HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

KenoFischer

4,368 karma · joined December 2, 2012

Julia Core Developer Co-Founder at Julia Computing

Reach me at keno@juliacomputing.com

submissionscomments
KenoFischer··on The unreasonable effectiveness of the Julia programming language
Just swap out the parser ;) -https://github.com/swadey/LispSyntax.jl
KenoFischer··on The unreasonable effectiveness of the Julia programming language
Creating your own little universe that nobody else using the language can understand sounds exactly like lisp ;).
KenoFischer··on The unreasonable effectiveness of the Julia programming language
That is how Julia started. In the early days it was a scheme reader macro. You can still run `julia --lisp` to get a scheme prompt since the frontend is still written in it. Obviously lots of improvements have happened since then. Julia itself also feels a lot like a lisp, since Jeff is a huge fan, but of course people get hung up on the syntax.
KenoFischer··on Introduction to Computational Thinking
I was impressed by his ability to still use explanatory animations during the live lecture. That seems very hard to pull off so seamlessly.
KenoFischer··on Pumas AI: A platform for pharmaceutical modeling and simulation
You're not wrong - Pharma is quite conservative. I wasn't convinced the the Pumas folks had any hope, but apparently the legacy workflow for what they have is so aweful that people are aching for something better. I'm not in the day to day, but from my perspective Pumas seems to be quite successful and well received in Pharma, despite the conservatism.
KenoFischer··on Pumas AI: A platform for pharmaceutical modeling and simulation
This is a really cool effort to overhaul the pharmaceutical software stack. They just had their big 1.0 launch today. Also 100% written in Julia. Super fast and uses all the latest tricks and ideas from pharmacometric science. I'm not working on this myself (other than fixing the occasional bug they run into), but some of my colleagues do. I'll see if I can point them here to answer questions.
KenoFischer··on JuliaDB
Just to set expectations while this package is decently stable and used by a number of people, both commercially and in the open source, it is basically in maintenance mode at this point in time. The intention a few years back was to build a complete analytical database on top of Julia, but have it be a mostly independent project. That vision didn't quite materialize, partly because not enough people wanted to do distributed analytical work (often a single big box is enough, particularly with a language as fast as Julia) and partly because the main developer left to pursue a PhD. I wouldn't be surprised if it got revived in the future, but for the moment, it's basically just the distributed tabular computing part (which is useful if you have that problem, but more limited than the name might imply).
KenoFischer··on Julia 1.5 Highlights
NVIDIA is the most mature, but AMD and Intel are in development
KenoFischer··on Linear Logic Flavoured Composition of Petri Nets
If you're interested in this topic, you may enjoy James Fairbanks' talk on Catlab.jl, which is an applied category theory software package: https://youtu.be/7zr2qnud4XM. Petri Nets are one of the examples.
KenoFischer··on Reddit AMA: We are the creators of the Julia programming language
I think if I had spare money lying around to bribe reddit moderators, I'd rather buy myself a nice server, or lots of steak dinners, or a new oscilloscope. Honestly, I can think of lots of better uses of my money than that.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
There was old flang which was basically just the PGI compiler stripped of its backend and with a piece bolted on that converted the compiler's internal IR to LLVM by basically dumping out strings and then parsing them back in. Many people in the LLVM community thought that this was not a maintainable long term strategy for a Fortran frontend, and after much debate, the flang team decided to start over on Greenfield compiler called f18, which was to be architected more like clang. Then Chris released MLIR and said team decided to target that rather than LLVM directly. The only thing that was kept from old flang were some of the runtime libraries. f18 was recently merged into the llvm-project repository whereupon it was renamed flang. Old flang is dead, but the terminology is a bit confusing now. Additionally there are two external LLVM Fortran compiler efforts: lfortran out of the US national labs (which also paid PGI for flang) and fc, which I don't believe is currently open source, but is being developed by as compiler consulting shop on India called CompilerTree (not sure who's footing the bill for that one). Anyway, long story short, none of them seem to work. Old flang generates binaries, but is abandonware at this point, so not the correct foundation to build on. New flang doesn't even generate LLVM IR yet. FC doesn't seem public yet as I said. Lfortran may work, but the authors say it's very alpha and it certainly didn't work out of the box. I know some folks are looking into it to see what would be required.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Perhaps! It's one of the two candidates that might actually work in the near term. It didn't quite seem to work out of the box and given the newness of the project, we are a bit cautious, but there's some folks looking into it, to see if they can work through the issues.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Yeah, I was surprised by that statement too, but then again, I know nothing about how GCC is architected. I'm hoping somebody will come along and just fix it in a few days, but who knows.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Apple's copy of LAPACK has not been keeping up with upstream and is missing some of the newer methods and bug fixes. Also while those are certainly the big two dependencies they are by far not the only ones.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
If you actually read the code, it turns out that said compiler is not yet capable of generating LLVM IR let alone binaries.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
See https://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=96168.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
> IIRC Erlang only supports GCC as the build system.

Since gcc doesn't work on Apple Silicon, I assumed the OP must be using clang :).

KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Yes, it works mostly fine under Rosetta. However, it is also precisely the area where you don't really want a translation layer, because you're spending a lot of time doing heavy compute.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Probably not super well tested with a bleeding edge clang compiler though (and even for non-bleeding-edge versions, I'd suspect mostly tested with GCC). Triggering compiler bugs or exposing technically undefined behavior would not be entirely surprising.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
There's several! We tried all of them without much luck :(. The most complete seems to be the old flang, which was basically an open sourced version of the PGI compiler hacked up to generate LLVM IR by concating strings to generate textual LLVM IR. However, that project is basically abandoned and also depends on LLVM 7, while you probably want at least LLVM 10 to generate good code for Apple Silicon, so somebody would have to do that porting work, which doesn't seem like a worthwhile investment.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Lots of students have Mac notebooks, but want to run julia/scientific python/etc.
KenoFischer··on Building Elixir from source segfaults on macOS on Apple Silicon while compiling
Well, for one, this means that Apple Silicon has no Fortran compiler, which breaks a decent chunk of the scientific computing ecosystem.
KenoFischer··on MIT and Harvard file suit against new ICE regulations
> Is admission for internationals in general need blind as well at MIT/Harvard ?

I think that's true now. I don't remember if it was true 10 years ago when I went through this process, because I do remember submitting financial forms together with the application.

> What about income level of people attending ?

The statistics get published, but I don't think they generally get split out between international and non-international students. Anecdotally, it strongly depends on the country the person comes from. Some smaller countries gear their educational programs towards sending their top students to the top universities abroad and have appropriate recruitment programs in their public schools. For those countries the parental income distribution can be quite varied (not counting of course the taxpayer money spent to say send them around the world to international academic competitions and conferences). I think for countries that don't have such programs (usually because they have excellent domestic programs), you tend to see students come from wealthier backgrounds (that is middle class and up - I don't mean to imply that you need to be filthy rich to get in, just that participating in those activities that look good on US college applications requires a certain amount of money and parental support that needs to be supported from somewhere). That's just my sense though, I don't have any hard data.

KenoFischer··on MIT and Harvard file suit against new ICE regulations
Oops. Fixed.
KenoFischer··on MIT and Harvard file suit against new ICE regulations
> There is no such aid for internationals.

That's not completely accurate. Both Harvard and MIT claim parity in financial aid for international and domestic students. However, there is a bit of a discrepancy in the way that income is evaluated, higher taxes abroad leading to less post-tax money even for equivalent incomes, as well as non-institutional funding that domestic students are eligible for, but foreign students are not. The overall effect is more of a shift in the distribution of incomes between international and domestic students (i.e. if you're international you will be paying more at the same parental income level), but there is still a level where attendance is basically free.

KenoFischer··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
We prefer not to break researchers' workflow because the group next door misconfigured their server. Happens all the time. We only sinkhole IPs if the traffic is malicious or on track to exceed or budget.
KenoFischer··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
Doesn't help for two reasons 1) If the has has enough bits to be useful for blocking, it's trivial to reverse 2) Even if it did make the IPs anonymous, we want to be able to email the NOC at whoever is sending the abusive traffic, so they can go investigate
KenoFischer··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
What's sensitive or not depends very much on what other information the entity doing the analysis has available. Of course raw log records are more sensitive than aggregate data. For example, if somebody is wiretapping your internet connection, then even if the connection is encrypted raw logs would let them draw conclusions from timing. To some extent you're trusting the Julia project (or at least the people who have access) to not clandestinely be in the wiretapping business, but then again you're already trusting it with arbitrary code execution on your machine, so if it were in that business, you'd have bigger problems ;).

In any case that's why it's important to be transparent about what is sent, and for what purpose and who has access, so people can make informed decisions. Ironically, I think people are jumping on the authors of this particular piece of functionality precisely because they tried to be very transparent.

KenoFischer··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
I don't work on this particular thing, so I can't say precisely what the planned retention period is. I suspect 48 hours is too short, since people do take weekends ;). It'll probably become clear with experience what retention periods work. DNS servers are in a very unique position of course since they essentially get your browsing history.
KenoFischer··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
As mentioned in the thread, the people who implemented these features obtained appropriate legal advice from lawyers specializing in this area and implemented their recommendations.
← PreviousPage 5 of 17Next →