HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Karellen

5,317 karma · joined October 27, 2011

submissionscomments
Karellen··on When Water Flows Uphill [video] (2013)
"The difference between science and screwing around is writing it down"

-- Adam Savage

Karellen··on Some people with insomnia think they're awake when they're asleep
> I’ve also had dreams where I’ve known it was a dream.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucid_dream

Karellen··on What Is PID 0?
Maybe it was only used as the `all in progress group` sentinel because it was used by the kernel and could never be the pid of a userspace process?

There's no reason that Unix couldn't have defined `PID_ALLPROCGRP = -2` instead.

I mean, what do you think came first the development of Unix? The pid taken by the kernel thread used for scheduling, or a special value to a syscall when someone realised "hey, maybe being able to kill the entire process group would be handy. What spare values do we have we can use to indicate that?"

(And remember, POSIX codified existing practice. Unices don't use pid 0 for a reason because POSIX says so; POSIX says so because that's what Unices did)

Karellen··on Super Heavy has splashed down in The Gulf of Mexico
> There are large bespoke payloads (eg JWST) but these are inherently so expensive anyway the launch vehicle costs almost don't matter.

If launch costs are going to be $250M, you need a budget of that order of magnitude to make a mission viable. At that point, you might was well spend anywhere from $50M to $1B on the payload because that's where your budget is. Or, to put it another way, only payloads with a $50M to $1B budget can afford to exist if the launch costs are of the order of $250M.

However, if launch costs are of the order of $5M, then missions with much smaller budgets suddenly become economically viable. And there are a lot more potential missions out there with $10M budgets than there are missions with $500M budgets.

Satellites get smaller not only because the tech gets smaller, but because launch costs/kg are so expensive, or so limited. Currently it's worth spending $10M to reduce your mass by 10%, if doing so means you can reduce your launch costs by $25M. Or, if doing so means you can double your onboard station-keeping fuel, and double the lifespan of the satellite.

If launch costs are less and available upmass is higher, your budget for engineering to reduce your payload mass is less, and so is the reason to do so.

Karellen··on The Distinctiveness of Human Aggression (2022)
IMO, you really want to be able to consider all of humanity to be part of your ingroup.

No matter how small your ingroup is, the members aren't all clones of each other. They have differences in how they were raised by their parents, and in some of the things they think. Differences are not automatic deal-breakers for your ingroup. So, if one works hard enough, it should be possible to consider everyone part of your ingroup. You may want to change some people's minds on some things, but that doesn't mean you have to consider them "the other".

Karellen··on The Distinctiveness of Human Aggression (2022)
If you get further down, they expand their view on Morality to be more nuanced, and something that sounds pretty reasonable. I think the core of their view is:

> My view is that morality is “real” in the same way that language is real. Both can change, but still operate within certain constraints. There are rules to every language, and rules to every morality.

> Saying morality isn’t real is like saying language isn’t real. And saying there is one true morality is like saying there is only one true language.

There's more to it than that, so it's worth reading that whole section if you want to give the author another chance.

Karellen··on Most life on Earth is dormant, after pulling an 'emergency brake'
> The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not "Eureka!" (I found it!) but "That's funny..."

-- commonly attributed to Isaac Asimov

Karellen··on You'll regret using natural keys
> For example, the order of query params is free to change but it's still the same URL.

Are you sure that's guaranteed by any spec? I thought an end-point would be free to treat `?a=1&b=2` and `?b=2&a=1` differently. I mean, it would be a nightmarish implementation, but I don't think it would be non-conforming?

Karellen··on Simple tasks showing reasoning breakdown in state-of-the-art LLMs
> > Question is: "Alice has 60 brothers and she also has 212 sisters. How many sisters does Alice’s brother have?"

> The right answer depends on how Alice identifies I guess? :)

Given that the wording of the question specifically identifies Alice as "she", rather than using a gender-neutral pronoun or no pronoun at all, I think inferring that she identifies as female is reasonable.

Karellen··on Simple tasks showing reasoning breakdown in state-of-the-art LLMs
You could call it the "Compose a symphony fallacy", after the scene in I, Robot (2004) where Spooner asks Sonny if he can compose a symphony, to which Sonny replies "Can you?"
Karellen··on Diffusion on syntax trees for program synthesis
It's different in the same way that using an LLM instead of a traditional Markov chain is a different way of generating text. You're still predicting the next word at a time to hopefully end up with plausible sentences/paragraphs, but the difference is in how you model the training dataset, and how you use that model to make each next choice in your live application.
Karellen··on in Rust, methods should be object safe

    // counter_associated.rs
    [...]
            let c = Counter::increment(f);
What is `f` here?
Karellen··on Unexpected anti-patterns for engineering leaders
> My definition of culture talks about the working values and processes in a company.

Yeah, that does change it. And while that's certainly a reasonable definition of "cultural fit", I don't think it's been the predominant meaning historically.

As far as I'm aware, "cultural fit" has often been a tool of exclusion to e.g. justify not hiring a woman because they wouldn't be a good cultural fit in a place where all the guys talk about women as sex objects, or not hiring someone who's gay as they wouldn't be a good cultural fit where everyone makes fun of the homos, etc...

But it's more subtle than that. If all the devs in a team grew up watching a bunch of white middle-class sitcoms as kids (e.g. Friends, or whatever the early-'00s equivalent would be for junior devs these days) and those are their cultural touchstones, then someone who grew up not watching those show because they didn't speak to their life, is not going to get the same cultural references as them. And so "lack of cultural fit" can be used to enforce homogeneity, not only without needing an actual policy of not hiring people from working-class minority backgrounds, but without the people in charge of hiring even needing to consciously realise that's what they're doing! It enables the kind of systemic marginalisation that can be perpetuated by well-meaning people completely by accident.

--

Looking back up-thread now, I think your definition might actually have been what the GP commenter was getting at. But it wasn't obviously so (at least, not obviously enough for me!) and without another explicit qualifier, "cultural fit" threw up a sizable red flag that I couldn't resist taking a swipe at.

Thanks for taking the time to write a thoughtful response that made me look at the previous comment in less reflexive light.

Karellen··on Lisbon, a city dying from its own success
> I suspect this is only transient.

But the effects aren't.

Once a 180-year-old bookshop closes and moves out, it's gone.

Yeah, if the tourists go and if the AirBnB revenue dries up, and the "locals" move back into the town, then maybe another bookshop will open in its place. But it won't be a 180-year-old bookshop. Part of the beauty of a historic city is the historic part. Once that's been erased, it can't be rebuilt again, except with the long, slow passing of more history. Until then, it's just another city with a bunch of new stores that are pretty much like all the new stores in many other cities. Except maybe for a couple of plaques that say "There used to be an awesome old thing here, until globalisation swept it away."

Karellen··on Hate Chatbots? You Aren't the Only One
> It would be much better to just publish a good knowledge base.

Yes, but a lot of companies seem to institutionally incapable of doing so. The number of FAQ pages (or worse, FAQ apps) I've come across filled with questions that no human has ever asked about a product, but instead list all the questions that the marketing department wished people would ask about their product because the answers paint it in such a good light, is astonishing.

The trouble with an actual knowledgebase that helps people who are struggling to use your product, is that it broadcasts to the world the ways in which your product is hard to use. And that just doesn't look good. So that info is either not published at all, or made deliberately hard to find, in order that people can't figure out where the warts are.

Karellen··on Seven Dyson Sphere Candidates
I thought the efficiency of a Dyson sphere/swarm was typically measured by how much of the star's total power was being used?

We are not capturing 10-15% of the sun's total power output.

Karellen··on Seven Dyson Sphere Candidates
One solution to this is the Matrioshka brain, which consists of many nested "shells" around the star. Each one absorbs the radiation from the hotter shell inside it (or from the star, if the inner shell), and radiates waste heat to the cooler shell outside it. The temperature differential between the inside and outside of each shell is what allows work to be done. The outer surface of the outermost shell, maybe 5 billion km (~35AU, or a bit further out than Neptune) from the star, will be close to the ambient temperature of the interstellar medium, and will radiate heat at only a few Kelvin into it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matrioshka_brain

Karellen··on Earth rotation limits in-body image stabilization to 6.3 stops (2020)
The same axis of rotation? Pretty sure they're about 23° off.
Karellen··on How to get 7th graders to smoke
> In british historical drama there is an old standard that any character that coughs will soon die.

That reminds me of the classic short-film subversion of this trope: The Man Who Has a Cough and it's Just a Cough and He's Fine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtQNULEudss&t=67s

Karellen··on Raspberry Pi Ltd is considering an IPO
Friedman's Malady

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine

Karellen··on Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liable in 737 MAX crashes
> I ignore the "limited liability" bs since it should not shield you from criminal behaviour.

It doesn't. That's not what "limited liability" is for.

> Limited liability is a legal status in which a person's financial liability is limited to a fixed sum, most commonly the value of a person's investment in a corporation, company or joint venture. If a company that provides limited liability to its investors is sued, then the claimants are generally entitled to collect only against the assets of the company, not the assets of its shareholders or other investors. A shareholder in a corporation or limited liability company is not personally liable for any of the debts of the company, other than for the amount already invested in the company and for any unpaid amount on the shares in the company, if any, except under special and rare circumstances permitting "piercing the corporate veil." The same is true for the members of a limited liability partnership and the limited partners in a limited partnership. By contrast, sole proprietors and partners in general partnerships are each liable for all the debts of the business (unlimited liability).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability

(emphasis mine)

Karellen··on It’s an age of marvels
...but you repeat yourself
Karellen··on Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction with Permira
I... what?

Great-Grandparent> most M&A transactions trend to have a 30% premium above the trading price. I [...] could not find a good explanation to why

You> It’s probably just a good rule of thumb.

Me> But why is 30% better than 15%?

You> The equilibrium appears to be 30% above asking

I still don't understand how that's supposed to explain why 30% is the stable value, instead of another, as the GGP was asking. How does what you are saying add anything more than "It is what it is" to the discussion?

Karellen··on Zero Feet: a proposal for a systems-free Lisp
> You cannot get around the Ken Thompson problem

I thought Dr. David A. Wheeler's 2009 doctoral dissertation "Fully Countering Trusting Trust through Diverse Double-Compiling" had been generally accepted as proof that you could?

https://dwheeler.com/trusting-trust/

Karellen··on Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction with Permira
Why is that a better rule of thumb than, e.g. 5%/10%/15%/20%?
Karellen··on The Great Flattening
> I joined the internet myself on IRC and NEWS

And email, right? You do have email, don't you? Which is not implemented over the WWW, and is pre-WWW by the best part of a decade. (RFC 821/822 are dated August 1982, and the first publicly documented version of HTTP 0.9 is, I think, 1991?)

I think it's pretty safe to say "The Internet", without any other qualification, came into being with the publication of the IPv4 RFC 791 in September 1981, by Vint Cerf and Robert Kahn.

Now, California might not be entirely accurate, as while a fair amount of the work on the Internet Protocols was done at UCLA and UC Berkley, MIT was also heavily involved along with co-ordination from DARPA's IPTO in Virginia (specifically, The Pentagon). But I think "California" is a much more accurate birthplace for The Internet than CERN.

Edit: I'm guessing you also use the not-built-on-WWW DNS system from RFCs 882/883 published in 1983?

Karellen··on 16 years of CVE-2008-0166 – Debian OpenSSL Bug
If it were a supply chain attack, I find it hard to believe that a) it would have originated from Debian at all, and b) that the people making the patch would have posted to the openssl-dev mailing list to ask their opinion on the correctness of the patch before including/shipping it.

https://lwn.net/Articles/282038/

Karellen··on Adam Curtis on the dangers of self-expression (2017)
It wasn't just "the Lord", it was that combined with the Doublethink of the wording.

But that quote from Kipchoge does put it in a more comprehensible framing. Thanks.

Karellen··on Adam Curtis on the dangers of self-expression (2017)
> There is another definition of freedom which simply says, “In whose service is perfect freedom.” By giving yourself up to the Lord, you free yourself of the narrow cage of your own desires and your own selfishness.

...and that's where they lost me.

Karellen··on Stack Overflow users deleting answers after OpenAI partnership
> Users are also asking why ChatGPT could not simply share the source of the answers it will dispense in this new partnership, both citing its sources and adding credibility to the tool. Of course, this would reveal how the sausage of LLMs is made

What? Surely the answer to that question is that ChatGPT doesn't know where the source of its answers is, isn't it? Isn't the question itself based on a fundamental misunderstanding of how LLMs work?

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →