HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Kednicma

185 karma · joined June 2, 2020

submissionscomments
Kednicma··on The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science
But Conway's Free Will Theorem certainly does! The superdeterminism cannot help, either; either the world is so superdetermined that falsifiability and the scientific method are totally meaningless, or the world is not sufficiently deterministic and the Free Will Theorem neatly cleans up the remainder by invoking Kochen-Specker.

I recommend that you examine whatever underlying beliefs are forcing you to require determinism! They probably need to be questioned.

Kednicma··on Time to Pardon Edward Snowden?
This administration won't do it, simply because Russia has more leverage over Snowden's cultural influence while he's unpardoned and in exile. The next administration won't do it, because Biden was in Obama's administration during Snowden's original actions.

We need to examine the situation not from whether enough time has elapsed to make the wounds heal over, but from whether our government is ready to admit its past mistakes and learn from them.

Kednicma··on The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science
My argument is the same one that Bell, Kochen, Specker, Conway, and so many others have covered before: If photons were locally real, then we'd see different measurements from what we actually do see. The video covers the basic idea of witnessing this using polarizing filters, as well as explaining Bell's inequalities using basic discrete set theory and Venn diagrams.

We don't have to lose reality; we could instead lose locality. However, then we also lose most of physical causality and spatial relevance. [0] covers all of the material but takes more than 20min to read. At the end of it, we're left with a very weak theory that has trouble ruling out FTL influences.

On the second point, it doesn't particularly matter whether those natural laws exist; my point was that they're not fully knowable. There's no reason why the universe ought to admit a short legible encoding of its own structure, especially considering that such structure ought not be observable by creatures like us residing in the universe.

Rather than knowing the natural laws, we know predictive models which are good approximations. There is fundamental uncertainty preventing our approximations from sharpening to some arbitrarily fine precision.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_nonlocality

Kednicma··on The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science
[0] is a 20min video which you can replicate for $20 at a convenience store. [1] has Conway explaining in detail, although it's not excruciating. I don't see why the burden of proof is on me; Bell's inequalities are not new.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcqZHYo7ONs

[1] https://plus.maths.org/content/john-conway-discovering-free-...

Kednicma··on The Knowledge Machine: How Irrationality Created Modern Science
Quantum mechanics demolishes the first two bullet points, so in some sense, science has marched on and progressed past that naive ontic naturalism, and exchanged it for a humbler epistemic naturalism. The points become rephrased:

> that there is an epistemic reality about which all rational observers can know half of the ontic facts

> that this epistemic reality is governed by natural laws which are themselves epistemic

And so on. Crucially, there are no local hidden variable theories which can reproduce what we observe already; there are situations where there cannot possibly have been an objective ontic reality in the laboratory.

Kednicma··on Optimizations on Linear Search (2016)
I understand the rhetorical dodges here, but as both a career SRE and a student of CS, I don't see anything here which invalidates the theoretical asymptotic behavior. All of the nuance added here is a complement, not a replacement, for traditional theory.

It is certainly true that the number of elements needs to be quite high before the question is theoretically interesting. The author is right to point out that L2 cache is quite large. Today's GPUs are also quite large in onboard RAM and have integer ALUs, so even millions of elements are not a problem for a basic consumer-grade video card. (Yes, I know that that sounds stupid, but GPUs and now TPUs in the datacenter are a real thing, even if they're quite unfair!)

Kednicma··on Einstein's description of gravity just got much harder to beat
The color of gold is better explained by an ad-hoc combination of SR, GR, and QM, than by any one of them alone. SR and GR explain the planets' motion better than Newton and Kepler alone. QM explains pi bonds in molecules like benzene better than classical chemistry. GR compensation is required by GPS satellites and receivers.

So it doesn't have to be a combination of GR and QM, but it does have to be something which is at least as good as GR and QM respectively in their existing domains of explanation.

Kednicma··on Einstein's description of gravity just got much harder to beat
To expand on this, Pirsig tears apart "just" as a completely useless word which reaffirms the speaker's belief but also trivializes the listener's inability to understand. "just" comes from ancient Latin "ius" and it means "I swear" or "I believe". When somebody says "I was just doing something", they are swearing a light oath that they were doing something.

Back in context, what the parent is saying is that the grandparent provided a "just-so" story: The parent finds it easy to believe that history happened in a way which neatly lines up with the story that they are telling. Did earlier humans know about perspective? Grandparent believes that it's obvious.

