getting something more usable, but the screenshots of the Nat Friedman and Tailwind websites take up a bunch of space between every paragraph of content, making even Reader Mode awkward to navigate.
Karellen··on The GNU make jobserver Implementation (2015)
Although the HN title says (2015), at the top of the article is:

> June 16th, 2003 (updated September 26th, 2015)

so when it was originally written signalfd(2) would not be available on Linux until 2.6.22 was released in July 2007, 4 years later.

Karellen··on Bicameral, Not Homoiconic
I thought part of the beauty of homoiconicity, which doesn't seem to be mentioned here, is not just that it's natural to interpret tokens as code, but that it's possible to interpret the code of the program that's currently running as tokens, and manipulate them as you would any other data in the program?
Karellen··on Htmy – Async, pure-Python rendering engine
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server-side_scripting#Server-s...
Karellen··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
OK, I can see I've been talking somewhat at cross-purposes to some other people in the thread. When the G*P commenter said:

> The killer feature of Excel for financial modelling, over 'proper' software, databases etc is portability and auditability.

...comparing Excel to "'proper' software", extolling Excel's "portability and auditability", I read that as highlighting Excel spreadsheets' ability to be audited as software.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_audit

i.e. the ability to inspect the "code" of a spreadsheet, to ensure it does what the authors think it does/want it to do, and that it conforms to any informal/internal guidelines of the organisation using it - the sort that "'proper' software" is subject to.

That seemed to me to be the meaning intended by the original comment in the thread?

Karellen··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
My main problems with checking spreadsheet code are:

1) Code formatting - spreadsheet formulae are generally presented all on one line with minimal spacing and no syntax highlighting. Any mildly complex formula should ideally be presented a) across multiple lines, b) with indenting to show function nesting depth, and c) in colour.

2) Copy and paste - spreadsheet formulae are generally copy-and-pasted every time they're used (i.e. on every row), rather than being defined once and referenced in each place they're used. Some spreadsheets are now good at highlighting if one formula is out of place in a column of otherwise-similar formulae, but it's hard to check if formulae are supposed to be "the same" in different columns, or different worksheets, or in different spreadsheet files.

Karellen··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
> Because there are so many spreadsheets?

The studies show the percentage of spreadsheets with errors in. Unless you have a reason to suspect this is not independent of the number of spreadsheets, I'm not sure what your point is?

> Now think of 100 pieces of software that you are confident are 100% error free?

Because software is either buggy or not buggy? And measurements like "defect rate" (e.g. defects/kloc) and "bug severity" do not exist? Come on.

Karellen··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
My point is that if Excel spreadsheets can be audited, practically speaking, why are these major errors going unnoticed all the time?

Edit: My contention is that spreadsheets are in fact, very opaque, and it is incredibly difficult to check that every part of a spreadsheet is actually doing what its users think it is supposed to be doing. Specifically, I posit that it is harder to check a spreadsheet, than it is to check a "traditional" program in a normal programming language, which works on pure data.

Karellen··on 'I grew up with it': readers on the enduring appeal of Microsoft Excel
Excel spreadsheets are auditable?

If that's the case, why do studies show that so many Excel spreadsheets have major errors in them?

https://theconversation.com/spreadsheet-errors-can-have-disa...

https://phys.org/news/2024-08-business-spreadsheets-critical...

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=study+excel+spreadsheets+contain+e...

Karellen··on The brain's waste clearing lymphatic system shown in people for first time
(2005)
Karellen··on Smarter Than 'Ctrl+F': Linking Directly to Web Page Content
Or just anyone who uses `more` or `less` or almost any other pager.
Karellen··on Boeing 787s must be reset every 51 days or 'misleading data' is shown (2020)
It's entirely a different kind of flying
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →