I recommend that you examine whatever underlying beliefs are forcing you to require determinism! They probably need to be questioned.
185 karma · joined June 2, 2020
I recommend that you examine whatever underlying beliefs are forcing you to require determinism! They probably need to be questioned.
We need to examine the situation not from whether enough time has elapsed to make the wounds heal over, but from whether our government is ready to admit its past mistakes and learn from them.
We don't have to lose reality; we could instead lose locality. However, then we also lose most of physical causality and spatial relevance. [0] covers all of the material but takes more than 20min to read. At the end of it, we're left with a very weak theory that has trouble ruling out FTL influences.
On the second point, it doesn't particularly matter whether those natural laws exist; my point was that they're not fully knowable. There's no reason why the universe ought to admit a short legible encoding of its own structure, especially considering that such structure ought not be observable by creatures like us residing in the universe.
Rather than knowing the natural laws, we know predictive models which are good approximations. There is fundamental uncertainty preventing our approximations from sharpening to some arbitrarily fine precision.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcqZHYo7ONs
[1] https://plus.maths.org/content/john-conway-discovering-free-...
> that there is an epistemic reality about which all rational observers can know half of the ontic facts
> that this epistemic reality is governed by natural laws which are themselves epistemic
And so on. Crucially, there are no local hidden variable theories which can reproduce what we observe already; there are situations where there cannot possibly have been an objective ontic reality in the laboratory.
It is certainly true that the number of elements needs to be quite high before the question is theoretically interesting. The author is right to point out that L2 cache is quite large. Today's GPUs are also quite large in onboard RAM and have integer ALUs, so even millions of elements are not a problem for a basic consumer-grade video card. (Yes, I know that that sounds stupid, but GPUs and now TPUs in the datacenter are a real thing, even if they're quite unfair!)
So it doesn't have to be a combination of GR and QM, but it does have to be something which is at least as good as GR and QM respectively in their existing domains of explanation.
Back in context, what the parent is saying is that the grandparent provided a "just-so" story: The parent finds it easy to believe that history happened in a way which neatly lines up with the story that they are telling. Did earlier humans know about perspective? Grandparent believes that it's obvious.
Not less racist, not more racist, just differently racist.
Incidentally, part of the culture which causes women to leave is your inherently-othering comment which seeks to divide women and men into a binary categorization.
Edit to the children comments: To spell it out more clearly: The proportion of laborers in different fields is wholly cultural. The entire concept of fields of labor is wholly cultural. The entire concept of labor as something done not just for survival is cultural. Your brains are extremely plastic and you exist almost entirely on cultural, not instinctual, impulses.
Similarly, there is no contradiction in both believing that humans should have universal healthcare without restrictions based on genitals or pre-existing conditions, and also that sex chromosomes are used as a societal excuse for genital mutilation, sexual assault, harrassment and discrimination, etc. Again, the oppression both happens and makes no scientific sense, and there is nothing logically wrong with this stance.
I'm blind to race and sex -- I don't inherently weigh the value of people by their skin color or genitals. I'm not blind to race and sex -- I know that racists and sexists exist, and I antagonize them in order to reduce their effects in society. The conclusion is that the idea of being blind to social constructions is a bit of a rhetorical gimmick!
For example, I'm currently watching a lecture about the Higgs boson. The Higgs field was not predicted by any Bronze Age religions (indeed not predicted by any religion I've studied) and its purpose is wholly mathematical and not easily deducible from daily life. I have no idea how religion could possibly climb to study the Higgs field without shedding most of its superstitions in the style of the current scientific tradition.
It wouldn't be a problem for folks to carry these ancient beliefs, as a first-order situation, but belief begets belief. Restrictions on diet are not much of a problem, but restrictions on sexuality are completely at odds with modern sexology and sex education, and we're not even talking about the millions of lives laid down in the name of God.
Edit to avoid posting too fast: Yes, I am saying that our knowledge of science irrevocably changed mid-century due to particle physics. This is Kuhn's incommensurability [0] and it is an essential part of understanding science: Sometimes we make leaps of understanding which are so radically large that they undo prior understanding and render it meaningless.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commensurability_(philosophy_o...
Some very specific viruses are carcinogenic; not all viruses are. Similarly, some very specific molecules are carcinogenic, but not every substance is carcinogenic in sufficient quantities. An obvious counterexample is water, which is toxic in large amounts but not carcinogenic.
The way she talks to her daughter is pretty fucked up.
Between these earbuds and Neuralink, I'm unpleasantly surprised at how fast we are approaching the dystopic brain-hacking of 90s-era sci-fi.
"It turns out talking about diversity, inclusion, and even just basic civil behavior can be controversial in technical spaces. I don’t think it should be, but I don’t get to make the rules." Yep. The three worst topics on HN are racism, sexism, and religious beliefs, precisely because it turns out that a lot of folks hold these beliefs and do not want to let them go, even in supposedly-technical fora.
I think that part of the problem is the need to ask why certain cultural practices arise. After all, no cultural practice survives without some sort of practical use, even if it's minor and selfish. Therefore, upon being told that a particular arbitrary cultural practice is simply not done in a certain context, the natural thing to wonder is by what justification, by why, the practice is unacceptable.
I think that this is the main reason why we cannot talk about racism, sexism, nor religious beliefs without having to explain why such beliefs are disprovable and incompatible with our modern scientific and empirical view of the world. People need justifications in order to be comfortable expanding their minds.
"This sentence doesn’t push my morality on anyone. If they want to do whatever it is elsewhere, I’m not telling them not to. I’m just cluing them into the local culture and values." Uh, that's explicitly not the case. Morality is memetic and thus part of cultural values. A society might forbid playing in a river because it has a dangerous undertow; this directly leads to a moral lesson.
Own your morality. Admit to being moral. To have morals is to opine that folks ought to do or not to do some certain things. Allow yourself to be part of your local culture.
Facebook employees, please do something about this.
Ten words or less to answer the headline: Because mass media is actually quite illiberal.