Kednicma··on Looking at the experience of black Britons through an American lens
In addition to the entirety of the author's examples and experiences, we need to recall that the UK/British view of race is heavily influenced by the fact that skin color is not the only way in which folks in the UK experience racial discrimination. For centuries, the Scottish and Irish natives have been variously oppressed by the British, creating a racial context which is distinct from one wholly concerned with skin tone.

Not less racist, not more racist, just differently racist.

Kednicma··on Pedigree Collapse
The main import of pedigree collapse is that it affirms that humans are one single race.
Kednicma··on Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, study finds
Mostly, because we know that there were eras when women dominated programming, typing, debugging, documentation, etc. So we know that there's no biological or innate reason why women are unable/unwilling/unskilled at this labor. Instead, we conclude that it's culture.

Incidentally, part of the culture which causes women to leave is your inherently-othering comment which seeks to divide women and men into a binary categorization.

Edit to the children comments: To spell it out more clearly: The proportion of laborers in different fields is wholly cultural. The entire concept of fields of labor is wholly cultural. The entire concept of labor as something done not just for survival is cultural. Your brains are extremely plastic and you exist almost entirely on cultural, not instinctual, impulses.

Kednicma··on US intelligence sources discussed poisoning Julian Assange, court told
Guess it's not only the Russians who plan international poisonings.
Kednicma··on [dead]
There is no contradiction in both believing that humans only form one single race, and also that some humans oppress other humans based on erroneous beliefs about skin color and heritage. The important part is to simultaneously understand that this oppression is occurring while also understanding the the oppression is scientifically incoherent.

Similarly, there is no contradiction in both believing that humans should have universal healthcare without restrictions based on genitals or pre-existing conditions, and also that sex chromosomes are used as a societal excuse for genital mutilation, sexual assault, harrassment and discrimination, etc. Again, the oppression both happens and makes no scientific sense, and there is nothing logically wrong with this stance.

I'm blind to race and sex -- I don't inherently weigh the value of people by their skin color or genitals. I'm not blind to race and sex -- I know that racists and sexists exist, and I antagonize them in order to reduce their effects in society. The conclusion is that the idea of being blind to social constructions is a bit of a rhetorical gimmick!

Kednicma··on [dead]
I understand what you're saying, but I can't find a way to save the opinions of the Bronze Age religions. They're so backwards compared to modern knowledge about medicine and other practical fields of science that a complete reinterpretation is usually required, and reinterpretation can assign any meaning whatsoever.

For example, I'm currently watching a lecture about the Higgs boson. The Higgs field was not predicted by any Bronze Age religions (indeed not predicted by any religion I've studied) and its purpose is wholly mathematical and not easily deducible from daily life. I have no idea how religion could possibly climb to study the Higgs field without shedding most of its superstitions in the style of the current scientific tradition.

It wouldn't be a problem for folks to carry these ancient beliefs, as a first-order situation, but belief begets belief. Restrictions on diet are not much of a problem, but restrictions on sexuality are completely at odds with modern sexology and sex education, and we're not even talking about the millions of lives laid down in the name of God.

Edit to avoid posting too fast: Yes, I am saying that our knowledge of science irrevocably changed mid-century due to particle physics. This is Kuhn's incommensurability [0] and it is an essential part of understanding science: Sometimes we make leaps of understanding which are so radically large that they undo prior understanding and render it meaningless.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commensurability_(philosophy_o...

Kednicma··on [dead]
Well, yeah. Science shows that racism is bogus (humans are just one race), sexism is bogus (human chromosomes have more than two arrangements), and many religious beliefs are bogus (stories of the Bronze Age are mythic, lacking historical evidence). It's understandable that they're uneasy about this stuff; as Colbert famously noted, reality has a liberal bias.
Kednicma··on Doctors Group Sues California for Failing to Add Processed Meat to Cancer List
I think that you're thinking of poisons; the central slogan of toxicology is "the dose makes the poison" [0]. Carcinogens, chemicals which aggravate the chance of cancer, follow different rules; usually DNA damage is occurring.

Some very specific viruses are carcinogenic; not all viruses are. Similarly, some very specific molecules are carcinogenic, but not every substance is carcinogenic in sufficient quantities. An obvious counterexample is water, which is toxic in large amounts but not carcinogenic.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dose_makes_the_poison

Kednicma··on A psychologist rethinking human emotion
On one hand, of course emotional palettes are cultural artifacts. On the other hand, though, by what logic does her choice of pop-science concepts lead to a deeper understanding of those cultural artifacts?

The way she talks to her daughter is pretty fucked up.

Kednicma··on In Defense of XML
The main problem with XML is that writing a safe XML parser is difficult. But writing, say, a safe JSON parser is not much easier; writing a safe ASN.1 parser is much harder. So it's not clear whether there's a better possible declarative format.
Kednicma··on [dead]
We should find ways to be better people.
Kednicma··on This Company Wants to Help Your Boss Monitor Your Brainwaves at Work
It's pretty scummy to claim to be peer-reviewed and scientific but simultaneously not have any studies published for the specific thing that they're selling.

Between these earbuds and Neuralink, I'm unpleasantly surprised at how fast we are approaching the dystopic brain-hacking of 90s-era sci-fi.

Kednicma··on Throw away code
"In the long run every program becomes rococo - then rubble." ~ Alan Perlis
Kednicma··on PG and Jessica
It's useful to read between the lines, because maybe YC-like things are not good for the world. In that case, it's worth studying PG and Jessica only in order to understand how to avoid being like them.
Kednicma··on Universal basic income gains support in South Korea after Covid
No; when are you thinking of? [0] gives a good overview of the North Korean struggles over the past few decades, going back to the Korean War. You might be thinking of the famine in the 1990s, when the government took total control over food supplies. However, this was not UBI. It was not cash handouts but food handouts, and it was not a supplementary diet but a restriction on total food per household.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXaIpTj3vOs

Kednicma··on We cancelled standups and let the team build
That heatmap calendar was upside-down from the typical calendar UIs which I've used; it showed time flowing bottom-to-top rather than top-to-bottom. Is this the typical style for Haystack or related tooling?
Kednicma··on [dead]
Needs a (2017).

"It turns out talking about diversity, inclusion, and even just basic civil behavior can be controversial in technical spaces. I don’t think it should be, but I don’t get to make the rules." Yep. The three worst topics on HN are racism, sexism, and religious beliefs, precisely because it turns out that a lot of folks hold these beliefs and do not want to let them go, even in supposedly-technical fora.

I think that part of the problem is the need to ask why certain cultural practices arise. After all, no cultural practice survives without some sort of practical use, even if it's minor and selfish. Therefore, upon being told that a particular arbitrary cultural practice is simply not done in a certain context, the natural thing to wonder is by what justification, by why, the practice is unacceptable.

I think that this is the main reason why we cannot talk about racism, sexism, nor religious beliefs without having to explain why such beliefs are disprovable and incompatible with our modern scientific and empirical view of the world. People need justifications in order to be comfortable expanding their minds.

"This sentence doesn’t push my morality on anyone. If they want to do whatever it is elsewhere, I’m not telling them not to. I’m just cluing them into the local culture and values." Uh, that's explicitly not the case. Morality is memetic and thus part of cultural values. A society might forbid playing in a river because it has a dangerous undertow; this directly leads to a moral lesson.

Own your morality. Admit to being moral. To have morals is to opine that folks ought to do or not to do some certain things. Allow yourself to be part of your local culture.

Kednicma··on [dead]
"I don't say this lightly; this is the most upset I've ever been during this show," says the producer, over an hour in. I agree; we all need to be taking a hard look at what our industry is producing.

Facebook employees, please do something about this.

Kednicma··on As Joe Rogan’s platform grows, so does the media and liberal backlash – why?
"liberal" is too wide of a brush, basically; most folks are liberal (and also conservative!) and so the label brings in too many folks. Rogan's further to the left than the "liberal" centrist media; if it were not for all of the "signaling" that he does, like being a person who enjoys MMA, then he would be branded as a "socialist" just like his guests Bernie Sanders and Andrew Yang.

Ten words or less to answer the headline: Because mass media is actually quite illiberal.

Kednicma··on The Battle of Philippi (42 BCE)
"It's like poetry; it rhymes." ~ George Lucas
Kednicma··on The Expression Problem
The current situation is that it's like Karnaugh maps: If there are overlapping clauses and default/generic implementations, then yes, typeclasses/traits/interfaces can cut down on the amount of code needed. However, in the worst case, all of the implementations need to be provided.
Kednicma··on [dead]
What are they going to do, invade their own citizens a month before election? They have no leverage even if there were veracity to their claims and a legal basis for DOJ to interfere.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →