185 karma · joined June 2, 2020
Concretely, imagine some judge Judy who is judging some dispute between some Alice and Bob. The article explores how we can evaluate Judy for fairness. However, justice is when Judy, Alice, and Bob all agree on an outcome which none of the three would change, even if they were to be forced to swap bodies in some unrelated way after the outcome is assigned.
I'd like to think that I'm pretty good with elliptic curves, given that I explain them to other folks. However, this tweet-thread still showed me things that I didn't know about the history of maths. Some of these tweets directly led to minutes (hours) on Wikipedia and chasing down various PDFs to read.
Honestly, you could stand to be less self-aggrandizing. It's okay if you don't get every joke immediately; you don't have to know every bit of historical background.
Elliptic curves aren't interesting because of the answers that we have. They're interesting because of the questions. One open question [0] is on the Millennium Prize list. Another open question is almost never written down because it's so simple; "why 1728?" [1] Coming to understand these questions is the goal of our entire process, so there's not much that I can really do other than to ask you to join the process of exploration.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birch_and_Swinnerton-Dyer_conj...
Suppose for absurdity I replay my original argument, but with humans, and you reply "that doesn't mean humans are conscious; it means that the things which are housed within skulls are conscious". I understand the nuance you're introducing, but don't think that it helps. Part of the difficulty of the Combination Problem is that the boundary of conscious control extends beyond the nexus of thought. I'll accept that rocks are just the substrate, but integrated circuits are just carefully cooked rocks; substrate-vs-consciousness thinking might be wrong.
I agree with you that science is done empirically, and thus doesn't experience objectivity. However, maths is quite formal, and in the past century we managed to achieve "formal formality" with category theory. We now can talk of certain objects as existing universally; in their context, not only do they exist, but they uniquely exist. For example, `1+1=2`, which is to say that there's an equivalence between any pair of objects selected one by one, and any pair taken both at a time; for any particular counting context, there's only one natural numbers object.
I am not quite as pessimistic as you regarding the quality of the conclusions that we reach. Rather than saying that our filters make us subjective, I would simply say that the experiences of humanity are essentially human. There's an anthropic bias because humans can't experience anything that isn't human; we can't think truly alien ideas or build truly alien artifacts. Everything we think is non-human is actually human. This doesn't prevent us from drawing conclusions, but it does forbid objectivity.
And the consequences are stark. We put people on trial for any attempt to reform the system. Murray's blog covers the attempted railroading of Alex Salmond, and Murry himself was investigated and legally attacked by the state simply for not taking the state's side.
It's interesting that folks are slowly inching towards genuine algorithmic justice, but we are still focused on defining fairness from the POV of a single judge, and not from the entire integrated awareness of every participant in the community. I suppose that the latter is uncomputable...
Their view on the Hard Problem is not new. They say that the main trick to the Hard Problem is compressing information about a "self" which is repeatedly re-quantified. However, they then must rely on some notion of human individuality in order to explain why qualia are subjective.
The only problems I have with this approach are the normal criticisms of panpsychic approaches: It's hard to observe, there's few useful predictions, rocks are a little conscious, etc. However, rocks are a little conscious, or at least a little alive, thanks to lithophile bacteria which form microscopic filaments threading through the rock; this wasn't known in Berkeley's time!
I also think that legislators are obligated to do their job. No Oregon legislator should live in Idaho.
I also think that you, being a non-Portlander, should not have any voice whatsoever in disputes between Portland's people and its elected leadership. Our problems are between us, and our city council and mayor and cops; you're not a party to it.
Edit: Downvoters, use your words. Show us why you think these points are bogus; explain clearly why you think that you should have a vote in a society which you don't live in.
From our perspective, you're just some hateful outsider who has no experience living in a society. If you want our respect, then you need to be a better person, or at a minimum you need to demonstrate that you're capable of being embedded within a societal context.
Portlanders continue to note that most of the city is unaffected by protests. Life goes on as normal. Only a couple specific blocks downtown are contested, and only because the police have chosen to make those blocks into a battleground.
Edit: Downvoters, which buildings have been burned? Bootlicking isn't cute, it's servile. If you cannot back up your claims about Portland, maybe stop making them.
[0] https://www.oregonlive.com/news/2020/09/portland-protest-dec...
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kochen%E2%80%93Specker_theorem
[1] https://plus.maths.org/content/proof-kochen-specker-theorem
This isn't a facetious suggestion. Every employer I've had in the industry has been drowning under their heavy codebases. They have massive amounts of vendored dependencies, and long tails of single-author modules. The bigger employers have to create special teams just for pruning codebases and cleaning up after old projects.
And they're losing the battles. Code sprawls between multiple cloud vendors. Services exist in ecosystems so large that they have echo chambers, network effects, and politics. New languages are slowly introduced and even more slowly removed, with most code being written in mid-level glue modules. Code ontology and navigation is primitive and limited to indexed search.
What makes FLOSS different? Political discussions have to bring technical justifications to the table, mostly; this is Linus' famous "talk is cheap, so show me the code" slogan. The openness of collaboration ensures that CI systems, code repositories, and other shared services are available to folks, although this is still a cultural situation that isn't quite uniform yet. (There's too many folks who only publish tarballs and don't share the rest of their infrastructure, which is fine but not very collaborative.)
The resulting ecosystem can directly and openly compare codebases, and deprecate code which is shown to be inferior or unsafe or otherwise undesirable. We have shown an ability to not just change code artifacts, but the protocols and languages which we use to communicate, at a very rapid rate.
By insisting that MBS is some sort of specially evil person, I feel that you are devaluing the importance of genuine ethical consideration. I do not disagree with your specific points about his misbehaviour, but I want to emphasize that it is the throne and crown which empower him to do so much harm, and not any sort of blackened and hateful heart.
[0] https://www.docker.com/pricing/resource-consumption-updates
It's worth remembering that dictators are not inhuman, and they are not so different from us.
> Asaker would pay more than $300,000 to Abouammo, deposited in a Lebanese bank account that Abouammo had a relative open for him. “Proactive and reactively we will delete evil, my brother,” Abouammo texted Asaker just before one deposit of $9,911.
They structured [0] the bribes to avoid SARs; structuring really does happen.
> A third, a Saudi, was “a professional” who used encryption to conceal his identity, though once he signed in without encryption, and Alzabarah was able to track his IP address.
> [Alzabarah] spoke with Asaker on an open phone line and communicated via email.
> So rather than follow the FBI’s request to keep things quiet to assist the case, Twitter lawyers brought Alzabarah in the following afternoon, accused him of improperly accessing user accounts, and told him he was temporarily suspended.
Operational security is hard. Just one slip-up can doom the entire scheme, and here we see those slip-ups from everybody; from the folks being targeted by MBS, from MBS's goons, and from Twitter.
Everybody's entitled to their opinion. They're not entitled to immunity from critique, nor are they entitled to have their opinion be true nor provable.
It's funny how American exceptionalism pops up over and over again. We're like Europeans, but different. We're like capitalists, but different. We're like police, but different. We're like mercantile traders, but different. It's like we're trying to say that we're the British Empire, but different.
With that viewpoint, it becomes more reasonable to understand how we came to embrace Canada and Mexico, by analogy with the British embrace of Scotland and Ireland. Our strategy to consider North America as a single large monolith, but to dominate the influence that North America controls, parallels their strategy of using the British Isles as a part of Europe which is apart from Europe and acts as a unified group, despite being mostly controlled by the Queen's political structure.
It's so funny to listen to euphemisms. We didn't colonize the Philippines, we "developed" them. Woodrow Wilson wasn't a racist, he just had "difficulties" with Native American reservations. Trump isn't a fascist, he just has "frictions" with other nations.
It's amazing to consider that we weigh whether to not interfere in revolutions. By default, it seems like we always have an opinion on which way a revolution should go, and this leads directly to our continued involvement.
I did not expect to hear about Vannevar Bush. Bush was an important foundational figure in computer science, to us, but he had several other careers, including as one of the people behind the Manhattan Project. He is a good reminder that we have capacity both for inventing the memex and also for inventing atomic bombs; we can both build and destroy.
[0] https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/force-cdn/highwinds/hornso...
Your bold claim "why something rather than nothing?" assumes that there is, in fact, a something to refer to, and QM directly challenges the simplicity of that assumption. So many words to fight against the lack of an ontic wavefunction!
[0] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUl4u3cNGP60cspQn3N9d...
> Dropping religious beliefs is only a first step towards freeing ourselves from eternalism.
And continues to explain how your beliefs, about how there are definite meanings and purposes to life, are illusions. The next page [0] states it clearly too:
> We cling to the idea that there must be a cosmic plan because we fear that without one everything would be meaningless. But this is mistaken; which means that most ideas about meaningfulness and meaninglessness are mistaken. Fortunately, life is meaningful without any cosmic plan or ultimate source of meaning.
If you like arete, you could also stand to read Pirsig. He was very concerned with ethics and values.
Finally, to directly critique your metaphysics, please first consider this phrase you wrote:
> Everything matters, because we feel everything, and thus it matters to us.
And then consider Russell's teapot [1]. Does Russell's teapot matter, floating out there around the rings of Saturn? Can we feel it? A bit of consideration will show that, while everything is connected to everything, not everything affects everything else equally. We are, in fact, far more sensitive to things which are close to us.
I don't have a straw man. I have any deity which is like Jehovah, with Jehovah himself as a special case. Any deity is subject to self-defeating arguments and open to criticism from science.
I am not a naturalist, but that's the closest position that you can imagine, I guess.
Anyway, if you don't actually want to talk about QM, then we'll just have to talk about how Jehovah's followers keep trying to do something about COVID-19, but all of their appeals have led to nothing. Meanwhile, science and technology give us models for understanding, combating, and preventing the pandemic. Are you really going to pledge yourself to your deity and cough your lungs out?
We're both deists, by the way. I follow the Flying Spaghetti Monster. However, the FSM is absurd, which means that I cannot use the FSM's existence to conclude facts, and additionally doesn't affect the material universe. Also, the FSM doesn't maintain cults, encourage child abuse, start wars, nor allow simony.
Your "traditional theism" is metaphysically and epistemically weak; it cannot say anything about the world other than that its deity exists and has material affect upon the universe. However, empirically, there is no evidence of the deity (because they are supernatural), and so the deity cannot have any scientific method associated with it. Simply put, there's no room in the natural world for a supernatural being! Every empirical effect is instead considered scientifically.
The only gap left would be for you to show that miracles or other supernatural phenomena are real. On that, I have nothing polite to say, just to wish you good luck on what will definitely fail.